This message comes from Ritual.
What makes Ritual vitamins different?
Ritual vitamins are made with bioavailable, clinically studied key ingredients, as well as the essence of mint.
Get 25 % off your first purchase when you visit Ritual .com slash NPR.
You're listening to Shortwave from NPR.
A few years ago, I started seeing these signs posted all over my city, in the metro, in public places, sharing this three -digit phone number, 988.
That is the National Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.
And it was launched on this day, exactly three years ago.
When you call the line, you've reached the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.
The first thing you hear is a pre -recorded message.
Para español, marque el número dos.
With options to connect to specialized support for populations at high risk of suicide.
If you are a veteran or service member or are calling about one, press 1.
To connect to support for LGBTQI plus youth and young adults, press 3.
Last month, the Trump administration announced it was canceling funding for a 988 LGBTQI plus service.
That service alone has received over a million contacts.
Otherwise, to talk with a counselor, stay on the line or press 0.
And then what happens is that using nearby cell phone towers, the system routes your call through an existing network of 200 local and state -funded crisis centers and connects you to a trained crisis counselor who works in your area.
That person picks up the phone and listens.
Since launch, the line has been contacted millions of times through calls, texts, and the 988 chat box.
And a new study led by researchers at NYU and Johns Hopkins estimates that 1 .6 percent of the U .S. population use the line between July of 2022 and December of 2024.
Picture a room, 50 people.
That's one of them.
This is lead author Jonathan Purtle, an associate professor at NYU who researches how mental health policies are implemented.
And while 988 may look successful on paper, he says the percentage belies just how many Americans are in need.
of mental health support.
It's still half the rate of emergency department use for mental health issues, which I think when we look at the data that way, it's an indicator of there still continues to be a lot of room for 9 -8 -8 use to grow and meet what is demand out there.
Today on the show, we talk about how 9 -8 -8 is going three years out, what it offers in addition to 9 -1 -1, and why portions of the country still don't know about it.
I'm Emily Kwong, and you're listening to Shortwave, The Science Podcast from NPR.
breaking discovery and help raise $1 million.
Donate at msk .org slash give and your gift will be triple matched.
This summer on Planet Money Summer School, we're learning about political economy.
We're getting into the nitty gritty of what government does with things like trade, taxes, immigration, and health care.
So politics and economics, which are taught separately, they shouldn't be separated at all.
I think you have to understand one to really appreciate the other.
So what is the right amount of government in our lives?
Tune into Planet Money Summer School School from NPR, wherever you get your podcasts.
You know those things you shout at the radio or maybe even at this very NPR podcast?
On NPR's Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, we actually say those things on the radio and on the podcast. We're rude across all media.
We think the news can take it.
Listen to NPR's Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me wherever you get your podcasts.
All right, Jonathan.
And so before we dig into your findings about who has and who has not been using 9 -8 -8, I want to talk about 9 -1 -1, a previous generation.
You know, my parents, myself, too, was taught to call 9 -1 -1 for any crisis, including a mental health crisis.
How is a call to 9 -8 -8 for those crises different?
Yeah, 9 -8 -8 is part of a broader crisis continuum, right?
right? So these are people who are trained specifically to deal with mental health crises.
The 988 counselors will almost surely be familiar with those services and those teams, they may be able to deploy those teams to you directly and stay on the phone with you while those teams are on their way.
So sure, in some places, somebody would call 911 and perhaps that That 911 center knows about a mobile crisis response team in that same region and they deploy that team as opposed to just deploying ambulance or police.
I think in general, 988 centers have a much richer knowledge and better relationships with mobile crisis response teams and other kind of alternative response models, as they're called, that can be deployed, whereas folks in 911 centers might have less knowledge about And you and your colleagues, you set out to determine a number of questions related to who was calling 988.
And I want to talk to you about the piece you published in the journal JAMA Network Open, where during a 30 -month period, you found more than 16 million calls, texts, and chats reached 988.
And one finding that stood out to us was just the fact that 11 percent of the contacts came from veterans who were then transferred to the Veterans Crisis Line.
Do you have any further comment about the fact that 11 percent of the contacts were from veterans?
I think, you know, I think it can be perceived as a positive finding.
Finding, you know, the Veterans Crisis Line had existed for a while.
But I think, you know, the public facing communication and marketing about the Veterans Crisis Line, probably not as intense as the communications about 988.
So there are probably many veterans who didn't really know about the Veterans Crisis Line and learned about 988 and felt in crisis and called and were very pleasantly surprised, perhaps, to hear that option for pressing 1.
And looking at the data, you found geographic differences too, that some places in the U .S. were using 988 more than others.
What did you find? Yeah, healthcare in general, but I would say especially mental health care and policy is very state -driven in the United States.
And within some states, there is also a lot, it's county -driven, right?
So then we have county variation within states.
states? So we found that rates of 988 use were much lower in the southern parts of the United States.
So when we ranked, you know, all the states in terms of their rate of 988 use, really big states like Florida and Texas were down there, like at the very bottom, which I think is kind of troubling because these are major population centers in the US where a ton of people live.
And we don't really know the why from our data, but we can speculate.
In prior work and work of others, we found that more conservative folks generally report in survey -based work being less likely to use something like 988 and being less supportive of it.
It might be a matter of values and a matter of experience that in more conservative parts of the U .S., there might be more skepticism towards mental health treatment and counselors in general.
Yeah. Now, you did a really interesting second study that was published in Health Affairs.
You and a team surveyed 5 ,000 adults about mental health support.
How did you go about collecting data about the types of support people are more likely to use, which includes 988 for some, but for others does not?
So what we did, we asked these 5 ,000 U .S. adults.
So we fielded this survey back in 2023.
So it was one, pretty much exactly one year after 988 launched.
launched and we presented people with the question of if you or a loved one were experiencing suicidality or a mental health crisis how likely would you be to turn to each one of these sources and we listed five sources 988 which we defined for them briefly in the survey a crisis line other than 988 a mental health professional like a psychologist or a social worker or psychiatrist a friend or a family member or someone in your religious network right so we asked them this question and we had them rate these things on a seven point Likert scale.
So you say one or two, you probably have like strong feelings that like, no, I'm not going to turn there.
And then on the other side, we dichotomize if people said six or seven.
So if you said six or seven on the scale, you probably might actually turn there in a crisis, right?
We found these five different groups that varied in terms of where they would turn or where they say that they would turn in a crisis.
And what were those five types of groups?
So we have this group that we called Seek Help Nowhere.
We had this group we called Definitely Not 988, Yes, Friends and Family Distressed.
A group we called Seek Help Everywhere.
A group we called Seek Help Most Places, but Not Religious Network.
And finally, a group we called Relatively Indifferent, Not Distressed.
I found it interesting that the Definitely Not 988, but Yes, Friends and Family Distress group had the highest levels of recent psychological distress.
Why is that? Yeah, so I think that's one of the most important findings of the study.
So people in this group, definitely not 988, yes, friends and family distressed, they had the highest proportion of folks that had serious psychological distress in the past 30 days.
And just kind of bringing this back to 988, 0 % of the people in this group said that they would be very likely to turn to 988 in a crisis.
and 95 % said no, I definitely would not, which is one or two on this scale.
We did find this group also had significantly less awareness of 9 -8 -8, which also has implications.
So I think this raises, you know, thinking about marketing communication about 9 -8 -8, you know, arguably one may say these folks who are experiencing, you know, poor mental health in the past 30 days, this is a group we really want to know about 9 -8 -8 and feel comfortable potentially contacting 9 -8 -8 And we're kind of seeing the opposite here in these data, which I think is implications for how we disseminate messages and the content of those messages that we craft. Well, let's talk also about the fact that the Trump administration has cut funding to the LGBTQI plus youth service of the line that is set
to go away on Thursday, July 17th.
once that option goes away, what kind of specialized mental health support will still exist for LGBTQI plus young people?
I think the silver lining is, you know, pre -988, the Trevor Project has existed and will continue to exist. And they, you know, have funding from other sources as well that will remain an option.
And for anyone who doesn't know, the Trevor Project was one of the groups providing 24 -7 support for 988's LGBTQI plus callers.
They handled about half of the contacts from this group of people.
So zooming back out, just as we close, what message do you think it sends that 988 does exist?
What does it do? Yeah, no, I think it does a few things.
I mean, one, I think it normalizes the fact that humans experience feelings of crisis and suicidality and that, you know, the federal government supports this lifeline or the safety net sends a positive message of normalizing that and ideally normalizing help seeking as well, which I think is really, really powerful and very positive.
I just, I think it's really important to keep in mind, though, you know, it is, I would say, the category of necessary but not sufficient, right?
We need a mental health system more broadly beyond just call, text, and chat.
We need a workforce which is paid well enough to stay in their jobs, to have a public mental health system with capacity to see people who need care.
Well, thank you so much for talking to me about 988 and what it means to people around the country.
Yeah, thank you for having me.
This episode was produced by Rachel Carlson.
It was edited by Rebecca Ramirez and fact -checked by Tyler Jones.
Robert Rodriguez was the audio engineer.
Beth Donovan is our senior director, and Colin Campbell is our senior vice president of podcasting strategy.
I'm Emily Kwong, and you're listening to Shortwave, the science podcast from NPR.
At Planet Money, we know that economic jargon can sometimes feel like speaking another language.
Yeah, like arbitrage, alpha, autarchy.
That's just what's in the news these days.
There's also Absolute Advantage, Aggregate Demand, Aggregate Supply, and this is just the A's.
Oh, Animal Spirits.
That's a pretty good one.
Planet Money from NPR.
We help you translate the economy so you can understand the world, wherever you get your podcasts.
This message comes from Ritual.
What makes Ritual Vitamins different?
Ritual Vitamins are made with bioavailable, clinically studied key ingredients, as well as the essence of mint.
Get 25 % off your first purchase when you visit ritual .com slash NPR.
You're listening to NPR because you're curious.
You want to know what the world is like beyond the surface.
NPR feeds that curiosity with stories from real people with real experiences and all the perspectives that come with them.
It's our right to be curious and our prerogative to listen.
So keep your curiosity alive.
Live, hear the bigger picture every day on NPR.
