The phrase that is used often is, you can't love me the way I want to be loved.
That's the recurring thing throughout the years.
None of the voices in this series are ongoing patients of Esther Perel.
Each episode of Where Should We Begin is a one-time counseling session.
For the purposes of maintaining confidentiality, Names and some identifiable characteristics have been removed, but their voices and their stories are real.
Support for the show comes from Focus Features and their new film Downton Abbey, the grand finale.
Glamour, romance, scandal.
Downton Abbey returns for one final unforgettable event.
It's 1930 and as a new era begins, the future of Downton is at stake.
Lady Mary is thrust into public scandal and shocking revelations shake the family to its core.
This isn't just a movie, it's a moment.
The time has come to say goodbye and everything has led to this.
See Downton Abbey, the grand finale, on the biggest screen possible only in theaters September 12th.
Support for the show comes from Paramount+.
Now streaming on Paramount.
Hunted by hackers, stalked by assassins and wanted by international police, Tony and Ziva are on the run and getting some action.
Car chases, killer drones, prison breaks, good thing espionage is their love language.
Get ready for the ultimate romantic escape with the premiere of NCIS Tony and Ziva now streaming on Paramount.
When a couple comes to see me, there's often one person who has reached out, and that person is either familiar with the process of a therapy session or is curious, at least open-minded, about it.
And the other person is often someone who is sometimes more skeptical, or that's not the world they live in.
They've never been in any therapeutic process before.
And they're showing up as an expression of love.
I want you to know that I care about us.
And that's why I'm here.
It's not because I want to be here.
It's because I want to be with you.
And this couple, they don't know where they stand.
Everything is fraught.
One moment, it feels like they're in, and the next moment, everything unravels.
It's a very, very shaky ground where I meet them.
I think what I'm looking for, The reason why I applied in the first place.
We had, you know, one of our, one of many fights, the latest.
Right.
And I said, you know, something needs to change.
Either we go to therapy and we actually truly work on this, or we just stay friends, raise the kid together and like clear boundaries.
We're not together yet.
Or we strictly co-parent.
We're not friends.
We don't talk.
Those are kind of my three options.
I have to tell you I am shocked that we are here right now, because I never thought it would actually happen.
He, as usual, said, why is it always you go too far?
You do too much.
Why?
Why?
Why?
You know, but I thought.
The analogy I gave you he's a car guy was if you had the chance to meet with a renowned car builder, wouldn't you?
This is a chance and an opportunity to see things a different way, to get a different perspective.
And I know I can tell you our problems from now until next Friday.
Can I ask you something?
In the midst of explaining to him why you did and why he should appreciate it, did you also tell him how much you appreciate that he's just coming along?
No.
All right.
Maybe that's where we start.
Yeah, I am shocked, and I do appreciate that you actually went along with this.
I'm very curious as to your motivation.
So it's kind of funny you mention that.
No, we're going to do this differently.
One moment.
Is it okay?
Because you just did what you typically both do.
In this case, it's you.
It could be him.
You explained yourself.
You justified yourself.
Then you told him why he should appreciate what you do.
And the piece that is missing is actually just simply, I know whatever I did.
And whatever you may think about it, it really means a lot that you're here.
I appreciate you actually doing this.
Yeah.
You're welcome.
And those are the little things that, you know, we talk about this often.
Stay here.
Not what happens often.
It just happened.
Okay.
Stay with that.
I know I throw things at you all the time and I'm spinning.
And that you thought this was another spin.
And I appreciate you just going with it and not saying, F you, there's no way.
You're out of your mind.
You're crazy.
I do appreciate you just going along with my crazy for once.
Yeah, you're welcome.
It's okay.
My first thought.
And I know this is wrong.
No, don't go there.
Okay.
If it's more of the same, if it's what you usually do which you both actually is the one thing you steadfastly agree on that it really doesn't work.
Then don't do it.
Oh, okay.
You need change. are you feeling it's nice that you know the acknowledgement of me being here is a you know i'm trying i'm not trying to blame you all the time for everything you know it's just it's it's nice that you see that that little thing that i did was it's actually fighting for a relationship And that's how I show, you know, that I love and respect you is by doing things like that.
But it just never gets.
It just did.
It did.
You're absolutely right.
Go to the never.
Yeah.
I hear what you're saying, you know, and it's nice.
And I frequently only see things through my lens.
Like he didn't, he didn't, he didn't, he didn't.
And it's hard for me to see.
Oh, he did, because he acknowledges that i'm asking for this and that i.
He said more to you.
He said i'm fighting for our relationship.
Oh, but i, i hear that, but My brain immediately goes to the other 300000 things that you're not.
And that's I think my acts of service and my acts of showing love and respect you don't receive because you just think that that is like I guess like baseline like that's like entry level.
Yeah.
And like you're.
I guess you would call it quote unquote love languages like being wined and dined and lots of attention being spent, affection and you know that kind of stuff.
And I'm more of a service oriented person, you know, fixing your faucets.
Still got to do that.
I get that.
I get that.
But I was raised, you know those were the things that were done within a relationship that show, you know, love and respect and care.
Care for one another is when you're doing.
It's just everyday, mundane things that, to me, show the most.
I don't think to take you, you know, on your 600 hour dinners and you know, that kind of stuff, to me that's, you know, that doesn't really show anybody can do.
That, you know, it's something that's not a shared thing that you want to do, but knowing back to you no no no, but i'm not allowed to say that.
Okay, it's not that you're not allowed to say, but you can't allow to say anything.
But i'm doing the bad too when people are trapped in the back and forth between blame and defensiveness and attack.
When they actually acknowledge something, what they've been asking for is actually right there.
It's so difficult for us to actually stay in that moment.
We instantly go to the usually.
But the other times, but yesterday, but the thousands of other things I want from you that you're not doing.
I think this session is a session that everybody can relate to.
We've all done this and been there, some version or another.
We start by creating a different quality of listening.
You both say a ton of things, but you don't listen well.
And listening shapes the talking.
The quality of each of your listening is what shapes the quality and the kind of talking that comes back from the other side.
My friend Paul Brody describes speaking is what enters into the bowl.
It's the thing that you pour into a bowl.
But listening, is the shape of the bowl that actually defines where the water or where the words will land.
So said in another way.
He says something how I listen to it, interpret it, understand it, internalize.
It is what is important there.
Essential.
And vice versa.
Right.
So, before we do this loop, something that I want to clarify.
You are divorced, correct.
You were married, you were married.
We were married for eight years.
You divorced about a year, almost two years ago.
You're okay and now we're.
Do you want to tell the story real quick?
What do you mean?
She's just asking if we're like back together or not.
I don't know what.
Yeah, so we're together, so i, we do not.
I do not know either Really.
Yeah.
Oh, okay.
I thought we were, like, dating, trying to figure it out.
The trying to figure it out is what confuses me.
I don't know what that means.
So my answer would be, yes, we split up for about a year.
I moved with our son about 10, 15 minutes away.
We stayed very close.
How many are you?
Right.
I have two older and then we have a son together.
And the two older are now out of college and whatnot.
How old is the son that you have together?
Nine.
Okay.
And lives with you.
Okay.
Yeah.
So...
We were, you know, ups and downs.
There was, of course, some animosity through the divorce proceedings.
Of course, yeah.
Yeah.
But at the end of the day, we were working pretty well together.
Now, I have to bring it up.
I started dating, I guess, last summer.
And he found out about it immediately.
Like, didn't came to me and said you were sorry for a lot of the stuff that went on in our marriage first time he ever said and immediately I was like come here we're done let's try immediately like there was in hindsight I'm not even gonna go there but there was no questions right on your yeah that but you said i'm sorry and i was like okay right and then like we went right back into it and that wasn't my intention like i was i that was my that was honestly my moment of letting go and letting her move on and finding what she needs because in my mind we are very different people What do you think it said that when you came and you took some responsibility over some of the things that you thought were yours, that that opened her heart unequivocally?
Yeah.
What did that say?
I know we love each other, right?
I know that.
I know that 100 percent.
I'm not fighting against, you know, is she a bad person or is she worthy or anything like that?
Like it's it's nothing to do with that.
It's just literally how we interact on a daily basis, which I'm not going to do that to myself again.
And I did realize like when I was apologizing to her throughout the divorce.
I was never at peace with myself because of all the internal conflict within our relationship.
And when I found that peace again, I realized like oh, I did a lot of things that were spiteful stubborn, that did not contribute to a smooth relationship.
And I realized that.
That's what I was apologizing for.
Things kind of just went from there.
And then once we got back into it, I mean, I don't even think it was 30 days.
And I started noticing like, oh, we're right back in this cycle.
May I ask you?
Sure.
Stubborn, spiteful.
What do you know about it?
In you?
In me?
Yeah.
For a very long time.
Instead of trying to eradicate that from my consciousness, I relied on it to get me through a lot of hard times.
In life?
In life, yes.
Regardless of her?
Yep.
Good.
Can you tell me more about that?
Um, yeah, I mean, that's just how I was raised.
I got a very sketchy background.
Give me the brief story.
Um, mother had me when she was 17.
Um, probably I'm a product of rape.
I'm pretty sure, you know, my biological father was a Vietnam veteran.
Obviously we were called PTSD nowadays druggy alcoholic.
Committed suicide when my sister was born.
So I was 18 months old.
My mom met my stepfather, who great man you know.
But again, blue collar Irish you know, for lack of a better term, white trash you know, like very.
You know dock workers, you know that kind of stuff.
So we were raised in that environment, biker gang.
Father moved us out to a small suburban town and we just paycheck to paycheck.
He was always working.
My mother kind of had her problems with addiction and just coping with her past life.
And we just grew up kind of yelling and fighting and very loud.
It just was how I was raised.
Some of it was a gift.
Some of it left me with bad coping mechanisms and traits and that kind of stuff.
I never went to college.
I fought my way into the corporate world, did very well for myself, opened up my own business.
I never would be able to do those things if I wasn't raised how I was raised.
With that stubbornness, the fighting every day for what you want.
It's my past.
You can't do nothing about it.
It is what it is.
Except that it's not your past.
It's my present and future too.
I get it.
When you look back, the kid who was in a rather chaotic environment and who needed to have a clear sense of what the hell is going on here.
Right, how old is he who?
Five through twenty, if you pick one moment um, eight or nine, eight or nine, eight or nine.
There was a pretty big incident.
Yeah, that happened in the house.
Tell me what you see.
Oh, so he was.
Um, my dad came home pretty tuned up one night and uh, my mom always had a problem with his drinking because of her past.
Alcoholism ran, ran rampant through the family.
So she was trying to deal with that clean up, get away from that herself stage.
So, like my dad wouldn't even be able to have one or two beers and when it did, it was a problem.
She would dig at him.
You know, push him, push him, push him, push him.
And uh, she pushed him way too far one night and uh, it's okay.
You just saw it.
I watched.
You know he didn't hit her but he definitely, you know, threw her on the bed and then he had like a nervous breakdown and it was just like, you know, his voice went up like 10 octaves, sounded like a woman.
You know just why are you doing this to me?
And you know, and at the time, like I, I didn't know what to do.
So I ran out of the house and uh, my neighbor who kind of raised me like as a second son, he was outside, so i yelled and come running over and he, like he broke things up and he took my dad out of the house and you know, that was just kind of like what?
What the fuck moment?
You know what is what is going on here.
So yeah, that was kind of like i guess would be the the start of fixing.
Fixing yeah yeah, it was rough And my mom is a tough woman man.
Like, she's a tough cookie.
And I argue with her.
And I make it a point to argue with her.
But to this day, we still go back and forth.
Any resonance with the way you argue with your wife?
I'm loud.
I'm loud.
I don't scream.
Like, I'm not.
She considers it screaming.
She comes from a very soft household, you know, soft smoking.
My volume, it's not an indicator of my emotion.
But your nine-year-old today, if he hears you yell like that or raise your voice like that, He gets upset.
He gets upset.
Yeah, he definitely recoils a little bit.
So when you see him, you can see you.
Me?
You can see the nine-year-old.
The nine-year-old version of you and when you want to, you want to understand the effect you have on him.
Right, that scene will help you.
Yeah yeah, because you felt it in your nervous system just now.
Yeah, and you saw it and you were right back there.
You were not just remembering, you were reliving.
Yeah, that is true.
So then, tell me how the growth of these three responses stubborn defensive, spiteful tell me about them.
How did they become so important, so necessary, And what do you think you fight for?
Not what you fight about.
I just fight the fight.
If I see something wrong or if I think somebody's being slighted, I'm going to fight.
Yes, that's an easy one.
But since you fight just for a separate opinion, you fight.
I fight.
You fight and every conversation is life or death.
Mm-hmm, me or you?
Yeah, so it's not just when you see it wrong or injustice.
Every difference is turned into conflict.
No okay, no.
So i honestly do value other people's opinions and i am always in for a healthy debate.
Like i'm, i am very open-minded to different thoughts and views.
You know, When things are thoughts and views and not actual problems, I guess, like if you have to, if there's a problem that needs to be solved, you know, I know that this is going to solve this problem.
I will fight to get that problem solved.
But in your mind, it's totally obvious that that difference of opinion is something to fight over.
This was a super important moment because I actually was amplifying on what he had just said.
I fight the fight.
But something in the way I worded it.
He didn't recognize himself when I said any difference can be a source of conflict, even though it's exactly where they go right after.
And he says, I disagree.
And that was very important because it meant he feels safe enough, he trusts me enough that he can fight with me.
Not really fight, but that he can disagree with me and hold his own.
And that is so important.
We have to take a brief break.
Stay with us.
Support for the show comes from Paramount+.
Now streaming on Paramount.
Hunted by hackers, stalked by assassins and wanted by international police, Tony and Ziva are on the run and getting some action.
Car chases, killer drones, prison breaks, good thing espionage is their love language.
Get ready for the ultimate romantic escape with the premiere of NCIS Tony and Ziva now streaming on Paramount.
You're basking on a beach in the Bahamas.
Now you're journeying through the jade forests of Japan.
Now you're there for your alma mater's epic win.
And now you're awake.
Which means it was all a dream.
But with millions of incredible deals on Priceline, those travel dreams can be a reality.
Download the Priceline app today and you can save up to 60% off hotels and up to 50% off flights.
So don't just dream about that trip.
Book it with Priceline.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start?
Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to.
Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is.
With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro.
You just have to hire one.
You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app.
Download today.
The Philadelphia fight was a good one.
That would be a great example.
It's the reason why I applied.
This fight.
This fight is what triggered it off.
That's nice.
How did you come here?
The Philadelphia fight.
The Philadelphia fight, yeah.
Yeah, chapter one.
All right, chapter one.
I'm all ears.
So we were vacationing.
Don't give me the long version.
Okay, yeah.
So basically, we were coming back from Quebec, and we were stuck in the car together for 10 hours.
And we got on to – I despise sports.
I hate them.
So somebody said Philadelphia fans have the reputation of destroying the city, whether they win or not over a football game.
And I was like, that's trash.
Like those people – that's trash to me.
Chapter two?
Chapter two is her – This is – so –
It was Super Bowl Sunday.
I'm a huge Eagles fan.
Family, we're all Eagles fans.
And yes, I think it's funny.
And I think it's... Okay, chapter three.
Yeah.
He said...
People in Philadelphia are trash.
I'm a higher caliber.
They are gross.
Even if you're not doing that, you're still condoning it by saying it's funny, blah, blah, blah.
And I said, it doesn't bother me.
I think Philadelphia is fantastic. culture, the food.
It's a great scene.
It's gritty.
It's dirty.
I love it.
Chapter five.
And she definitely said that.
And I did not take it like that.
Okay.
What I heard was is she started, instead of looking at the the, the generalization that I was making, she started giving me examples of why my generalization was wrong.
And she, Which any generalization I take technically wrong.
Right.
And she started giving me specific examples of why.
I didn't agree.
Didn't agree.
And then his voice got raised and then I shut down.
Right.
Yeah.
Thank you.
Now, what happens in this argument?
If I lift the hood, I know squat about cars, but I'm going to try a metaphor with you.
I lift the hood and I'm saying, what is going on here?
What would you say?
Why is this guy personalizing this whole thing?
So in my mind I was voicing an opinion of myself and others that it could have been.
Yeah yeah, I see what you're saying.
And yeah, I don't agree with that, but you know it wasn't that, it was she.
She had to try to prove my generalization wrong, which it's an opinion.
It's not wrong.
And then she starts trying to change my opinion.
And that's where I'm like, no, like I'm not, you know, That's that's how I took it.
But why did you take it personally?
You did, too.
I did.
And I fully I was telling the story to my mom and she was like, are you out of your mind?
And I said, what do you mean?
She goes, just be like, cool, cool.
Give him the double finger and you're done.
Which was and it's funny she says that because after the debacle happened.
I was like, all right, let me change the subject.
We'll move on.
And I tried breaking bread, extending the olive branch, and I got, I just want to go home.
At which point we sat in the car silent for 10 hours which, with the kid in the back, is now making him think like whoa.
This isn't good.
And then I started thinking of course we're riding home in silence, like Here we are again.
You know same shit from five years ago.
Do I really want to repeat this cycle?
Do I really want to get on this carousel and continue this?
And I voiced my opinion about that.
And then it turns into, well, then just break up with me.
Just break up.
I'm like, no, that's not what I'm.
This is the pattern that I see.
And tell me where I'm wrong here.
No, no, no, no, no.
Don't set it up.
You're setting it up for a battle before you've even said a word.
Oh, I didn't think about that.
You invite each other into a boxing ring.
We do.
We do.
You are not nearly that different as he thinks you are.
You do the same back and forth, and each one of you is making the other one do more of the exact thing that you don't want them to do.
Yes.
You are not different, and your differences are not your problem.
No.
Your differences of opinion or of tastes or of background, that is not what is problematic.
What's problematic that I see now, just on a very short chapter one, is that you escalate in no time.
You personalize everything.
You don't distinguish between facts or subjective opinion, experience, feelings.
It's all one and the same.
You live in an antagonistic, adversarial world.
Framework.
And underneath that is deep feelings, deep love, deep care, deep appreciation.
But boy, they don't get to see the sun very often.
Yeah.
And the two of you live like two threatened people.
And your boy sits in the back of the car and watches this for 10 hours.
And he is looking at you.
And no matter what you decide, together or not together lovers, not lovers, all of that you will have to think what do we show him?
Yeah.
Yeah?
Yeah.
Because what you show him is what you watched in your version of it.
Different story, but the nine-year-old is the nine-year-old.
Right.
And that nine-year-old is terrified.
That nine-year-old doesn't know what to do with what's in front of him.
Yeah.
Whether they are on shutdown mode and don't say a word to each other, or whether they are in explosion pounding mode.
Yeah.
Here was a moment where I made a choice.
Which was I could have continued in the exploration of the child that lives inside each of them.
That is that threatened child that feels that they have to fight for themselves all the time.
But I was also thinking about the actual child that they have that is sitting for 10 hours in the car with his parents not uttering a single word.
And I thought, I'm going to talk to the parents instead.
I'm going to talk to the adults.
And hopefully the adult part of them can hear me in this moment.
I'm going to rally for them and with them about engaging the more mature, responsible adult part inside of them.
Even though I know that I would need to help them have a different relationship with the part of them that is that child that they once were.
But I'm going to park myself temporarily in this spot.
You punch at each other.
Yes.
I escalate.
You want to come at me?
I'm going to come right back at you.
And I'm going to beat you.
And we're very competitive in that way.
What's your line?
Nobody's going to make me what?
Do anything.
Every personality test I've ever taken for work, I have to be in control.
I do not like people telling me or I'm going to do it my way. everything's fine.
I'm going to figure out a way.
I'm going to do it my way.
My way's better.
I can figure this out.
And what's the story behind that?
I think I've always just been an overachiever.
My parents never worried about me.
I'm fine.
I'm going to get straight A's.
I'm going to be in this program and that program.
I'm going to do it this, that, and the other.
Until teenager, they split up and I rebelled, definitely rebelled.
How?
Boys, drugs, teenage stuff, skipping school.
And then I waitressed and I hustled.
I had two kids young and got into the industry I'm in now and just used...
I'm an insurance sales, corporate, very corporate environment.
I have to hustle and I can do it.
And it's not easy when I come to him with the complaints that I think most people have about their jobs.
I don't want him to tell me.
And instead of being open to his feedback, I get resentful.
Because I don't need you to tell me how to fix it.
Of course I have it under control.
This is me.
It's under control.
I get mad.
You do?
I get very upset when you talk about your job.
And I do.
Because she is in the top 1% earners of the country.
She makes an extremely amount of money.
With no college degree.
She got there because of who she is.
But then when she's bitching about her job and like these little menial things that piss her off, I'm just like you are so ungrateful.
You're crazy.
People would kill to have your job and to be where you're at right now.
Appreciate it.
And That starts a fight.
That's a recurrent one.
Yeah, that's a recurrent one.
That's like a huge thing.
And it's just like, you know.
It's any time I have a feeling.
I have a feeling.
I feel scared and hurt and lonely sometimes.
Your feelings aren't valid.
So don't feel that way.
Well, that goes back to the beginning of the conversation, where she's not recognizing my acts of service as caring, loving acts.
And I guess I'm not the most affectionate person.
I'm not.
I'm not a PDA guy.
When she had her hand on your shoulder before, did you feel it?
I did, but like because of the position we're in right now and the amount of uncertainty doesn't feel genuine.
It doesn't feel like she's like reaching out to come for me or anything.
I don't know how to take it.
You know, I just don't know.
I don't know how to.
That's different.
Yeah, that's very different from it.
Doesn't feel genuine, is not the same, as I'm afraid to believe in it.
I'm afraid what it means.
I'm afraid to surrender to it.
You're probably afraid to actually accept it, because it's what I so long for.
Yeah, and they're still, you know, like She's, so she's very emotional.
Right.
She is very emotional.
So in moments of emotion like this, you know it's hard to discover because she can flip and she can be very cold.
Right.
So it's what am I getting into?
What is going on here?
So I definitely kind of recoil and.
That probably actually makes me more callous, because I don't know how to react or what she's looking for.
So you both hold each other on high alert all the time.
Oh, I'm so scared.
She can go from hot to cold, but you can go from supportive to callous.
Yeah.
And you wonder why this doesn't feel very safe. and why it becomes so impossible to trust.
Because if I accept and trust and lean into what's happening just now, God forbid what may happen in the second after that.
I didn't anticipate.
So I'm just going to keep myself in the boxing ring.
I'm going to avoid he runs.
I just don't want to fight.
You drop the bomb and run.
Mm-hmm.
And you're right into the I'm hot and cold.
I will scream, I love you.
This hurt my feelings.
And then when I realized it's not happening, I'm not getting the reaction.
He's not hearing me.
I...
I go internal.
I shut it down and I'm like, well, then app you.
I'm not calling you back.
I'm not talking to you.
And it's in my head.
And then I spin for days, days.
And then I'm scared.
Each of them. is able to describe their behavior, what they do, what happens to them.
They may not necessarily connect the dots to what is actually being activated for them, but they are very insightful and honest and able to be accountable for it.
So the choice here again, I decide I'm going to emphasize the similarities.
I'm going to emphasize similarities.
What they do well, because they're so mired in the mud and in what's broken, and they are divorced and they have come with one question are we salvageable?
We are in the midst of our session, but there is still so much, So stay with us.
New fall arrivals are at Nordstrom Rack stores now.
Get ready to save big with up to 60% off Vince, Kurt Geiger London and more.
How did I not know Rack has Adidas?
Because there's always something new.
Join the Nordic Club at Nordstrom Rack to unlock exclusive discounts on your favorite brands.
Shop new arrivals first and more.
Plus, get an extra 5% off every rack purchase with a Nordstrom credit card.
Great brands, great prices.
That's why you rack.
Support for the show comes from Focus Features and their new film, Downton Abbey, The Grand Finale.
Glamour, romance, scandal.
Downton Abbey returns for one final unforgettable event.
It's 1930 and as a new era begins, the future of Downton is at stake.
Lady Mary is thrust into public scandal and shocking revelations shake the family to its core.
This isn't just a movie, it's a moment.
The time has come to say goodbye and everything has led to this.
See Downton Abbey, the grand finale, on the biggest screen possible only in theaters September 12th.
This episode is brought to you by Swiped, a Hulu original from 20th Century Studios.
Starring Lily James as Whitney Wolfe, the visionary founder of Bumble.
Through extraordinary grit and ingenuity, Whitney breaks into the male-dominated tech industry and launches an innovative, globally lauded dating app.
Forever changing dating culture.
A Hulu original.
Swiped.
Streaming September 19th on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers.
Terms apply.
So here's the thing I want to highlight just for a moment.
You have managed to talk about your relationship highs and lows, mine and yours in a very collaborative way.
You've managed to talk about your dance without slipping into it.
And you're able to say, I know I do this and I know I do that.
So this, to me, is goal number one.
Because it doesn't matter what you're going to do.
If you don't change the filter, the gutter will get more full.
Yeah.
And you miss each other.
Yeah.
And you're persistent.
You've done this for 10 years, Scott.
It's not like you met yesterday.
Let me ask you this.
If each of you could pick one thing that you know.
If you did it differently, the relationship would shift.
What would it be?
Let her go first on this one.
What I think would change our relationship that you would like to focus on.
It's.
It's noticing you for you and being curious about what brought you there, what brought you to.
When you say a statement oh, where'd that come from?
Oh, tell me about that, without preparing a dissertation on why you should consider other things and why that's not technically correct.
It would be literally just Being curious about where you're going and appreciating what you're saying, without trying to prove you wrong.
Even when we have very different opinions.
When you start off on a political rant, and I shouldn't even call them rants, I guess.
Yeah, it comes out as a rant.
But I'm talking myself through it.
I might not have the conclusion in my head right then and there.
I wish you could just take a step back and say, am I perceiving this wrong?
I'm struggling big time right now because I think that if you were to go into the court of evidence, if you were to say here, let me present the evidence.
Does this man care about this woman?
And put the evidence in front.
Unanimously, the answer is no.
Is it?
Is it?
That's my perception.
Right.
Or could somebody look at it from the other lens and say you know, he does this, he does this, he does this, he does this.
And they can point to things that I do to show that I do appreciate you and love you.
I know that I should see what you do as love in my brain.
I'd rather you sit on the couch with me.
I'd rather be infected.
There's so many other things.
I miss you.
And we have been connected in so long.
I know.
Because you're angry.
I'm not angry.
I'm not angry.
Again, I just...
May I?
Yes.
Thank you.
When you talk together, and look how long you do and it goes fine.
But then there is that moment where one of you says one thing the other one doesn't agree with.
And of the nine things you agree with, you don't say a thing.
But on the one thing that you can't see yourself reflected in, that's the one you pick up on.
Okay.
So that is going to create more distance.
I don't think you did this consciously, by the way.
I don't think you intended this at all.
That's why I'm highlighting it for you.
So in my mind, what happened there was You wanted to reassure her that you're not mad and that she doesn't, And then spill into the reasons why.
Yeah, that's more of the explanation.
You are so mired in explaining yourself and justifying yourself and being sure it's accurate.
When, in fact, if you actually said me too i don't know if it's true, but if it's true, i do that you say i too miss us and miss connecting, you would have a whole different moment.
Yeah, that's it.
Yeah, i understand what you're saying.
Okay, shall we try it again?
Yes, all right, i want those things too, like i really do.
That's why i'm here, you know, i want us to have, I want that spark.
I want that intimacy.
It's hard sometimes, you know, it, it, it really is like, I'm, I'm, you know, I told you this before we came here, like I'm, I'm very on the defense and I don't know what's going to happen.
And breaking up again would just be like going through the whole divorce again.
And I don't you know in my brain I guess that thinks that if I keep a certain distance it's not going to suck as much if we don't work out.
And I also know, and I also know that, you know, that is not helping the situation.
So, you know, everything that I did to you before with everything, That I did when we were married.
It wasn't all bad.
I don't want to do it.
I don't want to do it either.
The reason I'm here is I want to be able, I want you to see me differently.
Not like I'm this needy, difficult person.
I don't necessarily think you're a needy, difficult person.
I don't like the person I was perceived as in the relationship.
I was always the bad guy.
I don't want to go back there.
You were the bad guy.
No, you're right.
I'm agreeing with you.
I'm not saying I'm agreeing with you.
I did always demonize you.
I did always say, aren't I perfect?
The question I would like to ask you is it's one thing to say nobody's going to make me, but it's another thing.
To ask yourself, why do I need to be perfect?
Oh, because fundamentally you think you're always right or misjudged.
You operate from a place of, I can't make mistakes.
This is why this curiosity bit is so important for you.
Because it puts you in a zone of not knowing for a moment, of being uncertain, of being open to the unknown, to exploring, to discovering that there's something else, rather than needing to know immediately.
It's annoying.
I annoy myself with it.
But that started early on.
Yeah.
I mean, I'm holding this daughter, so there's that.
And I was just the good one, the responsible one, the one that handles it.
And even now i'm the one who plans family vacations for our extended family and pays for it and organizes everything and makes dinner reservations, and then i get i didn't even really get a thank you for that.
I get resentful i do it at work too that i have to be perfect.
The expectation of the best is there.
I feel it internally all day, every day.
I am thinking about what I have to do next.
What is the best?
How can I manipulate the situation to get what I want?
To get what I think is the best thing?
The war in my head says if he would just let me do it, everything would be great.
And adore you for it.
Yes, please, please, please.
You know, let me do it.
And then say thank you very much for doing that.
And then be really, really loving and affectionate.
And anything short of that crushes you.
Oh, I feel it.
I feel it.
I feel very judged and unloved and feel like I'm a failure.
By you or by him?
By him.
The phrase that is used often is...
You can't love me the way I want to be loved.
That's the recurring thing throughout the years.
When I listen to her, I'm reminded of the drama of The Gifted Child.
It's a book I read a long time ago by Alice Miller.
It's the book that really introduced me to the concept of conditional love.
It's not that she needs to be perfect.
It's only as much as how perfect do I need to be before I can finally receive the love of my parents?
That is the conditional love.
I can only be loved if I'm pleasing, if I satisfy you.
If I take care of you, if I do everything and if I do it so perfect that you don't have to worry about me one split second.
She said this now a few times.
I do everything.
Nobody has to worry about me.
I raised myself and I am left with the whole wondering, what does it take to be loved?
And that's why she says, you can't love me the way I want to be loved.
And I chose that. as the title for the session.
Because if we were to meet again, this is where we would go.
How were you unloved?
What is it that you're wanting him to make up for?
What is the rage that kicks in for you every time?
He misses the clue and he, in a way, reinforces your worst belief about yourself.
That no matter how perfect and accomplished and worthy and responsible you are, you still can't be loved the way you want to.
And then you find yourself a partner who keeps telling you, I love you plenty, but I do it this way.
I do it with service.
I do it this way.
And unbeknownst to him.
Every time he says but this is my love language, he's reinforcing your belief that he really cannot love you the way that you want to.
And that's one of the pain points of this relationship.
So you each do things that actually make the other person respond in the way that you actually want the least.
Yes.
Yes.
Right?
So I have to start from a place of appreciating what is done.
It would change a lot.
Do you think it would change a lot with how you interact with me?
Yeah, I mean, any difference is going to enact a change.
But that means that each of you needs to decide, I'm going to do this.
This is back to the question I asked you before.
What's one thing you would do differently?
Because, in effect, where you land in the gutter is that each of you feels rejected, unappreciated and rejected.
Yes.
If that's the case, you have your answer about whether you should stay together or not.
On the other end, that doesn't mean that you're going to do better with somebody else, because these are skills you need to learn.
And you can explain them from the past and we can do a lot of insight, which that is what you would also do with a therapist.
But ultimately, there needs to be a change in the way you respond.
And that means in the way you listen.
Do you ever speak with your hands?
Do you reach out with your hands too much?
I don't touch people.
I'm not like that.
You don't touch at all?
I don't really do calming, soothing.
None of it.
That doesn't really work for me.
Meaning?
I don't need that.
I don't need to be touched.
I don't need to feel needed or wanted or comfortable, accepted.
Yeah, i guess, because i don't need it, i don't give it, which i know is probably a problem.
Yeah, does your boy need it?
What's that?
Does your little boy need it?
Yeah, he comes up to me a lot, right.
He comes up and he'll snuggle me.
I'll snuggle him right back, you know, but if it's not initiated, i don't.
So you see him.
That was once you.
Yeah.
You need it.
You may have learned not to.
Probably.
You may have had hands put on you that didn't feel very clear.
Yeah.
I was hit a lot.
By?
Parents.
Parents both.
Yeah, but i fully deserved it.
And that's kind of where i think she thinks i'm going to go there, but i don't.
I don't really have the need to go where, like hitting kids and stuff i'd kill you and i know it makes me super uncomfortable at the times you have hitting.
Yeah, It was just a spanking, like don't do that again, kind of thing.
It wasn't like fit of rage or anything like that.
It's scary, though.
You know it is.
I know where you're coming from and I know what you're.
But when you get upset, it's scary for him, for me.
You're very intimidating and scary person.
Yeah.
And I'm like the timid one in the family.
I don't do.
Half the stuff my parents did.
That just means that they did more extreme things.
Yeah.
And that your body shut down.
I've noticed the only time he will touch me voluntarily is if we're having sex.
Or about to have sex.
Or you want to have sex.
It's the only time.
It really doesn't dawn on me.
Again, because I don't need that to feel a certain way.
Listen.
I feel close.
There may be times when you're not thirsty.
But you may offer someone a glass of water.
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
So this notion of i don't need it, therefore i don't do it and therefore this is it.
Oh no no no, i'm not saying that at all.
I do realize that i probably should do that because she needs that, like absolutely, but it's just not.
It wasn't programmed into me to do that.
No, it was programmed out of you, out of me.
It was programmed out of me.
It was programmed out of you.
Yeah, Whatever you see when you look at your little nine-year-old is quite similar to what you once needed and loved.
Right.
That makes sense.
Yeah.
And there's no doubt that, on the moments when she's spinning and getting agitated or anxious, to hold her and not say anything would go a long way.
Yeah.
Because it would communicate in the most basic way, you're not alone.
I'm right here.
Right.
You don't have to hold it all on your shoulders.
I would hear that or feel that as so much more comforting than you telling me how to fix it.
It would help you tremendously and it would change the whole cycle.
But you also need to know that when you emote yeah, for him that signals shutdown.
I know, i don't know why though, because that's what it was like there, so it really has nothing to do with me being.
It's the implicit memory.
It does have to do with you, because you are agitated, But his response to you doesn't come from you.
His response comes from how he learned to protect himself, basically.
So he shuts down.
At a time when you would want him to put his arms around you is when his shoulders go up, his neck goes down, his tension comes in, his breath becomes more shallow.
Shut every feeling down and use intellect. which of course doesn't work on you at all.
It just makes you more agitated, which is making him repeat himself for the entire time and reason again, because everything else is really holding it together.
And he has a nine-year-old, but so do you.
And these nine-year-olds end up, having a relationship with each other.
Yeah.
So the adults need to calm them down.
While you're asking something that is totally legit and understandable, there's also a part of you that may want to even go to him and say I'm all over the place, hold me.
You can even ask.
Or you can learn to hold you for a moment so that you can come down one notch, which then gives his body a different message, which may allow him to then come more closer.
You know, this is a circle, yeah.
So whichever place you do a small shift, all the other pieces will need to adjust.
Thank you.
Where Should We Begin with Esther Perel is produced by Magnificent Noise.
We're part of the Vox Media Podcast Network in partnership with New York Magazine and The Cut.
Our production staff includes Eric Newsom, Destry Sibley, Sabrina Farhi, Kristen Muller and Julianne.
Original music and additional production by Paul Schneider.
And the executive producers of Where Should We Begin are Esther Perel and Jesse Baker.
We'd also like to thank Courtney Hamilton, Mary Alice Miller, and Jack Saul.
Thank you.
Hello, Spotify.
We interrupt your playlist for an important Journeys announcement.
They say a remix never hits like the original.
We took that personally.
Gus Dapperton covered You Get What You Give and recreated the OG video.
Click the banner, turn it up, forget the rules.
This is your anthem of self-expression.
Journeys, life on loud.
Everything feels a bit uncertain right now.
A few months ago, you never would have expected eggs being factored into your monthly budget.
New sources of stress equal more opportunities for breakouts to strike.
Luckily, Mighty Patch Original shrinks the look of pimples in just one use.
We'd say that's a pretty good deal.
Shop Mighty Patch at all major retail
