The narrative centers on the emotional struggle of Alan Adale, a young minstrel who finds himself in a desperate predicament. While traveling through the countryside, Alan falls deeply in love with a farmer's daughter named Ellen. Their affection is mutual; they share intimate moments by a "riverbank," where Alan declares her his "one true love" and they exchange a broken "sixpence" as a token of their commitment. However, their future is threatened by the girl's father, who intends to force Ellen into an arranged marriage with "Sir Stephen of Trent," an "old knight" whom she does not love. Alan is devastated, fearing that Ellen will "die of heartbreak" if forced into this union.
Upon hearing Alan’s story, the members of Robin Hood’s band, particularly Little John, express their indignation, asserting that an "old man like that has no right to marry such a young girl." Robin Hood, showing his characteristic wisdom and empathy, begins to formulate a plan. He recognizes that the success of their mission hinges on finding a way to legitimize the union between Alan and Ellen. Robin asks, "do you think Fair Ellen would marry you if we brought her before a priest and got her father's blessing?" This inquiry highlights Robin’s preference for resolving conflicts with a sense of social order and authority, rather than mere force.
The primary obstacle in Robin’s plan is the lack of a sympathetic clergyman. As Robin notes, finding a priest with "any great love for me" is the "sticking point." Fortunately, Will Scarlet identifies a potential ally: the "Curdle Friar of Fountains Abbey." This connection provides the group with a clear mission for the following day. The prospect of Robin’s help serves as a catalyst for Alan’s recovery; his "tears had dried," and he finds solace in the belief that Robin Hood can indeed provide a solution to his troubles.
The evening concludes with a display of communal camaraderie. buoyed by the promise of assistance, Alan Adale’s "spirits rose," and he entertains the men with his harp, singing until late in the night. The passage ends on a note of anticipation and purpose. Robin Hood directs his men to rest, emphasizing that they "must find the Curdle Friar" early the next morning. This chapter serves as a testament to the legendary outlaw’s role not just as a fighter, but as a guardian of the innocent and a champion of true love, setting the stage for a daring rescue mission designed to thwart the unfair marriage of Fair Ellen.