The narrative opens with a pivotal moment as Dr. Dolittle awakens and declares his intention to return to Puddleby. Having been away for a significant duration, the doctor feels that "it's time to return," a statement that catches the jungle inhabitants entirely off guard. The animals, who had grown accustomed to his presence, had operated under the assumption that "he would stay with them forever." This sudden shift in plans necessitates a formal gathering—the Monkey’s Council—to deliberate on the doctor’s departure.
During the council meeting, various leaders of the jungle community voice their confusion and desire for the doctor to remain. The chief chimpanzee questions, "Why would he go away?" while the grand gorilla suggests that perhaps the doctor’s living conditions are insufficient, proposing that if they "build him a bigger house and a comfortable bed," he might be persuaded to stay.
However, Chi-Chi, who possesses a deeper understanding of the doctor's life, offers a more grounded perspective. He explains that it is "useless to ask the doctor to stay" because he has "many responsibilities back home in Puddleby." Chi-Chi reminds his peers that the doctor left behind friends, specifically mentioning a worried horse and a fisherman whose boat was destroyed. Chi-Chi emphasizes the ethical obligation, stating, "It wouldn't be fair if he stayed here," acknowledging the doctor's duty to replace the crashed boat.
Following a period of contemplative silence, the council shifts its focus from preventing his departure to honoring his service. A baboon initiates the discussion by suggesting that they should not let "this good man leave without getting him something." The collective sentiment is one of profound gratitude, as they feel compelled to show him "how grateful we are" for all his work.
Various gifts are proposed during the brainstorming session, ranging from "a giant bag of coconuts" to "a hundred bunches of bananas." Chi-Chi, acting as the voice of reason, dismisses these suggestions, noting that they would be "too heavy to carry home" and would likely "go bad before they were half eaten."
The council reaches a breakthrough when a tiny red monkey proposes the gift of a "push-me-pull-you." This suggestion is met with immediate approval from Chi-Chi, who recognizes the uniqueness of the creature. He notes that "no one back home has ever seen a push me pull you," making it the "perfect" parting gift. By choosing a creature that is both extraordinary and distinct to the jungle, the monkeys find a way to express their appreciation in a manner that is both memorable and logistically sound, ensuring Dr. Dolittle leaves with a token that symbolizes the unique bond formed during his stay.