This message comes from NPR sponsor Capella University.
Interested in a quality online education?
Capella is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission.
A different future is closer than you think with Capella University.
Learn more at capella.edu.
Don't let the Spurs and the cowboy hats fool you.
At its heart.
The new Western series The Abandons is a sudsy nighttime soap, and that's a good thing.
Two steely matriarchs face off on the American frontier.
Lena Headey is the poor cattle farmer who's struggling to hold her found family of good-hearted misfits together.
And Gillian Anderson is the rich mine owner with her own brood of obnoxiously entitled offspring.
She wants Lena's land and will go to... any length to get it.
I'm Glenn Weldon, and today we're talking about Netflix's The Abandons on Pop Culture.
Happy Hour from NPR.
This message comes from AT&T.
America's first network is also its fastest and most reliable.
Based on RootMetrics, United States Root Score Report 1H 2025, tested with best commercially available smartphones on three national mobile networks across all available network types.
Your experiences may vary.
RootMetrics rankings are not an endorsement of AT&T.
When you compare, there's no comparison.
AT&T.
Support for this podcast and the following message come from Strawberry.me.
Be honest.
Are you happy with your job?
Are you stuck in a job you've outgrown or never wanted in the first place?
Are your reasons for staying really just excuses for not leaving?
Let a career coach from Strawberry.me help you get unstuck.
Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner.
Support for this podcast and the following message come from Lisa.
Lisa mattresses are meticulously designed and assembled in the USA for exceptional quality.
The entire lineup offers premium materials and full body support for restorative sleep.
Lisa has been recognized as best hybrid mattress by New York Times' Wirecutter.
Lisa includes free shipping, easy returns, and a 120-night sleep trial.
Right now, you can receive 25% off mattresses.
Visit leesa.com and use promo code NPR for an extra $50 off.
This message comes from Carvana.
Buy a car 100% online at carvana.com with financing to fit your budget.
Enjoy seven days to return if it's not a fit.
Limitations and exclusions may apply.
See return policy at carvana.com.
Joining me today is entertainment journalist Christina Escobar.
She's the co-founder and editor-in-chief of Latinamedia.co.
Hey, Christina.
Howdy, Glenn.
Howdy.
Nicely done.
The Abandons takes place in the 1850s in Washington Territory.
Gillian Anderson plays Constance, the widowed head of the rich Van Ness mining family.
But the mines are running dry and Constance has her eye on a patch of land owned by Fiona Nolan, another widow.
She's a tough cattle farmer who's adopted a bunch of outcasts.
She's played by Lena Headey.
No amount of money or misfortune can move us from this land.
God gave us this home, and only God can take it away.
Fiona refuses to sell to Constance, which sets off an escalating series of events as members of both families clash violently.
We should note that there is a sexual assault plotline in The Abandons.
We'll be discussing that today.
The series was created by Kurt Sutter.
He also created Sons of Anarchy.
Both The Hollywood Reporter and Deadline have reported that Sutter left The Abandons during production because of creative differences with Netflix.
NPR has not independently confirmed that reporting.
The Abandons is streaming on Netflix now.
Christina?
What'd you think?
Oh, man.
I wanted to like this show and I just couldn't.
Listen, I would watch Gillian Anderson read a grocery list.
I watched her in Tron.
Yep.
Yes.
You did that.
You put in your time.
This was not it.
There were so many issues with this show.
I will say it felt like she was stuck in a single note until some of the final episodes, when it finally got fun.
Maybe when she breaks a little bit and has some fun with one of her hired hands, if you know what I mean.
But until then, she was really stuck.
But I guess my main issue with this show was it felt like a season two.
Like we were supposed to be dropped in and already care about these people.
And I never cared about That's true.
The stakes of it never seemed real.
The characters never became people to me.
They remained types.
So the whole thing kind of just felt a little silly.
The other thing I would say is a lot of shows do this mix of language, where sometimes we're in the past but we're using modern language.
Sure.
This show did a really I want to say strange mix, where sometimes they would talk in this old-timey stilted way and then someone would drop a modern-day swear word and it would just catapult into shenanigans.
And I felt like this show didn't have any strong direction.
It really did not feel like they knew what show they were trying to make, and so it became just...
Nothing burger of a lot of really nice hats.
The hats were the highlight.
Really nice hats.
Beautiful hats.
Beautiful.
So many good hats.
The hat budget was off the hook.
If you love old-timey hats, watch.
Otherwise, I don't know.
Okay, okay.
I mean, I think the whole budget was pretty good.
I mean, for what we should mention, this show is gorgeous.
It looks expensive.
I mean, these landscapes are gorgeous.
I kind of was digging this for a lot of the same reasons you weren't.
I mean, this show does not go as hard as the previous Netflix Western American Primeval, which dropped on streamer in January of this year.
That show was very brutal and unsparing. very dad-coded, frankly.
And this show kind of wants you to think it's going to go as hard, with all the stuff about vengeance and moms protecting their kids very Greek tragedy.
But it is not that, as you know.
For one thing, this dialogue is so much less layered.
It's a lot more of people saying exactly what they're thinking the moment.
They think it in its entirety.
And there's also the thing that's related to that that's happening on a lot of streaming shows right now, where a character will say what's about to happen.
Then we watch it happen.
Then in the next scene, someone describes what just happened.
And once you start to notice this, you're going to see it every damn where, on pretty much every streaming service reportedly, or let's say the most generous interpretation of this phenomenon, which is everywhere, is that that's the streamers afraid that people are watching with their phones out and don't want them to get lost.
You cannot possibly get lost watching this show.
There's no getting lost.
Because, like, on paper, it's a huge ensemble.
There's a lot of characters.
A lot of B, C, and D storylines.
A lot of Anesses and Abandons coming together and clashing and smashing.
Lots of different factions.
There's bandits.
There's Native Americans.
There's townsfolk.
There's the military.
But the reason you're not going to get lost is because a lot of those tertiary characters don't matter.
This is a soap.
It's not just a soap.
It's dynasty.
I mean, it's got dreams of great tragedy.
And you know there's some Romeo and Juliet in there, with the two houses alike in dignity, with Fiona's son and Constance's daughter doing the star-crossed lovers thing.
But this show, this is the reason I liked it more than you did.
This show is smart enough to give us the reason why we're watching.
You do not cast...
Headey and Anderson and then just have them kind of glower at each other from across a great distance.
No, you give them scenes together to trade barbs and make veiled threats and be all stoic and resolved, which again Anderson kind of goes hard, really leans into the stoic and resolved.
But you get these flashes of vulnerability, like maybe a quivering lip.
And we get a hell of a lot more of those scenes than I was expecting.
Several per episode.
That's what this show is, right?
It's Crystal and Alexis on the frontier.
That's how you pay for all the other stuff with the kids and the bandits and all that stuff that I didn't care about.
Do you see where I'm coming from?
Yeah, I guess so.
And I do want to say I did appreciate that they didn't just have white people, which I feel like a lot of Westerns still do, even modern ones, like good points on that.
And it's interesting on some of the descriptions of the show it talks about, like a conflict between the haves and the have-nots.
And I did not think that that landed.
It did not feel like a meaningful class critique, as beautiful as the show was and as clear as it was on like These people have money and better clothes and a way way better house.
You know, but like, what does that mean on the frontier?
It felt really unclear to me.
And I mean, it was so soapy, it couldn't make any broader sense. points, I guess.
And to me also, the soap didn't work because I didn't care about them.
Okay.
No, good.
But let's talk about this frontier aspect because that's the one that I struggled with the most.
I do have a question for you, because the inciting incident, the real story trigger here, is an act of sexual assault.
And that sexual assault happens long before we know these characters.
We haven't had a chance to individualize them or characterize them or actually see them as people.
So it can't help but feel like anything but what it is, which is just a plot point.
It It's fuel for the storytelling engine.
And this is 2025.
That approach can't help but come off as lazy and cliche and forced and— And I would add gross.
It felt gross to me.
And gross.
Absolutely gross.
So here's my issue.
Narratively, that's inert.
Narratively, that's a nonstarter.
It made me kind of want to not watch.
But historically, right?
I don't want to say it's accurate.
I don't want to say it's justified.
It's not.
But, I mean, it's historically—
I mean, the Old West was a brutal place.
Am I giving this show an out that I shouldn't?
Yeah, I think so.
Okay.
I don't think it deserves that out.
And like, there's other ways to show brutality and different ways to manage brutality.
That particular aspect.
I think starting off with that, particularly as you mentioned before, we've gotten to know the characters does not make any sense.
And it puts you in a place where, because the characters, I would argue, don't really become people ever, that it's all just for a kind of pulpy entertainment, and sexual assault does not work as pulpy entertainment.
Yeah.
I don't think so.
Right.
And I want to say in terms of Netflix lady Westerns there was in comparing this show to Godless from 2017.
That show it had too many white people, but it had more interesting things to say about gender and the West that this show doesn't even approach.
Really,
Right.
Okay.
We talked about the soapiness of this show and I want to make it clear when I'm talking about soapiness, I don't mean its arch or its camp.
Right.
This is not lust in the dust.
It's not camp.
Until the last few moments of the last episode and I think you know what I'm talking about which tends to bleed over a little bit.
But what I mean is it's structured solidly, as far as I was concerned.
Soaps are plot-forward things.
Things happen, and they get heavily foreshadowed.
So you know they're going to happen.
But part of the satisfaction of watching a soap, or a nighttime soap or whatever the hell this thing is, is watching events slot into place.
I think this season builds to a climax.
I think the tension ratchets up and then explodes.
I was there for it.
But one thing we do have to give listeners fair warning about is that the climax does not get resolved.
This is a climax without any kind of denouement.
There's a big question about our characters that hangs over the series, about the fates, their ultimate fates.
I was okay with that because again, the climax did what it needed to do.
It delivered on like a cathartic release of tension and I don't know.
At that statement, we don't know if it's going to get a second season.
I would still tell people to watch it, given that we don't know what's going to happen, because I was satisfied by that increase in tension.
I'm going to guess you have a different opinion.
I mean, so the whole...
Ending to me.
Well, I do think they did a good job, perhaps with some of the pacing and the plot elements, and there is a big showpiece ending with a fire just really going for it that, whether it resolved or not, I wouldn't have changed my opinion.
Yeah. about the show.
It doesn't end in a way that is unsatisfying or more or less satisfying than the rest of the series, because you really have to care about these two matriarchs and their conflict for the show to work for you.
And for me, neither of them seemed particularly believable.
Gillian Anderson's character was really one note.
Her peer there was more conflicted, had both good and bad thoughts.
But that didn't come together to me in a way that felt like anybody I've ever met.
It felt like TV soapy silliness sort of trapped in this, like Western, sometimes gritty, sometimes not unsure of where it's going type of show that just didn't coalesce into anything other than a lot of quick, moving plot points.
Okay.
So if we could summarize, I think we're coming at this from two different places.
I'm coming from a place of seeing the flaws and giving a lot of slack, and you are coming from a place of having standards.
Yeah.
I mean... And I think both are valid.
I think yours is probably more valid than mine.
But now it's time for you to tell us what you think about the amendment.
Settle the dispute.
Find us on Facebook at facebook.com slash PCHH.
And that brings us to the end of our show.
Christina Escobar, thank you so much for being here.
This helped a lot.
I mean, I go into every show wanting to like it.
This one, no.
You have nothing to apologize for, especially when it comes to this show, which is what it is.
This episode was produced by Carly Rubin, Kayla Lattimore, Mike Katziff and edited by our showrunner, Jessica Reedy, and Hello Come In provides our theme music.
Thank you for listening to Pop Culture Happy Hour from NPR.
I'm Glenn Weldon, and we'll see you all next time.
This message comes from NPR sponsor Rosetta Stone, an expert in language learning for 30 years.
Right now, NPR listeners can get Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership to 25 different languages for 50 percent off.
Learn more at Rosetta Stone dot com slash NPR.
This message comes from BetterHelp.
The holidays are a time of traditions, like making your grandmother's pudding recipe or watching that movie you've seen a thousand times.
Incorporating therapy into your life can help you take time for yourself during what can be a joyful but sometimes tough time of year.
And by caring for yourself, you can show up more for the important moments.
This December, start a new tradition by taking care of you.
Visit BetterHelp.com slash NPR for 10% off.
This message comes from Capital One.
The Capital One VentureX Business Card earns unlimited double miles on every purchase.
Capital One.
What's in your wallet?
Terms and conditions apply.
Find out more at CapitalOne.com VentureX Business
