When I experience art, I can almost immediately determine whether or not I think it's good.
If I'm looking at a painting or a sculpture, or I'm watching a fashion show, or I'm watching a movie, or I'm listening to a song, I can almost immediately... decide whether or not I think it's good.
But I rarely ask myself why it's good. And recently, I decided to do that.
I decided to figure out What makes art good?
What's complicated about art is that It is subjective and everybody connects to art differently. good art to one person is bad art to the next person.
But I do think that there is, is an answer to the question, what is good art?
So that's what we're going to discuss today.
And listen, a conversation about art can very quickly turn pretentious and cringe, but I am going to do everything in my power today to make this not pretentious and cringe and you know what?
We'll see. We'll see. this episode is brought to you by Squarespace have you ever been shopping online and the website just Gave you the ick.
Let me tell you, that wouldn't happen if they used Squarespace.
Squarespace design intelligence empowers anyone to build beautiful, more personalized websites tailored to your unique needs.
And with Squarespace Payments, it's super easy to manage payments with just a few clicks plus With Squarespace's integrated and optimized SEO tools, there's all the help you need to get people to your site.
Head to squarespace.com slash Emma for a free trial and use code Emma to save 10% on your first purchase.
This is an ad by BetterHelp. The internet is a big place and the info you find isn't always the most accurate.
Every time I look up wellness or mental health tips, I met with so much information.
I don't even know how to sort through it.
And not all the information you're going to find online is from people who really know what they're talking about.
There's so much advice online, it can be overwhelming.
And knowing what works for you isn't easy.
That's why it's important to use trusted sources, or even better, talk to a living, breathing person who can help. like a therapist.
They're trained to help you gain confidence, improve relationships, to share positive coping skills tailored to you specifically.
Getting into therapy is less complicated than you think.
BetterHelp makes it easy to connect with a As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise.
Talk it out with BetterHelp. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com. slash anything.
That's better H-E-L-P dot com slash anything.
This episode is brought to you by eBay. We all have that piece, that one that's so you.
You've basically become known for it. And if you don't yet, you'll find it on eBay. that Miu Miu off the runway red leather bomber, the Cusco Barcelona cowboy top, Or that fleece in the 2017 colorway?
All of these finds are on eBay, along with millions more main character pieces. backed by authenticity guarantee. eBay is the place for pre-loved in vintage fashion. eBay. things people love.
Step one on my journey to answer the question, what makes art good involved digging into the archives of my mind and analyzing all of my favorite pieces of art and trying to figure out what I like about it.
And what I discovered was actually really fucking obvious.
Good art is honest. When an artist is being honest in their creation, you can feel that the peace was based on their life. and the way that they see the world. it's clear that they're pulling influence from their truth, their feelings, their beliefs, their point of view. it feels like you almost can feel the artist through the piece, you know?
It's so... special and unique and weirdly personal that the only way it could have been created was through honesty and when an artist is able to demonstrate honesty accurately and The person interpreting it is able to find a distinct emotion or feeling in within themselves when looking at the piece.
The two key ingredients to good art, number one, honesty, and number two, a connection with the viewer or the listener, the experiencer.
And those two things go hand in hand because I think honest art tends to evoke emotion in the person experiencing it.
Some examples of how art can be honest would be a painting. that kind of has a warped... weird look to it.
Like it looks like the real world, but it looks a little warped.
An example would be the famous painting, The Scream or whatever it's called.
It's like a warped version of reality. That portrays... the artist's point of view, how they see the world is warped.
Do you know what I'm saying? Maybe it demonstrates how they see the world when they're anxious.
Or maybe it demonstrates how they see the world when they're angry.
That's a great example of honest art or maybe a painting of a gloomy beach. the way that the painting was composed feels sort of mysterious and gloomy and dark and maybe a little bit unsettling.
The way that the artist composed the piece reflects that. reality in a way that feels incredibly accurate, as though you're like looking through their eyes.
And some examples of how art can connect with you.
Let's say you watch a movie and the way that it was shot in the way that it was color graded, in the story line just makes you feel nostalgic something about it makes you feel nostalgic and you connect to the movie.
Or maybe you're watching a fashion show and you see a creepy long black dress and it makes you feel weird inside you feel kind of uneasy you feel kind of some dark energy looming around Or maybe you hear a really vulnerable song about love and it makes you feel lonely.
Or, you know, it makes you feel a longing for love or it can spark intense love. gratitude for your significant other.
But I think good art is rooted in honesty.
When the artist wants to tell a story or...
Demonstrate an emotion that they experience or share something that is meaningful to them.
That is felt. I don't think art can evoke emotion. if it's not rooted in honesty, like I, I just don't think that it can because honestly, What allows the viewer... to connect is this piece of humanity in the art.
Like there needs to be humanity to connect to.
So that was my cringe explanation of... of what I personally think makes art good but I didn't want to stop there because I don't know anything.
So step two of my journey is to answer the question, what makes art good, was to obviously Google what makes art good.
And let's discuss what I found. So online, I found many results.
The use of colors which complement each other enhance art and make it more beautiful and inviting.
I do think this is true. I mean, obviously, color can be very powerful in evoking emotion.
And obviously, that, in my opinion, is key in good art.
Its ability to evoke emotion in some people.
And I think it's absolutely true. If you were to take a painting that was in full color, bright colors, and you were to redo it in black and white, it would absolutely have a different feeling to it.
So I think an artist's ability to utilize color to tell their story better, is incredibly important obviously this doesn't apply to music because that is only with the ears, but with pretty much all other forms of art, this applies.
Like even with a movie, the way that the movie is color graded makes such a big difference. it makes such a big difference.
If a movie's kind of scary, they might color grade the movie to be sort of cold and dreary and dark and that completely changes the overall tone and feeling of the movie.
So yes, I mean, I agree. I do think, the use of colors is incredibly important.
The next thing I found online, Repeating patterns, symmetry, and composition done well make art good.
There's definitely value in creativity involved in how you create things. the experience of your art piece, whether it's music and the way you compose a song or it's, an elaborate gown in how symmetrical you make it or It's a painting, how you compose the painting. where you put a tree, where you put a bush.
I mean, all of these things definitely do impact the experience in a big way.
But the thing is, I wouldn't say there's an exact... definition of what a good pattern is.
I struggle with this answer. Because there are art pieces that have an incredibly weird pattern. involved.
There are art pieces that are not symmetrical whatsoever.
And composition is a part of every art piece.
Like every art piece is composed in some way and, and whether or not it's good is kind of based on the beholder who's experiencing it.
So I don't know, like, This answer didn't really click for me, and maybe it's because I'm very dumb.
I don't know. But... I will say, in a good art piece, the composition is good.
In a good art piece, there might be symmetry.
There might be patterns. I don't know, but it just like...
I feel like saying all good art has patterns, symmetry and good composition. it's just not giving a lot.
It's not giving a lot of information. And it's also sort of putting things in a box because there are incredible art pieces that go a completely different direction and ignore symmetry and don't have a pattern involved and are composed unusually.
You know what I'm saying? Okay, whatever.
This episode is brought to you by Cozy. Getting your home to not just look right, but also feel right is so important.
I think what I love most about my home is how there are so many little details around the house that bring me so much joy.
One place that I hang out a lot is my couch.
I take naps on there. I get a bunch of work done on there.
When I'm shopping for a piece of furniture or home furnishing I'm looking for something that's comfortable but also Fun to look at.
That's why you've got to love Cozy. Their furniture is modern, practical, and designed to make your day-to-day feel a little more...
Well, cozy. They're modular and customizable, so if you wake up one day with the urge for a new look, Cozy makes it so easy.
Easily switch up the layout, switch up the style, switch up the color.
With cozy sofas, you don't just get a new nap spot, but the freedom to change your mind.
Transform your living space today with Cozy.
Visit cozy.com. That's C-O-Z-E-Y dot com.
The home of possibilities made easy. This episode is brought to you by Welch's Fusions, the newest drop from Welch's Fruit Snacks.
Isn't it so satisfying when you combine two of your favorite things to make something even better?
It's like when I'm putting an outfit together and I pair two of my favorite pieces together. that I've never put together before.
Like it just never crossed my mind. If you love a good pairing like I do, New Welch's Fusions are so good.
Each one is a combination of two fruity flavors and one juicy bite.
One flavor on the outside, another on the inside.
It's an unbelievable taste sensation. So I recommend them for experienced taste buds only.
You've been warned. New Welch's Fusions.
Please fuse responsibly. Next, I found online The ability and technical skills of the artist to create a sense of beauty or meaning. make good art.
I do think this is true. I mean you have to have some skills mastered in order to create art.
A certain level of experience is needed to get to a place where you can truly Get creative.
Like I'll use an example. Cooking. Because actually cooking in food can be art too.
I haven't mentioned that yet, but absolutely.
With cooking, you can't go off recipe and just start making shit If you've never cooked before, you have to have a basic level of understanding.
Before you can go in and start creating your own recipes.
You start out. by making recipes. Like when you first start cooking, you directly copy recipes from people who know how to create recipes. who are experienced chefs or home cooks who have experimented a lot in the kitchen and are really comfortable with all of the different ingredients and all the different methods of cooking, et cetera.
And they're able to be creative because they have such a deep understanding of all of the different methods and ingredients, etc.
I think this applies to all art forms. When you first start, you're just trying to figure out how to do it.
And so you're copying things that already exist.
You're trying to figure out how to play your favorite song on the guitar.
You're trying to paint a painting that looks like Van Gogh.
You're trying to sew your favorite skirt. you're just trying to get familiar with the skills that you need to one day be be able to sort of go off recipe.
You know what I'm saying? take the training wheels off and actually do something that's uniquely you.
But you kind of can't do that in the beginning.
So I do think it's true that you need a level of technical skills in order to make good art because that leads us to our next. point that I found online that good art is original.
I would say majority of art starts from inspiration from other pieces of art, but it becomes something brand new in the hands of a really great artist. it becomes unrecognizable to the inspiration, like you wouldn't ever look at the original inspiration.
And then the final piece is, and say, oh, those things are very similar.
A good artist takes inspiration and then makes it their own.
And the truth is you can't really do that until you have technical experience.
But having a solid toolbox filled with knowledge and experience and skills and understanding. is useful because it allows you to do your own thing and think outside the box.
But that's all I'm saying because I think a lot of people get it all wrong and think you need to have technical skills in order to create an art piece that's perfect.
And that is not the point. A lot of people confuse perfection for good art.
For example, an incredibly accurate painting or sculpture. or a song with a lot of auto-tunes so the voice sounds perfect.
And every single strum of the guitar is perfect.
And every single drum hit is perfect. And it's, you know...
A lot of people confuse perfection for good art.
I know for a fact that that's not how it works because what's interesting is for me personally, When something is too perfect, I don't connect with it.
Like when I hear a song on the radio and it's just...
So clean. It's so clean. The voice sounds so clean The whole song is perfect to the millisecond when it comes to timing of everything. a lot of times I can't connect with it because it just sounds like white noise to me.
It's like, It's so perfect and clean that...
There's no humanity left in it. It just feels robotic and empty.
And the same thing goes for Paintings like I find it incredibly impressive. when an artist is able to perfectly recreate reality in a painting by painting almost as though they're printing a photograph.
You know what I'm saying? When the painting looks... like a photograph.
Like it's so fucking perfect. That is insane.
I mean, it's amazing when an artist can do that.
But I don't really connect with that a lot of times because when it's too perfect, it can just feel like an image and if the image that they're basing their painting off of doesn't evoke emotion, then the painting won't either.
So I'm not saying that artists who paint reality very accurately... lack personality or lack depth or a story to doubt, but at times it can sort of feel too perfect.
What I'm saying is just because art was technically done well, from a technical standpoint, doesn't mean it's actually good.
And I think that's a huge misconception.
And I also think that that's something that deters people from wanting to create art in some way They feel like they have to create art in a way that's super technically well done.
They feel like they need to be an expert. in how to create things, but that's not really the point.
Yes, you need to have a certain level of knowledge and experience and skills in order to do your own thing.
But that, level of knowledge, experience and skills that you need is much less than you would imagine.
Like you really don't need that much experience before you can go off and start doing your own thing.
But I think people... become obsessed with the idea of creating art that's perfect.
And I think that that's missing the point.
The next thing I found online is that good art has a distinct theme.
I agree, and I think that this is something, I keep saying I agree.
Yeah, I agree with smarter, people who are smarter than me who wrote articles about this on the internet, obviously I agree.
Actually, I did disagree with one. I definitely think a distinct theme...
It's almost always present, if not always present in good art.
That's what people connect with is that theme.
But I do think... The theme doesn't always have to be meticulously detailed. created.
I think when an artist leads with honesty, and they're just trying to tell the truth in some way, a theme sort of comes out naturally at times.
It doesn't always need to be this deliberate choice.
Like, okay, this is the theme, and I'm going to keep this theme in mind when I'm making this art piece.
Sometimes the theme... develops on its own during the process.
I think the natural development of a theme is only possible when you're truly creating art in an honest way.
If you're not creating art in an honest way, I think the theme can sometimes get lost.
Now obviously you can sort of make a deliberate choice to stick to a theme But even then, I think it can be hard to accurately portray that theme unless it does mean something to you as the artist.
And sometimes the theme is the artist. I feel like Van Gogh is such a good example.
Like, everything Van Gogh painted was...
So him, he painted various different things.
He did portraits. He did. landscapes. He did Close-up flowers he did, whatever.
And when I look at his art, I feel like the theme of his art is him.
It's the way he sees things. Or it's the way he wants to see the world.
Who knows? I haven't read the book about him.
Listen, I don't know every detail about Van Gogh, okay?
Even though he's like the most famous artist in the world, I don't know everything about Van Gogh, okay?
But I feel the theme of his art was just simply him in a way.
The next thing I read online was about how good art requires effort.
Effort must be put in for an art piece to be good.
I think if we're looking at the word effort by definition, then I agree with this.
Effort by definition is a determined attempt which I think is needed for good art, because I think a certain level of determination is necessary to think outside of the box and create something that evokes a feeling.
So yes, I think that's true, but My problem with the word effort is I associate effort with time and that might be my own flaw. my own misunderstanding of the definition of effort.
Like my own personal definition of effort is, false.
But I do associate effort with time. And the thing is good art can take an hour or it can take 25 years.
It doesn't really matter. With art, time doesn't mean effort.
And I'd even go as far as to say that Sometimes the best art is created casually and in a way that's almost... therapeutic or relaxed.
Like, I don't know. I think sometimes good art can be created on accident where the artist feels that they didn't even put any effort in.
And they just on accident, through casual playing around, made something that works.
You know what I mean? So I do think yes.
Good art requires a level of effort, but also bad art can take a fuck ton of effort.
So I don't know, like taking a shit in the morning takes effort.
It's like, yeah, everything takes effort.
I don't know. Not sure about that one. This episode is brought to you by State Farm.
Insurance may all seem the same on the surface, But having insurance isn't the same as having State Farm.
It's like ordering an iced matcha but getting fake gourmet grass water.
You wouldn't settle for a lawn latte, so don't settle for just any insurance.
When it comes to getting the help you need, State Farm is the real deal.
Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
This episode is brought to you by IKEA. Classes check.
Textbooks check. Backpack packed. A dream study space doesn't have to break the bank.
With IKEA's College Essentials, it's easy to create a space that sets students up for success.
They've got affordable solutions and designs that help students customize their space the way they want it.
No time to shop in store? Choose pickup from thousands of locations or...
Find affordable delivery options that take the stress out of getting set up for college.
Check every box on your checklist while starting the year in style.
Shop now at ikea-usa.com slash ready for college.
The next thing I found online. Actually, the last thing I found online, art made when the artist felt that they had an eternity of time to create it. is good art.
This was incredibly profound and so true.
I would argue it's almost impossible to make good art when you have a deadline.
Nothing kills the creative spirit like a deadline.
I can't stress this enough. It's impossible.
When you feel like You can create things on your own time.
You create so much more freely. Pressure is the enemy to creativity.
So I think it's very true. Art that is not rushed is good art.
So I think we have a good understanding at this point.
And I think that we've answered the question.
What makes art good? I think we're there.
I mean, I feel really... I feel like we've really... fleshed it out.
I feel like we really accomplished a lot and that's something to be excited about.
But I find it interesting how often bad art can get mistaken for good art.
Now again, art is subjective, so what I think is bad might be incredible and good to somebody else.
But I would argue, There is also a definition to what bad art is, similar to how there is a definition to what good art is.
It's a vague definition. Bad art is unoriginal, lacks a theme, and isn't honest.
That's bad art. I went to an art show. probably two years ago now.
I think I've talked about this art show before because it literally traumatized me.
I went to this art show a few years ago and It was the most prestigious art show I'd ever been to.
All the art in there was like millions of dollars, okay?
I've never been to an art show or an art gallery with paintings over $3,000 ever before.
Obviously, I had been to museums where there were priceless pieces, but I had never been to an art show or gallery where things are for sale, where the pieces were above $3,000, okay?
And I get invited to go to this art show where the pieces are, up to millions of dollars.
I mean, I expected to see the best art I've ever seen for that price tag.
A bunch of celebrities are there. It's a whole scene.
I was like, whoa. I feel like this is going to be really cool.
I'm definitely not going home with any pieces.
But that's for sure. But yeah, like this will be cool.
I was... shocked at how unoriginal and dishonest a lot of the art was.
Now don't get me wrong, there were some cool pieces in there. for sure, that actually did feel honest.
You know, I didn't really see anything in the whole entire show that I thought was good, but I could still look at certain pieces and say, that feels honest.
It doesn't really connect with me, but that does feel honest.
But majority of them were dishonest and unoriginal.
Unoriginal. Yet I was seeing people walking around being like, oh, yes.
Now this one is really, wow. It's like a one shot. big red dot on a plain white canvas vibe.
Okay. It's like that vibe, right? One plain red dot, like somebody just literally like put one dot on a canvas and said done.
And everyone's like, wow, this reminds me of...
Well, this reminds me of the first time I got my period.
I just had one little drop of blood in my undies.
And this is evoking that memory for me. wow, I'm feeling this out.
It's like shut the fuck up. I could not handle it.
I actually got really mad about this event.
I talked about it for at least, well, I'm still fucking talking about it.
I'm not over it, obviously. I was watching all of these people talk about art and pretend that they thought it was good.
But I knew that they knew it wasn't good. or maybe they were convincing themselves it was good.
The whole thing was just mind boggling to me.
And, it really made me realize that bad art can easily be mistaken for good art.
And let's discuss why. Number one, a big price tag.
This event, that I went to this art show was incredibly prestigious.
A lot of the art pieces were millions of dollars and people were going into that event with an expectation.
They were like, For millions of dollars, we're only going to be seeing good art pieces.
That's obvious. But I don't care about money, okay?
I don't care how expensive something is.
If it's good, it's good. And if it's bad, it's bad.
There are art pieces that are priceless. millions of dollars that are incredible and there's a reason why they're priceless.
There are art pieces that are $50 on Etsy that are incredible.
There are pieces for a thousand dollars at a local art gallery that are fucking amazing, you know?
There are also art pieces on Etsy that aren't very good and art pieces at Local galleries that are like a thousand dollars that aren't very good.
It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter how much it costs.
If it evokes a feeling and it's honest, it's good, period, end of story.
And I know this But I also understand how easy it can be to... see a big price tag and assume that that means it's good.
I mean, I'd even compare this to clothing.
So if you were to look at fashion designers, the big names, right?
Like the big name, fashion designers i'm talking about the gucci the Louis Vuitton, the Prada, you know what I'm saying?
Just because they're products are expensive doesn't mean that they're good.
I mean, don't get me wrong. These brands create incredible sales beautiful pieces of clothing sometimes, but not all the time. price tag has nothing to do with whether or not art is good.
But I think, a big price tag can create an illusion and sort of sell a lie in a way.
And I think That's probably one of the most challenging things to figure out when You're trying to determine whether or not art is good if you're looking at the price tag.
It can really alter the way you perceive the art. it can kind of gaslight you into thinking that the art is good.
And yeah, It's a shame because there is some incredible art out there isn't millions of dollars because the person creating it isn't famous.
And that's it. And that's it. That's the only difference.
You know what I'm saying? Reason number two that bad art gets mistaken for good art The art is technically brilliant, but it's empty.
I referred to this earlier, you know, a perfectly auto-tuned song that Hits every note perfectly.
It's like the most meticulous song of all time.
But the lyrics... are empty but it sounds so perfect But it's empty.
A painting is so accurate that it looks like a photograph.
That's technically very impressive and very cool, but just because it's impressive doesn't and technically well done, it doesn't make it good.
It doesn't make it emotional. It doesn't make it honest.
But again. technical perfection can trick you into thinking that it's good.
And again, that's not how that works. And last but not least, number three.
Why bad art gets mistaken for good art. A convincing artist.
Okay, this is a little... Ooh, this is where I start stirring up some drama, okay? sometimes the artist themselves can convince you that their art is good.
I've again seen this at art shows and art galleries, you know, People go up to an artist and say, now, what is this?
What does this painting mean? And the artist just starts spewing pretentious bullshit out of their ass about like, Well, like just and you can just tell that it's a lie.
Or maybe they look a certain way on Instagram.
They act like this tortured artist online.
And when you see them, you're like, There's no way that they're not creating good art because they're so tortured.
But again, that's all a lie. Sometimes the personality of the artist can convince you that their art is good.
And that's kind of dark. I think artists that have to pretentiously over-explain and sort of belittle others in order to convince them that their art is good. are not real artists.
The act of Pretending to be an artist involves... taking the person who's experiencing your art and making them feel like they don't understand because there's something wrong with them or something.
That's not good. Good art speaks to the person who it needs to speak to and no words ever need to be spoken about it.
Some artists are, are not artists. at all.
They're con artists in a way. They're stealing other people's ideas.
They're playing this sort of con game just trying to become famous and successful and rich by belittling people who are giving their art a chance and maybe don't get it because there isn't really anything there Being like, if you don't get it, it's because you're not smart enough, you know, or convincing everyone that they're like this intellectual person.
I don't know. I don't know. A convincing artist can be a con artist and that's fucking spooky. like gaslighting vulnerable people who maybe don't have a developed taste in art and being like, no, this is good and here's why, but you just don't understand yet because You're not evolved enough, see?
See, like that's evil to me. Okay, whatever.
Well that's all I have for today. I hope that you enjoyed hanging out with me and if you have anything to add, to this conversation.
You can tweet me at AG podcast or send me a message on Instagram at anything goes.
You can. Follow me on Instagram at Emma Chamberlain to keep up with my personal life.
You can check out my coffee company. chamberlaincoffee.com at chamberlaincoffee on Instagram.
Use code AG15 for a little discount. Okay?
New episodes of Anything Goes every Thursday and Sunday, so come and hang out.
If you want, twice a week we get to hang out.
What a pleasure. I just appreciate all of you spending your time with me today.
It is... Truly, my honor. I love you all and I'll talk to you soon.
Bye-bye.
