That's the hardest part.
I can't help him.
I'm a mother.
I fix stuff.
A skinny, hurt feeling.
I cannot fix this.
I can't bring him back.
It was devastating when they found him.
The single dad, so passionate about helping others.
So dedicated to his bright young daughter, Sienna.
They were two peas in a pod.
She loved being with her dad.
She just was every single thing to him.
Every single thing.
For police, a puzzle.
It was such an unusual murder with a victim who seemed to have no enemies.
Then, the chilling on-camera clue.
There's a figure.
You see someone wearing a hoodie come out from the dark.
You're looking at the killer, you believe?
Yes.
You get the goosebumps.
You get the hairs on the back of your neck.
A father dead in the garage.
Who was behind it?
I'm thinking, what?
It's mind blowing.
Lies, delusion, betrayal.
You just don't want to believe that people can be that evil.
I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.
Here's Dennis Murphy with The Figure in the Garage.
Look closely, top left of the screen.
A hooded figure walks away from the camera.
Who is it?
What are they doing?
Why are they there?
Minutes later, a truck pulls in.
A different person walks out.
His name we know, Don Fluitt.
It appears that his trash can was tipped over.
He pulls it back up.
You look at him and he's fine and he's happy and healthy and picking up his trash can.
And then the garage closes.
That's the end of Don Fluitt's life, basically.
Yeah.
The neighbor's security camera captured these images and left a mystery.
That was one of those moments where you kind of get the chills and think I think we know when it happened.
Now we just got to figure out who and why.
There was just nobody that I could think of that would want to hurt him.
Albuquerque, New Mexico.
Thousands of people come here every fall to watch the colorful hot air balloons sail through the desert sky.
For others, it's just a pit stop as they continue their trek onto Santa Fe.
But for some, it's a place for new beginnings.
Would you just throw a dart at the map and it's Albuquerque?
Yeah, pretty much.
This is Dennis Fluitt, Don's younger brother, less than a year apart in age.
Born and raised in California, they grew up close, the two of them and two sisters.
We had to rely on each other, you know what I mean?
When my parents divorced, it was just my mom, so there was a lot of home time alone.
Like most siblings, the brothers were competitive.
Mom Sharon.
They had to outdo each other constantly.
What one did, the next one did.
The brothers' fluid led a hard-partying lifestyle until Dennis headed east at age 20.
Dennis matured, thought his brother could do the same.
He urged Don to join him in New Mexico.
He was on a dead-end trail.
You know, he wasn't doing anything good or productive, so I called him.
Convinced him to come out here.
Did you see your brother change?
Oh, yeah.
You know, I mean, he saw complete change.
Don turned his life around.
At 26, he got married, had two kids, but the marriage didn't last.
His kids moved to Oklahoma with their mom, but daughter Tiffany says Don never stopped being a loving father.
So he really had to go out of his way to keep you two in his life, too.
That's what he did.
Albuquerque's a far piece away.
It is.
He always made the drive, though.
When Don was in his late 30s, he decided to pursue a childhood dream, to become a firefighter.
Dennis joked with him, told him he was too old, but that didn't stop Don.
Was it the adrenaline, you think, running hot when it's all going down?
Maybe.
I just think that he cared for people and he wanted to do his part to save as many lives as he could.
And soon, Don met Dennis' neighbor, a woman named Christine.
She made him happy.
She was kind of quirky and silly like he was, so I think they got along real well.
And she was like literally the girl next door.
Yes, literally.
It wasn't long before Don and Christine married.
And just a little over a year later, they had a baby girl together.
They named her Sienna.
Don Sanjosh says Sienna seemed to complete Don's life.
He was above the world, knowing that we were so far away that at least he can have his own child right there with him every step of the way, every second of the day.
As you can see in this home video that Christine took, the couple doted on their little girl.
You can do it.
Keep pushing, keep pushing.
She loved him.
They were always doing goofy things.
They were two peas in a pod.
Life was great until Don, after eight years as a firefighter, lost his job.
According to a close friend Christine, who worked as an x-ray tech, had to shoulder most of the bills.
Financial strain proved to be too much.
When Sienna was only four years old, Christine filed for divorce.
The couple shared custody of Sienna.
Don made sure his life still revolved around his little girl.
He wanted to make the best life possible for Sienna and be the best man he possibly could.
This is Amber, Dennis' daughter and Don's niece.
She says Don taught Sienna to help others, as he always tried to do.
They would go to church every Sunday and they would have spaghetti on Sundays.
And one day they just made too much spaghetti.
They decided to find somebody and give them dinner.
They started calling it Spaghetti Sunday.
Don and Sienna would hit the streets of Albuquerque and feed the homeless.
She's not dragging her feet with all of this, or, oh, no, we've got to do this again.
Oh, no, not at all.
I think they were in cahoots.
From Spaghetti Sundays to silly homemade music videos.
He wouldn't do anything unless he can do it with her.
Just a few weeks before Christmas 2016, Don's oldest sister died of cancer.
His mother, Sharon, was devastated.
Don and Sienna, then 11 years old, took a road trip to California to spend Christmas with her.
And when the festivities were over... I didn't want him to go.
Don, who was now working at an agency that served the developmentally disabled, told his mom he had a meeting he could not miss.
So I went outside with him, hugged and kissed, and got everything in the car.
After an 11-hour drive, they arrived home in Albuquerque, where Sienna found a new bicycle under the Christmas tree.
But before she could write it, Dawn needed to drop her off with her mom, Christine.
The next day, Sienna, who spoke to her dad every day, didn't hear from him.
She called her dad's co-worker, Valerie Torres.
She says, I can't get a hold of my dad.
And I said, you know, honey, I said, let me try your dad.
I said, don't worry, he's fine.
Valerie called, texted, no answer.
She and a co-worker went to Dawn's home.
When I knocked on the door, the door gave a little bit.
So the front door wasn't locked?
No.
And I was able to walk in the house.
Valerie called out Don's name.
No response.
So I told my friend the only way we're going to know whether he's here or not is if his truck's here.
So I opened the garage door.
And when I opened the garage door, I found my friend.
When we come back, what had happened in that garage?
A clue from the neighbor.
And another from his ex-wife.
Had someone been in Don Fluitt's house?
He said, it's weird.
Someone used a pan in my house.
It was December 29th, 2016.
Even as the Rio Grande, the great but gentle river, ran through this bedroom community north of downtown Albuquerque, Valerie Torres made a grisly discovery inside Don Fluitt's garage.
Her friend called 911.
Don had been bludgeoned.
His throat slit and stabbed.
I absolutely knew he was gone.
I knew that there was nothing that I could do to help him.
Then she thought about Sienna, who was at her mother's house.
And I just remember my heart breaking, like literally.
I've never felt my heart hurt like that.
Where is he?
Within minutes, an officer from the Albuquerque PD arrived on scene.
Valerie and her friend were still in tears.
His body camera rolled as he walked past Sienna's new bicycle, still next to the Christmas tree.
Then into the garage, where Don's body lay.
As night fell, the yellow tape went up.
Albuquerque Police Detective Matthew Kaplan led the investigation.
Everything was in pristine order.
The only thing out of order was Don Floyd in the garage.
So the house hadn't been tossed?
Not at all.
There was no sign of forced entry.
Don's cell phone was on the couch, his wallet on the kitchen counter.
Police located all the kitchen knives and sent them off to the crime lab.
They also gathered other forensic evidence, including Don's fingernail clippings.
There was immediate blood in the vicinity, on the walls underneath him, on the truck that looked like handprints.
But the detective thought it didn't seem like enough blood, given the injuries Don had sustained.
And that's when we noticed an empty bottle of bleach on the washer and dryer and towels that smelled of bleach in the washer.
So they've been some effort to clean up.
That's what it appeared, yes.
His team did a test with a substance like luminol.
The kitchen sink lit up with traces of blood.
So it looked like either hands or the murder weapon was washed off in the sink.
The floor also lit up.
Same with the door.
Kaplan and his team had already started going door to door and met Dawn's next door neighbor.
She tells us she has two cameras in her house.
So that's interesting.
Yes, there's one which happens to catch a portion of Don Fluitt's garage.
And she told them she'd been home the night before.
When?
She hears the garage come up.
She happens to look at her camera and she sees Don Fluitt's truck backing out and leaving.
The time, 7.37 PM.
Kaplan had the first data point for a timeline.
He gathered more when he talked to Don's ex-wife Christine at her home.
Christine confirmed.
He dropped Sienna off with her at 745 pm and she remembered something Don told her that afternoon.
He thought someone had been in his house while he was away.
He said, it's weird, there's like cat hair in my dryer, and someone used a pan in my house.
Christine also told the detective that Don sometimes suffered road rage.
Yes, he'd had many heated exchanges as a driver before.
So maybe an angry motorist followed Don home after an argument.
Or maybe it was someone he knew, someone with access to the house.
Kaplan spoke to Don's landlord, Benny Ruiz, who'd shown up at the scene.
He told Kaplan that Don was a kind-hearted man and wondered if his murder had anything to do with his work with homeless people.
He opens himself to everybody.
You know, he opens his home.
Don's mom, Sharon, out in California, got a call in the middle of the night.
Detective Kaplan was on the line.
And he said, ma'am, I'm sorry your son is dead.
And I think I started screaming.
Just 19 days before, she'd lost her eldest daughter to cancer.
19 years before that, her youngest daughter had also died.
And now, Don.
And I had to call Dennis to tell him, now you're an only child.
I couldn't get my head around it.
It didn't seem real.
Dennis called Amber to let her know about her Uncle Don.
I just started screaming, no.
No.
Over and over again.
My dad was obviously a mess.
And the news soon made its way to Oklahoma, where Don's older children lived.
I was just like, no, this isn't real.
This stuff don't happen.
You just see this stuff on TV.
It was horrible.
This is an intimate murder.
This is a hands-on murder.
Yeah, yeah, very personal.
It was up close and personal.
Very violent and personal.
So who would put a target on your brother, of all people, Mr. Sunday Night Spaghetti?
My first thought was Terry.
I even told the detective that.
Terry White, Christine's husband, Sienna's stepfather.
Don told me a lot about him.
You know, I knew that there had been some altercations in the past.
Detective Kaplan went to see Terry the next day.
Terry, a truck driver, was back from his shift and at home with Sienna and Christine.
Sienna and Christine left the room.
Kaplan asked Terry about his relationship with Don.
You know, in the beginning, I would say it was rocky.
Terry told Kaplan that when they went to court over custody of Sienna, Don sometimes seemed to want a confrontation.
And if he can get me in any kind of way violent or yell or scream at him, then it would make him look good.
And he would ultimately, you know, win the court's side about, you know, he could have done it more.
So I just, I wouldn't bite for that.
Terry said to the detective that he mostly avoided Don and hadn't had any contact with him in a while.
They were not going to find any DNA or thing of Prince of Dior's anywhere in his house or on his vehicle or anywhere in that area.
Yeah.
I just would not get in the guy's life.
It's just, to me, it's not, it wasn't worth it because I love that girl.
Yeah.
And I don't want to make her hate me because she loves her dad.
Kaplan asked about the night of the murder.
Terry said he spent the evening visiting his sister.
He said he left about nine, stopped at a Wendy's for dinner, then drove to work and slept in his car until his shift began.
Terry's sister confirmed his story.
So did his boss, who said she had security cam video that would show Terry at work that night.
But by then, Kaplan had received an unexpected phone call from Don's neighbor.
She had become curious about her own surveillance video.
She had looked at it and made a discovery and said, hey, detective, you need to look at 7.41 p.m.
Coming up, a mysterious figure captured on camera.
There's someone in a hoodie and the individual walks off camera towards where Don Fluitt's door would be.
Did you think that surveillance camera had taken a picture of your killer?
I did.
When Dateline continues.
January 2017.
Instead of celebrating the start of a new year, Don Fluitt's family was making funeral arrangements.
His niece Amber made posters with photos of Don.
His ex-wife Christine pitched in.
She brought some pictures over that she had had that I could add to the boards, and she said can I help you?
I said, yeah, absolutely, let's do this.
And so we had a glass of wine and put the picture boards together.
Sienna helped too.
She lost her best friend and she wanted to be a part of it.
Sienna picked out most of the music and readings for the service.
It was held at the church she attended with her dad.
Meanwhile, the murder investigation continued.
Detective Kaplan spoke to Dawn's neighbor who said she'd found something on her home security video.
I started looking at the clip she's talking about, and believe it or not, There's a figure.
A figure?
A figure.
There's someone in a hoodie walking to Don Fluitt's trash can.
They lay the trash can down on its side and the individual walks off camera towards where Don Fluitt's door would be.
Don Fluitt returns and pulls into the garage.
You see him walk out of the garage.
He walks to his trash can, picks it up, and then walks into his garage again.
At this point, said Kaplan, you could see the light from the garage diminishing as the garage door closed.
And then inexplicably the garage shoots back up.
And you see a series of flashes.
I'm the hooded figure outside.
We went to the scene of the crime to understand how this could happen.
It's as easy as that, huh?
So where is Don?
He's in the house now?
I believe he's in the house now.
And there's the flashing light.
And there's your series of flashes that you see on the surveillance video.
Kaplan believed that hooded figure tripped the sensor and sneaked into Don's garage, the door closing behind him.
Did you think that surveillance camera had taken a picture of your killer?
I did.
A tantalizing image, but no face to go with it.
Do you see the figure depart?
No, never.
The garage closes and Don Fluitt's found dead the next morning.
Even as he puzzled over the hooded figure's identity, the detective started to hear about someone else Don's brother, Dennis.
Just days after the murder, Dennis got the keys to Don's house.
Don's children from Oklahoma wondered what he was up to.
They felt that it was odd that Dennis was there. and sort of kind of taking control.
Taking over his brother's life.
Yes, that was a concern to them.
Kaplan also learned that Dennis and Don had had a falling out a year before.
Dennis had moved away, lived in Arizona for a while, but he'd moved back to Albuquerque just a couple of months before Don's murder.
It kind of puts up a red flag for me.
You're in the process of reconnecting.
You had a falling out before, and now Don's unexpectedly been murdered.
Tiffany and Josh had the same feeling.
But did you think maybe your uncle, his brother, had something to do with this?
There was talk of it just because of a strange relationship and what had happened.
And when you're hurt and you're grieving, you don't know what to think.
Kaplan interviewed Dennis, who said it had all started after their father died.
I got a little bit angry with him about that because he took a lot of my dad's stuff.
There was just disagreements, just like I'm starting to see with my brother's death.
Kaplan had learned that Don had lost his job as a firefighter because of a drug test.
He asked Dennis about that.
That's true.
Marijuana.
Marijuana.
Okay.
Nothing heavy.
I guarantee my brother hasn't touched heavy drugs in 30 years.
Then Dennis came up with a name.
Someone else he thought detectives should be taking a look at.
You know, and it makes me mad.
I mean, you know, I'm no investigator.
I'm no cop.
You know, but this guy spends two hours in my brother's house.
You talking about the landlord, Benny?
Benny, the landlord.
Dennis said just days after Don's murder, he found Benny inside Don's home.
Benny claimed he was feeding the dog.
Dennis claimed, well, I don't know if he's messing with the crime scene.
Dennis told Kaplan that he had heard that Don was upset with Benny over a hole in his ceiling that hadn't been repaired.
Detectives asked Benny for fingerprints and DNA.
But as Kaplan questioned him, Benny told the detective he was uneasy about Dennis.
Benny said Dennis wanted to rent another townhouse Benny owned just a few blocks down from the murder scene.
He said he was going to move all the Don stuff over there and set it up.
Did he tell you why he wanted to do that? for Sienna.
He wanted to set up for Sienna for Don's little daughter, which is kind of weird.
Benny said he didn't rent to Dennis, not after a background check revealed that Dennis had a criminal record for assault and disorderly conduct.
Kaplan, of course, already knew about Dennis' record.
But more importantly I wondered why he had suddenly taken a massive interest in Don Fluitt's affairs with the condo and with CNN.
When we spoke to Dennis, we wondered that too.
Coming up, they kept talking about an estrangement between the two of you, the brother, the landlord, the stepfather, three possible suspects.
These were names that i just i, i couldn't eliminate, and one of them is about to change his story.
To say Don Fluitt loved the Christmas season would be putting it mildly.
He was obsessed.
We're talking lights, music, you know.
It was everywhere.
A month after Don's murder, his family was still grappling with the fact that he would never see another Christmas.
No one more distraught than his daughter, Sienna.
How was she doing?
She was strong.
She said she just was praying about it.
She would cry.
Meanwhile, Detective Kaplan was looking very closely at the apparent bad blood between Don Fluitt and his brother Dennis.
They kept talking about an estrangement between the two of you.
Do you know what they're referring to?
Oh, yeah.
When my dad passed, we all came to an agreement on the few assets that he did have.
Yeah, there was a set understanding, huh?
Set understanding.
Well, Don didn't keep his part of the deal and kept one of the trucks that we were going to sell.
According to Dennis, that led to radio silence between the two brothers.
Dennis said he tried to reach out to Don just a couple of months before his murder, but Don never returned his call.
And when he heard about Don's death, he only wanted to help.
I knew him better than anybody.
And he knew me better than anybody.
And I made a promise to him and Sienna early on that I was going to do everything to bring justice and protect them.
He said if some people found that suspicious, so be it.
Dennis remained on Detective Kaplan's list of potential suspects.
Benny, Dennis, Terry, these were names that I just, I couldn't eliminate.
So he kept the heat on all three.
Kaplan had already questioned landlord Benny Ruiz and obtained a sample of his DNA.
He also took another look at Sienna's stepdad, Terry White.
Remember, Terry initially told the detective that on the night of Don's murder he stayed with his sister until 9 pm, then drove to work and took a nap in the parking lot.
But when Detective Kaplan checked the security cam video, You can see Terry White pull in and immediately get out of his truck and walk to the front door.
So now there's a discrepancy in his story.
Again, thank you for coming down.
No worries.
You're a busy man.
Detective Kaplan asked Terry to stop by the station, go over his timeline one more time, and...
His story changed.
He didn't pull into the parking lot as originally expressed.
He went around the corner to a dark area and fell asleep there.
And then he pulled into the parking lot.
That wasn't the only discrepancy.
Remember, in his first interview, Terry said he'd only stopped at a Wendy's on his way to work.
But now... I stopped at Walmart.
Walmart?
Now what's he doing at Walmart?
That was an interesting story.
I want to stop to get a new sweatshirt for me for work because my wife bought me one for Christmas.
I said, I'm not going to wear that to work.
So I went and bought this one.
Kaplan asked Terry about Dennis.
He never met the guy, he said, but he'd heard about his troubled relationship with Don and that Dennis had moved into Don's home.
Now he's back and he's like trying to protect Sienna from whatever.
And it's just, it's making people feel kind of...
Off.
Terry willingly gave a DNA sample and Kaplan sent him on his way.
Two days later, the detective went back to Dennis.
I took his DNA and I took his fingerprints.
Dennis, too, was cooperative.
He told detectives he worried about Sienna and he felt bad for Christine.
You know, she's a mess.
I mean, I talked to her for half an hour on the phone this morning and there was probably four or five times she started to cry.
And he was still very vocal with his suspicions about Benny Ruiz.
I mean, how do we know that Benny didn't go over there and Don might have just let him in and everything, like everybody knew each other, and then it went bad.
Kaplan didn't think Dennis was helping himself.
Was he receding as a person of interest for you?
No, unfortunately not.
Do you have your eye on anybody in particular?
Oh, you know I can't tell you that.
Come on, man.
I can't tell you that.
Oh, that's right.
I'm still not clear it was a suspect.
Nobody is.
In my opinion, nobody is.
As the weeks passed, Dawn's kids began to worry.
Did you think it was going to be cold and not solved?
That someone was going to get away with murder here?
It scared me for a little bit that it may be that way.
But that was about to change.
Remember, fingernail clippings from Dawn's body had been taken for testing.
Three months after Don's murder, the lab reported a hit.
Someone else's DNA beneath Don's fingernails.
I remember just kind of jumping out of my chair.
Well, whose DNA is it?
Coming up... That's a bingo moment, huh?
Yes.
A final suspect at last.
We do have a suspect and we do have an arrest warrant.
Yes!
But can they get to him in time?
The deputy immediately thinks, oh no.
When Dateline continues...
One murder, three potential suspects.
Something had to break the tie.
Then, about 12 weeks into the investigation, the crime lab called with some major news.
The foreign DNA under Don Fluitt's fingernails belonged to none other than his ex-wife's current husband, Terry White.
That's a bingo moment, huh?
Yes.
It all started lining up.
Terry's strained relationship with Don, his shifting timeline, his sudden need for a new hoodie.
The fact that he's amended his second story to include buying a hoodie, what does that tell you?
In hindsight, a lot.
It tells me that there was probably a lot of blood on him and that he needed something to wear when he went to work.
And above all, Terry's DNA where it simply did not belong.
Maybe we're not going to find any DNA or fingerprints of yours anywhere in his house or on his vehicle or anywhere in that area.
No.
No.
Okay.
So if we did, it'd be weird.
Yeah.
Yeah, I would say that would be weird.
At this point, I'm 100% sure that Terry is our guy.
Kaplan spoke to Don's mom, Sharon, and his brother, Dennis.
We do have a suspect in this case, and we do have an arrest warrant.
It's Terry White.
The case seemed to be solved, but there was a problem.
Before Kaplan could find Terry, he got a call from Christine.
She said Terry was missing.
You're putting the noose around Terry's neck, but you're also finding out he doesn't seem to be around anymore.
Right.
Kaplan asked Christine to stop by the station.
He thought she might have information that could help him find her husband.
And you're having a contentious kind of a relationship now with Christine.
Right.
And I think at that point, um...
Her willingness to cooperate with me was sort of gone.
Kaplan got a search warrant for her car and phone, hoping to find clues that might lead him to Terry.
Interesting enough, we find her cell phone in the glove compartment and there's a last will and testament right next to it.
A last will and testament in the glove?
Yes.
It's Terry White's.
I found that to be extraordinarily unusual.
And how old again was it, the document?
Three days after we took his DNA.
Kaplan started to wonder if Terry would be gone permanently.
Then, a few days later, he caught a break.
A sheriff's deputy had happened on a pickup truck at an Arizona rest stop more than 200 miles from Albuquerque.
There's a hose traveling from the exhaust into the cab.
So the deputy immediately thinks, oh no, so it looks like someone's trying to commit suicide.
In the cab of the truck, the missing murder suspect.
Terry White is red-faced, probably from the carbon monoxide.
Looks a little bit drowsy and out of it.
Deputy runs his name and realizes he has a warrant for a homicide.
So he is arrested right then and there.
Detective Kaplan and his partner made a beeline for Arizona to see if Terry would talk.
Do you want to talk to me today?
Okay.
So Terry didn't feel like talking, not to the police anyway.
But once he was transferred back to Albuquerque, he did talk to someone.
Dennis received a Facebook message from a woman.
She's like, you don't know me, but my boyfriend is in jail with a guy by the name of Terry White.
And you can imagine, I'm thinking, what?
The boyfriend's name, Roderick White.
No relation, of course.
Rod and Terry shared the same last name, the same birthday and, for three days in April 2017, the same jail cell.
Soon, Terry's former cellmate was in the interview room with Detective Kaplan.
From what I understand, you want to talk about kind of what Terry's confiding you.
Yes.
According to Rod, Terry made a full confession.
He tells him everything.
He tells him how he snuck in.
He tripped the garage door and I thought I was busted right then.
But he ended up getting underneath the guy's car.
Terry told Rod that Don was a smoker whose routine was to smoke in the garage.
So he waited for Don to come out.
I got up and I was waiting right there by the...
Rod said.
Terry then described in gruesome detail what took place inside the garage, away from the neighbor's security cam.
He said as soon as he came out, He said, I hit him as hard as I could with that power thumper.
He said, I hit him so hard it split the power thumper in three pieces.
Kaplan showed us how the cellmate's story matched the evidence at the crime scene.
He explains that he hits Don with this tire thumper.
Don continues to fight.
It continues in here.
We know this because there's a coat rack that would have been right here.
There's blood on a jacket that belonged to Sienna.
There's blood on the garage door.
And then we find.
And then what, the action moves back out here, Matt, or what?
It moves back up here.
And this is a very narrow space because the bumper of.
He's got a big old truck and it would have used every inch of this.
To about right here.
What we do know is there's bloody handprints on the hood of this. truck.
There's handprints and blood swipes on the wall.
So we know that Don had fallen on his back this way.
He even described how Don got Terry's DNA on.
And he says, and I know exactly when it happened.
It was when I was raining down on the bus.
He reached up and his finger caught the inside lip.
Then Rod continued that Terry hit him so hard, Don finally went down.
So I'll give him this.
He fought for his life.
Then, according to Rod, Terry finished the job.
He said, I went inside the house And I got a steak knife.
And he said something about splitting the side of his throat.
And if the knife didn't work, Terry told Rod that he had a backup plan.
I had plan B. He said there was an axe there on the wall of the garage.
He said that was plan B. which you can clearly see in the crime scene photos.
There's no way you would know that unless you were there.
Now, importantly, were any of those details, Detective, that you just listed, were they online?
Were they in the newspapers?
No.
So this cellmate is telling you a story that exactly matches your evidence, huh?
Or the observations at the scene?
Yes.
Not only is it matching the evidence, it's filling in some of the gaps.
Yes.
The case against Terry White was starting to look airtight.
But Rod, the informant, wasn't done talking.
Coming up, she's the one that told him we've got to do this now, you got to do street family she.
She said we all have our dirty little part in this.
One more jaw-dropping revelation to come.
He was arguing as he fought for his life.
Informant Rod White gave detectives a virtual play-by-play of how Terry White murdered Don Fleury.
One revelation after another.
I had plan B. She said there was an ass there on the wall of the garage.
But just when they thought they'd heard everything, Rod had one more revelation to offer.
A big one.
Jerry told me on several occasions that he did it for her, that she's the one that told him we've got to do this now.
You've got to do this for your family.
According to Rod the, she in question was Terry's wife, Don's ex, the mother of his darling Sienna Christine.
Rod said, and would later testify in court, that Christine was the prime mover of the murder plot.
So Terry told you that Christine told him to do it for the family?
Yes.
They've been looking for an opportunity for a while.
The cellmate said that Christine and Terry called Don the black cloud and with him out of the way they'd have Siena all to themselves.
Of course, any dreams of a happily ever after had gone belly up once police zeroed in on Terry.
But Terry did have an ironclad life insurance policy.
So the reasoning would be then, I, Terry White, am in the can.
I'm going to go down for this thing.
They got me.
But I can do you Christine, and the little girl a final bit of good by killing myself, and the insurance will be paid off to you.
Having you collect $250,000.
Rod told the detective that Terry's suicide attempt in Arizona was his third.
And according to Rod, Christine was not exactly thrilled when Terry survived.
When he called me and said, what the f***, why are you still here?
Basically, why have you not killed yourself?
The cellmate's tale got even stranger.
He said after he was released from jail, he met up with Christine and made up a story.
He told her he would smuggle some pills into the jail so Terry could make good on his suicide promise.
And I said, I need to buy the pills and I just, I don't have money.
Rod said he never bought the pills or completed the scheme.
What did you do with the money?
But he said he had a vivid memory of the last time he saw Christine.
She was crying and she grabbed my hand and she was patting my hand and she said...
We all have our dirty little part in this.
Detectives had heard enough.
A few days after the interview... We arrested her.
Christine was charged with first-degree murder and conspiracy.
She was upset but resigned to what was happening.
But the case against Christine was flimsy.
It rested on the word of a felon.
It wasn't strong enough to move forward with her.
The charges against Christine were dismissed.
In June 2018, Terry White went on trial, the sole defendant.
The prosecution's star witness was Terry Selmay Roderick White, back in jail by then on an unrelated charge.
He told the jury everything about how Terry killed Don.
But even this career criminal couldn't seem to understand why.
Why did you kill him?
I said, was he touching the little girl?
And he was like, no, no, no.
Wasn't touching her.
And I said, okay, well, was he beating her?
No, he said, no, he wasn't.
And I said, well, why'd you kill him?
And he said, looked at me and said, the mother just wouldn't go away.
As a result of his testimony Rod, a meth addict, avoided prison time and enrolled in a drug rehab program.
He insisted he didn't come forward in hopes of a deal, but rather because he believed Don's murder was wrong.
They killed him because he was a good father.
That's why they killed this guy, because he was a good dad.
It took the jury a little over six hours to reach a verdict.
Guilty of first-degree murder.
Guilty.
It was just instantly relief.
That this man wouldn't be able to just walk freely ever.
You know that he wasn't going to get to take my dad's life and have his own still.
In August 2018, Terry White was sentenced to 42 years in prison.
But for Don's family, it's not over.
The puppeteer is still pulling the strings, though.
Who's the puppeteer?
Christine.
And the puppet is Terry.
I mean, think about it.
She manipulated that man into killing himself.
Think about that for a second.
I mean, it's one thing to talk somebody into murdering somebody for you, but then...
But to talk that same person into killing themselves that they got caught.
I mean, how do you do that?
Christine White did not attend the trial.
She declined our request for an interview, but wrote us a letter saying she and Don had no custody battle in December 2016.
Only different ideas and school choices.
Regarding Don's murder, Christine wrote.
I knew nothing of the events that occurred until I got a call from the co-worker of Don, who found him that night in December.
It was an awful and unbelievable thing to hear and even harder to have to tell your child.
Prosecutors Natalie Strub and David Waymire say the investigation into Christine is no longer open.
But if new information comes to light, that could change things.
We would have to be able to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she intended all along for Terry White to do this.
And more than that that, she actually did something concrete to aid in a bet to help the crime be committed.
Natalie, can you get there?
I'm hopeful.
I would like to say yes.
But if the evidence isn't there, we can't charge her for something we can't prove.
Anyone who knew him will tell you, Don Fluitt enjoyed helping people.
He loved being a firefighter, feeding the homeless, and helping people with disabilities find work.
But what he loved most was being Sienna's dad.
A bond so tight, people stood in awe of it.
She loved being with her dad.
I mean, she reveled in it.
She loved that man.
You know, to this day, I think about that void that's in her life.
Terrible loss, certainly, with your uncle.
But its primary victim here, in a way, seems to be Sienna.
I would say so.
Tiffany and Josh and myself, too, we got to live our childhood with him.
We got to go to him for advice and to share those milestones in life with him.
What about Sienna?
My dad is still here, you know, and hers is not.
That's all for now.
I'm Lester Holt.
Thanks for joining us.
