The narrative opens with a poignant and long-awaited reunion between Robin Hood and his kinsman, Will Gamwell, marking the end of a ten-year separation. The emotional weight of their meeting is palpable as the two men embrace joyfully. This encounter serves as a bridge to the past, reminding the reader that before Robin became an outlaw, he was a mentor to the young Will. Robin’s role as a teacher is highlighted by the fact that he was the one who instructed Will in the arts of archery and staff combat, skills that have clearly been refined over the decade.
The dialogue reveals that the two had recently engaged in a physical confrontation, with Will demonstrating remarkable prowess. Robin notes that his arm will "tingle for a few days" due to the force of the blow he received. Robin’s observation—"My heart dropped when I saw you unbrood that tree"—underscores the sheer physical power Will now possesses. Will, displaying humility and respect, apologizes for the intensity of the fight, but Robin is more impressed than injured, recognizing that Will has matured into a "very strong man."
As the conversation shifts to the reason for Will’s arrival in Sherwood Forest, the tone turns somber. Will explains the "long story" of his exile, revealing a tragic incident where he accidentally killed a man while defending his father. Despite his lack of intent, Will now faces a grave charge of murder. Robin offers immediate comfort, validating Will’s plight by expressing that he is "very sorry to hear of your ill fortune." In the code of the outlaw band, this tragedy acts as a catalyst for brotherhood; Robin welcomes him into the fold, emphasizing that Will must adopt a new identity to evade the "warrants for your arrest" that are surely being "sworn out."
Robin’s keen eye for detail manifests when he looks at Will’s attire and decides on a new moniker: "You shall be known as Will Scarlet." This naming convention is a hallmark of the Robin Hood legend, stripping away the past life of the outlaw to forge a new, protected identity within the greenwood. Little John, a pivotal figure in the band, greets the newcomer warmly, alongside another new recruit, Arthur Abland. The camaraderie is immediate, with Little John predicting that "many menstruals [minstrels] will sing" about Will’s victory over Robin in their staff fight.
The closing portion of the text focuses on the playful, yet sharp, banter between Robin and Little John. The tension of the earlier fight is diffused through humor, as Little John teasingly reminds Robin of his recent defeat. Robin, clearly sensitive about his reputation, warns, "Let us say no more about that," to which Little John retorts with a playful jab about Robin’s "fatness of my limbs." The exchange concludes with a humorous pact of silence, as Little John jokingly claims he was "blinded" and did not see Robin take a beating.
Ultimately, Robin reflects on the day’s events with pride, declaring that he has "gained the strongest men in all of Nottinghamshire." The group decides to abandon their plans for Ancaster, choosing instead to "return to the greenwood tree." This retreat to the forest serves as a moment of recovery, as Robin hopes that rest will "mellow the pain" in his bones and joints, solidifying the beginning of a new chapter for the band of outlaws.