Hey weirdos, it's Ash here, ready to share a little secret.
Have you heard of Wondery Plus? With ad free episodes and one week early access, it's like having an all access pass to our lighthearted nightmare.
So come join us on the dark side and try Wondery Plus today.
You can join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or in Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
You're listening to a morbid network podcast.
Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar.
Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love, You can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities and new ways of thinking.
Listening can lead to positive changes in your mood, your habits, and ultimately your overall well-being.
Audible has an incredible selection of over 1 million audiobooks, podcasts, and Audible Originals all in one easy app.
Find the genres you love and discover new ones.
Explore bestsellers like my sister's title. new releases, plus thousands of included audiobooks, podcasts, and originals that members can listen to all they want with more added all the time.
I have been listening to the Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club, which actually Elena recommended to me.
She did not listen to it, but she said, girl, this title sounds so you.
And let me tell you, it did. I've been listening to it while I walk and I am absolutely loving it.
I love all the different narrators. I love Audible.
There's more to imagine when you listen.
Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial and your first audiobook is free. visit audible.com slash morbid.
You know what's even more stressful than a packed calendar?
Realizing you're out of coffee right before a meeting.
That actually happened to me the other day. and it's exactly why I stocked up during the Thrive Markets back to school sale.
Even if you're not going back to school, I'm not, it's the perfect time to reset.
Thrive makes it easy to shop for high quality pantry staple snacks, vitamins, even skin care. without the errands or the ingredient label deep dives. with Aloha Protein Bar, Simple Mills crackers, and my favorite poppy drinks.
I love them so much. Everything is delivered super duper fast, and I saved up to 25% on all of that.
Their filters make shopping by diet or lifestyle a breeze, and their healthy swap tool actually helped me upgrade my usual buys with zero label stress.
I love the lesser evil popcorn. I get my chomp sticks from there.
I love Thrive and you will too. Now's the best time to try Thrive Market.
You'll get up to 25% off select items new members get 30 off their first order plus a free gift who doesn't love that Go to thrivemarket.com slash morbid to start saving.
The sale ends 831. Don't miss it. Hey weirdos, I'm Ash.
And I'm Alayna. And this is Morbid. It's Morbid!
🎵 you And we still sound a little bit like I've got like a Lindsay Lohan voice.
Yeah, I think I'm just a little dry. I don't sound too bad.
No, you don't. You really don't. And I probably don't sound as bad as I feel like I sound, but we're getting there.
We're getting healthy, guys. So... Here we are.
I just can't laugh too hard or I'll laugh myself into a coughing fit.
That's the problem with this. I don't know if any of you guys... I feel like everybody has a cold right now.
They do. Because... All our immune systems are shit, apparently, at this point.
But everyone I know has this cold. Everyone I know.
And everyone I know has had this cold because, like, hi.
Yes. Hello. I've had this cold for a month.
Yeah, you need to see a doctor. Yeah, like, probably.
But I don't have time for that. But I can't do that.
Where am I going to fit that into my day?
That's true. But it's important. Health is important.
It is. Health and wellness. But I feel like it's this cough that like... it's a tickle that keeps happening.
Like even right now I can feel it creeping up and I'm like, no, no, no.
Hit the pause button. Stay down there. Because I keep having to pause any like Zoom meeting we're doing or anything.
I keep muting myself to just hack up along.
She just like yeets to the ground. corner to like just to cough because I'm like I'm sorry everybody but hopefully everybody's feeling good out there I know some of you probably have this cold too because I know people were like me too solidarity brother feel better man we feel for you but Before we get into our case, which is going to be a two-parter.
Oh, because I don't know how to be brief.
A two potter after a two potter. This case is just wild.
So before we get into that, I just want to quickly mention again, Our UK lovelies, you can get my book, The Butcher and the Wren.
It's a fiction tale of a serial killer in New Orleans.
It's crazy. There's a female medical examiner in it.
You can get my book. You can pre-order it.
Signed. Signed. at Waterstones. So just go to the Waterstones book website, waterstones.com, and you can type in Butcher and the Wren.
It'll come up. You can get it signed on preorder.
It's going to be out September 13th of this year.
And if you are over here in the States, you can get, I always go Southern when I get back to the States.
I don't know why. You can get the book on pre-order as well.
You can get it at tinyurl.com slash the butcher and the wren.
That way you can get it from wherever you want to Amazon, Target, you know, Indie bookstores, wherever you would like to do it.
Barnes and Noble. Question. If I wanted a signed copy and I didn't know you personally, could I order from Waterstones here as an Americano?
You sure can. Cool. And there will be more.
As we go there's because I mean the release of the book isn't actually being like published to hold in your hands. until September 13th.
So before then, there's going to be a lot more fun stuff happening there's going to be opportunities to get books signed, but right now we don't have anything, like, set in stone.
So... There are signed copies at Waterstones right now, a bunch of them. and get your hands on them guys hell yeah we also as we're just like plug a plug Today is pretty much the last day where you can grab tickets if you want to see our show that we did while we were in Salem at the Daniels house, which was such a fun time.
So fun. Such a cool show. You guys really seem to be enjoying it, the ones who have watched.
The Dapper. Tap in the flappa. Tap in the flappa if you want to grab tickets to that.
I think you can watch until tomorrow, Thursday.
So you can get tickets at momenthouse.com slash morbid.
And FYI, those of you who love to hang out at our virtual shows, We are doing another one in May, so keep your eye out for that.
That's going to be fun. Yes. Already planning that.
Very excited for that. Yes. Maybe already have a venue that maybe is in town.
Hoping, hoping. Fingers crossed, my dogs.
Yes. But that's all we have to show at you today.
And we're not going to go into anything else because this is going to be kind of a long one.
And it's a doozy and I need to start talking about it.
So today we are going to start talking about part one of Matthew John Hoffman. otherwise known as the Leaf Killer, and his crimes are known as the Hollow Tree Murders.
Okay. This is a wild case. I know like the tip of the iceberg of this case like I've definitely heard it covered before but I don't know that I've heard it covered to the lengths that you went to It's very intricate.
It's very, very intricate. And there's a lot of people involved.
It's brutal. And so in this first one, we're going to be talking about the people involved, the victims.
We're going to talk about Matthew John Hoffman.
We're going to talk about the initial crime.
And then we're going to save the rest of it for part two, because there's more after that initial brutal crime that he commits.
So we're going to get right up to that. And then we're going to take a pause for part two.
And then part two, we're really going to go ham on the... crazy stuff that happened after that.
So we'll start November 10th, 2010. Okay.
That's when Valerie Haythorn was managing the Dairy Queen in Mount Vernon, Ohio. her employee and friend 32-year-old Tina Herman didn't show up for her shift.
Immediately no. A tale as old as time, unfortunately, and she was extremely reliable.
Tina never missed a day of work. She would never do a no call, no show.
She would have at the very least shot Valerie, her friend.
Right. So this was weird. Already Valerie is like...
I don't like this. So at the time, apparently, also, she had a boyfriend, Tina did, named Gregory Borders.
They had a good relationship, but at this time they were a little rocky and they were in the process of breaking up.
Which is always super scary in a heightened time of fear.
Exactly. So I I think Valerie had her red flags going up.
She was like, I don't know. I just I want to be safe.
So she called the Knox County Sheriff's Office and asked if they would do a welfare check.
Great friend. Because she couldn't get a hold of her.
So she was like, something's wrong here.
Now, Deputy Charles Statlett was sent to perform a welfare check on Tina's home in Apple Valley.
His report said, quote, Valerie advised that Tina did not show up for work today. and she is concerned that something may have happened to her because Tina was going to break up with her boyfriend, Gregory Borders.
That's what the report says. He went around 8 p.m.
He was on a shift, so he just stopped by.
He said nothing seemed amiss at the house.
There were no cars in the driveway and the lights were off.
Kind of seemed like no one was home. Okay.
So he knocked. No one answered. He... Couldn't really do anything else.
That's what a welfare check is. I was going to say, that's the thing about a welfare check is it kind of hard because a lot of times I feel like you just don't end up making contact with the person.
Yeah, and you can't really do anything about it.
Yeah, it's just like you don't have any reason to enter the house.
And you can't. If nothing... The only way you can really enter that house is if something looks like something is going on in there or something did happen and you can't... If the... shades are drawn and the curtains are drawn, what are you gonna do, you know?
Even if you find something that makes you think you should enter, it's like such a fine line, I feel like.
It is. That's the thing. They have to be careful about it.
They can't just barge into a house, even though that does happen all the time when they're not supposed to, but in this situation.
He was doing his job. You can't go further with a welfare check.
So he said nothing looked weird. So he went back onto his shift.
But he said later at around 1130 PM, so a few hours later, He was still on shift.
He was going by that area. So he's like, you know what?
I'm going to be a nice guy and I'm going to stop by and do another welfare check.
Yeah, let's just see what's going on here.
I'm going by. We might as well. due diligence.
Yeah, and he was like, you know what? Her friend apparently seemed very concerned so he was just trying to be like...
A good cop, I guess. And so he went by. He said the lights were on this time in the house and that a pickup truck was in the driveway.
He knocked on the door. Nobody answered.
Again, he had to leave. Can't do anything.
And he had to report. Then nothing seemed to miss.
Lights were on. Car was now in the driveway.
Didn't see anything weird, so we left. Now, the next day, November 11th, Tina didn't show up again for work.
And at this point, Valerie has not been able to get in touch with her still.
Those welfare checks are really not doing a whole lot.
They're making things weirder, in fact. And so Valerie again called the sheriff's deputies and said, We need to check on her again.
Something's wrong. What are we doing here?
We can't just wait. until weeks go by and then, like, what are we supposed to do?
Right. this is when things got a little heightened because it was also determined that Tina's kids, 13 year old Sarah, and 11-year-old Cody had not shown up for school either.
This is getting scarier. So now it's getting weird.
And while sheriff's deputies tried to contact Tina...
Valerie was searching for anybody that could be have had contact with Tina, anybody who could know where she is.
Yeah. So she called Tina's best friend, somebody she was with all the time and somebody who lived right down the street from her.
Her name was Stephanie Spring. She got no answer from Stephanie.
Okay, that's even weirder. No one's answering the freaking phone.
She's like, why can't I get anybody? Right.
Stephanie's boyfriend, Ron Metcalf, actually connected back with Valerie at this time and was like, I can't get a hold of Stephanie.
Like, what is going on right now? So together, Ron and Valerie were like, all right, we got to do something here because...
The police are only able to do so much. They are doing what they can, but what's happening here?
So they agreed to just meet at Tina's house and they were like, let's just check ourselves.
We're friends, like we can do that. So Valerie, they met at the house.
They decided they were just going to get in there.
They were like, we're just going to bust in there because something's wrong and I need to know.
And they're like, we kind of can a little bit.
Exactly. I think they were literally like, they'll forgive us for barging. in like the like we won't catch a case yeah exactly i think we'll be okay here so valerie went in through a back window And she just popped in and it was dark in there.
And she said, just silent. Oh, and that's so creepy.
On November 13th, 2022, four University of Idaho students were murdered.
Today, finally, the true story. Based on over 300 interviews, in their own words family members talk about their heartbreak and grief.
Students and townspeople describe that terrifying night.
Police detail the dramatic investigation and arrest of Brian Koberger.
You've never read a true crime like James Patterson and Vicki Ward's The Idaho Four.
The true story, it's finally here. Everybody knows there are things they can do to reduce monthly costs and improve their finances.
But who has time to go through all their expenses and decide on what to trim?
With Rocket Money crunching the numbers for you, leveling up your money game gets way easier.
RocketBunny is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending. and helps you lower your bills so that you can grow your savings.
Rocket Money shows you all of your expenses in one place, including subscriptions that you If you see a subscription that you don't want anymore, Rocket Money will help you cancel it.
Their dashboard lays out your total financial picture, including bill due dates and paydays, in a way that's super easy to digest.
You can even automatically create custom budgets based on your past spending.
If you have some kind of goal that you want to save for, Rocket Money can analyze your accounts and actually find the best time each month to set aside extra money.
Rocket Money's 5 million members have saved a total of $500 million in canceled subscriptions, with members saving up to $740 a year when they use all of the app's premium features.
Cancel your unwanted subscriptions today and reach your financial goals faster with Rocket Money.
Go to rocketmoney.com slash morbid today.
That's rocketmoney.com slash morbid. rocketmoney.com slash morbid.
She said she walked a little further into the house, and that's when she came upon a horrifying scene.
There was nobody in that house, but there was blood. everywhere oh my god it was on the walls on the carpet on the furniture there was massive drag marks of blood going through Oh my god.
Again, no bodies, just blood. Everywhere.
And she said tissue. She could see tissue.
And she just was like, I'm out of here. Like human tissue.
Yeah, not like Kleenex. Just clarifying because this is a weird case.
I was going to say, human tissue was on the floor.
Now, she ran out of there. Immediately, they called 911.
And all she could say over and over again to the 911 operator was, there's just... blood everywhere oh god and this is like her friend yeah so let's go to who these people are.
Tina Herman was 32 years old. She was a divorced mother of two children.
Her mother Barbara called her, quote, a fun-loving hard worker and a very caring mother.
Everyone who knew Tina said she was the kind of mother who would do absolutely anything for her kids.
She would move heaven and earth. I love it.
And she was a happy person. She was a very happy person, very kind.
Her mother said, quote, she loved dolphins and sunflowers. but most of all she enjoyed watching and cheering on her children as they participated in sports.
This is so wholesome and I hate knowing that it doesn't remain that way.
It's really sad. Now, Tina had met her ex-husband at the time, Larry Maynard. who did not live in the home, by the way, during this time, when they were 15 years old, that's when they met.
And they immediately had fallen for each other.
Now, before we begin with more into this, there is stuff that happened after this whole case with Larry and his new wife.
I will talk about it in part two. I just want to be clear about that.
I'm not going to pretend that it didn't happen.
Okay. But I want to keep it for them because it's after this whole case wraps up and it's wild.
And he and his wife have a lot to feel shame for.
And we will get into it. But for now, I will at least tell you the kind things he had to say for his family.
Literally only you would set up a cliffhanger within minutes of starting the fucking story.
Like only you. They're not great. Yeah, it's still a cliffhanger.
I'm going to start with the lovely things he had to say about his ex-wife. and his children because they deserve to be praised during this.
And we'll just kind of talk about what it was. what shit went down later.
But at the time, they had a very good relationship for a long time, Tina and Larry.
Larry later said she was so sweet. She was so kind and so beautiful.
And he said when he saw her at 15 years old...
He was just smitten. And he said she was beloved by everyone.
She was super popular. Everyone thought she was great, even back then.
And he said she was truly one of those lit up the room when she walked into it kind of people.
I love it. They had their first child, Sarah, when they were both 19 years old.
And she was actually born very premature.
Oh, wow. It was tough, but they worked together to get her healthy and they were able to very quickly.
And he said it actually just bonded them closer together, which it will do.
If you have a good relationship, that shit will bond you together or it will tear you apart very much so now everyone said sarah was a true fighter from the get-go And she was really happy, baby.
She was very energetic, super curious and sweet.
And two months after, or excuse me, two months, two years after she was born, her brother Cody came into the world and they bonded immediately.
Wow. Oh, I was just looking at pictures of them.
They are the cutest family. They are so sweet.
So adorable. And they all have like the happiest faces.
Like you, like you were just saying they were so happy.
You can see it on the screen. they were just like it seemed like it was a happy family they definitely went through some stuff financially and just like struggled that way.
There was, you know, there was a divorce.
Things were not always the happiest. Yeah.
But it seems like there was no recorded abuse in this household.
Seems like they all kind of got through it together.
Exactly. And Tina, especially, it seemed was just a great mom.
She's just a great mom. She looks like a great mom.
She has that... She would give you a good hug.
She would be... In my case, I feel like she'd be like my friend's mom that I'd be like, oh, you're the best.
Like, you're the coolest mom. Like, I wish you were my mom.
Yeah, that's the thing. And Cody and Sarah... like were really sweet with each other.
They fought like normal brother and sister did.
Anybody who says they didn't like ever argue with their brother or sister is They're like preteens.
That's like the height of the arguing. But they loved each other.
They supported each other. And they were like goofy with each other.
And both of them, apparently, according to everyone who knew them, both of them say or both of them were apparently just like super confident. kind oh like that's the one thing that is described like describes tina but also describes Cody, especially and Sarah, that they were just like kind kids.
Well, they were raised right, clearly. Yeah, and they were always sticking up for other kids and helping people.
In fact, Larry, their father, said he didn't even know if he could take credit for teaching them that kind of kindness.
He said it just seemed like who they were from the jump.
I think that's just how some people are.
It's just in you or sometimes it's not. Now, when they were struggling as a family, just financially a little bit, Larry had gotten a job as a long haul trucker.
And that's tough. That can be tough, you know, especially on a marriage.
It can be tough if you're not like super strong to begin with.
Because long-haul truckers work their asses off.
They work... All the time. They work for long periods of time and they're going across the country.
Right. And so he's gone from the kids. He's gone from her.
He said it was just like really straining on their marriage.
And it just... it didn't work out. So unfortunately, they did end in divorce.
But he said it wasn't a volatile, anger-filled divorce.
It was like they just grew apart. It's like sometimes, and it's like so scary, but sometimes people will say you just fell out of love.
That always like breaks my heart. Like that is just because I'm like, you what?
Like, it's never going to happen. Okay. No, never.
I can't like that. That breaks my heart when people say that.
Even saying that, I got that feeling like I was going to cry.
That little choked up feeling. I know. I'm like, no.
But it does happen. It happens to some people.
And usually it's for the best when it happens.
And I think it's a slow process. I think you know what's happening.
There are signs in there somewhere. You can usually only see them in hindsight, though.
Now, Larry and Tina put both the kids first.
And they didn't hold kids against each other.
They didn't use them in any way. They were like, we were very serious about not doing that, not fighting and front of them not doing anything that could make them feel like they were a part of the divorce Not making them pick sides.
Yeah, they were like, all we wanted was for both of us to have enough time with those kids.
That's the way you do it. Kids don't need to be an active part of divorce.
Yeah, just because your relationship doesn't work out. doesn't mean that their relationship can't work out.
So it's like, obviously, there's mitigating factors to every different divorce.
But like in a normal divorce, that's just like everyone's chill.
There was no abuse. There was nothing like that.
Just, you know, make sure the kids are always first.
Now, eventually, Tina met a man named Greg Borders, and they worked together at the Target Distribution Center They liked each other right away.
He was a good guy. They ended up dating and moving into an apartment together with Cody and Sarah.
Everything seemed to be going well. Larry said that at this point, everything was great between the two exes.
They were communicating, co-parenting. Everything was good.
And he said, quote, We had both matured by then and we both loved our kids.
We didn't want to argue in front of them or about them.
Both Tina and I wanted just what's best for them.
All right. Now, after Tina got laid off from her job at the Target Distribution Center, she got a new position at a Dairy Queen.
And she and Greg moved the kids to Apple Valley to actually a small home on Kings Beach Drive.
It was pretty idyllic and a very safe area, but it makes my stomach hurt knowing It was a very safe area.
The house was kind of away from other neighbors, which can be like, ah.
But, or it can be like, it can be like, yeah, but it can also be to make sure both.
And I think it's because of what the bad guy here, Matthew Hoffman says later. that really made me think about it more.
And I'll tell you in a second. It was a house that was away from neighbors.
It was in a safe area, but across the street from it was just woods.
No other houses. Now, that sounds great.
Because it's like you're just like in the woods.
Everybody leaves me alone. Neighbors can be tough.
Yeah. Neighbors are rough. Yeah. You know, I dig my neighbors now, but we, you know, you go through it with them.
My neighbors are like super chill. I dig my neighbors.
And it's nice to have neighbors that you like and that everybody's looking out for each other.
You can wave when you leave the neighbors. yeah exactly and everybody's just looking out for each other yeah that's the thing neighbors can be great for that when you guys are bros which like I love that we're bros now like everybody's looking out and when they see weird stuff they're the first ones that are They're going to be like, ring, ring, excuse me.
Now, when you don't have that, it can be a little scary.
And I say this because Matthew Hoffman later said, I chose this house at random and I chose it because it didn't have any close neighbors and it was across the street from Woods.
Okay. And he also said their garage door, just a little... their garage door was broken and it didn't go down all the way.
Oh, man. There was a little crack on the bottom where he could... like shimmy it up.
Yeah, that's that's what he said. He let out that like terrifying dark information. that was in his head.
He was like, PSA. Take without what you will.
A PSA. But that freaked me out and I was like, whoo, glad I have neighbors.
So like this because this is really scary.
But the thing is, everybody was happy. They were healthy at this point.
The kids did well at school. They were playing sports.
They were doing stuff after school. Everyone, and Tina was working her ass off.
Later, you know, like the kids always said that they had everything they needed and Tina made sure of it.
Those kids were provided for. So it's like a very just kind of like all-American family.
Yeah, they're doing what they can to just like pay their bills.
Right. The kids are all able to do sports.
She's making sure that she can pay for sports.
Everything seems like it's going great. If your dog could talk, they'd warn you about what's lurking in their bowl.
Mass-produced kibble isn't just unappetizing.
It could be a crime against canine health.
Mysterious byproducts, unpronounceable preservatives, and who knows what fillers.
Sounds more like evidence from a crime scene than dinner.
Ollie is here to crack the case on pet nutrition. with fresh human-grade meals made with the highest quality ingredients.
No mystery meats, no artificial junk, just real minimally processed food made in U.S. kitchens.
It's the kind of clean eating that keeps tails wagging and nose sniffing for more.
With five fresh protein-first recipes, like beef with sweet potatoes and turkey with blueberries, your pup won't have to wonder what's in their food ever again.
Because when it comes to their health, the only mystery should be where you hide the treats.
Dogs deserve the best and that means fresh healthy food.
Head to ollie.com slash Wondery. Tell them all about your dog and use code WONDERY to get 60% off your welcome kit when you subscribe today. plus they offer a happiness guarantee on the first box so if you're not completely satisfied you'll get your money back That's O-L-L-I-E dot com slash Wondery.
And enter code WONDERY to get 60% off your first box.
Take two. Now during this time also, Tina found a friend in her new neighborhood.
Because although she didn't have a lot of neighbors around her, like nearby, there was houses down the road.
And a couple of houses down was a woman named Stephanie Sprang.
And she immediately hit it right off with Tina.
Yeah. They were fast, like best friends.
They were like around each other all the time.
Stephanie was apparently super energetic and fun.
She was kind as well, just really sweet.
She was the perfect fit for Tina and the perfect fit for her family to be like an Auntie Stephanie.
Not to Steph. No. A family member said, quote, Stephanie would walk into a room and light it up.
And she said that that was just the kind of personality she had.
She laughed a lot and seemed like a happy person all the time.
Stephanie and Tina were the best of friends and did everything together around Apple Valley.
So that's what people who knew her said about her.
When two people... who are best friends, are described as lighting up a room.
Like together. By two different people.
Right. Then I think they lit up a room. I would say these two are the ones that light up the room.
I'd put money on it. I would too. So in fall of 2010, unfortunately, like I said, Greg and Tina were a little bit on the rocks.
They were deciding to break up and Tina was going to be looking for an apartment to move the kids out of the house.
Oh, God. This is why when she didn't show up for her shift twice, immediately people started worrying that something went sour with the breakup.
Let me now say that Greg and everyone around them maintains their relationship.
Rocky, but never abusive. But obviously a lot of times when a breakup is happening and someone goes missing, you really do have to look at the X and what is happening here first.
Because you don't know what happens behind closed doors.
Obviously, in this situation, Not really much was happening behind closed doors other than their relationship was breaking down.
But sometimes you just... Yeah, you don't know.
People can... People can snap. Snap, yeah.
Have you seen the show, Snapped? Yeah. And it's like, okay, so, but I will say I couldn't find anything to say that there was abuse in this home.
So I just want to be clear on that. Of course.
Now, during that fall of 2010, before Tina failed to show up for work and Stephanie's boyfriend couldn't contact her... and Tina's children didn't show up for school, there was an actual monster waiting in the woods across from their home.
He had watched them for a little bit, camping out at night to see what their routines were. to see when people left the house every morning because Greg had to leave very early in the morning because he was I believe like 60 miles away from the Target distribution center.
Oh, wow. So he had to leave at like 3 a.m. or something.
This monster was sitting there watching him leave at a certain time, watching Tina leave at a certain time, watching those kids get on the bus.
And that's the thing. I feel like when you're kind of like, oh my gosh.
Like you're a family like this. There are routines that you just can't switch around.
You fall into these routines. And it's like we say all the time, like switch up your routine if you can.
But when you have a fan. and kids especially you leave the house at a certain time exactly it can be hard hard so as much as you can do it but it's like there's only so much you can do here which is scary And as he's doing this, watching their routines, he was planning what he later claimed was supposed to be a routine burglary. where no one got hurt.
I don't know if I believe that. I don't at all.
That monster's name was Matthew John Hoffman.
So unfortunately, let's talk about Matthew John Hoffman for a second.
Okay. Matthew John Hoffman was born November 1st, 1980.
A scorpion. A Scorpio. His parents were Robert and Patricia Hoffman.
He was born in Warren, which is in northeastern Ohio.
His parents, he had like a pretty like whatever childhood.
Nothing crazy happened. Right. His parents.
No, his parents divorced in 1997 He ended up moving in with his mother Where they both moved to Knox County.
Oh, weird. We just covered a case from that.
Right? Isn't that weird? Yeah. He was quiet and kept to himself.
Everyone who did know him said he was just a quiet kid in the beginning.
He wasn't, you know, all... aggressive or someone they worried about should always nothing that happened about the quiet one However, they did say that he would say things that would like, like he started turning. as he got older, like hit puberty and stuff, like he started acting strange.
Okay. It just made people raise their eyebrow.
It's always the quiet ones. And again, not aggressive or mean, but just strange.
He could be blunt. Which like, same. He could be blunt.
He marched to the beat of his own weird drummer.
Finding this weirdly relatable. I know.
As I was reading this, I was like, okay, we can't say anything about this.
Oh, in the next line, I see the word stubborn.
Yeah, his mom said he was very smart. but very stubborn.
Sounds like someone I know. This is actually very terrifying.
It is very terrifying. He wouldn't budge when he was fixated on something and he refused to admit that he was wrong.
Ash is literally sitting there with her head tilted, blinking at me.
Oh, girl. Oh, we diverge at some point.
Don't worry. I will admit, up until this point, I was feeling weirdly like, What is happening?
But don't worry. Am I a sociopath? Ready?
We're going to diverge hard right now. Yeah.
He was obsessed with trees. Can't say the same.
Two roads, we diverge. Actually, not. Not like to a big degree, but my case for this week has a little tree moment.
Oh, hey. Which is weird. It's a quick tree moment.
Welcome to tree week. Yeah. Yeah, he was obsessed with trees.
It wasn't like he just enjoyed breathing oxygen like all of us do.
I do enjoy that. I love breathing oxygen.
I love a good O2 moment. I suppose we all had that in common, but...
He just like and he didn't enjoy just like seeing a cool spooky tree or like a pretty tree, which like I do.
I love a spooky tree. Yeah, like give me that.
Yeah, give me an elm, a witch elm. But he was fixated on trees.
And part of it with him, I will say, it seemed to be that he loved heights.
He was a risk taker. And in high school, he got in trouble for being kind of like rebellious.
He would climb onto roofs and jump off onto trampolines and into pools.
That's fun. It was like a thrill-seeking thing and trees were the ultimate place to climb.
Trees! man. The ultimate thrill, man. I'm like, I love heights as well, but not...
Trees are cool. Well, and he was outdoorsy.
So this was just like his thing. It's like a natural thrill-seeking thing.
Couldn't be me. He was also said to do things like you would just be walking with him.
And again, I'm going to say right ahead of this, I always hate when people are like, oh, yeah, he would do this weird thing.
And I'm like, that was just a weird thing.
That didn't mean that he was going to go kill people.
Like, can we not attribute weird behavior like that is very innocuous and not harmful to...
Later, he was a serial killer, and that definitely told us.
What was it? No. He would do things like you would be walking with him and he would just like jump onto like a picnic table and like backflip off of it.
Oh, parkour. Parkour. And later, exactly.
And later people were like, oh, weird. And I'm like, no, it's not.
That's normal teenage kid behavior. You ever seen like the kids, like kids walking into Target, they always do like jumping on those little things over the red ball.
Yeah. Yeah, that's not a serial killer.
And apparently his neighbor said he made, like, a tightrope between two trees in his backyard and would, like, walk tightrope all the time.
Okay, that's... That's not like serial killer behavior, but if my neighbor started doing that, I'd be like...
Huh. It's one of those things where you just be like, okay, just make you go, huh.
Does that make you happy? Cool. Because it's literally not hurting anybody.
That's the thing. So I don't like when we like attribute these weird, but I had to bring it up just because of how angry it makes me that we like.
I get that. end up attributing these things yeah because of course we can go back and say whoa that's that's weird or like that's strange behavior.
Like, yeah, like that. I would, I would be like, why are you doing that?
But like, it's not the making of a homicidal maniac rapist.
So let's not just like pin a label on people who are like a little offbeat. as like, oh, I bet they might be a homicidal maniac later.
It's like they might just be eccentric. They might just be weird.
Right. Like, you know, it's just like, that's fine.
Yeah, we're all weird. We literally open up the show with, hey, weirdos. attention to things that are harming other people or even harming that person. or just things that are like violent, aggressive, that kind of thing.
Like tightrope walking is not Tightrope walking and parkour are not things that you really need to be that concerned about in another person.
Just let them live. Parkour. Parkour. uh he was weird but it didn't indicate at all what he was capable of doing or even violence until later which then he does show that there's some signs.
So we have things to look at. So that's the other thing.
We have things to look at that do indicate violence, so we can just leave those other things.
So let's leave the parkour and the tightrope walking and the I like to climb trees kind of thing when he was younger to the wayside. of these things is not like the other exactly because we do have violent behavior later that I think just makes people immediately, which I get it.
We all do it. I do it. Which you go into hindsight and you're like, oh, that's weird too.
So yeah, he was weird. And it's like, okay.
Yeah, I guess. But it's like a Venn diagram of weirdness.
It truly is. It truly is. Some things go over here in the innocuous category.
Some things go in the holy shit, that's aggressive.
And then some things go weirdly all over the place.
Now, it's hotly debated. whether he had a legitimate attraction or fetish for trees.
To be honest with you, like, I don't need to know.
No, I mean, I'm not dying to know. That's called dendrophilia and actually translates to love of trees, which he definitely had a love of trees.
But it's kind of been turned to mean a sexual love of trees now.
Like a lot of in psychology, a lot of that is said.
Now, it's basically a term for when you like... literally fuck trees or you want to fuck trees.
Like that's, it's become like a paraphilia kind of thing.
But I don't know if he went this far. He seemed to find comfort mostly in trees.
And I think he was mentally ill. Yeah. I'm not going to sit here and diagnose him.
I have no idea what he... Did or did not have.
Sure. He seems like he was mentally ill in some way. and that he was struggling at times.
And he was very obsessed with like, He struggled financially when he was on his own, and I think he very much fixated on getting money and getting enough money.
And I think he found comfort in trees, which like...
That's a whole different thing. That's where money comes from.
It sure does. Now, I definitely think you found comfort in it.
And I think it turned into an unhealthy obsession for sure.
But nothing publicly released, at least that I could find, truly suggests that it was sexual.
OK, so maybe it's all just kind of like over the years, it's kind of been like thrown into the story.
It's. sexual part it's for sure unhealthy and it's definitely strange right And there is a possibility that it was sexual.
I have no idea. He definitely had some kind of like I don't know if I would use, I'm sorry, I'm like started.
I don't know if I would use fetish. But possibly, because to me fetish kind of indicates a sexual nature to it.
Right. Again, there's no reports that he was fucking trees.
There's no reports that he was like rubbing up on trees.
He never said he wanted to fuck a tree. So what was it that people speculate he was sexually attracted to them?
Because he was so obsessed with them. We talk about them a lot.
Well, and as we'll see, The trees and leaves become a very big part of this crime.
They do, and I know that. And I've never been able to wrap my brain around it. discuss a little bit of it in part one, but we're really going to get into it in part two.
But I just wanted to put that out there that I technically could not find something that definitively said that he fucked a tree or that he wanted to fuck a tree.
Stop saying fuck a tree. But it's a possibility.
And who knows, because this guy, one, you can't believe a word out of his fucking mouth.
And two, he's a monster. Right. And he's like a deviant.
Like he... As we're going to find out, he may have known that there was a 13 year old girl in this house.
And he may have planned this, and personally, I believe he did.
So if he's going to do that, who is to say what else he is?
Going to go into. Yeah. Well, and he definitely did know there was like at least a young girl because he saw the routine.
Exactly. But people, you know. He likes to say, my intention was not to go in there because it was this 13-year-old girl.
And how did it end up the way it did? He's a lying sack of shit.
So he also said that his intention was to go in and rob the house, which I also don't believe.
Exactly. Now, after high school, Matthew took courses to study in industrial electrical engineering, because remember, He's a really smart kid at this point.
What a waste. And he had a ton of jobs. He wasn't great at keeping a consistent and responsible thing going for long.
Look at that. His odd ways or his boredom was really the thing that would get the best of him and he would be on to the next one.
Because he would just start acting. He could really get into things and get into people's lives by being pretty normal and just quiet.
And people were like, yeah, nothing's wrong with him.
And then he would start to let these... strange behaviors out and people were like, okay, like I'm a little creeped out now.
Off-putting. Yeah, exactly. He would unnerve people in ways.
Yeah. Like he would never assault them outright or like say anything that was like inappropriate to that degree.
But it was like things that were just like, Oh, I don't know.
Probably one of those people where like when this did end up happening and getting reported, multiple people who worked with him were like, I always knew there was something off.
Exactly. Like I couldn't put my finger on it, but there was something.
And those... Things make sense. Like when you can look back and go, you know what?
I did always feel off around him. Right.
That is something... That happens. Trust your gut.
The body knows. It sure does, is what my therapist says.
The body knows. No, so he just couldn't find something that made him happy or made him feel fulfilled.
And he was kind of struggling financially.
And again, he was always bored, always searching for the next adventure thing that he could do.
But he was... so very much underperforming for his intelligence, basically.
Now, in 2000, he got a job finally, and he got this job out in Colorado.
In Steamboat Springs, which like what a name for a place that sounds beautiful and idyllic.
It does. I would go there. Steamboat Springs.
I love spring. Yeah. Now, he got a job with a plumbing company called Scott Barnes Plumbing.
He was living at a place at the time, because again, he's not making a ton of money.
He was living at a place called the D Bar K Motel.
This was a pretty gnarly motel and basically just like workers would sometimes stay or live there while they worked there.
Mm-hmm. It wasn't great. So in September 2000, he found himself really down and really fighting urges to do something recklessly. again he was getting bored he was ready to move on to the next thing but he's like just he's one of those like restless motherfuckers that just had has like all this shit pent up in him and he uses it in fucked up ways. okay before you got to the end of that sentence i was like i wonder if there's sagittarius in his chart because like sagittarius always has to fight the urge to like like go away and do the next thing.
Oh really? I'm a Sagittarius rising and I constantly feel the need to just run away. whoa and like do something like crazy but then come back crazy but but i don't But not like reckless and harmful.
Not reckless and harmful ever. But I just, I have a lot of things to do so I can't.
Yeah, you do have a lot of things to do.
Can confirm. Yeah. So I fight the urge.
You fight that. I appreciate that. No problem.
Now, so what he did... was he ran out in Steamboat Springs, and he stole three signs from a city park.
These were huge signs. It's also like hard to steal signs.
Oh, these were huge wooden signs. Right.
And they basically were the signs that said like, welcome to Steamboat Springs.
Like that's what they said. And he was like, he just took them.
And you have to like dig those out of the ground and they're in there pretty far.
I'm not going to go too further into it, but it's hard to steal It's hard to do it.
And these were giant wooden signs that you literally had to dig out of the ground.
You had to get a truck to haul them away.
He stole three of them. And you have to lift them yourself.
By himself. What the fuck? And why? look at him you're like you what now people somehow just people police actually police people They somehow traced these signs back to the motel room where they found them.
Because they're gigantic. They were able to like trace it in some way.
It's really not that important, but they found them back there.
And when they went back to the room, no one was in there.
But they found the signs. I think two of them were in the room and one of them was like under the building.
Why? Yeah. And so they were like, what? So they looked at the records and found that Matthew Hoffman was the one who was renting that room and the only one. who was renting that room during that time period, but he was gone.
He had skipped town. Is he stealing another sign?
And it's like he left the signs. He just did it for the thrill of it.
The town of Agde in France is famous for sun, sand, sea and sex.
But lately, life on the coast has taken a strange turn.
The town's mayor, a respected pillar of the community, has been arrested for corruption.
His wife claims he's been bewitched by a beautiful clairvoyant.
Then there's the mysterious phone calls that local people have been getting.
I am the Archangel Michael. The whole town has been thrown into chaos.
As the mayor is unable to carry out his duties, I would like to address you all.
Legal proceedings have been initiated. Join me, Anna Richardson, and journalist Leo Schick for The Mystic and the Mayor as we investigate a story of power, corruption, Binge all episodes of The Mystic and the Mare exclusively and ad-free right now on Wondery Plus.
Start your free trial in Apple Podcasts Spotify or the Wondery app So they track Hoffman down back in Ohio and he just straight up admits to stealing those signs.
He's like, yeah, I did it. And he doesn't give a.
Well, and they were like, why did you do that?
And he was like, I just wanted a souvenir from Steamboat Springs.
Or three massive ones? And he said he wanted the novelty of it all.
He said, I'm doing So he was like, yeah, I did it.
I stole them. And then he told them. So they were like, you need to come back and face the charges now.
And he was like, all right. He was like, cool, cool, cool, see you there.
So while they're waiting for him to return this crazy weird story started circulating the police department because who the fuck steals giant Welcome to Steamboat Springs signs, then admits to it And also he left them in the motel room when he said he stole them to keep as a souvenir.
Yeah. So it was strange. And all the police officers are like, what the fuck?
They're like, we have hats in town at CVS that you can buy.
You want a sweatshirt, bro? Like, what is wrong with you?
You can get a magnet that says that a picture of that sign you can have.
Get all of those little trinkets. We'll give you a gift basket.
We'll even give you the sign on a magnet.
Exactly. How about that? And it was strange and it wasn't adding up.
So another detective was like, wait. That name sounds familiar, Matthew Hoffman.
And he was like, wait. I know that he works for Scott Barnes Plumbing Company.
And he said it was pertinent to him and he had remembered it. because he read the names of the employees of that company a couple of weeks ago because there had been plumbers that Johnson Shipley Management Company had hired to provide services for a huge condo complex.
It was like townhomes. And that was the plumbing company that this management company had hired.
Now, the reason he was looking through this was that condo complex had weirdly burned to the ground two weeks ago.
Oh shit. On August 28th. Oh shit. Yeah. couple of weeks after that plumbing company, the one that Matthew Hoffman worked for, had actually done work on that complex.
Dude. I didn't realize arson was a part of the story.
Now, arson was what they believed happened.
They didn't think it just burned down accidentally.
Well, and it's crazy because they have ways of like telling.
Yeah. Which is so wild to me. Well, they had traced the point of origin of the fire to a unit seven.
Now, that unit was the one that Matthew Hoffman had done working.
Gotcha. So they were like, okay, so this guy works for this plumbing company and that this management company hired to do work on this specific unit in this specific townhome complex.
Yes. And that complex burned down. And now this guy stole three signs, left them in the motel room.
And then just skip town. Like, he's acting all kinds of bizarre.
So they're like, I feel like we could talk to him about this.
I feel like we have a nice little connection here.
So he comes in from Ohio to be questioned about the signs formally.
And all went as planned. He was like, yep, he admitted it again.
I stole the signs. Then they start asking him about his plumbing job.
And they're like, did you do a job in Unit 7?
And he was like, yeah, I did. Just, yep.
They asked, they were like, oh, cool. Why were your fingerprints on a ton of shit in the owner of that unit's vehicle?
What? And they were like, and why was that vehicle stolen and actually abandoned in the middle of town?
Wow, you buried the lead on that one, motherfucker.
So he was like, oh. I think I like moved stuff out of the way when I was doing the plumbing job and like put some stuff in the car so like that probably worked and he was like But like you didn't have access to that car.
Never have I ever needed my plumber to put stuff in my car.
No. Like the Dawn dish soap and the extra sponges and the fucking dishwasher pods, they can just be put to the side.
You don't have to. and put them in my car.
And these were like boxes and shit in the car and of like random stuff from the condo. that had nothing to do with like- That didn't need to be in a box and didn't need to be moved.
Like weren't in the way of plumbing. And then he said something like he had, it was like a Subaru, I think.
And he was like, oh, yeah. They were like, why was your fingerprints on the Subaru?
And he was like, oh, I think I touched it because I just like looked at it.
And they were like, why did you look at it?
And he was like, I don't know. I love me a good Subaru.
He was like, you know, who doesn't love a white Subaru?
He said, I want to know what makes a Subaru.
I want to know. There you go. i just wanted to i just wanted to know i just came there you got that was great thanks no he fully admitted finally You got me.
I burned it down. He didn't admit to why.
He just said, you obviously got me. And they're like, what do we get you for, though?
We need to go a little further. So they're like, can you explain what we got you for?
So he fully admits. He goes, yep, I knew the unit owner was going to be out of town because I had done that.
I had ascertained that information when I was doing the job for him.
He said he was going to be out of town for a while.
So he said, I went back to that unit myself five times.
I broke in five times. I used everything in it.
I cooked myself meals. I showered there.
I watched TV for hours on end. Ew, God. Get the fuck out of my condo.
He actually said, quote, I stayed in there and watched TV because my own place didn't have cable TV.
I cooked myself meals. and use the Jacuzzi.
Ew. He also stole stuff. Get out of my house.
And here's what he did. He stole stuff and just left it other places.
He stole a stuffed mountain lion. question mark which like what the fuck and a dresser and a bunch of clothing he stole a dresser and he put it in the Subaru in the man in the Subaru downtown He was apparently planning to go get it again, but like it went awry.
So also this poor man who lived here comes home.
Yeah. His dresser is missing along with his Subaru.
There's like a weird stench of ramen and wet jacuzzi. in the air and he's like what the fuck happened except that doesn't even happen because he comes down to the place it's burned to a crisp I was just going to He didn't even get a chance to smell the ramen.
He came to a burned down house. He also stole a fax machine and a camera. a fax machine what fucking year was this it was like 2000 oh okay Then he said he started a fire in the unit after the five times hanging out there because he said, I just couldn't clean up all my fingerprints.
They were everywhere. So he said I had to eliminate the whole crime scene.
And this was tricky because remember, this is like a townhome complex, right?
He lit he had lit a unit on fire and the police were now asking him if he knew that there were other people in the adjacent unit.
Right. And he said he knew they were there, but he was sure the fire alarm would warn them to get out of the building before they got hurt.
However, that's risky. And how can you be sure it wasn't attempted murder?
It's tough. Yeah. Like, you can't take his fucking word.
And he had used 10 gallons of gasoline to start the fire and 16 people. had to run for their lives out of those buildings.
Oh, God. Were there any kids? Everybody was fine.
No one was hurt. Okay, good. But they had, they narrowly escaped and there was $2 million worth of damage.
I was going to say, not only did they narrowly escape on their lives, but they lost everything.
Now, he was charged with arson, unlawfully and knowingly breaking and entering into the condo. first-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft, theft of property, and reckless endangerment.
So why wasn't he in jail for like a really long time?
Well, he pled guilty. He didn't want to go to trial.
He wrote a letter to the judge saying he now understood the full weight of his crime and that he was promising to be a better man and to not let these kind of impulses based on money and material shit control him anymore he ended up getting eight years in prison that's And he actually told the judge at his sentencing, quote,
Now that I think back to it, I would not have done it.
I wonder. Which is like, thank you, sir.
Yeah, like, gee, hindsight. Thank you so much.
I do wonder if he actually felt that way, like he was worried about the other people or if this was an appearance thing.
Yeah, I wonder. For me, I feel like this is more about appearances, and so you don't have to spend forever in jail.
To me, at this point, I could see it being that he really did just want to eliminate the crime scene.
More of an escalation. And that he was just like...
And I think he also just is like his way of thinking is like, well, they'll just leave.
It's not a big deal. Like he doesn't think too much on it.
Like he's not thinking too much. And I think in his set, he's probably like, and if someone dies, someone dies.
Like, I got to do this. I don't think his intention in this case was to kill a bunch of people.
No, it doesn't. But I think collateral damage wouldn't have actually bothered him. urge was too strong.
Yeah, and I think this was all an act of him being like, I wouldn't have done it.
No, I think you would have. And I think if somebody died, you would have been like, oops, I cleared the crime scene.
Thank God nobody did. Now the prosecutor said of this case later, this is just a true miracle that there was not a loss of life.
This was not a quick childhood loss of judgment.
This was a thought out premeditated plan, which is exactly, you should have got more.
Unfortunately, he was a model prisoner and he got out in six years.
So shave two years off of that. I'm not sure what two more years would have done for him, but it still sucks.
Now he ended up getting parole and he was able to move back to Ohio.
They allowed him to serve his parole in Ohio.
Yeah. He paid back some of that $2 million, though.
So, like, that's nice. He paid back... $4,800 of it.
Okay. So at least he repaid his debt to society, you know?
It's 48, like what fraction of 2 million is that?
I cannot math that. No. I cannot. I cannot math that.
He was good on parole. He always met with his parole officer, seemed to be turning his life around.
Things were looking up a little bit. Uh-huh.
No, he didn't have a ton of friends. He was a little bit of a loner.
Not like the super loner where you're like, what's that dude doing?
It was just kind of like, he was just around.
He wasn't really creepy at this point or off-putting.
He was just quiet. You know, it seemed like he maybe learned his lesson at this point and everybody was just kind of like letting him be because maybe they were like, maybe he's just like.
We're fully marinating in the consequences of his actions.
So let's not aggravate this arson move. Yeah, let's not poke that bear.
So for a while he was just camping out a little bit and living in his car because he didn't have enough money to really get a place.
Okay. But he was working. He wanted to work to get somewhere of his own.
So he would often just kind of like wander around the woods and like got to know the area and the forest really well. wander around the woods i would like just climb trees a lot okie dokie yeah um And he had like tree climbing gear too.
So he was like an avid climber. I mean, that's, I don't know a lot of people that just like climb trees all willy nilly.
I don't think I know anyone who climbs trees willy nilly.
I don't. Yeah. Either. Not a lot. I don't.
But I do wonder if like there's more of them that I would ever know.
Yeah. Who knows? I don't know if people are open about their tree climbing abilities or pensions.
You should be. I think it's fine. I want to know.
Just don't go down this path. But I'm just like, so is this super weird?
Like, do people wander the woods and climb trees a lot?
I don't know. yeah i don't know i'm not here to judge you on your like if you like to climb trees like climb trees just be careful yeah be super careful But, like, when you put it in context with later...
It gets weird. That's when it gets weird.
The tree climbing itself, not weird. Gets a little weird in a little while.
Okay. Little, I mean, a lot. Not a little.
Not slightly. Very much so. This case confounds me.
Yeah. Now... Luckily for him, he ended up somehow meeting a woman and starting a relationship with her.
Did he meet her in a tree? He might have been around a tree.
I don't know. I don't think so. He was like, you?
You? Oh my goodness. You as well? They just swung to each other.
I never ran into anybody on this elk before.
No, but elk is not a tree. See, clearly not climbing.
An elk. On this animal before? No, he got a job at a tree trimming service.
So he's really just leaning into it. This service was called Fast Eddie's Tree Tribbing.
And he ended up making a little money. He's doing well.
He got a small home for himself. Should have paid off the rest of that $2 million.
Things were looking up. And eventually his girlfriend and her son, who I think was eight years old at the time, moved in with him.
What the actual fuck? Yeah. So they had two dogs.
Seemed to be the American dream. Everything was going fine.
This is so. Now, let me tell you right now, his neighbors said they really liked him.
He was a nice guy. their kids and his girlfriend's kids would play together.
Like... they would let their kids go over to his house and play outside.
Like he was a very normal human being. Seemed like when he was first in this relationship, he was settled.
And he... that part of his personality came out where he was like a bird.
They said he was quiet, but not like unnervingly quiet, not rude.
Yeah. Yeah. As was well established, he was a very outdoorsy guy.
So he still loved trees and he was teaching kids in the neighborhood out here with these trees.
He's still loving on those trees. And at this point, he was using it in like a... like a positive way, because he was teaching kids in the neighborhood how to climb them and teaching them like the different types.
And like, he would be there to spot them and like, kind of just like showing them leaves and showing them like how to. name different ones like he was being like a nature guide kind of thing interesting and like and he seemed to love the squirrels Again, not in like a... Not in a gross way.
Not in a weird way, but like a little weird.
He just liked squirrels. He just liked squirrels.
So he would feed squirrels. I mean, people have pet squirrels.
Kids would be psyched to be there when he was feeding the squirrels.
Everything seemed like it was like, okay, maybe he's turned it around.
Maybe he spent the time in prison. He did that shit.
Yeah, he's going to now learn. Just be like a weird eccentric neighbor, nature loving dude.
Which, gosh, I wish he didn't. I know. Now, it was towards the summer of like 2010 that things...
Suddenly started turning the other way. As they do.
Because remember... As we have well established, Matthew Hoffman is not great at staying in one spot for a long time and doing the same thing for a long time and being responsible for a long time.
He gets bored. He gets that urge to be reckless.
It's about that time. So neighbors said he suddenly became really grumpy and really off-putting.
Like he all of a sudden was just like, and one day his two dogs just disappeared.
With no explanation, one neighbor actually said, quote, I believe in my heart he killed those dogs.
Oh no. Now, suddenly he began acting more like a survivalist for like no reason at all.
He was catching the squirrels now and killing them to eat.
See, I just think that's a really bad plan if you're a survivalist, because Lots of times squirrels have rabies.
That's how to survive in the wild with ash.
Thank you for tuning in this week. We'll be back with another hot tip.
Probably never. Probably never. You can catch us again.
Never. I literally have a shirt that says indoorsy.
But I know... enough to know that you don't eat squirrels yeah he was i mean i don't know maybe there's people eat squirrels No, I don't want to talk about it.
Yeah, people eat squirrels. But I don't, but like people do.
But he was eating squirrels all of a sudden.
And the thing was like... He liked these squirrels.
He was like bro-ing out with these squirrels for a while.
So why are you suddenly killing them and eating them?
Some people, his ex-girlfriend said that he would barbecue them.
Is that when she left? No. So I can't imagine coming home. to a couple of squirrels on the bobby.
I think she... This is definitely when she started being like...
I don't know about this. Because she said he just suddenly turned.
Like, he wasn't like this before. And now that shit is getting weird, even the neighbors who knew them as like a little like pseudo family. we're noticing that her behavior was starting to turn.
She was getting really depressed and quiet and was like, not really speaking about it a lot.
And they were like, what is going on? They could tell something... was really awry in this relationship, like it had turned sour.
Well, and she's in like such a weird spot, too, because her child lives here and she lives here and it's like.
Now she's probably wondering, do I have to find a new place for me and my kid to live because this guy is going off the rails?
Exactly. Now in that fall, she finally did break things off.
Yeah. said it was just his erratic mood changes and his really strange behavior was just she was like you said.
She had a son. Yeah. And she was like, he doesn't need to be around this.
You need to be by yourself or you need to figure stuff out.
But she came back October 24th just to pick up some of the remaining things she had left in the house.
It's always such a fucking long process.
And that's a very dangerous time when you come back to get the stuff.
And shit got wild. Now in the police report, she said, quote, we were in his living room talking and he got upset. and pushed me against a wall.
He had his forearm up against my neck and was choking me.
I got loose, but he grabbed me again and we tumbled over a chair to the floor.
I was fighting to try and get him off me, but he choked me on the ground.
She said she was scared of him and thought that he was going to kill her.
Yeah. She was like, I just want him out of my life for good.
So she did file a police report, but she never pressed charges.
Oh, which everyone has their own reasons for doing that.
Yeah, absolutely. And she really was like, I just wanted to get away with my son and just get him out of my life for good.
I didn't want anything else to do with him.
I made the police report. That's the end of that.
Yeah. And you know, when you press charges, it's like, sometimes these things go to trial, it gets expensive.
There's so many reasons why people don't always press charges. obviously now you can say back, like you wish that charges were pressed, but like, you got to understand that it's like, I could never imagine being in that situation.
It's a harrowing And with your child. Right.
Now, he had got that job at Fast Eddie's tree trimming service.
And at first... Like I said before, everyone there thought he was great.
It was during that time where everyone was like, wow, what a normal dude.
He was on the up and up. Just loves trees.
But then, after a while, during this whole period, the demeanor started changing at work as well.
He wasn't able to hold it together in both spots.
And he was changing completely. And he suddenly became strange and really creepy.
People were like, he just gave off a vibe suddenly.
And people at work were becoming very wary of him.
And he was now actually just hanging out in trees for hours and hours.
So like I know I've said it before that like he really likes trees.
That's like part of his whole pathology here.
But now, and like he liked climbing them before.
He liked being in them. He liked being around them.
But it was like... somewhat on a normal, just like, wow, he really likes trees level.
Now he's just sitting up in trees in his yard for hours.
Hours. his neighbors said that he would just sit there and also watch them like sit from his vantage points and like see people Yeah.
And he would just do it forever. Like, what do you do to stop somebody from doing that too?
Because that feels like a weird fucking experience.
A weird violation. of something. That feels like I want to call the police on you, but what do I say you're doing?
But I don't even know what to say. Hey, my neighbor's watching me from his tree again.
Can you stop him? So imagine a grown man who is your weird neighbor.
Just sitting in a tree for hours and hours, just touching leaves, staring at everybody.
Like staring at you. you he would fall asleep up there sometimes he would eat up there he would just hang up there If that was all he did, it would be strange, but somewhat harmless because you're just like... you're being kind of voyeuristic, which that should be taken away.
Right. If you just want to hang out in a tree somewhere and not look at anybody else, we can't stop you from doing that.
Yeah, if you just want to vibe in your tree, go. off but like don't stare at me while but don't look at people's houses and also What?
You're gonna have me like paranoid of like the trees.
Just look for trees, man. I'm gonna be like driving and looking at the treetops like...
Like, are you in there? Well, unfortunately, that's not all he did was just sit in trees for hours.
Because again... If he wasn't hurting anybody else and he wasn't like voyeuristically looking at anybody else, sit in a tree for hours, do what you want to do.
Whatever. else what is he doing that's not all he did what did he do so at his job You know, his boss suddenly found out like because people are starting to look into him now because they're like, you're acting weird.
So his boss was already like, he turned weird.
And this is strange. And I don't know what happened.
Yeah. Then the boss found out that he actually lied about his experience as a tree trimmer to get the job.
And he had also not disclosed that he had been in prison for that whole sentence. stealing welcome to Steamboat Springs signs and lighting a condo on fire with 16 people in it.
After spending many, many days in somebody else's condo.
So he was fired from his tree trimming job.
Uh-oh, but then that is gonna set off a motherfucking...
I don't even know. Avalanche of anger. Correct.
And it's beautiful, beautifully put. Spoken like a true author.
There you go. She wrote a book. No, now he's down a job and he's starting to really spiral.
He's down a job. He lost his girlfriend.
I was just going to say. he's spiraling and then his electricity was shut off because he didn't have any money to pay for it.
It doesn't sound like he's using it a lot anyways.
Well, he was also he was like a computer guy too.
Hmm. So I think now that's shut off. He's taking that as like a personal hit.
And there's just nothing to distract him.
He's just got trees and his anger. So now he's breaking into homes for fun like he did before.
He starts doing it again. God, I hate it so much.
Whenever we talk about people breaking into homes, I have nightmares of home invasions.
It's so creepy. And he's doing it just to like steal things, but also just for the thrill of it.
Because again, he's in that whole vibe where he needs that thrill.
Paul Hull says it always escalates with these home invasion people.
Exactly. He also says pillow. He does say pillow.
But that's, yeah. And I agree with him that not about pillow, but about the fact that these always escalate into something else if they are not caught.
Right. No, November 2010 is when he found a home that he zeroed in on and decided to watch to make his next target.
So he sat across the street from that home on King Beach Drive in Apple Valley, the home of Tina Herman.
There was that big stretch of woods where he could camp out across from it, which he did.
And he watched that house, the comings and goings.
And November 9th at 1 a.m., he made his move.
He parked a mile away from the house and he walked through the woods to get there.
Thank you. in the middle of the night. He brought with him a sleeping bag and he camped out one final time across the street from the house.
In the woods. So creepy. So there in his fucking sleeping bag...
He watches as the kids go to school, he watches As Tina goes to the grocery store, she left the house to go to the grocery store and get gas.
And as she went to the grocery store, he entered the house.
Now she returned home for like around noon, I think from the grocery store and the gas run.
As soon as she entered the home and walked to the kitchen, Matthew Hoffman jumped out and attacked her.
Oh God. He dragged her to the bedroom and hit her in the head and stabbed her with a hunting knife he had brought with him.
That's what tells me that he did not go just to rob this house.
Why do you have a hunting knife? He claimed that he was only planning to rob this home, but like Ash just said, and I just wrote in my notes, why the fuck did he bring a hunting knife?
Right. He claimed he waited for everyone to leave the home so he could rob it in peace and then leave undetected. but he brought a large serrated hunting knife with him.
No. Now what he said about this was, quote, I confronted her and made her get onto the bed lying face down.
I believe that we were in their bedroom.
I had a blackjack. I was going to try and knock her out.
I hit her a couple of times in the head, but this would not knock her out.
It was not doing the job and I started panicking. and that's when he started stabbing her so while this was happening and tina is being brutally beaten and stabbed in her bedroom Stephanie Sprang entered the home because she and Tina had plans to look at apartments together that day.
That's the other, like, just horrible part about this case.
Wrong place, wrong time. Wrong place, wrong time.
Not only that, but the fact that they weren't even going to be staying in this house much longer.
Nope, they were going to be leaving. And she found them, came upon them and immediately tried to help. was overpowered by Hoffman and chased into another room.
She went into Sarah's bedroom where she was killed.
Hoffman stabbed her twice viciously in the chest and then continued to stab her long after she was dead.
Oh, my God. Blood was everywhere. Later, he said of this, quote, and stabbed the woman on the bed through her back twice.
I chased the other woman down and stabbed her a couple of times in the chest.
Then he went back to Tina and stabbed her more and more and more.
So he's clearly enjoying it. He stabbed her long after she was dead, too, and also tore her abdomen open with the knife.
Oh my. He then dragged Tina into the bathtub and used his hunting knife to dismember her.
He said he had to pull her joints apart because he didn't have anything to cut through bone with.
Oh my God. He put the parts of her into trash bags.
Meanwhile, and this is an animal thing, so quick trigger.
Oh no. Give you a second. The family dog was going nuts.
No. He said he knew someone would hear it and become suspicious or even call the police, so he killed the dog and dismembered it as well.
He did the same thing to Stephanie Sprang.
What I don't understand is why he didn't just let the dog out.
Yeah, just let the dog run away. I mean, I don't understand this whole fucking thing, but. he said quote i took the bodies into the bathroom and began processing the bodies to dispose of them I use garbage bags from within the house and place the bodies within.
You know what, too? That totally tells me that his dogs didn't just disappear because there's no way you can do that without thought. like that he then poured motor oil over the huge blood drag marks because it would like dilute it and spatters that were everywhere.
He was putting the motor oil on it. And then he was planning to burn the home down and he figured the motor oil would stop them from seeing how much blood was there.
Huh. What he didn't count on is Sarah and Cody coming home from school.
When they arrived, there was blood in the entryway and they immediately were concerned.
They called for their mom, both of them, and Hoffman came charging at them out of nowhere.
Sarah said he literally charged out of nowhere at them.
He tackled Cody as he tried to flee out the front door.
Sarah was able to run to her room and try to get her phone out of her bag to dial 911.
Before running to stop Sarah, Hoffman instinctively stabbed Cody in the back of the head as he tried to run out the door.
He was dead immediately, and he stabbed him a couple more times when he fell.
Now, quickly about Cody, because we should know.
I said before that these were like super kind kids.
He loved baseball. He loved anything athletic.
He was a goofball. And his father Larry said, quote, You know how kids can be pretty mean at times, excluding others from their group?
Unpopular kids are kind of pushed to the side.
But when Cody saw that kind of thing, he would go out of his way to include those kinds of kids. and he wouldn't allow any bullying around him.
So then Hoffman ran straight for Sarah into her room.
She'd been trying to get her phone free to call 911, but he got her before she could dial.
She said he went to stab her. and then just stopped and instead cut the cord from the fan in her room and tied her hands with it.
And then he told her he would kill her if she made a sound.
He later said he didn't know why. He didn't just kill her, too.
And he said he just couldn't bring herself to himself to do it.
That's what he said. That doesn't make any sense to me, though, because you just killed, what, an 11 year old?
It makes perfect sense. He went in there to get that girl.
Yeah, well that's exactly it. That's what makes sense.
That's what I mean. I couldn't bring myself to kill her.
Of course you couldn't. That was your whole plan.
Exactly. Your whole plan was to kill everyone around her. and take her.
Right. That's why that statement doesn't make sense.
Good try. you killed everybody else. But he loves to pretend that was not his intention at all.
I just, you know, and by the way, he's a rapist, so So that just happened.
Like, I don't know. No, this was your. intent all along.
Your intent was to wait in that fucking house.
Maybe you planned on stealing some shit.
I'm sure you did. But you planned on killing anyone that got in your way and you were going to get that girl.
Right. And there's no thing in his past about like rape or sexual assault.
Or being like a pedophile? No. Because she's 13.
No. That's so weird. Nothing that I could find and nothing like... in reports or anything well like he was around he didn't have a criminal record before that condo thing So strange.
Because I agree with you. I think that's why he went in this house.
I think that's why he went in here. Because it just makes sense.
His story, other than his story that he tells, doesn't make sense for what happened here.
Yeah, it really doesn't. He was too, and he went right into like dismembering bodies.
Right. When we find out later where he put them, which I'll tell you later, that was very much planned out.
He had very much planned out that he needed the bodies in parts and in bags to be able to do what he did later.
I know it. It just, there's no way this guy, his story is bullshit. but he didn't kill Sarah and he just tied her up with that electrical cord.
He said he was planning to burn the house down.
He could have gotten rid of that evidence, but he said, suddenly I just had this urge to keep her alive.
That was his... his whole thing. So he gagged her.
He put a pillowcase over her head and then brought her down to the basement.
He then took the rope from an old sled in their basement and tied her legs together.
She said, quote, he was really angry. His voice was like a yell almost.
He was telling me what to do. It was like when someone yells at you and it's a command. which is so scary he then brought her upstairs and threw her on the kitchen floor and left her there while he cleaned up the scene So she's just lying there, gagged, bound, and terrified while this guy mills around her home. he was dismembering the rest of the bodies and cleaning up the evidence.
Like, I hope nobody ever has to feel the fear that must have been coursing through that little boy.
And she couldn't move, couldn't get out.
Nobody's around to hear her. And then he threw her into Stephanie's Jeep. with a ton of trash bags and blindfolded her.
She had no idea she was sitting next to the dismembered bodies of her mom, brother, dog, and mom's best friend.
Yeah. So he drove her a while and it was dark out.
She said he told her once they parked somewhere.
He told her, stay still, do not move. And he said, I'm going to be watching you.
And then he left the vehicle. So she decided to take a peek because she was like, fuck you, dude, I need to know where I am.
So she looked under the blindfold. She was able to like maneuver and they were at a baseball field and it was dark.
And he said he came back suddenly as soon as she looked and was yelling at her.
I told you I was going to be watching you.
Like, so he really was. And he said, if you try to look again, I'm gonna kill you.
And then he tightened her blindfold. And she said she had seen the trash bags when she had lifted her blindfold, but she had no idea what they were.
Of course not. Of course. So he left her in that car again for over an hour.
And what he was doing was walking to where he had left his car the night before, which was a Toyota Yaris. and he had left it to walk to that patch of woods across the street from their home.
Right. So it was a long walk to go back there.
Yeah. And he drove the Yaris back to the stolen Jeep and then transferred Sarah into his Yaris.
Now he drove her to his home and carried her into a bathroom.
He then took the blindfold off her and she saw a strange sight.
The walls were white, but in this particular room that she was in, there were drawings all over them in black ink.
There were animals and people like weird, deformed people.
And like yin and yang symbols and peace symbols and all of it was just like trippy looking and like... scribbled on there.
And like, I guess This is according to the book that I read about this case, which let me tell you what it is, because it is like...
This book is so extensive and it's so well done and it's long.
You'll get everything you need out of this book.
Let me tell you what it is. It is called The Girl in the Leaves by Robert Scott.
And I'm telling you... Of course, I will link it like we always do.
This book is amazing. And in that book, he says that there was one, like the faucet had a drawing around it that made it look like a guy with like the faucet was coming out of it. his mouth what the fuck which is just like so trippy and scary And, like, can you imagine that's what you see after you've just been kidnapped?
No. Like... I must have added to her anxiety.
So much anxiety. And then he duct taped her and tied her with a rope in the bathroom. told her that he would be back, but he said, I have people watching the house, so if you try anything, you'll die.
And he had already proven the last time, when I say I'm watching you, I'm watching you, so she's not going to move.
He then went back to the stolen Jeep and got the trash bags filled with dismembered human remains.
He then stopped at a Walmart where he is on CCTV footage walking around very casually.
And this is in the middle of the night, by the way. bought a blue tarp and more garbage bags.
And he also bought a turkey sandwich and a $1 Halloween shirt.
Oh, okay. Very casual, too, on that. You watch that CCTV footage knowing what he has just spent. hours doing and that there is a 13 year old girl duct taped in his bathroom at home And people dismembered in his car in the Walmart parking lot.
And he's just walking by people just... No big deal.
So he now disposes of the bags with Cody...
Tina, Stephanie, and the dog's bodies. I'm going to tell you where he disposed of them in part two, because that at this point was not known.
So I just want to tell you that later. And he then drove the Jeep back to Tina Herman's home and left the tarp and garbage bags in the garage there. then got into the pickup truck that was in the garage and planned to drive it to take to the gas station to get gas to then burn the home down.
So this was their pickup truck? Yeah, he just stole it out of the garage. but the truck kept stalling, so he had to abandon it somewhere and walk to his yaris again.
Now this is the point. where the lights were off initially, no one was in the driveway, the cops saw that, nothing's going on.
Then when he comes back, suddenly the car's back in the driveway.
Lights are on. That's because he came back.
So the truck kept stalling, so he had to abandon it somewhere.
He walked to his Yaris again. He was a fucking mess.
Like he was this was I believe he had a plan.
But I believe what happened is he had no idea that Stephanie Sprang was going to walk into that house.
And it threw him off. Stephanie Spring, I think, was the thing that threw off his plan.
Other than that, I think he was going to kill Tina.
He was going to dismember her. He was going to put her in a trash bag.
He was going to wait for those kids to come home and he was going to kill Cody.
And then he was going to take Sarah and it would burn the house down.
The end. Right. But I think another adult walking in unexpectedly while he was in the middle of everything threw him.
So far off kilter. Right. And then everything just became, because now there's an extra car that you have to get rid of.
There's this, there's that. there was another whole person that you're going to have to now figure out what to do with.
I think it threw him totally off kilter in this because he's just a fucking wreck.
Yeah. Like truly. So now instead of going back to the crime scene like he originally was going to to burn the place down, He just goes home because he's exhausted.
And he said he was just like, he went home to Sarah, who's still tied up in his fucking trippy bathroom.
Meanwhile, Sarah had been trying to come up with a plan.
Mm-hmm. And she realized the really only thing she could do here was comply and try to appeal to something inside of him.
Right. And she was like, he stopped before he killed me.
So clearly, maybe I can appeal to something here.
And he was bigger and stronger than her.
And she needed to get out of there without a physical.
She was like, that wasn't going to work.
She also thinks that people are watching this house.
Yeah. She doesn't know if it's just him involved.
Of course. So when he came home, she decided to just talk to him.
Okay. She asked him questions. What a brave little girl.
I wouldn't even be able to get words out.
She asked him what he did for a living. She was so fucking strong and smart about this.
I'm in awe. And he answered and talked to her, but it would also kind of shut down a little bit and get cold at times.
But after a while, he decided they were moving from the bathroom and he wasn't going to blindfold her anymore.
Mm-hmm. Which makes me nervous. He took her out of the room after hours and hours and she saw his home for the first time.
There were leaves everywhere. You heard that.
There were leaves, leaves from trees, crunch crunch leaves. covering the floors and stacked up in bags along every single wall.
The walls were literally leaves. floor to ceiling leaves in every room except for like one tiny bathroom and she was like what the fuck is with the leaves, bro?
Like she was like, what is this? Right. she was like my immediate thing was like oh i'm gonna ask you about this that's for sure she was like your bathroom is something but guy we gotta talk about So she was like, what's with all the leaves?
And he was like, oh, I use them for insulation.
I don't know about that. Honey, what? I feel like you use them for really gross things.
She was like, I let that go. Like I'm not, she's like ask any further, like no more.
Sure. And then he said that he had not killed her brother and mother. and that he let the dog out of the house.
So he's just an asshole. He's a lying sack of shit.
He then told her that he would feed... He was like, are you hungry?
And she was like, I'm actually very hungry.
And she was like, do you want some squirrel?
I have some in the freezer. And she was like, I'm not that hungry.
Like, no. And she literally told him, like, no, I'm not eating a squirrel.
And when she was like, no, he was like, alright, I have cereal.
So he gave her cereal with sour milk ew what the fuck yeah and she said she ate it because she didn't know when she was going to be able to eat again oh my god He then tied her to him and took a nap because he was exhausted and tied her to him.
Ew, ew, ew. And that is where we are going to end for part one.
Because... It gets caught pretty quick, so don't worry.
He's going to be taken downtown. But it's wild.
Yeah. it's wild and it gets rough and he this guy is i don't know what his thing is for trees could be called But it's something fucking weird.
It's really something. And he's a really scary individual.
And I am so glad that he is never going to be able to walk outside again.
All right, well, I'm excited for part two.
Hope that you are too. As well. And... Oops, sorry.
I just cracked my knuckles. Stress. We hope that you keep listening.
And we hope you... Keep... It... Weird.
But I don't even, I'm so stressed out right now, Not so weird that like you do all the things that Matthew Hoffman did, like break into somebody's condo, find out what makes a Subaru a Subaru, like just... leaves, murder.
None of it. Stop. None of it. If you want to climb a tree, climb a tree.
Leave it at that. Yeah. Leave it at that.
Nature is great, but not that great. Just climb one tree and then go home.
Thank you. If you like Morbid, you can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wondery.com slash survey.
