Episode 222: The Mysterious Murder of Julia Wallace Part 1 | Morbid

Hey weirdos, before we unleash today's macabre mystery, we were wondering, have you ever heard of Wondery Plus?

It's like a secret passage to an ad free layer with early access to episodes.

You can join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or an Apple podcast or Spotify.

You're listening to a morbid network podcast.

Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar.

Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love, You can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities and new ways of thinking.

Listening can lead to positive changes in your mood, your habits, and ultimately your overall well-being.

Audible has an incredible selection of over 1 million audiobooks, podcasts, and Audible Originals all in one easy app.

Find the genres you love and discover new ones.

Explore bestsellers like my sister's title. new releases, plus thousands of included audiobooks, podcasts, and originals that members can listen to all they want with more added all the time.

I have been listening to the Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club, which actually Elena recommended to me.

She did not listen to it, but she said, girl, this title sounds so you.

And let me tell you, it did. I've been listening to it while I walk, and I am absolutely loving it.

I love all the I love Audible. There's more to imagine when you listen.

Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial and your first audiobook is free. visit audible.com slash morbid.

I am absolutely obsessed with a sweet treat after dinner, and my favorite sweet treat right now is my mochi.

I'm not yours. Just kidding. You can have some too.

This is a cool creamy scoop of ice cream. wrapped in a soft, chewy dough.

It's like a sweet little ice cream dumpling or ravioli.

I'm obsessed. It's pillowy. It's satisfying.

I feel indulged. I just love it so much.

I really am obsessed with the strawberry flavor right now.

My mochi is only around 70 calories per piece, which like, hello, that's amazing.

My mochi is gluten free and each box has six perfectly portioned mochi snacks.

Do I eat two a night? Yeah. Yeah, I do because they're that good.

And guess what? My mochi is the number one mochi ice cream in the US of A.

The strawberry flavor is bursting with fresh picked fruit flavor that tastes incredibly refreshing.

I love, love, love them after dinner this August.

Look for the purple box of My Mochi ice cream at your local grocery store. and feel joyfully chill with the coolest treat around, my mochi.

Hey, weirdos. I'm Elena. I'm Ash. And this is Morbid.

And we're sitting closer to each other than usual.

We are. I'm like, hi. Don't touch me. We can high five if we want.

Here you go. We can fist bump. No, that's a Oh, I have a big ring.

I'm sorry. Ah, there we go. Big cocktail ring was about to fuck up my knuckles.

Usually I have like rings on every finger too.

I just have that one ring that I've got for like, it's one of those rings that I saw on like TikTok.

Is it Etsy? Wait, is it one of them that like come in a candle?

No, it didn't come in a candle, but it was, I think it's like.

Jumanji or something like that. That's fine.

It's cool. They have cute rings and they're like pretty cheap. that's fine oh it didn't turn my finger green so i got us a present that is a ring but i'm not going to tell you what kind it is i'm excited i got it on etsy Did you get one for everyone else?

No. What? Sorry guys. I was like, what?

No. No. I was like, who's everyone? All of them.

Yeah, guys, check your mail. I got you a ring.

You guys want to marry me? Who doesn't?

Probably someone. Probably someone from my past that was like, dodge that bullet.

Oh, yeah. Trust me. I got a couple of those, too.

They're like, whelp. Guys, it's because we always have to tell you the time of the day.

It's morbid at night if you couldn't tell. you can always tell the difference late night ash and elena my voice sounds a little different in the morning yeah it's you know it's the end of the week We are catching up with ourselves.

We're getting ahead of ourselves a little bit this coming week and we're excited about it.

So we won't be like scrambling to get episodes out in time.

So... Get ready. It's going to be great, guys.

You're going to see a lot more of us. Yeah, we're feeling good. and anywhere.

So this was originally going to be a one part.

And I was like, oh, fun. Fun case. Like...

Cool. I'm going to do that for one episode.

Okay. And then I did what I do, and I looked, and I was like, oh, okay.

It's probably going to be eight parts. I can make this an entire season.

Season 82 of Morbid. So this story is often referred to as the impossible murder.

Oh, yeah. Sorry I had to clear my throat.

Let me clear my throat. You don't even know how excited you just made me.

Yeah, so this is the impossible murder. It's been covered by a ton of TV shows and movies and...

People have been hemming and hawing and trying to figure this mystery out for decades.

That's weird because I never heard of it.

For decades. I have heard of it, but I never looked super into it.

Now that I have, I'm like, I get it. okay i totally get it all right i don't get what happened no but i get it i get the fascination what are you looking at I was trying to figure out which knob was mine because I was going to turn down my headphones without asking you to.

She keeps looking. I was like, what is this?

What is crawling up the side of my chair that you're looking at and don't want to tell me no I was actually just trying not to interrupt the podcast to ask you an annoying question but I guess you're gonna make me turn my headphones down.

Yes I can. Just a smidgen. Just a smidgen.

Sometimes, that's so much better. Sometimes I ask Alina to turn down my headphones and she pretends that she does and she doesn't and I'll go, that's better.

And she's like, I didn't change it i do that so much but you did but i did do it this time you saw that Yeah.

Right. That's like so much better. Thank you.

We were like screaming in my ears. Here you are, guys.

Sorry to interrupt. So this takes place in England.

So hello, England. Hello. Oh, boy. That wasn't me.

I just want you to know that. Ash really took it back.

Again, it's a weird night. It's Easter.

It's Easter. Oh, I had a brownie. not no like I was saying I was gonna say like I didn't eat a lot of candy like I don't know why I'm so hyper and then I was like oh I had a brownie I didn't know what that was.

I was like, what is the connection? And like a regular brownie before anybody tweets at me.

Yeah, just a regular brownie. Yeah, there's kids. those kids yes fucking kids man all right so we're gonna talk about are we we're gonna talk about A man named William Herbert Wallace.

Yes, William Wallace. Not the same William Wallace from Brave Hat.

Brave Hat. But a William Wallace. William Herbert Wallace.

You know, I'm saying. And he was 52 years old.

All right. He was born to August. You said that like I accused you.

It was like he was 52 years old. You were like, all right.

Shit. I believe you. Should we podcast right now?

I feel like, you know, with this and the last Listener Tales, I feel like we're killing it.

All right. I always worry that, like, my giggling is going to annoy.

I like your giggling. Oh my God, thanks, Mom.

You're welcome. So he was born on August 29th, 1878.

Okay. And he lived in Anfield. Or Anfield.

Uh-oh. Oh no! Pause. Yeah. Anfield. Wow, it's like Jeeves took over your body.

It did. Ask Jeeves. You know, I think somebody described it in more detail on Twitter, and I was like, I actually think I do remember that.

I don't know. all right maybe maybe I don't I don't know so William all right so William So Anfield, right?

I didn't just forget that. Honestly, I have no recollections.

Anfield. Alright, he was a Prudential Assurance Company employee, so he sold insurance.

Okay. He had done a ton of jobs growing up and he had actually landed this job because his dad got him this job.

It wasn't what he really wanted. to do but he did it and he did it well and you know it did him well You know, that sounds dirty, but it wasn't.

It didn't really sound that dirty. Maybe I just meant it that way.

But William was known to dress like very fancy.

Well, yeah, you're selling insurance. You got to look the part of insurance.

Well, and he kind of like, he went with like the old fashioned look.

Like he liked to have a bowler hat. He had like the raglan shirt and he was always dressed in a dapper, dapper blazer.

Oh, I love a Dapper Dapper Blazer. Yeah, and I imagine he always had, like, a pocket watch somewhere.

Or, like... Even just like a flowered pocket square.

Very Carson Kressley. Exactly. I love Carson so much.

That's exactly how I would describe him.

I mean, he was also he was tall. He was slim.

And he looked kind of like what we all think Jack the Ripper looks like almost.

Did he have a mustache? He had a mustache.

And that's not a commentary on whether I think he's guilty of this crime or not, that he looked like Jack the Ripper, but I'm just saying.

Okay. But he loved to play the violin and he would play the violin while his wife, Julia, played the piano.

Bitch. Love. Seems adorable to me. I'm just saying.

So I want to say so scenic, but that's not the right thing to say.

I meant wholesome. So scenic. So scenic, so wholesome.

And they would often have people over to their home, their flat in England.

And they would play together. They would like duet music.

Put on a show. Yeah, put on a little show.

A little number. A little folk number. Unfortunately, he was sick a lot.

He had a lot of kidney issues. At one point, he had gone on a business trip, I believe, to India.

And while he was there, he ended up having a severe... kidney issues, he ended up having one kidney removed and the other kidney like never really picked up the slack.

So he had a lot of issues throughout his life with the kidneys.

Kidney issues? I feel like must hurt a lot because you've had a kidney infection.

Oh my God. Kidney infections hurt. So bad.

And they're real bad. They make you so sick.

Oh, I feel for him. So he was married to a woman named Julia.

Yes. Julia's maiden name was Dennis, Julia Dennis.

She was born April 28th, 1861. This would, remember he was 52, this would make her 69 when she died.

The only reason I point that out is because her gravestone says that she was 52 when she died. oh that's weird even weirder she married william in 1914 and the marriage certificate says she was 37

But she was 53 in real life. Oh. So her gravestone shows her as being one year younger than she was when she actually married William.

She was lying about 17 years. What? She was literally saying that she was 17 years younger than she actually was.

Oh, what a bad bitch. And... There's like so many, anytime I've read anything, people are like, I cannot figure out why.

She didn't want to age. Or if William knew, which it doesn't seem like he did because on her gravestone...

He would have had it say the correct thing.

And it's like, she wrote that she was 37 when they got married and she was 52.

She was 52 when they got married. Yeah. Wow.

17 years older than what she was actually saying she was.

She must have looked great. It's bonkers to me.

Botox before Botox. Botox before Botox.

Well, the thing was she was having a lot of ailments as well. like she was always sick as well because she was old because she was 17 years older than yeah But it's just really weird.

I don't understand. The thing is, William wasn't understanding why she was sick all the time. because he didn't know that she was old well that's why i assume he does he didn't know her real age yeah That's what it sounds like to me.

That's a pretty big secret to hide from your... literal partner for life maybe she thought at some point she would start like benjamin buttoning it Maybe.

She didn't, unfortunately. Maybe she thought that she was going to find the fountain of youth like in Tuck Everlasting.

There you go. Deep cut. Maybe. Maybe. I think that's what she was thinking.

You can't rule it out. You don't know. Yeah.

Well, either way, she was described as gentle, shy at times, brilliant, artistic.

Uh, well kept. She was also raised, um, like pretty well to do and it showed, uh, They lived a modest life, but they had money.

They were comfortable. They were definitely comfortable.

And in a time when a lot of people were not comfortable, like hello, Great Depression.

Yeah. Did they like not live beyond their means?

I don't think they did. It didn't seem like they did.

It's the best thing you can do. And she dressed very prim and proper like her husband.

And she also dressed old fashioned like her husband and kind of eccentric.

Also because she was old. Well, I was just going to say, but was it really old fashioned?

It was kind of from her era. To be real.

So I think people were like, wow, you're dressing so much older for your age.

And she's like... She's like, I'm just so proud of you.

I'm almost two decades older than I'm saying I am. like it's one thing to be like oh that would be like me no i'm not even shitting you right now that would be like me saying i was four years old right now Hi, I'm four.

Like, that would be a problem. I'd be the orphan.

You know? I do. I do know. That would be like you saying that you were 14.

Yeah. That was quick-ass math for me. That was, because I was like, I'm not doing that.

No, you'd be 15, actually. That works. But honestly, it makes sense if I was like, you know, hey, I'm 30.

Yeah. That makes sense. Honestly, you could probably trick someone into thinking that you were 15. i think about it i don't think no well there's been times where you get caught i get carded and you don't Or the other way around.

No, I get carded and you don't. But that would mean that you're, like, young... looking and I'm not.

If you're getting carded, that means you're wrong.

I was like, no. I said what I said. You were so confident.

I was like... No. Do I let this go? Or do I fight?

Fight to the death. Finish him. Bully Ash. either way yeah but there julia was she was i don't know i don't know what it is you look at a picture of her and you're like get it julia yeah was she pretty she was and she was eccentric she just like it didn't give a fuck when it came to that i'm obsessed with julia julia with her She knew several languages.

She was a painter. She loved literature, music, obviously, her and her hubby there.

She just liked to learn and experience things.

That's awesome. But she was also kind of shy so she didn't like like social things kind of freaked her out a little bit which like i get it she kind of sounds a lot like you other than lying about her age i'm like julia you and Well, you don't dress old either.

I try not to. I think she just sounded smart, so I was saying that you're smart.

Oh, thank you. Yeah, yeah, yeah. She sounded pretty cool, though, to be honest.

Yeah. Like you. Like I said, shit was definitely rough at this time because, you know, like, that large depression.

The great one. But that really great one.

Massive depression. But again, he had a good job as an insurance salesman and together they had their flat.

I think it was like a three bedroom flat.

Like it was a nice. it was a nice place um like she had a room in the flat that was like just for her like handbags and hats Yeah, I was like, wow, that's great.

She had a walk-in closet before there were walk-in closets.

There you go. Now what's weird is the conflicting ideas of what people say about them as a married couple.

Okay. Now, some people will say that they were very happy.

They seemed very normal together as a couple.

Others describe their marriage as like, kind of cold haters and like tension filled that's what i'm saying It's weird.

So the age thing kind of is like weird later on, too. um because like if you're lying about 17 years what else are you lying about oh yeah like that's a big lie I want to know why she was lying.

And no one can figure it out. Do you think it's because she like loved him so much and she didn't think that he would want to marry an older woman?

Which like, that's sad. But then there were people that later said that it seemed like she thought she kind of married down.

Well, she was like, well, to do. Yeah. So I think I don't know.

It's maybe she makes sense. Maybe it was like what I said, like she lied because she really wanted to marry him.

And then maybe she realized that it wasn't what she wanted, but you couldn't get divorced back then. maybe so maybe maybe the marriage and the love fizzled out because like maybe people were lying Well, people around them would say different things, but their neighbors, the Johnsons, who figure very heavily into this story,

Okay. They were around them all the time, and they said, like, they were very affectionate with each other, like a normal affectionate couple.

Yeah. Like, not over the top, but... By no means were they cold with one another.

Well, I believe the Johnsons. I believe the Johnsons to be honest.

I don't know on what basis, but I believe them.

But with the age thing and how she lied about that, later we will see that William was asked whether his wife had... had her own money stashed in the house at all?

Or do you know if she had her own money?

And he said he didn't know if she had her own money.

And if she did, he didn't know where it was.

And I was like, that's a weird question.

Huh. But I was like, that's weird that like you wouldn't know.

Yeah. If she had her own money, you know what I mean?

Because like back then it's not like she was like going off to work.

You know what I mean? Right. You don't know if she does.

Like that to me says there was more secrets in this marriage than they were letting on.

Well, unless they were like, oh, did she hide money?

And he was like, I don't know. I don't think so.

He's like, I don't know. Like, maybe. Maybe he's like, I never thought about it.

Like, I don't know. It just seems like it was like one of those things that they are definitely it's weird hiding more from each other than a normal or like a seemingly normal couple you know what i mean yeah it's strange just strange and especially now after you know you have the case you're like that's a little weird okay So one other thing that was just interesting to me is like, they're like me and John because she was 5'2 and he was 6'2.

So she was very short and he was very tall.

I like that you gave yourself a couple extra inches there.

I gave me a couple of extra inches and I took an inch away from him.

Because John is 6'3", and I am 5'1". You're 5'.

So they would also, like I said, they were both pretty sickly.

Yeah, but what was funny is people would say that they would like switch off ailments.

One of them was always sick. I think that's like a phenomenon.

Well, this was more... This wasn't one of those things like, oh, like I get the cold and then he gets the cold.

It was like, one of them would be down and out, sick in bed for a week, and then when that one was better, immediately she would get sick and down and out, but with something different yeah that's weird and what people said was it wasn't one of this like oh funny things it was like a competition almost Like my I'm sicker than you.

Do you think one of them had like Munchausen's?

I don't think so. I mean, because William was definitely sickly.

Like he had the kidneys. Yeah. Yeah. Like the kidney thing really probably would take him out a lot.

Do you think she would? I think she was actually, what we will find out later, she had a lot more ailments than like real ailments than people were letting on to.

Alright. But it's just people were saying like they were just always sick and it seemed like they were always like People kept describing it as a tit for tat with sicknesses.

Which is very weird. Yeah. And actually, William kept a diary. which figures heavily into the court case later, they really go into it.

And he would say sometimes like he was kind of annoyed with how she was always sick.

Well, because even when you're getting over it, like even when he wasn't sick anymore and it was her turn, he was probably still getting over it.

So he's probably like, I don't want to fucking take care of you right now.

And it just is one of those things where you're like, can you just like give me a minute?

Just give me a minute. Let me have my time.

Take care of you. Yeah. But they did have a housekeeper that came by the house every Wednesday.

Her name was Sarah. All right. She commented later that it did seem like William was not happy, like I said, being an insurance salesman.

He... felt kind of saddled with the gig and he really, he was making money out of it, it was fine, it was good work. but he really loved and wanted to pursue science.

Oh. And we'll see that later. I'll explain it.

Um, And he couldn't, and I think it was kind of depressing him.

Like, he did say in his diary that, you know, they poured over. that he said he would feel depressed at times and down and like not happy with his life.

But then he would, you know, gush about his wife sometimes.

He would talk about how much he loved her, cared for her.

And then other times he would be like, she's really annoying and sick all the time.

It's kind of like... So it's like a normal stream of consciousness, I think, for somebody going through a lot of shit.

Yeah. Because it's not like this is like... a very constant economical, you know, like, there's no...

There's nothing that's comfortable right now.

No. Because everything was in flux. Not only is like the economy in flux, but like their health is in flux.

Maybe their love situation is in flux. Yeah, it just seems like there's a lot going on and he's not happy about his job, but he still has a job.

So I'm sure he was like good days and bad days.

Yeah. So it sucks. Yeah. So that's who they are as people.

All right, where are we headed? Let's take you to January 19, 1931.

All right, let's go. Now, we're going to take you to the Central Chess Club at City Cafe on North John Street.

Chess is kind of a big thing in this case, which is interesting.

Weird. You know those photos sitting in your phone, the ones that make you smile every time you scroll past them?

Well, at smallwoodhome.com, they believe that you deserve better than that smallwood home transforms your favorite memories into stunning gallery quality artwork that tells your story All you have to do is upload your photo to smallwoodhome.com, choose your style from classic framed prints to elegant wrapped canvases. and they'll handle the rest with natural wood finishes like stained almond black or white plus options for sleek acrylic fronts, there is a perfect match for every home.

And the best part? Every small wood home piece is handcrafted right here in the USA by real artisans who care about quality.

No assembly lines, no shortcuts, just beautiful, personalized art that is made to last.

I love a handcrafted thing. Over 3 million happy customers have already discovered why smallwoodhome.com is just different. they deliver gallery quality at prices that make sense and ship in just days I have so many photos in my phone that I'm about to send over to them that I can finally hang up on my walls and I'm really excited about it.

Right now, get 30% off when you use code MORBID at smallwoodhome.com.

That's promo code MORBID to get 30% off your first order at smallwoodhome.com.

Give your memories the showcase they deserve.

You know that person in your life who just can't stand mayo?

Call them traumatized. Call them close-minded.

We get it. They're stuck in their ways. But here's the thing.

They just haven't tried Hellman's flavored mayo.

We're talking bold flavors that will flip even the biggest skeptics.

Spicy mayo that adds the perfect kick to your burger.

Garlic aioli that transforms ordinary fries into something extraordinary.

Chipotle mayo that turns your basic wrap into a smoky sensation.

So to all the mayo haters out there, yes, we're looking at you.

It's time to eat your words, because with mayo this flavorful, Any hater is just a mayo lover waiting to be convinced.

Hellman's Flavored Mayo. Get ready to eat your words.

So William did join a chess club. He was part of a chess club for a while.

And it was literally like they would meet like two times a week and they would all like play against each other.

You had like matches. They would have tournaments.

It was like a thing and it you know keeps your mind working that sounds cool do you know how to play chess I don't.

I used to know very loosely how to play chess.

I have not even the vaguest. I've also, I've actually always wanted to like sit down and really learn chess.

Maybe we should do that. We should do it together.

I feel like it's such a good mind work I just, I don't even give a fuck about that.

I just want to say checkmate. and like and then i don't even want to play i just want to say check no i want to play and i want to throw the board when i win at the end i love that like overturn it yeah just flip it up like Teresa.

I would love to get a really beautiful chess set.

Oh. But I don't want to be one of those people that has one and doesn't know how to play chess.

I need to know how to play chess first. Yeah, that'd be stupid.

I want to earn my beautiful chess set. Oh, and you could get like really like, like, um, like, mm. pieces like cool gothic yeah yeah like a gothic castle chess set yes that's all i want Or we could get one of those giant ones like in Harry Potter and we could explode at the end if we lost.

And there we are as people. That right there.

I love it. Yeah. That's why I love you. I love you.

I love you. I love you. So Captain Samuel Beatty.

He is the guy that would run the chess club.

He sounds like he would. Yeah, and he was a cool guy.

He's the guy that originally gets a phone message this night, January 19th, 1931. which is for William Wallace at the chess club before he arrived.

And it set this whole thing into motion.

All right. So we're going to see. Sam. Now, Samuel Beatty According to The Killing of Julia Wallace by Jonathan Goodman.

Yes, she dies. Spoiler alert. Spoiler alert.

The Killing of Julia Wallace is a great book.

They go into like massive detail about every single second of this case, and I could not put it down, so I highly recommend it.

Kindle? It is on Kindle. All right. So go get it.

Um, so he, they said that, um, Beatty would come straight from work and go to the cafe on Mondays and Thursdays to set the chess club up.

He knew William Wallace for about eight years.

They were very friendly. They played chess together a lot. you know all that fun stuff at the chess club whoa he said he was a very nice man Like very nice.

At most, I could not find anybody that was like William Wallace was a dick. or anything less than like, he was so pleasant.

He doesn't really sound like a dick. He seemed like a nice guy.

He did say that he could be a little flaky.

And he said because he was sick a lot. Same.

Well, he said he's sick a lot, so he doesn't show up for matches.

He's at chess club one week. He's not there for three weeks.

That's not flaky. That's just somebody going through illness.

Yeah. And I think he also was just like, he just wouldn't show up sometime.

Like he was just kind of like, whatever.

I feel that so hard. But he didn't hold it against him.

But he said he did only show up here and there for chess club.

He was definitely not like a regularly attending person.

He hadn't been there since December at this point in January 19th, so...

He had once told them that he just didn't like leaving his wife at home at night alone.

Bitch. Which... Like my heart. The deeper we're getting into this, this is starting to sound familiar to me.

Is it? Yeah. Look at that. Well, around 720 p.m. on January 19th, the waitress at the city cafe named Gladys Harley.

Of course. She answered the phone. Gladys.

I don't know why it fell out. What the fuck was that?

I just feel like even if someone in your body just come over a second.

I feel like even in England, I feel like she's like, hey, it's Gladys.

I don't think so. I just feel that even your whole entire face that was honestly a little scary Oh, guys.

Okay, okay, okay. Sorry, I had a possession moment.

Gladys took over my body. I almost laughed.

Gladys answered the phone. Hey, it's Gladys.

It's Gladys. Okay. reflect ourselves and i'm ready to talk about gladys everybody i'm ready to talk about gladys She answered the phone and it was the operator who was telling her someone's on the line for you. whoa, what the fuck is that all about?

And she's, so she waited because that's what you do in 1931.

You wait. Wait. And she just heard a couple of voices on the other end.

And she said, she was like, it sounded like they were just talking to each other.

So she was like, do you need something? Can I help you?

Because Gladys is not fucking around. She's got waiting to do.

She doesn't have time for this. So she heard a man's voice and she said it sounded kind of like a little fancy, a little upper crusty. you know and it was asking um if she was on the line with the central chess club and then he so she was like yes i am and this person said is mr wallace there And she was like, I don't really know who that is.

So she was like, I will ask. Because she was waitressing there, but she didn't know everybody's names. so she went to Beatty and she asked him And he said that Wallace wasn't there yet, but he was due to play a match later that night.

So he was expecting him to show up, but he told her, you know what?

I'll just talk to the guy on the phone for you and see what he wants.

Yeah. He was like, why should you relate? all this.

So he tells the guy, hi, Wallace isn't here, but he may be arriving shortly. but it's kind of a crapshoot because like Wallace, am I right?

And, So the guy on the other end says, can you give him a message for me?

And he's like, sure. So he says, can you tell him to call me tomorrow at 7.30 p.m.?

? Or come see me tomorrow at 7.30 p.m. at 25 Menlove Gardens East.

Men love gardens. Men love gardens. East.

So he said it's business related, it's insurance related, he'll know what it means.

Uh, so he's like, sure, dude, what's your name?

And I bet that's what he said. Yeah. And he says, what's your name?

And he says it's RM Qualtrough. No, it's not.

Yeah. Qualtra. Qualtra. That's what it is.

And he wrote it down for him because he was like, how the... fuck do you spell Qualtrough?

I was trying to be fancy and I was like, fuck.

That's what he said. How the fuck do you spell that?

I can't think of any other fancy name. That's the only word I could come up with.

How on God's green earth do you spell that?

Ah, so Qualtra. So we wrote it down for him and that was that.

Sure. The call came right before Wallace arrived, because he arrived right after that.

Weird timing. A little bit. He had apparently been recovering from the flu.

He said he had the flu the week before. Oh man.

And he said Julia, his wife, had also been recovering from a nasty cold.

Ugh, Julia. So when Wallace got there, he started catching up on some matches with other players.

And because he's so flaky, he was kind of behind Wallace.

And there are rules that you have to like do so many matches to get into a tournament.

So he was trying to get his shit together.

You know what I mean, man? Yeah. So he's playing chess and Beatty comes and tells him about this Qualtra.

I'm probably saying the name wrong, but I don't know.

Q. Q-U-A-L-T-R-O-U-G-H. Qualtra. Or Qualtrough.

Qualtrough. Either one. He doesn't exist.

Spoiler alert. Spoiler alert. I kind of felt like he didn't.

So he's like, what? Qualtrough? What is that?

He was like, I don't know anyone. named that and he was like i'd never even heard that name yeah it's weird but he's like well he wants you to meet him or call him tomorrow and he gives him all the information So he made it clear.

Wallace made it clear right there. He was like, I don't know this address.

I've never heard of this address. I don't know this guy.

It sounds made up, all of it. He was like, this whole thing is weird.

So after the matches, he walked and took the tram with a couple of the other men from the club.

And he walked home partially with a very good friend of his and a fellow chess player named James Caird. who said they spoke about the mystery caller, like as they walked home.

And he said Wallace was genuinely confused by this person. yeah and said he had never heard of him and he said what a funny sounding name yeah he was genuinely like what the fuck like why was he calling me a chess club it's weird Well, that's the thing, because it's like, can you have them call me?

And it's like, well, then he has a phone, so... Well, that's why in...

By all accounts that talked to him that night, he did seem genuinely like, what the fuck?

Yeah, so there's that. But a weird little tidbit about the street that Julia and William lived on.

It was Wolverton Street, and according to that book, The Killing of Julia Wallace and a couple of other articles I read, It had a lot of death attached to it.

Oh. Like weirdly so. Almost cursed. People would say it was cursed and I kind of believe them.

Fuck that. In the year before Julia's death, three people had killed themselves on the street.

Five women lost their husbands in weird, tragic ways.

Accidents. Another person who lived on the street died while watching a soccer match and another fell to their death on vacation off a building.

In England, that would actually be a football match.

I almost said a football match, but then I was like, no, it's soccer here.

So... I'm just going to stay in my lane.

But yeah, you would say football. Football.

I don't know. I was like football. Kind of sounded like you said football.

Football. Football. A football match. You know, a football match over there, a soccer match over here.

You all get it. So lots of people dying on the street is the moral of that story.

Again, people were thinking it was cursed.

On top of this, on top of all that gnarly situation, there was a creep. and he was creep creep creepin on this street uh during this time there was a guy or a gal referred to as the uh and the on-field housebreaker bitch and he had gonna break your house He's going to break the shit out of your house.

And he had broken into upwards of 30 homes recently in the area.

He was, and I'm saying he because I'm just generalizing here.

He would usually do it when no one was home, but the strange thing about this is they used a key, whoever it was. are um these are are they like apartment buildings no these are like flats like actually like homes yeah and either he would either use a key that was copied or he would use or they thought maybe like a skeleton key that he could get into everywhere That's spooky.

And they didn't catch him. Oh, man. Or her or them, whoever it was, because we don't know.

Never. Yeah. We have no idea. Maybe it was Qualtrough.

And this was all happening as this is going on.

So that's something to keep in mind. Now, that night he had dinner with Julia at home.

Julia had made a nice dinner. Um... all was well that evening she was like getting over this cold she still wasn't feeling that great apparently though she was upset because her black cat was missing No, I'm not even talking about it.

Yeah. Nothing bad happens to the cat, so don't worry.

No, I know. It's just like my worst fear is losing Franklin or Lux.

Yeah, I feel you. I think about it every day.

I feel that too. So that was that night.

The next day, January 20th, 1931. Wallace worked all day.

He would go around collecting insurance payments all around the area.

I was like, a very tiring job i was gonna say sounds like bullshit yeah and at lunch he would come home and he had lunch with Julia and then he did a little bit of work on his own.

Because like I said, he loved science. This is when it comes back.

He had a very big interest in science, particularly biology and chemistry.

His prized possession was a microscope that he spent a pretty penny on but he had once actually tried to build his own microscope.

Yeah, like what a badass. He had actually gone to school early on for science.

He had gone to technical school And after he got his certificates in biology, chemistry, and I think electrical science, Yeah, he went on to become a part-time professor of sorts at the Liverpool Technical College.

Wow. I wonder why he stopped. I think because he just needed more.

He needed the money. I think it was really just like trying to make ends meet.

He spent about an hour there doing some experimenting in his makeshift lab.

So he made in one of the like the three bedrooms.

She had a hat room. He had a microscope room.

I love that. i love it um and then he left again around three to get back to his insurance work okay Now, sometime before four, a friend and a client of his named James Rothwell saw him walking And he noted that he appeared like he had been crying to him.

Wallace looked like he had been crying? Yeah, and he described him as, quote, haggard and drawn, very distressed looking.

Okay. Which is interesting. And he was a very good friend of his.

Like he, and a client. He saw him all the time.

So he knew what he would look like. And he said he was like wiping his eye with like his shirt.

Oh. So that's interesting. Yeah, it's weird.

But then another client, however, said that he was his normal self that day and said she saw him often wiping his eyes or nose with a kerchief. because she said he always seemed to have the sniffles or a cold.

Because he was sickly. Exactly. So I just want to make sure all of these get said because this is what makes this case nuts.

It's like a he said, she said. Nothing adds up.

One person says this, another person says this, and they both make sense.

It's like, what is the truth here? So there was actually a boy named Neil Norbury.

And he delivered baked goods, and he went to the Wallace home that day while... Why does no one deliver baked goods?

I know things were so that sounds so lovely.

But this was wonderful. when William was out doing his insurance thing.

And he said that Julia answered the door and she was very sweet and nice, but she did appear sick to him, like not feeling well.

Well, she was just getting over the flu.

Yeah, and I think it was getting worse almost.

Yeah. I think she wasn't getting that much better.

Perhaps pneumonia. Perhaps. Now his last appointment that day was a woman named Margaret Martin and she She was actually going to be ending her insurance policy, so there was a lot of paperwork for that one.

She was fuzzy on the time that he came by at trial later.

They believe he was with her at 545, and it's between 6... to about 7.05 PM that no one can really account to where he was.

Okay. So he just kind of like disappears.

No one can say where he was. No one can say that they saw Julia.

Right. She was at home supposedly, but like no one can really say anything.

He spoke to many people once he popped back up.

Which seems a little weird. It does. He popped back up around 7.06.

Now, this is the night he's supposed to meet Qualtra, remember, at 730.

Mm-hmm. So he was on his way to meet Qualtrough.

I was going to say. He was like, I'm going to go meet him.

He's a prospective client. I got to make the money.

That makes me nervous. So he said he got he asked conductors of the tram about which tram to take. to the specific address.

He talked to ticket takers about this important meeting that he had.

He kept talking to people. He talked to the people on the tram and kept saying how he was lost and he didn't live here.

And so he didn't know his way around here.

And if somebody could tell him where this address was.

And he kept saying, I'm just like the new guy in town.

I don't know where I'm going. And he just kept talking to people.

And what people think later is that this could have been him being like, hi, hello.

Here's my alibi. I'm here. What's going on, everybody?

You'll remember my face, right? I'm the guy talking about not knowing where I'm going.

New in town guy. Hey, I'm supposed to be going to this address.

Make sure you tell the police that later.

Again. I don't know. Nobody knows. I'm just saying that's a possibility. like wallace so far so i don't want to hate him i know i'm saying so he changed from the four trim trim I almost said train.

I said tram and then it turned into train.

So tram. It was a tram. He changed from the four tram and took the five tram from, uh, Was it Anfield?

I'll never say it right. I have no recollection.

Anfield to Menlove Gardens. Now, the first stop was Menlove Avenue. and a conductor pointed him in the direction of Menlove Gardens West. and said it was likely around there that he would find Menlove Gardens East.

But he said, I've actually never heard of Menlove Gardens East.

Only West. So he was like, but I imagine it's near the West.

I don't know. Yeah. So at 7.45, so he's going to look for it.

He can't find it. So at 7.45, he actually stopped a police constable and asked him for it allowed. directions now he the police constable was like yeah i've never heard of that like I don't think that exists.

Yeah, he was like, I'm not really sure. And during this time he actually talked to at least four different people for directions.

He said he talked to seven different people later.

That would be a lot of people to ask. But they only brought four and they were able to bring four for trial to say he did talk to them.

The first one was a guy named Sydney Green, and he told him the whole thing.

And he said, OK, I don't know about East. but I know there's a West.

And he said, maybe this person gave you East and meant West.

Yeah, they just messed up. Yeah, so why don't you go to that address, 25 Men Love Gardens West, and see if that's the person.

So he did. And it was actually the lady that was living there was an elderly lady named Katie Mather.

And she said, yeah, I don't know who Qualtra is.

And it wasn't me who called you. So she was like, I don't know what to tell you.

I've never heard of that one. So the constable he spoke to was James Sargent.

And he said, yeah, that address doesn't exist.

And so he said after that, Wallace just told him the whole story.

Like, it was just like, well, you know, I go to chess and I was at chess and this guy named Qualtrough called my chess captain.

And he went through the whole detailed story and the constable was like, that sucks.

Like, I don't know what to tell you. So you could see that as weird, but have you ever met somebody that just continues to tell you things that don't matter and you're like, Exactly.

So it's like, you can look at this as... he's really trying to establish an alibi and he's trying to tell the constable every detail of this so it's like really in there.

So later this constable... Right. Or he's just frustrated.

He can't find this fucking address. He doesn't know who this guy is and...

Do you ever get frustrated and you're just like, can I just tell you why I'm frustrated?

Yeah. I'm pissed. And this is what happened today.

You know, you're. Or he may be. didn't want like the constable to think he was like a crazy person was like i sorry to like bother you like this is what happened that's why i thought this address was real There is many, there's so many things that could be the reason for this.

And you could go in any direction based on which one you feel like you want to lean on.

But I don't want to be on Wallace's side if he's a murderer.

I don't know. Fuck. You won't know. That's the sad part.

Great. So he directed him, the constable did direct him to the post office and the police station, was like either one of those. you can go for like a directory and see if somebody can help you there.

So he ran into a woman named Lily Pinches at the post office where the directory was.

And again, she was like, No, that address doesn't exist.

So after this, he was like, fuck it. Definitely doesn't exist.

So he gave up. He was like, I'm not doing this.

So 8.35 PM, a woman named Lillian Hall, who is a 20-year-old typist, She said she saw Wallace with a man on Richmond Road and they were chatting.

And it was close to Wolverton Street, which is where he lived and where the murder occurs.

And this was at 8.35 p.m. This will come back later, obviously, like Lillian just came forward afterwards.

Um, but that's just interesting that she said she couldn't say who it was.

A man, just a man. So 845, that's when he was seen by his neighbors, John and Florence Johnston.

But he they saw him he was outside of his home and they said he looked kind of flustered and they said he appeared a little nervous and like like, you know, weird.

And so they were like, you okay, William?

Like, what's going on? And he said, I'm trying to get in my house but all my doors won't open.

He was like, they're all locked but my key won't work.

That's weird. And they were like, what? Like, that's weird.

So they were like, are you sure? Like, are you sure you're not using the wrong key?

And he was like, no, I'm not. And then he said...

Did you hear anything weird tonight? that's a little bit weird and they were like no but like let us help because they again they have no reason to see he's never been weird He's never been violent.

He's never been somebody they would have to like raise an eyebrow at before.

Well, and I say that's weird, but then it's like, It's not that weird because he's like, did you hear someone like fucking with my locks?

Exactly. It's not that weird, actually. Upon first listen, you're like, oh, that's weird.

And then when you think about it, you're like, well, you might ask that actually.

Yeah, like I might be like, did you see anything?

My locks aren't working. Did you hear weird shit happening out here?

Like my wife's in there. I'm a little nervous.

Yeah. So, yeah. So it's like, that's weird.

So he said... So he told them, I arrived after being out since 6.45.

I left Julia in here. The doors were locked.

And he said... I couldn't open them with my key when I came home.

And he said he had tried them all, the back and the front.

So they suggested, you know what, let's try again.

We'll help you out. We'll try to see what's going on here.

And they walked towards the back door and he just randomly said to them, she won't be out.

She had such a bad cold. And they were like, okay.

But maybe he said that like something has happened here and she's still home.

Exactly. Like, I think, again, upon first listen, you're like, that's weird.

And then we were like, no, I think maybe he's running through it in his head.

And he's like, she's not answering the door, but there's no way she's out.

She has a backpack. cold so he's trying to reason it in his head like why the fuck isn't she answering the door she's in there so it's not weird at least to me So they both walk around back and they try the door. click it opens with easily with the key okay now they said he now that that's Well, and then they see that he seemed very flustered and shocked by this.

Okay. Like that he was like... i it didn't open before i swear he's having like some kind of like mental break And he wasn't.

He was very with it. They said he was very clear, but they said the door opened and he was like, it wouldn't do that before.

He was like, I swear to you, it didn't open before.

He was like, what the fuck? They said he looked genuinely shocked that the door opened.

Okay. So it was pitch black in the house.

Spooky. So he does what you do in the 30s, which is light a fancy lantern.

And he walked in his home. That's what you do.

He called for Julie. a couple of times and then he came out a minute later and they said he was white as a sheet and he said oh come and see she's been killed Well, you really can't control if you lose color from your face.

No, you really can't. of course that could be that he's like oh shit they're here now and i have to deal with this and like put on a show so it's like you would definitely go a little white because you'd be like fuck yeah uh And also it could be that he is genuinely upset that he found his... This is frustrating.

It's also a little weird that, like, come and see...

That's a weird way to say that. Who knows?

Again, we're also going to be dealing a lot. with somebody who is in a strange position and it's like, you can't really say what you would say in this situation.

Nope. come and see is a little weird. I don't know.

Like, come and see. Wouldn't you just be like, oh, my God, I found her in there.

Like, don't go in there. I'd be like, holy shit, don't go in there.

I don't know, though. So they went and they saw they found Julia on the floor in front of the fireplace face down.

And she had very clearly been beaten to death very violently in the head. her skull which seems personal certainly does her skull was bashed in like caved in There was blood sprayed all over the entire room, some as high as seven feet up.

Holy shit. She was laying on a coat and in a large pool of her own blood. her eyes were wide open and staring and her right arm was outstretched above her okay And her other arm was to her side, down by her side.

Her dress had been partially burned. And it looked like the coat had also been partially burned.

Almost like she must have like maybe fallen into like close where the fire was, and then maybe she was moved or rolled over there. her brains were exposed on the floor get the fuck out of here along with pieces of skull And William turned to his neighbors and said, They've finished her.

Look at her brains. oh okay which again but okay then the other thing is like a lot of times people who like love science like I don't know why I think of like Sheldon from the Big Bang Theory, but like you say things in like a way that like maybe I wouldn't.

You know? Maybe I'm thinking of, like...

I don't like I don't know how to respond correctly in a highly emotional situation.

And I probably sound. very like weird off-putting sometimes like that I'm sure that can happen but it's just because like my brain doesn't function well in these like very highly emotional and I'm and I feel like that's a very like science-y like right brain kind of thing yeah I think it's just like some people like that would be a lot for me Like, it would be a lot for anybody, but obviously, but, like, that would be... You're not good at it.

I'm not saying it in a mean way. You're not good at emotions.

No, and my brain just wouldn't compute what's the correct thing to say in that situation.

Like, socially, it wouldn't work for me.

Right. I feel like a lot of times sciencey people, like when you say something, like it's a little bit like harsh and somebody else would be like, oh, oh.

Okay, that's very like, it's almost like a doctor.

Sometimes doctors will say something to you and you're like, okay.

Yeah, you know, and that's because that obviously happened a lot in my life that people will be like, Oh, shit.

Okay. Yeah, that's very blunt. And I'm like, no, I didn't mean for that to come out that way, but I don't know how else to say this.

Yeah. And it's frustrating, trust me, it's frustrating for the person being that way, but I'm sure it's frustrating for everybody around them. it's a it's a very like I just said right brain yeah right brain versus left So, again, you're right.

That's one of those things where that might just be he doesn't know what else to say but the obvious, which is look her brains are on the floor like they really killed her yeah that's Who knows?

And he might be if if he didn't do this, then he's completely stricken with grief and shock.

I will say it is weird that he said they.

That's and he does say he says it. He says it a few things like they've finished her.

Yeah. But I don't know if that's just again.

Right. It's one of those. Yeah. Like they does imply that like he might know something else, but it can also just be him being like, I don't know what else to say.

Yeah. So they said he, again, they said he was absolutely white as a sheet and clearly in shock.

He just kept saying over and over, they finished her.

Over and over. Yeah. Weird thing to say.

Just saying, because if we're going to... straddle on over to this side that's a weird fucking thing to say yeah well just keep saying it over and over that's weird If I was there, I'd be like, you should probably stop saying that.

Hey, hey, stop saying that. I'd be like, maybe talk about how much you loved her.

William like how sad you are maybe like we get it yeah they finished her it's cool like just maybe like Oh, no, my beautiful wife.

Or, you know what? Or just shut up. Yeah, be shut up.

Or Lauren in the corner. Be. Don't be suspicious.

Don't be suspicious. That's what you need to say to him.

Don't be suspicious because you're being suspicious.

They say that time waits for no one, neither should payday.

To keep your money moving in the direction of your dreams, get earnin'.

What is Earnin', you ask? Honey, Earnin' is an app that lets you access your pay as you earn it up to $100 and $50 a day with a max of $750 between paydays.

Earnin is the app that is helping millions of Americans take charge of their pay and avoid falling into debt traps.

Ernan's mission is to make financial momentum accessible to everyone.

It's your money, so put it in your own hands with Ernan.

I just feel like earning is good for so many things.

Every now and again, you get in your car and you say, oh, wow, who knew that I was on empty?

I should have known that, but I didn't. And then you look at your bank account and you're like, oh crap, I haven't been paid yet.

You'll never run into that problem if you have earning.

An unexpected trip to the vet will not ruin your day because you'll have the money to pay for it.

Download Earnin' Today, spelled E-A-R-N-I-N, in the Google Play or Apple App Store.

When you download the Earn It app, type in morbid under podcast.

When you sign up, it will really help the show.

Morbid under podcast. Earnin is a financial technology company, not a bank.

Access limits are based on your earnings and risk factors.

Standard cashouts take one to two business days with no mandatory fees.

Expedited transfer is available for a fee.

Tips are voluntary and don't affect the service.

Available in select states. Terms and restrictions apply.

Visit earnin.com for full details. Download Earnin now and take control of your pay.

Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach?

Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families.

With Greenlight, you can send money to kids quickly.

Set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on your kids' spending with real-time notifications.

Kids learn to earn, save and spend wisely and parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money with guardrails in place.

Try Greenlight risk-free today. at greenlight.com slash wondery.

So John Johnston, he and Florence brought Wallace out of the parlor. and away from Julia's mutilated body.

In the kitchen, they notice that a cabinet... had literally been torn, like the door had been torn off of it.

And it was laying in pieces on the floor.

And it was Wallace who actually first noticed it and pointed it out.

And was literally like, hey, look what they did.

Like, literally was like, they did that.

I didn't do that. Like, what is that? And so there was a few coins on the floor as well around it.

And he said he looked in there because they were like, you should check and see if anything's been stolen.

And he said that about four pounds had been stolen out of the cash box that was hidden in there.

So they were like, OK, cool. They stole stuff.

So they had him look upstairs, which is a bad plan.

But like, go off, Johnston. yeah i suppose like they were like hey you should go upstairs and go check more and it's like guys there could still be someone you don't know if this person's still in the house and also like I don't know just why don't you get the police here Yeah, maybe just call another constable.

Like, I think they were all in a little bit of a shock, but like... But that's the thing.

You do silly things when you're like... But like, just don't...

Don't send him upstairs. Don't do that. I just didn't think that was a great idea.

Yeah. Hindsight's 20-20. Yeah, so he went up there and he said he hadn't seen anything at like strange up there and he said there was actually a jar upstairs that was sitting right in the open with money in it and it was still there That's weird.

So that's strange. Yeah. Unless they just didn't go upstairs.

Yeah, exactly. So Wallace was shocked clearly and said something also to them about like the dishes in the sink.

And how he said something like offhand, like she didn't even have a chance to clean up after tea.

Which, again, could be looked at as strange, but it could be looked at as somebody who is literally like... careening off the edge of like grief and just horror being like she didn't even get to clean up after tea you know like you just think of weird shit So again.

Now, John decided, Mr. Johnston, he left to get the police and a doctor.

Good call. Florence checked Julia. again because she was like, I need to make sure that this is what it is.

She's definitely out. Florence is, and Florence seems like she like really has her shit together.

Okay. I appreciate Florence. I feel like she was trying to hold everyone down here.

She's the machine. She is. And she said that she was still warm.

But she said she was getting cooler. Like she had felt her when they first went in there and she was warm and she said she was getting slightly cooler.

But Wallace inquired about what they could have used to hit her.

He was like, what could they have used to do this?

The fire poker? And there was nothing that they could see. that was used or could have been used.

Like, nothing had blood on it. There was nothing there.

So they were like, okay, they must have taken it with them or put it somewhere.

Yeah. did find was spent matchsticks next to her and in the kitchen.

So that's interesting. Wallace then noticed the coat under her was actually his coat.

And when he noticed that, Florence said he started to sob uncontrollably.

Did he really love that coat? I don't know.

So she tended to the fire, Florence did, to keep Wallace warm.

And it was in the kitchen because it was another fight in the kitchen.

And she tried to keep him comfortable. Oh, Florence.

Just trying to, you know, Florence everybody.

Trying to ease the pressure. Florence. She's Florence Nightingale is who she is.

Aww. Look at that. So the Liverpool City Police Force finally showed up.

They were known at this time... as a little bumbling.

I'm going to be nice. There was police strikes in 1919 and Like that kind of really threw a wrench into their like effectiveness.

For 11 years. Well, they just couldn't get their shit together because the police strike happened, Then people were starting to get jobs on this force that probably had no business.

And then they stayed there. Then you're not going to get rid of them.

It just becomes a problem. It really does.

It really does. It's like you've dealt with it.

It really does, guys. Let me tell you. It really becomes a problem.

So they were bumbling as fuck. So luckily the cop who showed up first here was at least like passable, so that's good.

Officer Fred Williams, or Constable Fred Williams, he checked that he came, he checked that Julia was dead, And then he asked for a statement.

But the problem was he didn't record this statement right away from William.

He didn't record it until an hour and a half later.

Mind might be a little fuzzy. There's that.

Now, this is the statement that he recorded that William said.

Like, perhaps. At 6.45, I left the house in order to go to Menlove Gardens. and my wife accompanied me to the backyard door.

She walked a little way down the alley with me and then she returned and bolted the backyard door.

She would then be alone in the house. I then went to Menlove Gardens to find the address that had been given to me was wrong.

Becoming suspicious, I returned home then went to the front door.

I inserted my key to find I could not open it.

I went round to the backyard door. It was closed, but not bolted.

I went up the backyard and tried the door, but it would not open.

I again went to the front door, but this time found the door to be bolted.

So now he's saying that he went to the front.

It wouldn't work. Went to the back. It wasn't bolted, but he couldn't open it.

Went to the front. Now it's bolted. So like, what the fuck?

Like someone bolted the door between you going from the back to the front.

And you didn't see and you didn't say that to anyone before.

Like, that's a little strange. But also, did the constable just fuck that up because it was an hour and a half later?

Well, it becomes a weird thing. So this is William's statement.

He did say this. Okay. He said, Okay. I entered the house, and this is what I found.

Okay. This is very, like, knives out. It really, right?

It is. This is a straight up murder. murder mystery game like this is this doesn't sound real but it's real that's what like astounded me about this yeah That's why you're getting a part two, because I can't stop, won't stop.

I can't. Quit you, murder case. I'm only going to get you as far as him being, like, questioned.

And then we got so much more after that but I just couldn't jam it into one episode.

It would be rushed. So Florence did say that while he was being questioned here in the kitchen that the cat appeared.

Just walked in the door. Isn't that weird?

That is weird. So two more cops showed up, and Williams had Wallace search the home with him.

And he did note that the money was missing and that there was money undisturbed upstairs.

So he put that down in his report. He said there was also handbags up there and a handbag downstairs of Julia's that had not been touched. not been rifled through, and that no drawers were open, which he thought was weird.

If someone was going to be like rifling around, they usually leave the drawers open.

Yeah. So at this time, Constable Williams seems to take Wallace as...

Calm and emotionless, he said. But? But, you know.

He said he was very cool, very composed, very with it, but you know, sometimes people in these situations snap to it and get where they need to be when they need to talk to an authority figure or that's just how they Or you might just be like really fucking shocked.

So you're just kind of like, let me go through the motions.

And then later when everybody leaves, it hits you.

Exactly. And he's sobbed. He's coming up.

He's going to be on like a roller coaster here.

But the other side of that could be that he's only sobbing about his jacket because maybe he realized first. fuck, I left that jacket there and that's really going to pin me to this.

Right. So who knows? Not me. Too much. So when they asked him if he thought it was strange that the thief had taken money from the cash box, and then put the lid back on the cash box and placed it back on the shelf, but left the door on the floor.

He didn't have anything to say. But he said.

Sure. Like it's strange. Yeah. But he didn't have any like. answer for it and of course you wouldn't if it wasn't you at around 10 p.m this is where things get Really kooky.

So at around 10 p.m., Professor John Edward Whitley McFall came to do some Emmy work.

Yes, he did. Now, this dude is a legend in his own mind.

But in reality... He's a big bowl of what the fuck.

Oh, I love that expression you just said.

He really is. He's a giant, giant bowl of what the fuck. he was a weird dude apparently who smoked opium but was wow but was well known He had various reviews about him.

Some people thought he was like brilliant.

Other people were like, what the fuck? He was just one of those things.

Maybe he used to be brilliant. Yeah, people who worked with him thought he was brash, very eccentric, but he was...

Pretty smart. Just a lot. All right. He was the chair of forensic medicine at the University of Liverpool. and was an examiner of medical jurisprudence at four other universities, so he did have a lot of credits to his name.

This is when shit gets weirder. He just basically walked in, looked at her, touched her for a minute, noted the rigor. looked at the blood and then he was like yeah she's been dead for like four hours Excuse me, sir.

It's 1931. 2021, you couldn't walk into a room and be like, she's been dead for this many hours.

Like, no. No, no, that's not how that works.

It's not CSI Miami. Didn't look at lividity.

No observing that, no temp checking, nothing.

Just boom, four hours because of the appearance of rigor.

She has rigor in her face. So I'm going to say four hours.

And then they were like, yeah, the blood's clotting.

So that works for me. Okie dokie. That's not enough, my friend.

That's not enough. So at the At the very least, you take the temp of the room and take her rectal or liver temp to get a core temp for her.

That way you can use the formula that they definitely knew back then.

They knew this formula for body temp and like checking how long it takes your body to cool to ambient temperature.

So you would use that formula to determine the cooling time. and where the body has reached the temperature of his or her surroundings.

Because your body starts cooling or heating depending on where you are, the second you stop breathing.

So it's trying, basically your body wants to make its way to ambient temperature. which in this case would have been the temp in the room she was found in.

Mm-hmm. It goes about that by like, you lose like 1.5 degrees Fahrenheit every hour. until you kind of plateau where the ambient temperature is.

Or if you're in a really hot place, your body will warm to that temperature.

So you take that rectal or liver temp Liver is a little harder, especially if there's a lot of wounds.

You can't go into an existing wound to take the temp and you'd have to make an incision.

Yeah. So a lot of times they will take the rectal temp for that core temp.

But you don't care because you're dead. And they'll take that and you subtract it by the normal body temp. which is about 98.6 degrees for most of us.

But that can vary. And you get that number and then you divide it by the 1.5. which is how your body cools or warms, that number that you get usually can give a decent estimate of time of death.

Right. How many hours? Particularly in this scenario. where the environment is pretty temp controlled because it's indoors.

And we're not in the forest where the temp is like constantly changing and fluctuating.

But unfortunately, her temp may not have been 98.6 because remember, she was sick.

So she could have had a higher temp. And was there a fire going?

There was a fire going. At some point. So it's like. this is going to fluctuate slightly.

Yeah. And she was... burned. Right. So it's like that temp could definitely mess up.

But he didn't even... try any of this. He just knew.

Not only did he not even give it a shot, but like the amount of variables would have even made it hard if he had done it, but he didn't even bother.

So for him to claim four hours based on rigor, which is also very variable on temperature, like cold or hot, how long it's gonna set, how hard it's gonna set, how long it's gonna take to break.

It's insane because this room is a hot room.

Of course, it's going to be different. You don't even take that into consideration.

He didn't even give a range. He just said four hours.

Boom. Now, 2021, they still are going to give you a range.

It is so hard to pinpoint time of death.

That's insane. Now that would mean also that she was dead once. way before Wallace claimed to have said goodbye to her and watched her walk back into the house.

Yeah, so this motherfucker. is wrong. Because he was saying that that was at 645 that he said bye to her.

I mean, unless he killed her before that.

And he's saying she's already been dead.

But then he claimed that the blood that was clotting around her body and her head He said that clotting indicated to him about two to three hours before that she was killed.

Okay, so which one was it? Is it four hours?

Because that's going to make her dead before Wallace left.

Or is it two to three hours? Which is going to make it kind of a big variable here.

Pretty big thing here. Yeah. But he's just like, yep, that makes sense.

Kind of like one of the biggest pieces of the pie that we need to solve the crime.

And it seems like you just took that like two to three.

Maybe four. I'm going to go with four. Like, that's just, he said at least four.

That was his thing. At least four. It could have been more.

He said at least four, but then said two or three.

So at least what, motherfucker? It doesn't make sense.

And he also... He becomes an issue, too, with blood spatter soon, which we'll see.

He didn't do a good job. Now, the detective superintendent was supposed to be on scene at this point. of the police and he was nowhere to be found and by nowhere to be found I mean Not only was he not on the scene, but when they called and were like, hey, can he come here?

His name was Hubert Rory Moore. They were like, yeah, we don't know where he is.

We haven't heard from him. So they ended up finding him in a pub.

Oh, no. And they dragged him to the scene.

Oh, man. I feel like you should just give him a cold shower first, at least.

Oh, yeah. The people that were there were like, he was clearly drinking.

He smelled of alcohol. It's like a me breed.

And he's like, what the fuck is that? Yeah.

And they were like, he definitely shouldn't have been dealing with this murder scene, that's for sure.

Also, imagine seeing a murder scene, I mean, ever.

But in that state, it's like, and imagine being like in charge of that murder scene in that state.

I mean, maybe that would sober you up. I would hope it did.

Slightly, at least. But he came and was basically came in and was like, Shit.

And he just like looked at William Wallace and was like, Did you see anyone?

He literally looked at him and said, did you see anyone when you got here?

I mean, like, that was him literally being like, I'm gonna give this a shot.

Did you see the murderer when you got here?

And maybe you just haven't said that to anybody yet.

I'm going to go out on a limb and hope that you just didn't say that you saw the murderer when you got here.

I mean, but is that a crazy question? Because he was like the door was bolted.

Then it wasn't. Then it was. Then it wasn't.

Well, and he was like, did you see anyone?

And he was like, nope. And the Johnstons were like, nope, we didn't see anyone either.

And he was like, okay, cool. He was like, now we got that out of the way, let me think of my second question.

He's like, I'll be right back. So he goes back to the police station.

And this is when he sent... Where he makes himself a hot cup of joe.

I'm pretty sure he was like, I need to take a cold shower right now. some coffee.

But he sends a bunch of investigators to rooming houses, all night cafes, tram stations, like lodging of any kind, and he says, look for people that are just hanging out with bloodstained clothing.

As they do after murders. Which I love that kind of police work.

I love it. All right. Look for some people.

I want you to fan out. I want you to look for a guy that is absolutely soaked in blood.

And if you see that guy... What you bringing me?

Like, okay. Okay, sir. Who would stay on their bloody clothes?

You dingus. So then he was like, all right, I got to go back to the scene.

He's like, well, shit. This is when our... our wonderful Emmy is looking at the blood in the parlor.

And he's like, okay, there's a lot of blood here.

And at this point they were like, bloodstain analysis is happening.

So they were like, okay, we can do this.

And they determined that she was likely sitting with her head, he said to her head, with her head to the side talking to someone.

Sure. Which, wowie, you got all that. Yeah.

So he said he was sitting. They think that he was sitting, she was sitting on a chair, which was next to the fireplace.

Okay. Um... This is insane to deduce, but he did so because the marks they looked at were only about four feet in height.

And they looked like what he referred to.

They are not actually referred to as these, but in his report, he referred to these marks, these bloodstains. as soda water bottle marks.

What? Apparently that's what he thought they looked like.

I don't know. What does that mean? Soda water bottle marks.

They were likely just what I think is probably what they were. was elliptical blood spatter, which is like the elongated blood spatter.

Okay. They probably had satellite trails that made them look like exclamation points.

Is he saying if you open a bottle of soda and it explodes and gets on your wall, that's what it looks like?

I don't know. I don't know what that means.

It's a very interesting way to say it. I've never read it said that way otherwise.

Who knows? The opium was telling him things.

So these particular little exclamation point kind of marks...

They will help to show what direction the motion is moving in because the tails of those marks will point in the direction of the motion.

So the marks they saw were pointing to the easy chair, which had not a lot of blood on it.

So That's kind of a void pattern, which does indicate that somebody was in that chair when it all happened.

Because that's a void where there had to have been something there to stop the blood from spraying there.

They said she was likely sitting in it or on the arm of it.

Okay. or at least near it or standing in front of it.

And then do they look like exclamation points because when you like pull back?

So, unfortunately, that's a problem. He didn't account for cast-off marks.

Yeah. from blood flying off the weapon used, and those tails can help determine the motion again in that case.

And you can count the amount of arc, which is when they swing a...

A weapon and it gets covered in blood and then it keeps swinging.

I just like slammed it. Yeah. And then it keeps swinging, and when they keep swinging back and forth, hitting the person...

Collecting blood on the weapon and then drawing back.

It forms arcs. an arc pattern, and you can count how many arcs there are and see how many times that person was hit.

I hate to say that, but that's really fucking cool.

It is cool. I love blood. You always have.

Blood stain analysis, like, fascinates me.

It is really. I love it. crazy that you can do all that.

I used to want to get like really into that.

At one point I was like, I want to be a blood spatter analysis.

And you probably will be like a a couple of weeks.

I said analysis analyst. But blunt objects can also cause like a pretty varied size pool of blood drops.

So they think a blunt object was used to hit her.

So that's going to change the kind of blood droplets too.

And he wasn't accounting for any of this.

And so the angle of blood spray matters too.

So like a 90 degree angle hit will almost look circular.

And as the angle decreases, it becomes more like it spines out, like the circle will look like spiny at the outsides.

And eventually... The circle on the wall.

Yeah, like the circle splatter. The blood splatter.

And as you move like so and then it kind of like as you decrease that angle, it's going to keep elongating into those exclamation mark kind of splatter.

Sounds like physics which I failed. That's how you can tell.

But if it hit the wall at a certain angle, and then dripped, that can mess with the appearance and make it look like a different type of blood spatter Or that it was a different impact location or angle.

He just didn't account for any of this and just went and was like...

Exclamation point. That means one thing and one thing only.

At that point, did they know that it meant more things than that?

They could definitely... They knew more.

And it was more just a matter of like... you can't just look at that and be like, that's it.

You would know, and especially in the 30s, they knew that forensics and that this kind of science was... highly variable and that you can't just look at something and be like, 100% of the time, that's what this means.

So... He worked super quick. He sketched some of these stains and like droplets.

He like sat there and drew them. But I guess he drew them like really shitty and you can't even tell what they look like.

Well, at that point, why didn't he just take a picture?

Yeah. And then he just, that's when he drops like, all right, so she's been dead for four hours.

Boom. Nailed it. Like, that's it. He also said Wallace was too calm... at this point too like he also mentioned that so it's like this dude i'm like get out of here yeah like shut up i don't know he's definitely he has like Small dick energy.

Yeah, he just, I don't like him. He also at trial said that he described Wallace as, quote, too collected.

And then he said, whilst I was in the room examining the body and the blood, he came in smoking a cigarette. and he leaned over in front of the sideboard and flicked the ash into a bowl on the sideboard.

It struck me at the time as being unnatural."

Why is that unnatural? So like it's because he's smoking?

Like he's chain smoking probably because he's having a fucking nervous breakdown.

Yeah. And the dude smoked. Right. I imagine that's just something he would do.

Very normal thing to do. do in a like stressful situation is fucking pull out a square why why is flicking ash unnatural to do when someone dies.

Right. I had no idea that once someone ceases living... that your ash has to just remain attached to your cigarette.

Why is that? Is he saying it's the way he leaned over him and ashed?

I guess. But it's like, where the fuck else was he going to ash?

And it's just like, can we just stop judging?

This guy after finding his wife with her head bashed open.

I agree that when it's coupled with other things, you can definitely take things from it you can deduce you know judgment from it had he said something weird i feel like it's like he's getting shit on yeah But, you know, sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.

Now more cops said that they were shocked by his behavior as well.

One said he was just sitting stroking the cat at one point.

And he said, quote, I didn't see any sign of emotion in him at all at the death of his wife.

But again. Right. Sometimes you're unemotional because you're in shock.

I literally laugh at funerals. Like I will burst into laughing.

I have seen that with my own eyes. I'm so incredibly uncomfortable.

And it's because I don't know what to do with the other kinds of emotions.

So laughing is just the easiest thing. Well, and... Everyone can get... And I can imagine if it was like...

So when you love so much. I can't even put myself in that position.

No, fuck that. I can't even think about that.

I don't know how I'd act. He also like you're comforting an animal and he's comforting her animal.

That makes sense that he was sitting there petting the cat.

It would make sense, and she was very upset about the cat the night before, so it makes sense that he would just be like, I'm just going to pet this cat because it came back.

Well, that's also very comforting to pet a cat when you're stressed out.

Now, meanwhile, they're all judging him, but they're all just like a bunch of bumbling crazies walking around this house.

I know, I love that they're not judging the fucking police chief who was at the bar.

Now... No officer was really in charge at the time.

The superintendent was, but he wasn't taking charge.

No one is communicating what they're doing.

So they're all just touching things and not recording things or recording things that the last one just disturbed. and it's now in a different position there's no chain of evidence absolutely none It's mayhem in there.

Bonkers. And in fact, the cash box that had money missing out of it. had police fingerprints all over it.

So they couldn't even pull any other police, they couldn't pull any other fingerprints off of it.

Well, shit. So immediately, Wallace, they're all looking at him like he's the main suspect.

The husband did it. So they start asking about the doors and the locks to him again.

They're like, go over that one more time.

Yeah. Because they're like, that is weird.

And he had said in that statement that the front door wouldn't open.

So he went to the back and the back door wasn't bolted, but wouldn't open either.

So we went back to the front and he said the front was now bolted.

When they asked him about it now, they said that he tried the key in the front lock and it was a defective lock.

So they tried it and they said, yeah, it is a defective lock.

It's like broken. So the key works, but you have to like zhuzh it.

Sometimes it doesn't. Like it makes it wonky.

So he never said again that that door was bolted.

He never mentioned that again. Okay. So they were like, well, you said before that, and he just wouldn't, he just like wouldn't acknowledge that again.

Okay. So that's weird that he's not being like, no, what's weird is I came back around and that door was bolted when it wasn't a second ago.

Right. He never said that again. And he just like had no explanation for that, which is weird.

Yeah. Definitely weird. Because they were like, well, if that door was bolted when you came back around the front, you wouldn't have been able to unlock it either way, even if it wasn't wonky.

Yeah, no matter what. That's an important piece of information.

But again, maybe he was just in shock. Who knows?

So then they ask him about the coat that she is lying on, because they said earlier you mentioned that that was your coat.

And they were so they wanted to kind of like coax more information out of them.

So they were like, is this your coat? That's here.

And he didn't answer them. He just like sat there.

And so they were like, is it her coat? And he wouldn't say anything.

That's weird. And they were like, okay. So they took this immediately. as he knew he fucked up by using that coat and leaving it there and that he didn't want to incriminate himself.

It's really not that weird for your own coat to be in your house on the floor, though.

It's not. But I think maybe he was like, they're thinking that he's sitting there going, oh, shit.

Like I've admitted multiple times that that's my coat that she's lying on.

Who wouldn't think that that might be? like come back to bite you in the ass yeah yeah um then they just picked up the coat before it was photographed to look at it yeah Which makes total sense.

Cool, cool, cool. And when they were done looking at it they just placed it back down. that's where it was yep he admitted again finally that it was his and he said he left it on a hook in the hallway when he left that day.

And he said what happened was, he said, I was wearing that coat initially. but it's actually nice out today.

So I changed into a lighter coat and I put that on the hook.

Okay. Makes sense. Yeah. Now around 11 p.m. our good old Emmy, all of a sudden was like, wait a second.

And he said, I'm in the The upstairs bathroom and I found a small clot of blood on the upstairs bathroom toilet rim. bitch like she could have had her period let's be real it was slightly streaked and he said he was sure It was because the murderer had gone upstairs to wash up.

This would obviously mean it was either Wallace, because he would be comfortable in his own home.

Yep. Or a really stupid murderer who hung out, hung around for a while, washed up upstairs, but didn't steal any of the goodies up there that were Alston. not like right in front of him.

So likely Wallace. That's what it's really pointing to.

It seems like everybody's trying to be like, Wait a second.

Totally Wallace. So this could be true because these cops were bumbling as hell. and could have missed this.

Right. Because the ME said that the dim light in the bathroom may have caused a shadow on that clot and the clot was really dark so it could have been obscured in that shadow and they wouldn't have seen it.

Yeah. but multiple, like a dozen cops were in and out of that bathroom over the course of the last couple hours. they could have easily accidentally transferred it there because there was no protocol that they were following.

And they're all touching shit. And the ME could have transferred it up there.

Who knows? Yeah. There was no other blood in the house anywhere else.

Right. So it's very unlikely that they traveled around the home after the murder.

And didn't get blood anywhere else. Only on that one little speck.

It doesn't make a lot of sense. So at near midnight, the police medical officer, Dr. Hugh Pierce, came. and he was going to be kind of a second set of eyes.

He examined the body, and he said she had been dead for six hours.

So now he's tacked on a couple more hours.

So it agreed with the idea that she was dead when Wallace said he had spoken to her. and said goodbye to her.

So both of these are now saying that. But also are they just trying to do that to make the investigation easier?

I don't know. That's the thing. So now he is brought to the police station to make another statement.

He is not under arrest. But of course, everyone is outside now.

They're seeing all the commotion. So now everyone's seeing the scene and they're seeing him being led away.

So they're gonna- are starting to happen gossip is starting people are saying they saw him in handcuffs he wasn't in handcuffs he was just coming to do a statement he was not detained he was not arrested yeah During his interrogation at the police station, he said that Julia would not have opened the door to someone unless she knew them personally.

Right. He was like, I know that 100%. And she said she always entertained people we knew in the parlor. and when he was asked if anyone could have gained entry into the house forcibly they were like do you know anyone that would have wanted to hurt you or hurt her, he said, you know what, I do know someone that could have done this.

And they were like, who? And he said, it was a guy I used to work with at the insurance company named Richard Gordon Perry.

And he said Perry, the motive that he was thinking of was he said Wallace had confessed confronted him several times about coming up short on his insurance collections, like, He would write down one thing and his money would be short like he was stealing.

Yeah. And this happened a bunch of times.

And he said Wallace had informed their boss and Perry was fired.

Okay, so that's a pretty good fucking motive.

So he said Perry had been in his house before, so he knew the layout.

And he said that he had actually been inside the house because when Wallace was sick with kidney issues, he kind of took over his route.

And so he was in the house to kind of give him all the lay of the land.

And then he said he's actually been inside that cash box because he had to put the money in there after his rounds.

Oh. So he said he's deposited money in that cash box.

He knew it was there. And it would make sense that he didn't go in, like, her purse or upstairs.

He was just going straight for the money he knew.

It makes sense. That does make sense. So Perry was brought in for questioning and without prompting, gave an alibi of being with his girlfriend the night the phone call was made to the chess club.

And had he not been told about the phone call?

Exactly. He also gave an alibi the night of the murders but it didn't ring weird to anybody in the police station that he just offered up an alibi for the night before without anyone asking him Well, and what does the night before have to do with anything?

Exactly. Perry. So he's trying to say, I couldn't have made that phone call.

Wasn't me. I wasn't Qualtra. Right. But it's like nobody knew that, so it doesn't make sense.

The police were probably like, what phone call?

And at this point, alibis are kind of moot, at least for the murder time, because this Emmy was playing... Didn't even know what it is.

This Emmy was playing real fast and loose with versatility. forensics, to say the least.

I don't think we need to rely on that time of death so much.

But remember Perry later because we are not done with him yet.

And you are not done with him either. You know who we are done with?

The episode. I knew it. Hoo boy! I don't know what to think.

Let me tell you, it's only going to get weirder and it's only going to confuse you more. because in the next episode, we are going to talk a little bit more about Perry. and what's going on with him it's gonna make you think a little a little bit more about him being Oh, yeah.

We're going to talk about the trial and everything after.

Obsessed. All right. Guys, that was quite a case.

Quite a case. We hope you keep listening because we're going to come over.

We're going to go over part two this week.

We are. We're going to come over and we're going to go over.

Part two. Part two. So yeah, we hope you keep listening.

And we hope you keep it weird! But not so weird that you don't know who killed your wife and you don't know what you're doing as a medical examiner.

Or a police constable. Bye. Take the rectal temperature, everyone.

Do you ever do that? always do it always put the thermometer in your booty hole bye Thank you.

If you like Morbid, you can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.

Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music.

Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wondery.com slash survey.

The town of Agde in France is famous for sun, sand, sea and sex.

But lately, life on the coast has taken a strange turn.

The town's mayor, a respected pillar of the community, has been arrested for corruption.

His wife claims he's been bewitched by a beautiful clairvoyant.

Then there's the mysterious phone calls that local people have been getting.

I am the Archangel Michael. The whole town has been thrown into chaos.

As the mayor is unable to carry out his duties, I would like to address you all.

Legal proceedings have been initiated. Join me, Anna Richardson, and journalist Leo Schick for The Mystic and the Mayor as we investigate a story of power, corruption, Binge all episodes of The Mystic and the Mare exclusively and ad-free right now on Wondery Plus.

Start your free trial in Apple Podcasts Spotify or the Wondery app

[The Enigmatic 'Impossible Murder': The Case of William Herbert Wallace]-[Episode 222: The Mysterious Murder of Julia Wallace Part 1]

📋 Summary

The Mystery of the 'Impossible Murder'

The Mysterious Phone Call

The Crime Scene

Forensic Failures and Suspects

Conclusion

🎯Key Sentences

📝Key Phrases

📖 Transcript