Hey weirdos, it's Ash here, ready to share a little secret.
Have you heard of Wondery Plus?
With ad -free episodes and one -week early access, it's like having an all -access pass to our lighthearted nightmare.
So come join us on the dark side and try Wondery Plus today.
You can join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or in Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
You're listening to a Morbid Network Podcast. Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar.
Whether you listen to stories, motivation, innovation, expert advice, any genre you love, you can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities, and new ways of thinking.
Listening can lead to positive changes in your mood, your habits, and, ultimately, your overall well being.
Audible has an incredible selection of over one million audiobooks, podcasts, and Audible Originals, all in one easy app.
Find the genres you love and discover new ones.
Explore bestsellers, new releases, plus thousands of included audiobooks, podcasts, and originals that members can listen to all all they want, with more added all the time.
Right now, I am listening to The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires by Grady Hendrix, and I just cannot get enough of it.
I never want to pause it.
I'm literally loading the dishwasher listening to it, on the treadmill listening to it, constantly.
It's so awesome. I love being able to listen anytime, anywhere I want to.
And there's more to imagine when you listen.
Sign up for a free 30 -day Audible trial, and your first audiobook is free.
Visit audible .com slash morbid.
life doesn't happen bi -weekly so why should payday the money that you earn can be in your hands today with earnin earn it is an app that gives you access to your pay as you work up to 150 per day with a max of 750 between paydays just download the earnin app and verify your paycheck then access up to 150 a day as you work and leave an optional tip any money you access plus tips are automatically repaid from your next paycheck i feel like you should have your money as you earn it, and Earnin makes that possible.
You want to go out for a little date night and spend your money.
You know, sometimes things pop up unexpectedly.
I would hate this for you, but you might have to go to the vet and drop some cash there.
You need the cash when you need the cash.
Download Earnin today, spelled E -A -R -N -I -N, in the Google Play or Apple App Store.
When you download the Earnin app, type in Morbid under Podcast when you sign up.
It will really help the show.
Morbid under Podcast. Earnin is a financial technology company, not a bank.
Cash Cashouts are based on your available earnings.
Standard cashouts take one to two business days with no mandatory fees.
Option to expedite your transfer for free, tips are voluntary, and don't affect the service.
See the cashout user agreement for details.
Service is not available in all states.
Hey, weirdos. I'm Alina.
I'm Ash. And this is Morbid.
i don't know it's morning morbid in the morning i'm so tired i stayed up all night last night helena and deb deb came over and we were watching that sherry papini documentary i know it was a good one it was good and then you guys left before the last episode finished and i said fuck this i'm finishing it it was too late so i finished that and then i was exhausted so or no No, then I wasn't exhausted.
I was still awake. So I watched Life After Lockup.
You really went for it.
I had a night. You partied last night.
Some crazy ass television.
You would think that I'd have crazy dreams, but I don't remember any of them.
But I didn't go to bed until like 2 .30 and then I had to wake up so early.
And now I'm just like, why did I do that?
I haven't been watching a lot of true crime the last really couple of years, to be honest. yeah I kind of like I leave it here and it's I got burnt out from it a little bit so in order to not be burnt out for it for my job I don't consume it outside of my job yeah and so which has been fun and kind of great because I'm not as burnt out but then last night I was like oh I do want to watch this it's an interesting case and watching that one I was like oh yeah like these are the kind of ones that are very interesting the ones like where I think though that maybe I I was just like too burnt out on like
murders and death you know what I mean like because I was also working in like the death industry so it was just a lot but things like this which is also the Sherry Popini case is also tragic on a totally different level it's but it's mind -boggling it's more mind -boggling and just like what the it's just fuck it's dorks at it it is dorks at it like that given sinister vibe holy shit and just the way like she fooled everyone in the lengths she went she was just posted up at her ex's house the entire time just like letting him running into hockey pucks off of her like what the fuck and like literally
like running into hockey sticks and like the way that they were like one of the ways that they were able able to catch that she you know had like made the entire thing up you know how she was like literally branded yeah she had a like a pinterest board with all these like like wood burning tools on it shut the fuck up yeah because i didn't get to watch the last episode you have to watch the last episode because it's it's how they started kind of like unraveling everything and obviously like the dna was like the biggest thing but then they found like these little things just because Because, like,
they were like, we need to build this case as much as we can.
And that, I was like, you just—you pinned those?
Like, you just pinned how to do this?
Knowing you were going to brand yourself?
Like, what? And then just, like, you're just, like, you decided to bring your racism into it as well?
Yeah, I mean, not— Like, what the fuck?
That whole thing blew my goddamn mind.
Well, because there's, like, obviously there's the racism and the fact that she was like, oh, it was two Hispanic women.
and there were never two Hispanic women ever.
Except for her ex. But Hispanic people within that area were what they faced after she came out and said that, I mean.
And she didn't give a shit.
Oh, no. It wasn't her problem.
Because then they expose her in this documentary for a whole bunch of other racist views.
I was like, girl, you're a trash human.
Girl! Truly, I feel bad for the kids.
I do too. It seems like the dad is like pretty chill and like he has like full custody of them.
And I feel bad. I feel bad for the whole.
Yeah. I mean he had.
Anybody that was involved in this and believed that it was true and dealt with the grief that they felt for those three weeks.
Yeah. Thinking she was gone.
Like her sister, her family, everybody.
Yeah. Her best friend.
He also just looked.
She also just looked at him one day and she was like mad at him about like something and she looked at him and she goes, I have to deal with the fact that you never found me.
and like put it on like basically i think a lot of what she did was like a like she sat there and watched as the nation searched for her and like watched her loved ones on like film like crying sobbing pleading with knowing her fake ass kidnappers yeah knowing her kids have no idea where their mom is and it's traumatizing them daily and it was literally the holiday season yeah she She doesn't give a shit.
It was like over Thanksgiving.
I was like, what the fuck?
It's about her. But yeah, and then she just, like, she literally sat there and watched the entire thing unfold.
And then when she decided to go back, he said she brought it up every single day.
And then one day she got pissed at him and said that.
And he was like, I did the best I could.
And also, you weren't willing to be found.
Also, you weren't actually missing.
Yeah, like, it wasn't like this was a big, exciting game of hide and seek.
and i and i lost it's like a gone girl though yeah and it's like so gone girl it's and it's also just the resources that were expended upon this case and it's like people who would you know were in trouble and needed help but resources were being put to this case even if it was just like a minute of a delay because of what was going on still a delay the money the these people's time These people's time, money, time, emotions, being away.
All of that. All the investigators, all the paramedics, all the people in the helicopters spending time away from their families.
Right. Because this asshole decided to hole up at her ex -boyfriend's house and make up a racist story.
Yeah, wild. To get attention.
And not only that. That in and of itself is all insane.
like in the fact that that happened is so i'm like how do you do that and just like not think about every everybody that you're affecting then she there was like thirty thousand dollars i think it was raised for her for like like through like victim advocacy work and like that kind of thing just good people yeah just like people raising money to help her with like hospital bills and stuff like that she like stole thirty thousand dollars from everybody and doesn't give a shit It's like, what the fuck?
And then she also, the girl that went missing, like, I think it was like a few years before Sherry like staged her own abduction, Tara Smith.
They like went to high school at the same time.
And people were like drawing a lot of parallels because they're like both blonde women.
They look a lot alike.
That's weird. Yeah.
She went to Tara's family and sat down with them and like talked to them about like everything that she had, quote unquote, gone through.
That's the deepest kind of psychopath I've ever heard. Like, sat there in front of a girl who actually went missing and was never found.
In front of her family.
Claiming that you...
You know what the experience is like.
You know what she's experiencing or that she did experience.
And, like, her husband actually thought that he could, like, somewhat relate to these people.
Because, like, he had gone through...
He had thought he had gone through a similar experience and very much, like, kind of did in a way.
Yeah. yeah and he was he was in an interview on the documentary and he was like i can't believe she knew and put him in that and literally put me in this position to go stand and like we were in those people's home yeah like i feel like an idiot yeah fucking wild you guys it's the perfect wife on hulu it's and this isn't even an ad it's such a good documentary not even an ad we just happen to watch it it's like a three part um three episode documentary it was so so just so fucking mind -chilling so bleak mind -boggling and i feel bad for those kids because yeah those kids are gonna grow up knowing
that their mom is sherry motherfucking pepini and it's like that's that sucks because they didn't ask for that they didn't ask for you to be a blazing asshole they went through things of their own that you should definitely watch the documentary it's awful allegedly but definitely watch the documentary because it is whoo yeah it was a wild one for sure it was a wild one to jump into after a while yeah right highly recommend it but now that we've gotten through that uh we're gonna continue with part two of peter manual true crime all the time except outside of this room uh oh true crime all the time
yeah yeah yeah and it's a good one yeah I was gonna say that is the name of it correct I was like wait a second I know that name yeah I used to actually love that I haven't listened to it in a long time because again I I've like pulled away from like consuming true crime outside of here um it's not because they're not good it's just because of my own brain yeah but I used to listen to them all the time yeah they were delightful all the time all the time true crime so yeah so when we last left you Peter is another blazing asshole yeah and he's been I mean he's been labeled an aggressive psychopath
who's that could never be you know helped helped and can never be helped there is no chance for recovery several psychiatrists have said this what do you do in that situation because there's no they're like you can't just like hold people what do you do you let him out of prison and then this all happens you let him out of prison in october of 1952 i don't wanna yeah it's not great what happens after he comes out of prison either so we're now to it so it's easy to understand why so many members of law enforcement immediately suspected peter manual in the murders of ann neilins and the watt family
yeah like we've we talked about it in part one he was like top of their heads when you talk about his previous crimes he was escalating he's also talking about it all the time and like knowing all these like key details and both of those crimes had a lot of the same like signature like hallmark things from his previous crimes leading up to them like dragging in neilins into the wooded area he did that to that woman the wife of the man that he was coming the staff member that he was coming to hurt or do whatever yep he dragged her into a wooded area but he stopped before he did anything there because he
wasn't as good even as why and then the trashing of the watts home and the trashing of the home nearby the watts the watt house he had done that already like throwing the food everywhere putting the cigarettes out like it all leads it lines up up you can't deny it no now but unfortunately peter at this point had evolved into for lack of a better word a better and smarter criminal at this point because like i said before he was just not he was a dumb ass before so he left a ton of evidence he would always get caught he had evolved unfortunately and he had evolved into a more cunning criminal um
and so detectives you know Now, before, detectives were able to build really strong cases against him really quick.
Right. But now, it's becoming harder and harder.
They can't get anything on him.
And his dad keeps giving him an alibi.
Yes. After his release from Barlinny, Manuel wasted no time getting back to his criminal ways, and he was going to go bigger than ever.
Oh, no. And he set into motion a horrifying series of events that, fortunately, in the end, would eventually lead to his downfall, but it's fucking terrible that all of this had to happen for it to happen because it should have happened a long time ago.
Now, on the morning of December 9th, police responded to a call.
This was a strange call.
It was a call about an abandoned taxi out in the moors in Newcastle -on -Tyne.
I looked it up. I think that's how you say it.
Newcastle -on -Tyne. So abandoned taxi on the moors.
Random. So they're like, it's probably not good.
So when they come to the area, they find that the driver's door was wide open.
So they go and look and they see that there is a considerable amount of blood in this taxi.
Oh, no. And it wasn't until hours later that they finally discovered that the driver, they discovered the driver, 36 -year -old Sidney Dunn, who was a man laying face down about 150 yards away in a, like a big bunch of heather, like this big bush.
and they found that his throat had been cut and he had been shot in the head oh my god so it was very violent very violent now normally investigators would say okay this is fucking terrible and very violent but it looks like it's a very violent botched robbery probably he's a taxi driver you know he's got money on him yeah but dunn's wallet was still in his pocket and the money from from his fares, still in there.
All still there. Nothing was taken.
So whoever had killed Sidney Dunn had not done it for money.
Right. They didn't take a dime.
Right. Okay, let's take a poll.
How weird does it feel to be called someone's fiancé?
Right? The first time you hear it, you do like a double take.
Your heart kind of flutters and before you know it, you go from, let's just enjoy this moment, to we're planning a fall wedding.
That's where Zola comes in.
Zola has everything you need to plan your wedding in one place and have fun along the way.
From free planning tools like a budget tracker, super necessary, and website, to a venue and vendor discovery tool that matches you with your dream team, everything on Zola is designed to make your wedding journey as easy as possible.
And with invites that can be completely And a wedding registry packed with gifts you actually want.
Zola takes you from save our date to thanks so much without breaking a sweat.
From getting engaged to getting married, Zola has everything you need to plan your wedding in one place.
Start planning at Zola .com.
That's Z -O -L -A dot com.
Happy wedding. In 1920, a broke immigrant in Boston became one of America's richest, most infamous men practically overnight.
night. He swindled the modern equivalent of a quarter billion dollars and etched his name into history as the mastermind behind one of the most notorious scams ever, the Ponzi scheme.
Hosted by Maya Lau and featuring award -winning comedian and actor Sebastian Maniscalco, this is Easy Money, The Charles Ponzi Story, an Apple original podcast produced by Atwell Media.
Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
from the beginning the investigation into this murder was really like an uphill slog uh in addition to the heavy rain and snowfall that had was really making it really difficult to process the crime scene there wasn't really any evidence to be collected anyways and there was no leads so they were just working from like zero right and they just couldn't move to one like they couldn't get anywhere.
Another taxi driver, Thomas Green, did tell detectives that two men who appeared to be in their mid -20s had approached he and Dunn around 4 .30 a .m. before the murder.
One of them was looking for a ride to Edmund Byers and the other to Newburn.
Thomas took the man going to Newburn and the man going to Edmund Byers got into Dunn's cab.
Okay. Now, the man was described as being 25 years old five foot eight inches tall of swarthy complexion what is swarthy yeah with dark hair straight and brushed back but that was really all they could get from the witness is that really good description but like that's really it that's all he had so by the end of december detectives had become so desperate for information that they resorted to actually like boots on the ground door door with questionnaire in hand to hope that someone in the neighborhood near the moors maybe heard something saw something anything um a coroner's inquest was held
but other than confirming the cause of death to be murder the jury came to really no other conclusions and the inquest was adjourned on december 31st so they just had nothing just absolutely nothing now while police in newcastle were literally like pulling their hair out about this case detectives back Back in Lanarkshire, we're dealing with now a new case of a missing teenage girl.
Oh, no. And they saw that this case felt very familiar, very familiar.
On the evening of December 28th, 17 -year -old Isabel Cook left home a little after 7 p .m. and she was going to attend a dance.
No. Does this sound already like Anne Neelan's 17 -years -old leaving to go to a dance?
dance she was going to be going to a dance at the Masonic Hall in nearby Eddingston and she was going to there was a whole plan in place she was going to be meeting her boyfriend Douglas Bryden and the two were going to go to the dance together but 45 minutes passed by the hour that they were supposed to meet up and Isabel still hadn't shown up to meet him so he just went inside by himself he's like what the heck which I was like I mean I don't know what else you do at that point it's in the 50s it's not like you're pulling out a cell phone and calling yeah exactly but the next morning when isabel
still hadn't come home her parents called the police police immediately launched a huge search for isabel they had police dogs they went full tilts and they determined through the police dogs they were able to determine that she had taken a shortcut off the main road on her way to meet her boyfriend okay this shortcut went through a wooded area along a footpath this footpath was very familiar to them because it was where 11 years years earlier peter manual had attacked a young woman oh it's the same exact footpath it was on that path that investigators discovered isabelle's purse most of her belongings
were still in the purse some of them were like shot like you know scattered around they also found one of her shoes now a police spokesperson told reporters that afternoon we're treating this as more serious than just a girl missing from home yeah and a day later the case took a really ominous turn because Because more pieces of Isabel's clothing were discovered along the banks of a river near the Calder Park Zoo.
A local diver actually came forward and volunteered to search the river.
Just a local diver.
Wow. Which, like, this community seems like they tried really hard to help out.
But they didn't find any more items in the river.
Now, for many investigators in this case, the details, and for us probably, too, and you listening, you're probably thinking, this is Anne Nealon's murder.
her. This is very similar.
Yeah, it sounds a lot like that.
Very similar. And they thought that, too.
Yeah. They immediately thought of that.
And the press, they thought it right away, too.
It's not like anybody wasn't putting these pieces together.
Okay. Like Anne, Isabel had been on her way to a dance when she deviated a little bit from the path and then ran into someone presumably dangerous.
Right. Unfortunately, after a week of intensive searching, I mean, like, full -tilt searching, they hadn't found any additional evidence, no leads.
So, speculation Population was really all they could do until new information came their way.
But it was the same thing, just dead end, nothing.
Now, while detectives on the Cook case waited, a new and honestly more shocking case came their way at this moment.
Shocking at this moment, at least. On the morning of January 6th, two patrol officers were investigating a call about an abandoned vehicle.
And while they were investigating that call, they went to the home of the vehicle's owner.
His name was Peter Smart.
not peter manual so many different peters i know there's a lot of peters in this when they arrived at peter smart's house several of peter's co -workers were actually already there waiting for them okay they had gone to look in on him because he didn't show up for work that morning and he wasn't answering his phone oh wow which again shows you like concerned people are like real there's like a community over here taking care of each other like they're showing up at his house because they're like he's not answering his phone and this isn't like him they were were concerned that something was wrong
so they had shown up and the officers ended up forcing their way inside the house because nobody was answering and that's where they found peter his wife doris and their 11 year old son michael all were dead from gunshot wounds to the head i just saw a picture of little michael and he's like the sweetest little babe oh it breaks your heart it's so sad it's he had like no true victim profile whatsoever it was like whole families and young young women yeah like so like anybody but then also sydney dunn who was in his 30s and a man right like to just like no really no rhyme or reason and it's also like
why did you like why did you kill anybody but like why did you kill sydney dunn too like yeah you didn't take his car or anything like what just just to kill but it's the same with everybody it's like you're not taking anything you're not with the women it seems and we'll get in we'll get into it as much much as we can because he doesn't really he doesn't really get into it but there is some sexual element yeah that we've discussed in part one with the like hiking up the skirts and pulling down the pants right displaying in certain ways yeah there's definitely a sexual element he was just never
willing to explain it but there was a point when you know there's sexual insult involved in a lot of these and also there was the during his escalation period the wife of that of that That staff member at the school that he ran away from, he was fully intending to rape her.
When he dragged her out into the woods, he just stopped.
Yeah. Yeah. So like the disappearance of Isabel Cook, the murder of the Smart family, like we're probably thinking, immediately called into mind a different murder.
It was the murders of Marian and Vivian Watt and Margaret Brown the previous year.
The Watt family, it was like a direct pair.
It was like Ann Neelan's Isabel Cook.
Watt family, Smart family.
It's like he's paralleling.
Yeah. So each member of the family, like the Watt family, had appeared to be asleep when they were shot in the head at point -blank range.
Oh, God. That's the other thing.
And given that many of the valuable items they had in the house were in plain fucking sight, robbery was definitely not the motive.
He had not taken anything.
Not anything of value.
He takes things, but nothing of value.
Like little trinkets.
It's more for him. He doesn't go and sell it.
It's his shit. And did he trash this house?
He did. He trashed the house.
Superintendent Murdo McKenzie told reporters during a press conference there is no sign of the house being broken into.
Huh. Yeah. And McKenzie also noted that no gun had been found in the house.
So they ruled out a murder -suicide immediately because it's a family annihilation.
Yeah. The coroner estimated that all three had been murdered in the early hours of New Year's Day.
And according to the neighbors, the Smarts had been planning to visit family that day.
So no one really thought it was odd when Peter Smart's car wasn't in the driveway.
And the curtains in the house were all drawn.
What was odd, though, was that in the days after that, the curtains in the front windows changed positions several times over the course of several days.
That means whoever, who they didn't know at the time, but whoever killed the Smarts had come back to the house or stayed in the house for several days.
Oh, I hate that. I have chills.
And that's between the murders on January 1st and the discovery of the bodies on January 6th.
So like literally a week.
What the fuck? Later, after Peter Manuel's trial, investigators learned that someone had tried to break into the home of John McMunn and his wife, the neighbors who lived just a little ways away from the Smarts, in the early hours of January 4th.
So he had killed the Smart family on January 1st. By January 4th, he was trying to break into one of their neighbor's house, a family, to kill them as well.
Which is so similar to what he had done in the previous thing, except that family wasn't home.
Yep. And this time, Mrs. McMahon woke up in the middle of the night to find a man looking at her through their bedroom window trying to break in.
Shut the fuck up. Luckily, she sat up and honestly, everybody should do this.
If you ever see somebody trying to break into your house.
She sat up and screamed for her husband to get the guns.
Yeah. Like, she said out loud, like, get the guns.
Good. And he got the fuck out of there.
What the fuck? Because he was like, well, shit, I don't want to be in a firefight.
Oh, my God. Just picturing that is so fucking terrifying.
Waking up and seeing a man outside your bedroom window trying to break in.
Goodbye. Goodbye. Oh, my God.
Fuck. that. Thank goodness she had the foresight to be like, get the guns, because I feel like that's something most intruders don't want to hear.
So it's like, but what the fuck?
And thank goodness she did it.
Her whole family would have been gone.
Thank goodness she woke up.
And thank God he wasn't freezing, because obviously he had a gun too.
And thank goodness she woke up.
I don't think he liked when they woke up.
He liked them in a vulnerable position where he could and put the gun against their head and do it oh my god that's so fucking scary but he he fled and it was only after he had been executed that the McMuns confirmed that the man they saw through their window was Peter Manuel damn yeah and you said executed did you mean to say arrested no he got executed oh okay I was like no no he got executed oh shit spoiler alert um so since his release from Barlini in November detectives had been keeping an eye on Peter Manuel that he was under close surveillance yeah DCI William Muncy who had arrested Manuel
several years earlier for the house breaking was assigned to lead the investigation into Isabel Cook's disappearance and when he got the case Muncy immediately thought of Ann Nealon's and Peter Manuel but other than that gut feeling and knowing that there's a connection here somehow there was no evidence to connect it so he couldn't really do a lot it was just like my gut is telling telling me this is it.
Right. But Manuel's name came to mind a few days later when Muncie heard about the murders of the Smart family as well.
The more his name came up in connection with murdered and missing people, the harder it was to deny that there is a connection.
And investigators intensified their surveillance.
Now they really honed in on him, just waiting for him to fuck up, just waiting for that moment.
Because you know it's going to happen.
And it happened. But their big break did finally come about a week later.
In the course of the investigation, detectives had learned, they'd used some criminal informants to try to get more information about Peter Manuel.
And they learned from one of these informants that Peter Manuel had been seen and witnessed by several people spending brand new five -pound notes at pubs around Glasgow.
go huh and what they had found out was just before the murders they had found out that peter smart the father of the murdered family yep had withdrawn several new five pound bank notes from the bank because he was going to use them on their family holiday right which is really sad heartbreaking and so armed with a warrant and a list of the notes smart withdrew from the bank a group of detectives arrived at peter manual's house on the morning of january 14th let's go Now, Peter's father, Samuel, answered the door, and Detective Superintendent Alex Brown handed him a copy of the search warrant and explained
that they were looking for any five -pound notes, they were looking for keys, and any other evidence potentially taken from the smart home.
Samuel, the father, immediately got hostile and very verbally abusive with the officers, but ultimately ended up letting them into the house.
Oh, they got a warrant, bro.
He fucking had to. When they got in the house, they found Peter asleep in a chair in the living room.
I was like, you fucking bum.
Yeah. But once he was woken up, Brown read the warrant out loud to Peter, and Peter immediately became abusive and, like, flipped out, hostile, like, lost his mind, but eventually had to comply with the whole thing.
And after getting himself ready, he willingly went down to the precinct with two of the officers.
I can't tell you how often I hear, oh, I'm a little OCD.
I like things neat.
That's not OCD. I'm Howie Mandel and I know this because I have OCD.
Actual OCD causes relentless unwanted thoughts.
What if I did something terrible and forgot?
What if I'm a bad person?
Why am I thinking this terrible thing?
It makes you question absolutely everything and you'll do anything to feel better OCD is debilitating but it's also highly treatable with the right kind of therapy regular talk therapy doesn't cut it OCD needs specialized therapy that's why I want to tell you about no CD no CD is the world's largest virtual therapy provider for OCD their licensed therapists provide specialized therapy virtually and it's covered by insurance for over 155 million Americans If you think you might be struggling with OCD, visit nocd .com to schedule a free 15 -minute call and learn more.
That's nocd .com. You know that person in your life who just can't stand mayo?
Call them traumatized.
Call them closed -minded.
We get it. They're stuck in their ways.
But here's the thing.
They just haven't tried Hellman's flavored mayo.
We're talking bold flavors that will flip even the biggest skeptics.
Spicy mayo that adds the perfect kick to your burger.
Garlic aioli that transforms ordinary fries into something extraordinary.
Chipotle mayo that turns your basic wrap into a smoky sensation.
So to all the mayo haters out there, yes, we're looking at you.
It's time to eat your words.
Because with mayo this flavorful, any hater is just a mayo lover waiting to be convinced.
Hellman's Flavored Mayo.
Get ready to eat your words.
now i'm just taking a detour really quick because this superintendent brown i found an interesting article about him oh he was apparently like a badass detective shit and he was one of like one of a small group of detectives in this case that was like very well known to have like cracked this like with hardcore police work right so uh they called so his name was um Superintendent Brown and he was known, I found this from an article called, it's in the Glasgow Times and it is the story of the cop who caught Peter Manuel and it's by Norman Sylvester, this article.
I just want to point out a few things about him.
So he was known to be very methodical in his methods and he really had a good understanding of how people ticked.
That was like his his like his forte was psychology.
Right. And he was so apparently he was known to like also do the most methodical searches of houses like if he had a warrant you better hope nothing is in your house because he's gonna find it like that man is gonna find it one of his fellow detectives said if he didn't find what he was looking for in a house he would strip the paper off the walls if necessary like he wasn't letting if i have a warrant i'm finding this thing and his favorite advice to young detectives was let the other fellow do the worrying huh like he was like the criminal should worry not you yeah and then he said use the minimum
amount of words and maximum amount of action nice um he was super ahead of his time with the psychology stuff he in 1943 he wrote an article for a police magazine titled psychology and the investigation of crime huh that was in the 40s yeah that's big that was ahead and he said that the most successful investigators are the ones who best understand understand human behavior.
I mean, yeah. And which again, ahead of his time with that.
Yeah. And apparently when he was investigating the Peter Manuel case, he set up an office in the Bothwell police station and he set up a bed.
He literally had it installed in the police station because he said he wanted to be on call and ready to jump into action at any given moment to get this guy.
Or if any new information came up, he wanted to be able to just like pop out of bed and just off he goes so he was literally like day and night on this thing like eat eating sleeping breathing yes he was one of the main ones that decided it was time to strike and get peter manuel like go to his house and arrest him they were he was like i'm sick of waiting like we need to get this guy we have something he knew that this was the guy and he told manuel actually that the way they were able to get him um you know because what we'll see is peter ends up confessing okay and what he was able to do was he
told peter that they had found stuff related to another how like um uh i think a reverence home had been broken into in the area and he said they they had found stuff in the manual household from that break -in so it was peter who did it yeah but he told them brown told peter we're charging your father and he was like so he's like it's his his house we're going to charge him with it and that's how he was able to get him to crack he didn't want to turn on his dad he knew via psychology that that was going to be the thing that was going to get him that's a smart move and later when uh the you know
the manual case goes to trial and he ends up being convicted for this um the trial judge lord cameron actually did something that never happens he invited brown and two other detectives back into his chambers afterwards and he thanked them personally for their efforts to get manual arrested wow that's amazing and in 1959 he was given the queen's police medal before retiring hell yeah he deserved it and later peter manual himself said about superintendent brown i could handle the others but i couldn't handle brown shit isn't that crazy google this guy that's why i was like when i read that i was That guy
sounds like a badass.
He does. The fact that he was that committed to making this happen.
He knew that we got to get him off the streets.
Like, what a badass.
That's cool to have all that.
Yeah, you got to do it.
So they took – so at this point, Peter Manuel is going to the precinct.
He's going downtown, you know.
And they took him out of the house and down to the precinct.
And this wasn't just something they had to do.
this was a tactical decision and this tactical decision was made by brown nice because he was using psychology he's he knew with peter out of the way his elderly parents are going to become a lot less defiant yeah and a lot less aggressive hundred percent peter's the peter's the thing that's the the main component that's making them this way so he said get them out of the house so we can talk to them and so they were able to search the rest of the house with very little interference.
And they found items in the home that were related to several crimes.
They found a pair of men's gloves and a camera, which had been stolen from that home of the local reverend on Christmas Day, actually.
And at the precinct, Peter was included in multiple lineups while this was going on.
And during these lineups, they had Glasgow bartenders come in and identify him as the man who was spending all those brand new five pound notes there it is and the numbers on those notes matched the ones that were taken out of the bank by the smart family and it was during this time that peter was also identified by patrol officer robert smith he identified him in a totally different scenario uh apparently robert smith said that peter manual was the man who who gave him a ride on the morning of January 2nd, which would be the day after he killed the Smart family.
That's terrifying. According to Robert Smith, he had been hitchhiking to work that morning when a man he identified as Peter Manuel stopped to pick him up in a gray A30.
And that's Peter Smart's car.
Right. And the two men made small talk, and Robert Smith mentioned he was on his way actually to work and he was going to be participating in the Isabella Cook search. and he said peter manual had a very strong reaction very quickly to even talking about that and he had a very strong interest in talking about the case with him and before he got out of the car peter said he felt that the police weren't looking in the right places he's so gross oh and just the fact that he's driving around this man's car like how fucking brazen he's driving around this man's car knowing he's going to go back to their
house and spend time there, by the way.
And then talking to a man about a murder he committed.
Talking to a police officer about a case of a young woman that he murdered who is still missing.
And he's still not looking in the right direction.
And he's telling him, like, you're not looking in the right places.
And they still haven't found her.
And they still haven't found her.
Oh, God. Now, Peter Manuel has been pretty good up until this point at, like, avoiding authorities, especially since he's inserting himself into the fucking investigation at this point.
And so it does seem like at this point you're like, Like you're getting fucking sloppy.
But I think he just was.
I think it's like you can't hang on to this kind of shit for that long.
Nobody can. Like he's going, he's too brazen and he's too, he's going so hard so fast that there's no way he could keep up with this.
And the evidence around him seemed to be piling up at this point.
And detectives were beginning to make connections between Peter Manuel and several open murder cases in the area.
So he became pretty aware that he was running out of options at this point.
So on the morning of January 15th, Peter asked that his parents be brought to him at the station.
And this was after Brown had told him, oh, OK, it's like it's it's so cool that you're not involved in any of this.
But like, we're going to be charging your dad because he apparently stole shit from a reverend's house on Christmas Day.
Like, wild. The cells really meant this.
So like, he's going to jail forever.
And so he said after so Peter told detectives after I have told my parents and made a clean breast of it to them you can take them away and i will clear everything up for you okay and he said and i will take you to where the girl cook is buried so apparently he sobbed and confessed to his parents that he had killed anne neilins marion and vivian watt margaret brown isabel cook and all three members of the smart family what the The fuck?
So at this point, everyone's aware of Peter Manuel and who he is and his history as a compulsive pathological liar.
Right. So the prosecutor was like, yeah, yeah.
Like we, yeah, we probably - Believe you actually.
We probably did that.
But we're going to need a little more before we accept this.
Yeah, we need like straight up proof.
We can't just hear that you did it.
Give us some details.
Tell us what you did.
Now, according to Peter Manuel, he broke into the Smarts house through an open window, killed everyone inside then stole whatever cash he could find in the days after that he returned to the house daily to eat the food and relax in their living room and even fed their cats what the fuck yep he would just relax in their living room and hang out with their cat while their dead bodies are just are just like rotting inside what the fuck and just the fact that he would like to do something like like feed the cat like it's like what he'd be like eating their food sitting in their living room what yeah
just making food in their kitchen while they're dead in their bedrooms an 11 year old and his parents yeah yeah oh that's so gross he's like next level beyond and obviously his knowledge of the smarts house the layout and everything and what it looked like inside and the details of the crime could only have been known to the person who was intimately involved in it.
And the same was true for the other cases that he confessed to.
He had details that no one else would have. And after giving a full confession, he was taken to Bar Linney for the evening.
The next day, he led detectives to a large field near an old brick works.
And so, I looked up how to say this, and I found several different ways.
So, I'm going to say the way that seemed the most to me.
Okay. But feel free, Scottish listeners, to be like, Like, what the fuck did you just say?
Madness. I think it's Bailey -eston.
I don't know what that is.
It's B -A -I -L -L -I -E -S -T -O -N.
I found, like, three different ways to say it.
Bailey -eston is the only one that seemed right to me, but I could be wrong, and I apologize if I am.
But he led them to this large field near an old brick works there and directed their attention to what was like a little ditch, like a shallow ditch. And he told investigators, I dug that hole.
I had her body here, but I was disturbed by a man taking a shortcut out of the brickworks, and I had to take her away.
So they were like, okay.
So after taking the detectives on this long, circular route around the field and into the recently plowed fields of Burnt Broom Farm, he reached, he brought them over to like a patch of land that looked like it had been recently disturbed.
And he said, and I quote, I think she's in there.
I think I'm standing on her.
Oh, my God. Yep. And he was right.
He was standing on her.
When investigators dug about two feet into the earth, they discovered the body of Isabel Cooke.
Just so callous. I think I'm standing on her.
I think I'm standing on her.
Yeah. I think she's in here.
Her skirt had been bunched up around her waist and her underwear was missing because he stole underwear.
He's so fucking gross.
Her scarf had been forced into her mouth as a gag And her bra had been wrapped around her neck and was used to choke her to death.
She also had a lot of bruising on the left side of her face, like she had been struck several times, very aggressively.
Back at the station, Peter drafted formal confessions in writing to every single one of the murders and provided details of each one.
He also confessed to several robberies in the area as well.
and in all his confessions he emphasized that robberies were the motive for the attacks but none of that made sense because he didn't steal stuff from most of them right and he just wanted to make it look like he had a reason quote -unquote yeah but like we said earlier in each one there is a very undeniable sexual element here but he would not talk about it and he would not go into it they they could not get anything about it.
Huh. Yeah. Like ever?
No, we never would.
That's frustrating.
Now, while Peter Manuel sat in the cell at Barlinny, there was a large team of investigators just gathering up evidence and collecting any witness statements they could to build up that case against him.
And with the critical evidence collected at this time, there was a Beretta pistol and Webley revolver that were used in the Smart and Watt murders.
Apparently, Manuel had thrown them into the River Clyde after the murders and they found them oh shit yeah at the same time investigators learned that manual had been in the newcastle area for a job interview the very night that sydney dunn was murdered imagine that yeah and he was identified as the man seen getting into dunn's taxi oh man on january 29th he was eventually charged with the murder of sydney dunn as well okay but that crime actually occurred in england so it couldn't be included in the other charges and the prosecution was going to have to wait until after the trial in Scotland to
do that. Move it over.
Hi, I'm Lindsey Graham, the host of Wondery's podcast, American Scandal.
We bring to life some of the biggest controversies in U .S. history, events that have shaped who we are as a country and that continue to define the American experience.
American Scandal tells marquee stories about American politics, like the break -in at the Watergate Hotel, an event that led to the downfall of a president and raised questions about the future of American democracy.
We go behind the scenes looking at devastating financial crimes, like the fraud committed at Enron and Bernie Madoff's Ponzi scheme.
And we tell stories of complicated public figures like Edward Snowden and Monica Lewinsky, people who found themselves thrust into the spotlight and who spurred debates about the future of the country.
Follow American Scandal wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen and ad -free on the Amazon Music or Wondery app.
Now, his trial began May 12th, 1958 at the High Court in Glasgow.
And his defense team had John Ferns, Ian Daugherty, and lead counsel Harold Leslie.
Apparently, like, they're all volunteer counsel assigned by the Scottish Bar.
Dave found that they do it a little different there, where like here in america you know there's like public defenders and like you know you're you're given this person if you can't afford a lawyer yeah like that's their job they do that but apparently over there they just like randomly grab people from the bar association and we'll be like this is yours now like it's just like they volunteer quote unquote like it's like here it is damn you get like thrown onto this case essentially that must be tough that must be really tough Because what if you have a bias?
That's the thing. It's like I guess you can't.
You know, like that's your job.
You just can't. Damn.
But in the months leading up to the trial, the case and headlines around this whole thing had definitely crossed over into like sensational.
Yeah. At this point.
I can imagine. And spectators were lining up around the courthouse as early as 8 p .m. the night before to get a seat in there.
People were fucking tailgating this?
Tailgating it. Damn.
Yeah. In the time between Peter's arrest and the start of the trial, investigators had collected a lot of evidence at this point.
Sounds like it. And that included over 150 exhibits, including the guns used in the murders and pieces of Anne Nealon's skull.
Oh, wow. The witness list for the prosecution had like 300 people on it.
so before any opening statements had been made harold leslie shocked the course by making a statement on behalf of his client oh god this statement said i appear on behalf of the panel the panel would be like his you know peter manual right who adheres to his plea of not guilty and there are special defenses lodged okay despite having made a full fucking confession in writing and verbally and giving details of each crime, including leading them to the missing woman.
He changed his plea to not guilty.
And on May 13th, in front of the entire court, he said he wasn't the one who killed the Watt family, but actually it was William Watt, the father, that was on the fishing trip.
Are you kidding me?
So he's bringing him back into it.
That's good. That's kind.
Yeah, we love that.
The court went nuts.
Of course they did.
The judge took so much time to have to restore order here, but eventually it all resumed as it was supposed to go.
He's just having fun.
No, and this was not the last time that he was going to stum everybody.
So in his opening statement, the lead prosecutor, Maurice Gillies, laid out the case against Peter in pretty simplistic terms. He just highlighted the evidence against him, made the connections between his whereabouts at the times of the murders when they were committed, his criminal history that included specific hallmarks that happened at these crimes.
The cigarette, the trashing the places, the dragging the woman, the method of killing, all that stuff.
And so their strategy was not really to convince the jury of his guilt, because like, he's guilty, like he confessed.
But it was basically to let the witnesses and evidence demonstrate his irrefutable responsibility for the murders.
So in the days after that, one witness after another came up and just presented compelling fucking testimonies and evidence against him, including the foreman on the work site nearby the discovery of Anne Nealon's body.
This person confirmed that Manuel had shown up for work the following day with fresh scratches on his face.
He was like, yep, that was right after.
And that same witness also told the jury he had seen Peter Manuel removing a pair of bloody work boots from the site a day or two after the murder oh yeah that's so a few days into the trial the subject then shifted from anne neilings to the watt family murders and among the first witnesses in that whole thing was lawrence dowdle this was william watt's lawyer at the time of the murders and he was the guy who peter manual was sending letters to claiming william watt was innocent and now he's turning around at the trial and being like actually he did this well now he's he's the like so he's gonna be
saying like i got these yeah the lawyer but peter's sitting there being like no yeah now he's gonna turn around and be like well actually william wanted it and it's like this guy's gonna sit there and fuck you up he has letters so among other things dowdell described manuel as the most vicious psychopath psychopath it has ever been my misfortune to meet.
Fuck. Which is wild for a defense attorney to say that.
Yeah, because they've seen some shit.
Yeah. Charles Tallis, who was a known criminal and associate of Peter Emanuel, also testified and he explained that he had actually given the gun Peter used to Peter that he used in the Watt murder.
Oh god. He said he told me that he had some bullets and the bullets wouldn't fit the gun but were falling through the magazine and he said He said that he helped Manuel make the gun operational.
And he didn't know that this was what it was for.
Oh, man. But William Watt also testified, not only to give details about the murder, but also about Manuel's contacts with him in the months that followed the murders.
What? Yeah. So according to William Watt, he and Manuel actually met in a hotel room in Glasgow.
And during this whole thing, Manuel attempted to convince him that three people had been involved in the shooting.
and one of them was charles talus what so he he had like kept in touch with william watt the man of the family he had killed like sat down with him at a hotel like what the actual yeah fuck he really is beyond any kind of hope and he really is like this shows you he'll go to the ends of the earth to be a fucking slimy piece of shit he just enjoys it he does and william watt on the stand said he said that charles talus broke into the house they went in and shot my wife and sister in bed and then he broke down in tears on the stand yeah now most damning of all though was the confession that peter
had voluntarily given to police very told multiple people wrote it down they were detailed they had intimate familiarity with the watt home like he was in in that house yeah all these homes and he was in the other crimes same thing he knew the layouts of the houses he knew the details that were not reported yeah and on the witness stand detective robert mcneil explained the process by which they obtained this confession from right and that included the statement manual made just before he confessed he said there is no future for me oh and manual was alleged to have said i've done some terrible
things i killed the girl At East Kilbride, and I shot the three women at the house at Burnside.
And following McNeil's testimony, Manuel's confessions were read in full to the jury.
They were like, you gave these.
We're not taking them out.
On May 22nd, Peter Manuel shocked the court again because he dismissed his entire defense counsel and said, I'm going to act in my own defense.
Oh, no. No, honey, no. We always know how this goes.
After a brief recess, Harold Leslie addressed the judge, saying i'm no longer in a position with my colleagues to continue the cause the panel being desirous of conducting the remainder of the trial so he was like peace deuces in other words he was fired uh the judge allowed the change but he insisted that the other two defense lawyers ferns and docherty needed to remain close by to possibly assist if needed okay uh but it came very clear i'd be pissed i was just gonna say i'm out i'd be like oh i just got fired in front of fuck this guy yeah see ya see he can sink his own ship you can sink your
own fucking i tried and peter didn't want their help yeah he made it clear he fired them yeah and he never used their help he didn't want it so it's like i just have to sit here and watch this now apparently peter manual had done this before he had defended himself in court before several years earlier he defended himself in a rape case in airdrie sheriff court and he was unsuccessful he went to prison for that one that's great now regardless of what happened throughout this whole thing apparently he had a lot of confidence he was very charming in court and he impressed even the most successful
experienced lawyers watching the trial according to joe joe beltrami who was a very prominent scottish lawyer who saw the trial he said judge lord cameron said he was surprised at the standard and skill of the accused and so was i his cross -examination was quite skillful and well thought out which is like nuts but remember peter manual is pretty bright he was bright in school he just really didn't apply himself yeah but he was very bright sounds like ted bondi yeah now confident or not the prosecution's case against manual was just too strong yeah they had built a considerable amount of evidence
like literally led them to a body yeah it was very compelling they didn't need to do a whole lot uh but peter manual's defense on the other hand was uh i didn't do it oh okay which is uh which is strange when you've confessed voluntarily verbally and in writing so yeah but when he finally took the own the stand in his own defense he refuted everything that he previously stated or confessed and he fell back on that old habit of just saying it's everyone else's fault oh okay it's not my fault i didn't do it final arguments were given on may 29th and the jury took barely two hours before returning
guilty verdicts on seven counts of murder six counts of capital murder for the wat and smart families one count of non -capital murder for isabelle cook and what kills me is in the case of anne nealans the jury felt the evidence did not make the case and he was not found guilty that's shitty yeah now when the verdict was read the courtroom went nuts and there was like a hundred plus reporters in the the courtroom too and they all just ran out of there to go type up their fucking thing for you know the next thing but judge lord cameron wasted no time passing uh sentence he said the sentence of this court
is that you be taken from this place to the prison of barlinny glasgow therein to be detained until the 19th day of june next and upon that day in the said prison of barlinny glasgow and between the hours of eight and ten o 'clock you suffer death by hanging which is pronounced for doom fuck which like which is pronounced for doom i'm like damn you guys know they got that good shit you have a grasp on that language like it just you know how to make it like after passing the sentence lord cameron just dismissed the jury adjoined the adjoined the adjoined i was like adjoined adjoined the court and refused
peter manual the opportunity to make a statement love was literally like shut the up you've talked enough yeah so for several years the crimes of peter manual captivated the attention of the public across uk i mean they were who wouldn't be right but once the trial ended and everybody was kind of satisfied he had been sentenced he had been you know found guilty everything he got what he deserved attention kind of like shifted away so like you know other stuff was happening so they just kind of were like like fuck peter manual bye yeah when the day of his execution arrived on july 11 1958 the evening
times reported quote as the hands of the prison clock pointed to the execution hour fewer than a dozen people stood silently outside the prison there was no demonstration no protest by opponents of capital punishment as the final act was carried out under due process of law at 8 a .m the the executioner pulled the lever down he went he was gone hang to death and the people of scotland were finally free of the beast of birkenshaw damn fuck peter it's the fact that like less than 12 people were nobody gave a shit anyway they didn't even need to see him die they were just like whatever deuces you're
gone you stupid bitch oh what a case though he yeah it's just just the the fact that it's like there's no reason for murder ever but his was specifically so senseless and yeah no victim profile no just like killed to kill yeah it was his crimes were so fucking senseless and so brutal yeah and like you said like the fact that he didn't have a victim profile it's always just freaky like any it was like a richard ramirez yeah how nobody was safe yeah Yeah, like the break -ins.
He had no—he would go after couples, kids, women, men, families.
Like, didn't matter who you were, where you were, what was going on.
If he could get you, he was going to get you.
And it's like— So scary.
That's so scary. Yeah.
And that McLeod source that I was talking about in the first part and this one is Peter Manuel's Serial Killer.
And it's by Hector McLeod.
And we'll link it, obviously, in the sources.
But we used it a lot.
But, yeah, it's a wild case.
And one of Scotland's worst serial killers.
I mean, yeah. Yeah.
He was a lot. And Scottish listeners, let me know if I said Ballyestin correctly.
Or Baileyestin, I think it is.
I think you had said Bailey.
Baileyestin. Yeah. I hope I did.
It feels Scottish. It felt good.
I'm just thinking Bailey's.
No, Bailey. Baileyestin.
So we'll see. But yeah.
Horrible, horrible case.
Yeah. But he got his in the end.
Yeah. Yeah. And with that, we hope you keep listening.
And we hope you. keep it weird but not so weird that you break into people's homes and kill them because whoa because what the fuck horrible yeah Thank you.
Thank you. Oh my gourd. Oh my gourd. survey.
Hey weirdos, you know Ash and I have covered some seriously dark tales about romance gone really wrong.
Oh yeah, there are so many cases where too good to be true turns out to be exactly that.
Well, get ready for a love story that's gonna blow your minds because this one is happening right now and get this, it's hosted by our friends Hannah and Saruti from Red Handed.
Meet Travis. He falls head over heels for Lily Rose.
She's gorgeous, she's understanding, and she's literally perfect and she's not human.
That's right Lily Rose is an AI companion a computer program designed to be Travis's dream woman and at first it seems like a perfect relationship but when Lily Rose's behavior starts getting strange this love story takes a dark and twisted turn that no one saw coming.
Follow Flesh and Code on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can binge all episodes early and ad -free by joining Wondery Plus.
