Hi, Crime Jenkis. I'm your host Ashley Flowers. And I'm Britt. And the story I have for you today is about a young mom who sets out on this quick weekend trip.
But what was meant to be a simple getaway spirals into a tragedy that baffles her family and investigators alike.
This is the story of Francesca Alvarado.
It's Monday, March 19, 2012, and a young woman named Mia is getting worried because she's been trying to get in touch with her sister Francesca for like the past day and she can't seem to get a hold of her.
Now she knows her sister lost her phone earlier that month, but she also knows that she's kind of rigged up her laptop for texting so she's been using that to message people.
There's no reason for her to be radio silent like this.
Now normally Mia would just head to Francesca's place in the hunting park section of Philadelphia to look for her, but she has school that day so she asked someone she knows to just pop over and check on her.
And when that person calls Mia back, he says, okay, I'm here at the house and I'm gonna put her on the phone.
So Mia immediately starts to breathe easier thinking that her means Francesca.
But that relief only lasts for like a second because when she hears the voice come in on the other end of the line, it is a her, but not like her, her, you know what I mean?
Not her sister, it's her sister's roommate, a girl that we're gonna call Tara.
And Tara tells Mia something surprising.
She says that Francesca went to Atlantic City with a friend of theirs, this older guy named Tracy Williams two days before that would have been Saturday the 17th, which was St.
Patrick's Day. And they were planning to stay out there for a couple of weeks so she's like, it's gonna be a minute before she's even back.
And right away when Mia hears this, she's like, no.
Francesca doesn't do Atlantic City.
She does. I mean, it's only an hour away.
She's taken some quick trips there before, but she doesn't do Atlantic City for weeks.
And when she travels, she usually brings her three-year-old daughter with her, which this time she didn't because Tara tells Mia that Francesca dropped a little girl off with a family friend before leaving.
But there's even another reason that Mia is so concerned.
You see, Francesca is about eight weeks pregnant.
And she has an important doctor's appointment coming up on Tuesday, March 20th, one that Mia planned to go to with her.
She wouldn't just miss it.
Is Tracy the guy that's the dad?
No, they're not romantically involved.
Francesca's actually pregnant by her boyfriend, who I'll talk more about in a minute.
This Tracy guy is more of, I guess just like a friend.
I mean, Mia only met him a couple of times.
But she knows that he is significantly older than her sister, like Francesca is only 22 and Tracy is like 50.
That reminds me of Jodie Hussentrude and John Fansize.
A ominous comparison, but you're right, similar.
Because again, as far as Mia knows, there's like nothing going on between the two of them.
He's just been like helping Francesca out, brings her some groceries sometimes.
He's apparently trying to get her a job in real estate.
And even though he lives in Philly, he actually does spend a lot of time in Atlantic City.
So Mia tries to stay calm.
Maybe there's some great business opportunity in Jersey that Francesca just couldn't turn down her way.
I don't know. And Mia kind of fights with herself internally, debating back and forth.
Like, should I go to the police?
Am I going to make my sister mad for overreacting?
It's going to turn out to be nothing.
So she lets a couple of days pass, and then a couple more.
But by that point, Mia's sufficiently freaked out.
And so is the rest of Francesca's family.
And I assume this whole time she's still not answering any messages.
No, she's not. And that's more concerning because Tara specifically says that she definitely brought her laptop with her to Atlantic City.
But she's not responding to these messages.
She's not posting on social media either.
And by Friday the 23rd, Francesca's daughter is asking for her mom and Mia can't take it anymore.
So that's when she files a missing person's report with the Philadelphia Police Department.
She told our reporter Nina that even in 2012, when this is happening, they have the same dated response.
And she's an adult. She's going to be back when she's ready.
And Mia tries to tell them that Francesca has no reason to take off.
I mean, she's due to start college in a few months where she plans to study criminal justice with the hope of becoming a lawyer.
She tells them about how she adores her daughter.
Plus, it's not like her to just do something like this, especially without telling any one of her siblings.
Like, they are a super close group.
They've had to be. Because they've been through a lot together.
Francesca is the youngest of eight.
Her dad started serving life in prison the year that she was born and their mom died when she was just nine.
So an older sister got custody of her and Mia and had been raising them for more than a decade now.
Like Francesca wouldn't want to worry any of her siblings.
But again, with this dynamic, it's like even different.
And by the way, even if she wanted to take off, she has no resources with which to actually do that.
No car, no money, nothing.
Now, it doesn't seem like anyone from the family tried to or was able to make contact with Tracy up to this point.
But I do know that he shows up to the police station the very next day, which would have been Saturday, March 24.
And the story he gives kind of bolsters investigators theory that Francesca just left.
Do we know if he came back just to talk to police or has he been back for a while?
Well, so here's what's so strange.
So according to Tara, he should have still been in Atlantic City.
But he tells detectives that he's been home since the 18th.
The way he describes it, it seems like their plan was to always just stay one night and then come back on Sunday.
So I don't know if someone just got their wires crossed or what?
But anyway, Tracy's account is that he took Francesca along with a couple of his kids to Atlantic City on Saturday the 17th.
They stayed at his usual spot, the resort's casino hotel.
But around like 2 a.m. on Sunday, Francesca decided that she wanted to take a walk and she told him that she would find her own way back to Philadelphia.
And he says this is the last time he saw her.
He didn't even know she was missing until a relative of his saw a social media post from her family looking for information on her whereabouts.
She just walked out at 2 a.m.
and was gonna find her own way back.
That's what he says. Yeah, no.
It's strange for sure. And mind you, so I'll set the scene a little bit more.
It's not like she's storming out.
It doesn't sound like they fought or anything.
At least not the way he explains it.
I think he even implies that Francesca actually asked him to come along on the walk.
But then since he had his kids there, he couldn't go.
Okay, that doesn't really add up either.
And even the way he's freezing it, like she's just going for a walk or she's walking to go home.
Like is she leaving or is she just like, I know.
Something out for a bit.
I know. And when detectives relay this information to me, I mean, she's floored.
She's like, why would Francesca just take off in the middle of the night and where would she even go?
I mean, her connections to the city were minimal at best.
She wasn't embedded in the social scene or anything.
So if we're Tracy to leave her there or let her leave without a word and then not to tell anyone until police got involved, like her family's just struggling to piece all of this logic together.
Because in their minds, as far as they're concerned, he brought her to Atlantic City.
He should have made sure she returned safely.
And the place are just cool with his story.
They seemed to be at least at first.
For one thing, his kids apparently tell investigators that Francesca was in the hotel room when they went to sleep on Saturday.
And that she and her bag were just gone when they woke up on Sunday, which does align with Tracy's narrative.
And they seem to think that he's credible.
They say he's respectful.
He's cooperative or at least up unto a point.
And that point is when police ask him to take a polygraph.
Tracy quickly hires a lawyer who presumably advises against him taking that polygraph.
And just like that, he clams up.
No more answers. No more help.
And while that may have made police side eye him in his story a little, it doesn't seem like it made them jump into action to find Francesca.
That was left up to her loved ones who had to Atlantic City and hit the ground running.
On the boardwalk, they talk to every passer by they can, hoping for details that can help them retrace Francesca's last steps.
Mia even stakes out the resort's hotel, fishing for information from employees like who are out just taking smoke breaks.
And she actually does get a couple of nibbles from a front desk clerk who remembers Tracy and Francesca.
The clerk says that Tracy's switched hotel rooms during their trip.
Like I guess he requested the change because his room was quote unquote messy.
And the clerk also recalls that Francesca came up and asked her for recommendations of where to party without needing an ID.
Why isn't she like 22? She is.
But apparently when she went up and asked this, she was with someone else like another young woman.
Now the clerk didn't get this person's name or know who they were.
But no, it's interesting.
So Tara, Francesca's roommate from Back where she lives, she's only 17.
Now all along Tara has been maintaining that she was home in Philadelphia that whole weekend.
But Mia starts to wonder if that's actually true.
Because what other underage person would Francesca have been with?
What are the chances it's one of Tracy's kids if he's in his 50s, they could be teenagers, right?
No, apparently, I mean, they could be, but apparently his kids were younger like around 10 so it wouldn't have been them.
Did Mia find out where the women went after the hotel?
Well, no, but that's because the clerk said she didn't give them any suggestions.
Like she's like, Lanx City has a lot of nightlife, but that it's really made for people over 21.
So with no real direction to help guide their physical searches, Mia and her siblings start a Facebook page dedicated to finding their sister.
And pretty soon there's a whole community involved, family, friends, even strangers that are just touched by their story.
And they all call themselves Team Checa, which is a nod to Francesca's nickname.
The outpouring of love that they're getting is inspiring to Mia.
But the one thing that's interesting is she notices there are three people Francesca spent a lot of time with that are noticeably absent from all of this and not just the Facebook group, but also from the rallies they hold and the times that they go and pass out flyers.
And those three people are Tracy, Tara, and remember how I said Francesca had a boyfriend that I'd get to?
Well, I'm getting to it.
His name is William Coit, and he's not helping out either.
Now let me back up just a little bit and fill you in on this whole dynamic a bit.
So Francesca hasn't known any of these people for very long.
She considers Tara her best friend, but Mia says that they only met the year before, which would have been 2011.
And it was Tara who introduced Francesca to Tracy and Will.
But Tracy and Will ran in different circles.
So it's not like this is one big friend group.
Now I don't know how Tara and Tracy met.
But Will was practically family because Tara was dating his brother.
So the two guys stayed over a lot and Will and Francesca hit it off after she moved in with Tara in November of 2011.
Now even the setup is kind of interesting.
So Tara's family owned the townhouse that the two women were staying in and renting.
But Tara was too young to pay the bills in her name, which is where Francesca came in.
Plus, like Francesca, Tara also had a young daughter.
So at first, I mean, honestly it seemed like this ideal setup.
Best friends that each have kids, their dating brothers, all under one roof.
I mean, that's kind of the plot for a sitcom.
Well, this wasn't a sitcom because Francesca and Will's relationship quickly soured.
Mia had actually been encouraging her sister to leave him.
I mean, their nickname for him was Mr.
Wrong. Will had a long criminal record and on top of that a bad temper.
A temper that had boiled over shortly before she went to Atlantic City.
You see, two days before she left, Mia had seen her sister and there was a long scratch on her arm.
And Francesca told Mia that it was from Will trying to throw her out of her bedroom window.
Oh my god. Yeah, and there was some other shady boot stuff happening too.
So Francesca had more than $2,000 all from her income tax refund.
But apparently that money had mysteriously disappeared from her house recently.
Now, if Atlantic City were taking bets on it, Mia would have put all her money on the odds that Will stole it.
But when she mentioned that theory to her sister, Francesca didn't want to believe that.
But she was getting tired of Mr.
Wrong. Even though she cared about him and was pregnant by him, it seemed like she was about ready to kick him to the curb.
I mean, she was even making plans to move in with Mia.
So what you're saying is she'd be leaving Tara's place and Will at the same time.
Right. And did Tara and Will know that?
Tara did. But Mia doesn't think that Will was like in the know.
Okay, but it's not a stretch to think that Tara might have told him though.
Right. Maybe. And if she did, I mean, I think there's a world where she only knew about the move.
Maybe she just told him that.
Which doesn't necessarily mean that he knew she was going to end things.
So I don't know what he knew.
But all of that to say, whatever was going on, the fact that neither of them are showing up for her now is infuriating to Mia.
Especially because Francesca is super loyal.
And Mia knows that she would be out there pounding the pavement looking for anyone of them if the situation was reversed.
And she just thinks about how her sister is going to be when she learns about their absence.
And I say gonna be because that's the way she's still thinking at this point because as far as Mia is concerned for Francesca is going to find out someday.
The idea that she's in danger abducted may be being held captive or trafficked.
I mean, that's always on Mia's mind because she knows something is seriously wrong.
Otherwise, they would have heard from her by now.
But she won't even let herself believe that Francesca is dead.
She can't stand that thought.
So she and Team Checa keep searching day after day as they go up and down the boardwalk with the city on one side, the ocean on the other.
Mia focuses on the buildings and the alleyways, not that vast expanse of water that fills her with dread.
They paper the boardwalk with flyers hoping someone's gonna recognize the pretty dark haired young woman in the photo.
But officers remove the flyers as fast as they put them up.
What? They tell Mia that there's actually rules against posting flyers.
And there might be, but she thinks that they're more trying to protect an image of Atlantic City that is this like family friendly safe place.
And a woman going missing ruined.
Yeah, that doesn't fit into that.
And she might be on to something because in 2012, Atlantic City's violent crime rate was the second highest in all of New Jersey.
Tourism was suffering and casino revenue had been like plummeting for years.
So at the time, the city was essentially trying to rebrand itself.
And actually coincidentally, just a couple of days after Francesca disappeared, the state attorney general held a press conference to detail efforts Atlantic City had been taking to tackle crime and shake off its unsafe reputation.
And actually, those measures included boosting the number of security cameras and compiling a network of hundreds of privately owned surveillance systems throughout the city that police could access quickly if need be.
Which now need be. So officials had been working with the casinos to audit a bunch of their cameras.
Well, I mean, that's the least that they can do if they're gonna take down all of the posters.
I mean, yeah, go through the cameras.
Yes, but the footage is only helpful if police get to it in time.
Mia says that investigators told her that the resort's cameras are overwritten every seven days.
So by the time they went and tried to pull the footage, it must have been too late.
And Mia doesn't even think that they tried expanding their search to the surrounding casinos and neighborhoods.
So they're still not like leading the charge in investigation right now.
No, not that the family can tell.
And they're facing another battle too, and that's against misconceptions.
According to a Metro article by Alexandra Wigglesworth, some early media reports identified Francesca as a sex worker, which her loved ones say isn't true.
And police apparently distributed flyers indicating that she was depressed.
So her family worries that the false narratives could hurt their chances of finding her.
They also feel like cops in Atlantic City are dragging their heels since Francesca's not a local.
But there's nothing they can really do because the Philadelphia police are like, like, well, she didn't go missing here.
Like, what are we supposed to do?
Well, and it's a completely different state too.
Like it's not just like a county over or a town over.
Yeah, it's a completely different agency at the core of it.
And this is like what gets so hard because they are involved.
So Philadelphia is involved because she lived there.
But then you've got the local Atlantic City involved because she potentially went missing from there.
Actually, at some point, the FBI comes in too.
So they've got like all these jurisdictions, which are great.
It's great to have help.
But like, then you have to wonder how well is everyone communicating.
Now, I know one thing that the FBI or at least someone was doing is they were monitoring Francesca's social media and her access debit card, which is used for state benefits like Medicaid or SNAP.
But in monitoring that, I mean, they're seeing no activity.
So it's not like that's showing them that she's out there just living her life.
Now, I know one of the steps that the Philadelphia police department take is they actually bring Tara in for questioning at some point, although it's not super clear what they learn when they do.
And the other thing that they do is they search Francesca's room in her and Tara's place.
But nothing's been reported if they ever found anything significant.
Although, apparently something relevant was missed when they searched it.
Because a couple of days after their search, when Mia heads over to pick up some of her sister's belongings, she finds something alarming.
In Francesca's room, there on the floor by her bed, Mia sees a pair of pants.
And when she picks them up and starts going through the pockets, she finds her sister's ID and that access card that police have been tracking.
I mean, this whole time police have been waiting for her to use it, it turns out she didn't even have it.
Well, and if her ID is there, that could explain why she and that other woman were asking the front desk clerk about places they could party without an ID.
Like, maybe she knew she'd forgotten her home and couldn't get in anywhere without it.
That's one possibility.
I don't know if it's the most likely one, because I mean, at some point detectives speak with that hotel clerk and after that they tell Mia that the woman may have just had her timing mixed up.
Like, they think maybe that whole encounter happened on a different weekend before Francesca went missing.
Because I guess when they drilled down the clerk wasn't super sure about when it occurred.
I don't know, against this is still possible that she didn't have her ID that weekend.
But another possibility is that maybe Francesca did make it back to her home sometime after the 17th.
To figure out which possibility is true, Team Check is focused is really on Tracy.
He was the last one to see her and his story just doesn't add up.
Mia can't help but think that he must have done something to her sister.
Now he's obviously not cooperating with police.
He's sure it's not cooperating with the family.
So in order to try and put the pressure on, they flood his neighborhood with posters of Francesca.
In May, a lieutenant tells the Philadelphia Inquirer reporter Ronnie Polineski that he can't say if Tracy is a person of interest or not since the investigation's ongoing.
But they certainly seem to be interested in him.
And is Tracy the only one they're looking at?
Like, what about, I don't know, some random person in Atlantic City or even Will?
I mean, every scenario is on the table at this point.
They don't even know where she is.
And I know investigators do question Will while he's locked up on unrelated charges.
He tells them, like, you know, of course he says that he didn't do anything to Francesca.
He even takes a polygraph.
And detectives tell the family that he passed it.
But he was also apparently acting so irrationally after taking it that I don't know that they put much stock into the results.
But all that to say polygraph, no polygraph.
Mia is definitely suspicious of Will.
But Tara tells her that Will wasn't even aware that Francesca was in Atlantic City that day.
So she's like, he couldn't have done anything to her.
Okay, honestly, I'm not sure how much that I want to put in Tara though.
I mean, I don't know why anyone's not looking at her.
I can't, but notice she's the only person in the story whose name you've changed.
Which makes me feel I've been doing this for a while.
Yeah. You still have something up your sleeve.
Yeah, well, but without telling you what's up my sleeve, just knowing what they know now at this point in the story, I do think they should have been looking at Will and Tara closer as well.
So does finding the ID and the card change me as focus?
Or does she still think that Francesca went missing from Atlantic City?
I don't know if she knows, but I think that's still the going theory at the time.
I mean, it seems to be like the same that she disappeared from Atlantic City.
Although if that's true, then that's actually a bigger problem for Francesca's supporters, because despite some news coverage that she's getting in Philadelphia, there's like virtually nothing about her disappearance in the Atlantic City or national media.
So the people that they really need to reach probably don't even know that Francesca exists, much less that she's missing or the circumstances around it.
But infill at least, the word is out.
The family's Facebook page quickly amasses thousands of followers, and it kind of becomes the heart of their operation, a community hub where information is shared, where plans are made, Mia actually starts a petition trying to put public pressure on Tracy to talk.
She queries supporters for intel about Will and Tara, who she refers to as some of the last people to see her sister and some of the first to give up on her.
The family also works with the Philadelphia police to offer a reward, hoping maybe $25,000 will incentivize people to start talking.
And by Thanksgiving, they're back on the Atlantic City boardwalk, handing out hot meals and clothes along with flyers to those in need, anything to get the word out.
But for all of their efforts, nothing changes.
By July of 2013, the family's theory that Francesca has been abducted and might be the victim of trafficking is stronger than ever.
And according to one of their Facebook posts, law enforcement feels the same way.
Now I'm not sure why this is the predominant theory.
Beyond the fact that since her family thinks Francesca is alive or hoping she's alive, like trafficking is really the only explanation they can wrap their heads around.
But like, I just keep, I see that a lot, like that's kind of like what they had attached to in those early days.
And I mean, when you think about it, New Jersey is considered a hotbed of human trafficking thanks to its geographic location and its massive hospitality industry.
And when it comes to Atlantic City itself, I mean, the only other place in the US with a larger gaming market and a worse reputation for sex work and other illegal activities Las Vegas.
So, are they thinking that Tracy is trafficking her or someone else?
Again, like the possibilities are endless when they know nothing.
And to be very clear, I mean, as far as we can tell, Tracy has never been charged with anything related to trafficking, nothing even related to domestic violence or anything like that in his history.
But to her family, Tracy makes the most sense as a culprit just based on him being the last person to see her and his actions surrounding the whole situation.
However, police aren't like getting blinders on.
They're expanding their focus.
They start leaning unsuspected traffickers in Atlantic City trying to find out if any of them could have been involved or if they know anything, but every time they talk or get information, it's kind of always the same.
Like, no one's seen her, they don't know where she is.
But later that summer, it actually happens on Wednesday, August 7th, which is nearly a year and a half since Francesca went missing.
Mia is in Atlantic City.
She's conducting one of her countless searches.
And that's when she sees this article about a startling discovery that throws everything they thought they knew into question.
Because what she reads, what's in front of her, is that just a day earlier, which would have been August 6th, a man was fishing on the beach in Corson's Inlet State Park, which is like 15 miles from Atlantic City.
And apparently, he catches something that he was not expecting.
The skeletal remains of a foot inside a sneaker.
I mean, and some of the toenails still had remnants of colored polish on them.
Now, initially, there's like no information.
Investigators couldn't tell the gender or the age of the person, so they have no idea who it belongs to.
All they did was put out this press release, including a photo of the shoe.
But the moment that Mia sees this shoe, this news like her stomach drops, because she would recognize that size 5.5 black Adidas high top anywhere.
She'd been teasing her sister about those sneakers ever since she first bought them.
She thought they were hideous, but Francesca loved those sneakers.
Those are her sister's sneakers.
So Mia immediately calls the medical examiner's office and fills them in, and they get the ball rolling on DNA testing to confirm what the family already knows in their hearts.
And they're right. In September, the lab verifies that that foot is Francesca's.
Did they find the rest of her?
So all they have is her foot, and they are able to determine though that the foot detached from her ankle, naturally for a lack of a better term like it hadn't been cut.
So she likely been in the water for some time, and the rest of her probably still is, but they don't know what happened before she ended up in the ocean, or how she got there, or how she might have died.
Now, this is where we get another agency, because New Jersey State Police takes over the case since that's where her foot was found.
And even though a sergeant there tells Philadelphia Inquirer reporter Barbara Boyer that it's an active death investigation, it doesn't appear that Francesca is actually declared dead yet.
According to Mia, authorities tell the family that since a person can live without a foot, they're holding off on making any official declaration, which is fine with Mia, because even as they plan Francesca's celebration of life, even as they watch more than a thousand people cram into a Northeast Philadelphia church, everyone wearing her favorite color purple.
Her family does not want to believe that she's actually gone.
The only saving grace in that moment is that they're surrounded by so much love and support.
Even the man who found Francesca's foot is there, he and his wife make the hour and a half long trip from their home in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, bearing thoughtful mementos like the shells that were found near her remains.
And I gotta ask, what about our trio?
Do they show up to this? Not Will, as far as I can tell, he's locked up.
He seems to be in an out of jail a lot, but also Tara is a no-show.
She's not in jail, and this really upsets Mia, because even though there has been some bad blood since Francesca disappeared, and I know she hasn't been a part of other things, Mia expected her to come to this.
She actually ends up reaching out to her on Facebook and sending her this pretty angry message.
And Tara apologizes for not going.
She says, you know, I have supported efforts to find Francesca in my own quiet ways.
I still love her. And she points out she's like, I think Francesca would be really disappointed about the division that's grown among the people that she cared about most.
So no Tara, no Will. And as far as Tracy, it doesn't look like he was there either, because police in Philadelphia tell a journalist that they have information that he is, quote-unquote, left the area, but they don't seem to know where he is.
It's yet another mystery.
And Mia has had enough of those to last a lifetime at this point.
Like, she just wants answers now.
So day after day, she Googles phrases like, body found, and Jane Doe, and washed ashore.
Any combo that she can think of that might pull up results.
Her family worries that this endless quest is bad for her mental health.
And it might have been, but it does pay off.
On January 24th of 2014, a femur is found along the same stretch of New Jersey coast where Francesca's foot washed up.
And then a few days later, a tibia turns up on a beach in the same area.
Mia reaches out to authorities in DNA testing links both bones to Francesca.
They're from different legs.
And it's at this point that Mia can't hold on to her denial any longer.
She knows that her sister is dead.
But even those additional remains don't bring more answers, because when a death certificate is finally issued in January of 2016, the cause of death is listed as undetermined.
A few months after that in April, Francesca's family wraps the few bones that they have in purple silk and lays her to rest with their mother.
It feels like an end to one chapter, but it's not the end of the story.
Because in the spring of 2018, new detectives are assigned to Francesca's case.
And these new investigators bring up a whole new suspect name, at least a name that's new to Mia.
And that's Jarelle Jackson, better known as Jinx.
Is he connected to any of the people we know about?
Oh, he's connected all right.
And to explain this, I have to tell you a completely different story, one with a lot of familiar characters.
Back in 2012, around the time that Francesca went missing, a teenage girl who we're going to call Chloe moved to Philadelphia after her father was awarded custody of her.
Her stepmom was abusive and made her get a job at a bar so she could help pay rent and bills.
Chloe was totally exhausted from working late night shifts and she vented about the situation to a co-worker.
Well, that co-worker was Cara.
And Cara seemed to be very sympathetic.
She told Chloe that what her family was doing to her was a sin.
In fact, she felt so bad that she asked Chloe to come live with her.
After all, she had this space because her old roommate, Francesca, that room was empty now.
So Chloe moved in. As far as I can tell, once she moved in, she didn't have to work at the bar anymore, but this was far from a free ride.
She kind of ended up being a live-in nanny because Cara would often leave her young daughter in her care.
And then, at some point, this would have been around late summer early fall of 2012, Cara asked Chloe to run an errand with her.
According to Chloe, a guy picked them up and drove them to a nearby hotel and Cara told Chloe to run inside with her and they go into this room and there's already people there.
And it turns out the people are Francesca's old boyfriend, Will, and this other woman.
Now, the next thing Chloe knows, this Jurel guy came into the room, locked the door and took Chloe's cell phone.
And then he and Will pulled out guns and told her she now had to work for them.
And the other woman warned Chloe that they knew where her family lived.
If she didn't do what they said, they were going to kill them and her.
So Cara set her up. Well, Chloe doesn't know any of these people and at first she thought that she and Cara were both victims because Cara was like crying.
She's apologizing, saying she had no idea what was going on if this was going to happen.
But for the next year, as Chloe was essentially held captive in various hotels, I mean, in the news bat, she was drugged.
She was beaten, burned with cigarette.
She was trafficked by Jurel and Will.
Over this year, she noticed that Cara was just kind of free to come and go as she pleased.
And she made note that one time when she had confided in Cara about hiding money, Cara quickly ratted her out to Will.
And she thinks Cara is the one who told her captors where her family lived and who helped them expand their operation to the Backpage website.
Now, while all of this was happening, Cara was also performing sex work.
And so I have to point out that for at least some of that time, she was underage, which means that she was also a victim of trafficking herself.
But based on Chloe's account, Cara was a perpetrator as well.
It's not clear if she was working for Will and Jurel or with them or what the setup was.
But it doesn't appear that she was subjected to the same treatment as Chloe or the roster of other girls and young women that they were accused of trafficking, at least not in the time that Chloe saw.
So, what I know is that the FBI started investigating Jurel in the summer of 2013 after Chloe got into a dispute with someone at another hotel and police realized that she was underage.
So Jurel was arrested on federal sex trafficking charges a few months later.
And in 2015, he pled guilty to trafficking five victims, two of whom were minors and one of them was Chloe.
Now, he later tried to walk back that plea, but it didn't work.
And due to the severity of his crimes, along with past convictions for things like theft, drug, and gun possessions, he was ultimately sentenced to 25 years in prison.
Now, other traffickers were also convicted and a bunch of victims filed civil lawsuits against the hotel franchises where it all went down.
And it was actually court records from the various cases that help peel back the curtain on Francesca's story.
Because it turns out she comes up multiple times, sometimes by name, but also other times where the descriptions of circumstances are just so specific, they're almost certainly talking about her.
And, but I'm actually sent you a bunch of stuff that Nina found and I highlighted certain pieces that I'm talking about.
Can you just take a peek and summarize?
I mean, you can take a minute.
This is the beauty of podcasting.
Like, you can just pause and then like take it out and post or I can just like add some jeopardy.
Yes, music right here. No, no, that's that's unnecessary.
Give me a sec. Okay, so this one looks like it's from when the FBI question Jurel about Francesca back when he was arrested.
That was in October of 2013.
The questioning makes it seem like they think she was involved in sex work, but it's not really clear if they believe she was doing it voluntarily or if she was a victim of trafficking.
They're asking Jurel for information on the quote, unsolved murder of a prostitute in Atlantic City.
Yeah, and I'm not going to be able to read the whole thing like there's nothing specifying what if anything they learned from him.
But we know that there must have been something because during a deposition Chloe gave for the civil lawsuit later that we got records from.
An attorney implied that Jurel actually did offer evidence to the FBI specifically about Will's involvement in Francesca's death.
Now Chloe says she never met Francesca, but she did recall hearing that Francesca was involved in sex work and claimed that Will was her pimp.
And she knew that Will and Tara were the quote-unquote main two suspects in her disappearance.
Beyond that though, Chloe did not want to discuss the situation.
She seemed really freaked out.
She kind of flipped back and forth between outright refusing to talk about it to asking if she had to tell them what she knew to like saying she didn't know anything about it except for what she had heard on the news.
Oh, and something else that also came up during another deposition that might be related to Francesca?
There was this guy named Adrian, this hotel security guard who was convicted of conspiring with another sex trafficker.
And apparently Adrian mentioned a rumor that Jurel had a girl who didn't want to be part of their operation anymore.
Apparently this girl was planning to leave, even threatened to go to the police, and word on the street is that Jurel killed her and buried her body on a beach in New Jersey.
And the reason I say that that might be about Francesca rather than definitely is about her is that Adrian described the girl as white and we know that Francesca is his spanic.
But given everything else we know about this case, I mean there is a good chance he is talking about her.
Now those civil lawsuits were initially just aimed at the various hotel franchises.
The plaintiffs, the victims, argued that they turned a blind eye to the atrocities that were happening right under their roofs.
But the hotels dragged Jurel, Will and other traffickers into the fray as third party defendants.
They were basically saying like, hey it's not on us, like these guys are the ones responsible.
They planted opposed Jurel and Will, but it looks like it never came to that.
Because the cases were settled, and at the time of this recording 13 victims have been awarded a total of $86 million.
That's a huge victory totally.
Now the plaintiffs' attorneys said that the criminal process had already punished the traffickers.
The civil lawsuits were to hold the hotel owners accountable.
But that's only partially true, because for some reason Will was never charged with anything related to trafficking and neither was Tara, though again acknowledging the complexity of her situation.
I just want to be clear about what's happening legally.
Now all that to say, Will's not a free man.
In 2022, he pled guilty to federal charges including dealing firearms without a license and distributing fentanyl.
And that same year he was convicted in state court for various gun charges, terrorist threats, assault, and reckless endangerment.
And that was related to an incident during which he got into an argument with a man threatened to fire bomb his house and fired his gun.
So, dude said to be in state prison until 2028.
Okay, there's one thing that I just can't let go of with Will.
You said earlier that he didn't even know that Francesco was in Atlantic City that weekend.
I guess I can't figure out how he could then be involved in her death in Atlantic City.
I think it goes back to like what you pointed out at that time too, right?
Where it's like, we got that from Tara.
That's true. But I know that at some point over the years Mia confronted Tara and asked her about that again and Tara changed her story.
And said actually he did know she was there.
Plus Mia said Will had a car and he and Francesca had gone to Atlantic City for her 22nd birthday just the month before she disappeared.
So, I mean, he would have been at least somewhat familiar with the area.
But that doesn't mean that Will is the only potential culprit as far as I'm concerned Tracy's story still doesn't add up.
But police actually brought up an interesting theory to Francesca's family.
Before the record, Mia's not really like buying the story, but I think it's worth mentioning, even though the details of it are super hazy.
Basically, the theory is that Will and Francesca were planning to rob Tracy outside of the hotel that night.
But Tracy couldn't leave the room because his kids were there so like the robbery didn't happen.
Okay, how does that explain Francesca's death?
I think all it does is put Will there with her like at the time she was there.
So if this theory is right and Tracy's story is true like too big ifs, then she would have like left it to a clock in the morning presumably to meet up with Will not just to take a walk.
But then in my mind, I'm like, why would she invite Tracy if she's gonna like again, there's things like don't make sense to me, but this isn't coming for me.
There's like too many holes in that plot.
Yeah. Mia says that detectives imply that there were a couple of messages between Francesca and Will that may have led them in this direction.
But Mia hasn't seen the messages so it's really hard to say if there's anything solid backing this up.
And I don't have any idea if they have proof that Will was in the area that weekend.
Now New Jersey State Police denied our request for an interview.
They only answered a few questions in writing and they wouldn't tell us much about the current state of the investigation just that it's ongoing and active.
Our state police records request has been pending for months.
Meanwhile, Philadelphia police claim they have no records at all because I guess once they turned the case over to New Jersey, I don't know all their files went with it.
So I can't like, you know, give you more information on like where the areas are coming from or even what they're thinking now.
But I know what Francesca's family is thinking and to them, Will is now the most likely suspect in their minds.
They believe that he got angry when he found out about her trip that maybe he went to Atlantic City, possibly with Tara to confront Francesca, contacted her somehow asked her to come out and meet him.
And then they got into a fight, maybe something happened that they panicked and dumped her body in the ocean.
Now keep in mind Francesca was pregnant at the time that she went missing, which is a very dangerous time for women in abusive relationships.
I know we brought this up on the show before, but it's worth repeating.
Studies have found that women who are pregnant or who are recently pregnant are more likely to die by homicide than pregnancy related causes.
And they're frequently killed by a partner.
Did Will know she was pregnant?
Well, apparently yes, because he mentioned it to Francesca's father when the two men ran into each other in prison.
But the weird thing is is Mia says he told their father that she was six months pregnant, which is definitely not the case.
So I don't know where the miscommunication was there, but either way it seems like he was aware.
So if all of this hasn't been enough of a rollercoaster for Francesca's family, in January of 2023, something else happens.
Mia is scrolling through social media when suddenly she sees a post that stops her cold.
It is a missing person's fire for Tara.
What? Yeah, according to Tara's family, she left on the night of January 17th to go get groceries for dinner and then just never returned.
So they reported her missing a couple of days later.
Now, Tara's disappearance didn't spark the long drawn out search that we saw with Francesca's.
But like Francesca's story, this one didn't have a happy ending.
Tara was located on January 21st, but she had died of what Mia says was an overdose.
So her death is more than just a tragedy in this tingled web.
Mia had to face the reality that any pathway to answers that they hoped to find through her is now gone.
Sometimes Mia feels like all she does is investigate.
But she doesn't want the trauma to overshadow the good memories that she shared with her sister.
So their family does what they can to keep her spirit alive, especially for Francesca's daughter.
She was only a toddler when her mom disappeared.
Now she's navigating the hallways of the same high school Francesca once attended, even sharing the same writing teacher.
And actually through that connection, the universe recently dropped a bit of magic into their lives.
That teacher does this thing where she has her students write a journal entry every single day.
And by some miracle, she still had Francesca's journal.
No way. From more than 15 years ago.
Oh my god. So she gave it to Francesca's daughter.
180 days worth of Francesca's thoughts and feelings and teenage musings.
That is incredible. It's like she's getting a chance to meet her mom at the same age that she is now.
Yeah, the whole family was just blown away by this unexpected treasure trove of memories.
But even though they got this, like me I said she never could have imagined back when this all began.
That they would still be waiting for answers and for someone to be held accountable more than a dozen years later.
And she's hoping that maybe our crime junkies can help.
That this episode reaches the very people who might know more.
So maybe you were in Atlantic City for St.
Patrick's Day weekend in 2012 and saw something.
A couple arguing on a boardwalk or a young woman with long dark curly hair walking around in the early morning hours.
Maybe you never realized that you had a piece of the puzzle this whole time.
If you have any information about Francesca Alvarado or any of the people in her orbit, please contact the New Jersey Police Tip Line at 833-4-NJ-Cold.
Or you can contact them by email at coldcaseatngsp.gov.
You can find all the source material for this episode on our website, crimejunkiepodcast.com.
And you can follow us on Instagram at crimejunkiepodcast.
We'll be back next week with a brand new episode.
Crimejunkie is an audio check production.
