Hey weirdos, before we dive into today's twisted tale, let me tell you about a place where the darkness never ends.
Wondery Plus. So come join us if you dare.
Morbid is available one week early and ad free only on Wondery Plus.
You can join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or an Apple podcast or Spotify.
You're listening to a morbid network podcast.
Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar.
Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love, you can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities, and new ways of thinking.
Listening can lead to positive changes in your mood, your habits, and ultimately your overall well-being.
Audible has an incredible selection of over 1 million audiobooks, podcasts, and Audible Originals all in one easy app.
Find the genres you love and discover new ones.
Explore bestsellers like my sister's title. new releases, plus thousands of included audiobooks, podcasts, and originals that members can listen to all they want with more added all the time.
I have been listening to the Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club, which actually Elena recommended to me.
She did not listen to it but she said girl this title sounds so you and let me tell you it did.
I've been listening to it while I walk and I am absolutely loving it.
I love all the different narrators. I love Audible.
There's more to imagine when you listen.
Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial and your first audiobook is free.
Visit audible.com slash morbid. Happy Egg believes in spreading happiness through the simple pleasure of high quality and delicious eggs.
And when I say delicious, I am not joking you.
They're... eggs are the highest quality eggs that have ever, ever come into existence, in my opinion.
They're free-range farming standards, working with small family-owned farms to raise their Happy hens outside on a pasture, coupled with the care and treatment that their hens receive, lead to tasty, tasty, ridiculously tasty, yummy orange yolks. that are rich and full of flavor.
Happy egg hens spend their days outside and they're better for that.
They have those deep orange yolks that just look incredible if you're like a You know, you want to put that on your food Insta, that's the kind of egg you want on your Insta.
And you want that egg in your body as well because it just tastes so yummy, yummy, yummy.
Taste the difference and look for that yellow carton at the store near you.
Visit happyegg.com to find a store near you.
Hey, weirdos. I'm Elena. I'm Ash. And this is so morbid.
This one's morbid as poop. This one is one of those that's like high-level morbid.
All of the morbid qualities. Exactly. And more.
That's right. It's going to be crazy. So hang on to your booties, everybody.
Fasten your seatbelts. Let's go for it. ride and before we jump into this crazy ass terrible case We have a couple of business things to attend to.
I was trying to come up with a better word than things but that's the only thing that came to my mind.
Yeah, we have a few business things. So let's talk to you about it.
It is hard and I'm fucking tired. Let's talk to you about our live shows.
Let's do it. First, we are going to be at the Gramercy in like fucking four minutes, basically.
Yeah, basically, after we record this, we're just going to be on stage.
That's wrong. Well, it is, but it feels like it.
I'm pooping my pants every day until then.
Don't worry, not my fancy pants. Nope. After that, we're going to be in Philly and D.C. in April.
We sure are. Yep. And then in May, we're heading over to Alabama.
And I would like to apologize because I left out.
Oh, yeah. It's not just Roll Tide, baby.
It's War Eagles. War Eagle. War Eagle. Fuck me.
Just war eagle. War eagle. Singular eagle.
One eagle. He has no Cub Scouts. And also, we wanted to say thanks so much for everybody being so cool about telling us that, except for that one asshole who gave us a... four star review because we didn't say war eagle that's ridiculous that has nothing to do with my podcast that's not cool eat my butt so everyone else was super cool about it so war eagle and roll tide Or eagle, roll tide, balls, foots in your ass.
Except for that one person. Yes. Fuck you.
Anyways, back to business. Oh, my belt is over there.
Sorry. I was looking for that belt when I got dressed this morning.
Fuck. There it is in the laundry room. I don't even live here.
The laundry room. Don't edit that out. That was kind of funny.
I sure won't. So yeah, we're going to Alabama.
We're going to Nashville. Nashville. We're going to CrimeCon.
We're going to CrimeCon in Orlando. May is going to be wildin'.
Yeah. Guys, come to CrimeCon. Please. It's going to be awesome.
It's going to be the titties. Everyone cool is going to be there.
And us. And me. All the cool people. All the cool people plus us.
And us. So it's worth it. That's it for live shows, yeah?
Yeah, that's it for live shows so far. Wink wink.
Wink wink, nudge nudge. Maybe we have a big announcement tomorrow.
And just, you know, stay tuned for that.
Stay tuned. And also, if you want to go to CrimeCon, use our code MORBID2020.
And you can get some, some shit. I'm not really sure what you get, but like, it's, do it.
Because it'll be great. You could get some shit.
It's like Christmas. You don't know what shit you're getting, but then you get it and the shit's fucking merry.
The shit's awesome. It's gonna be merry, yeah.
It's merry and bright. Fuck. this is gonna be we're gonna be punchy up until the time when we start this awful case yeah yeah let us get it out now I just ripped my jeans more than they were already ripped.
Because I just put my hand in the rip. Because you're uncomfortable.
Because you know what case is coming up.
Yeah. And I'm cold. So yeah, all those fun live shows, go on morbidpodcast.com.
And I have all of the live shows listed out.
I'll be adding them as they come because you know what get more i hope and make sure you click on the links it'll bring you right to the ticket sites for each show where you can buy the tickets Do it.
It's going to be awesome. I promise you'll have fun.
If you don't, you can write me a strongly worded email and I'll delete it.
So... So, yeah. She made a motion too. She literally whipped her hand back and then pushed it forward with a button and hit delete.
Big old delete button. The fake delete.
Fake giant delete button. While you're over on our website, check out our merch.
Buy some shit. John touches the stuffing. sends it out to you he does it's got john dna on it so john just took a dna test he's gonna send you your merch yeah And also Patreon, Patronuses.
Babies. You listening, Patronuses? You listening over there?
Hey. Hey, you. Hey, Patronuses. Hey. We got a big announcement coming next week, so stay tuned.
And we're also working on a bonus episode.
But before we give you your bonus episode, we're going to have a giant announcement.
Huge motherfucker. Keep an eye out. Things are about to get way better. far better so hang on tight and yeah I think without further ado I think that was all the business we had to attend to right Yeah, let's talk about horrible things.
Ready, set, go. So tonight's case is one that I'm sure a lot of people know about or have at least heard of.
The case of Polly Class. This one's a real, real downer.
I knew this case, but reading it again and researching thoroughly through it, I felt like very few cases in this, I don't know if this is going to make me sound like a terrible person, but after researching cases, like I'll feel like sometimes I'm like, wow, that was a bummer.
But very few actually make me feel sick.
Yeah, no, I need to like step away and like, yeah, hug my kids and stuff like this is one of those.
It just like really makes you feel sick.
100%. And I think because this is such an invasion of privacy and an invasion of safety and comfort, this whole case, and you'll know when we get to it.
So let's start off. This is the first case that really utilized the internet in real time.
To like document the case? I didn't know that.
That's cool. This is the first time when it really became a thing.
So this revolves around Polly Hannah Klass.
She was born January 3rd, 1981 in Fairfax, California.
At the time of this case, she was living with her mother, Eve Nickel.
Her father is Mark Klass. They had divorced and her mom was separated from her second husband at the time.
By 1993, Mark was living in Sausalito and running a Hertz car rental company in San Francisco.
He was super close to his daughter, like really good father.
They had an awesome relationship. They talked every single day.
They spent every weekend together. Like, this was just one of those... I think it was one of those where the parents were like, we didn't work out, but, like...
We're still good parents. I love that. That's so important.
So in 1993, she was only 12 years old. She lived with her mom and younger sister, Annie.
They lived in Petaluma, California. Polly was described as loving, sweet, very outgoing very funny like just had a really cool personality everyone who describes her is like she was just like a cool kid like just a kid you wanted around um she was also like a drama club girl which i was like girl after my own heart hey that's all you man she loved being in school plays like really came alive on stage she had aspirations of becoming a famous actress when she grew up stop it Yeah.
So Eve and her two daughters lived across from a place called Wickersham Park.
Mm hmm. This was a park that was near the Greyhound bus station in Petaluma, California.
And it was not a great place. Not a good place.
It was frequented by, you know, people passing through from the Greyhound bus station, which people, you know.
Whenever there's like a big hub of transportation in a tiny town, it can be sketchy because you're getting all All kinds of people from all kinds of places.
You don't know what they're all up to. You don't know if they paid $50 for VIP on a Greyhound bus.
Like Ash did. It happened. it did they offer vip and it's not different it's not different you still sit near the bathroom lesson learned lesson learned yeah Well, this one, the Wickersham Park was home to a lot of transients, a lot of nefarious characters were in there.
Okay. People went in there to, you know, get super drunk, steal drugs, you know.
You know, there was a lot of ODing happening in there.
It just wasn't a place where you wanted to be walking through at night.
No. Or ever. Or really ever. And it was right across from Eve and Polly and Annie's home.
Okay. now october 1st 1993 so this was before you were even born you sure what's crazy sometimes I say that I'm like oh my god I wasn't even born yet but I don't feel jokey about this case and that's it just like blew my mind for a second I was like wow whenever I realized that you weren't born during these things They're like, oh, I'm like, damn, that time period sucked because Ash wasn't here because she wasn't here on Earth.
Polly and her friends Jillian Pelham and Kate McLean had planned to have a little sleepover party at Polly's house.
You know, as you did when you're 12. I used to fucking love sleepovers.
Gotta love sleepovers. That night, Polly and her friend.
So Jillian came earlier. I think she came around like seven o'clock.
So they were hanging out first. Then they waited around and Kate was dropped off by her mom sometime between like 8 and 830.
Mm-hmm. So at around 9.45 p.m., the girls were, like, already, like, well into their sleepover mode.
Like, giggling, doing all kinds of fun. Like, what you do at fucking sleep?
Yeah. Hell yeah. But it was 945. Polly's mom told them she was getting ready to go to bed with Annie.
She was going to have Annie sleep in the bed with her.
Um, and she said, you know, could you guys just be a little bit quieter?
Cause she had a raging migraine and she was like, yeah, I feel you girl.
In fact, I woke up this morning with a migraine.
I knew that was going to happen. I said that to John.
Yeah. But luckily, you know what? Excedrin migraine.
I got prescribed medication for my migraines and excedrin migraine works better.
That's insane. Yeah, I don't know what it is.
Sponsor us. I think it's just like different strokes for different folks, I guess. my like i'm off topic but i'm sorry i know a lot of people have migraines that listen so we're just trying to reach out and help you i'm just trying to reach out to you But I know like my prescription migraine stuff made me feel like really like loopy and drunk.
I don't like that. An excedrin migraine doesn't do that.
Yeah, an excedrin migraine doesn't do that, but it always takes care if I catch it in time.
And I did because, look, I'm talking to you and I'm not wanting to, like, drill a hole through my head.
That makes me happy for you. Me too. Bye.
Bombas makes the most comfortable socks, underwear, and t-shirts.
Warning, Bombas are so absurdly comfortable you may throw out all your other clothes.
Sorry, do we legally have to say that? No, this is just how I talk and I really love my bombas.
One item purchased equals one item donated.
Feel good and do good. Go to Bombas.com and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase.
That's B-O-M-B-A-S.com and use code audio at checkout.
Why choose a Sleep Number smart bed? Can I make my site softer?
Can I make my site firmer? Can we sleep cooler?
Sleep Number does that. Cools up to eight times faster and lets you choose your ideal comfort on either side.
Your Sleep Number setting. It's the Sleep Number biggest sale of the year.
All beds on sale. Up to 50% off the limited edition smart bed, plus free home delivery with the purchase of any smart bed.
Ends Monday. All Sleep Number smart beds offer temperature solutions for your best sleep.
Check it out at a Sleep Number store or sleepnumber.com today. uh so yeah so her mother had a migraine she wanted to go to sleep so she was like she wasn't like you guys have to go to sleep she was just like quiet down a little bit um now her bedroom was directly across from polly's oh shit um she was so she knew that you know She was like, this is a loud night.
I have a migraine. I gotta sleep. So she took her prescribed sleeping medication.
Okay. It wasn't like over the counter or something.
She just took randomly. It was like she was prescribed this.
So the girls were doing the typical sleepover shit, they're playing video games, and because Halloween was coming up, it was October 1st, they were trying out different makeup looks on each other.
Oh my god, fun. So they all had makeup on like making up like different like monster faces and like, you know, glam girl faces.
Yep. Um, so, so around, I don't remember exactly what time it was.
I believe it was sometime around like 10 30 ish in that hour.
Polly opens her bedroom door because she's like, oh, I'm going to go get the slumber bags, the sleeping bags for all of us.
So she opens the door. And when she opens that door, a large man is standing in front of her bedroom door.
Now this isn't outside. This is in her bedroom door.
She opens her bedroom door and a man is standing in the hallway.
Right outside her bedroom door, which is directly across from her mother's door.
It's the most terrifying thing I've ever heard in my fucking life.
It gives me heartburn. Because I'm picturing me opening my bedroom door.
I just think I'm like this man just walked into this house.
Anybody that waltzes into your house like you don't want to fuck with them.
Not good. And that's what all of, I'm sure I've mentioned this before, but like my, all of my criminal justice professors in college were all like, cause most of them were like detectives or cops or some sort.
And they all said, if someone breaks into your house in the middle of the night, do not go downstairs and confront them.
No. You stay in a room. You call 911 upstairs and you wait until they leave because you don't want to meet that person anymore. motherfucker who breaks into a home that they have no idea what's what or who is in that house that's a crazy motherfucker and you do not want to deal with them And it's the best advice I ever got.
It's true. Because my house, we have like a lock so nobody can get up to the second floor. and it is the greatest thing we ever did because it makes me feel so much when i have a home someday i want that it's it's makes me feel so much better because i'm like fuck that yeah Fuck that so hard.
So this man is standing in the hallway. He had a large butcher knife in his hand and a duffel bag.
Oh, my God. He immediately told them all, if any of you scream, I will slit your throats.
So he said, everybody be quiet. So they all just were like, holy shit.
Because can you imagine? No. You're 12. You're at a sleepover.
No. So immediately the other girls think this must be like a prank or something.
Because they're like, it's Halloween time.
Maybe like this is somebody that Polly knows and they thought it would be funny.
Yeah. They said they did not think this was a funny prank, but they thought it was a prank nonetheless.
So they quickly were like, oh, this is not a prank because he quickly started tying all of their hands behind their backs with silk material that he had torn. and the cords like wires that he cut from the nintendo wires in the room oh my god yeah Because he used the butcher knife and sliced off the wires.
Jesus. And he keeps telling them, right?
Like, fuck you, man. Eat a dick. Yeah. And so he keeps telling them all to be quiet, stay quiet, I'm not going to hurt anybody. i was like then what are you here for bro well and that's so he's saying he's saying you know whose house is this is anyone else in the house So Polly is like, it's my house and my mom and my sister in the house.
And he seemed very like... I think from what I've read, he was like, what?
Someone else is in the house? And I'm like... bruh these are like three like 12 year olds you really think they're in the house all by themselves like you got fucking dumb right which spoiler alert he is Um, so the girls are all like crying at this point because again, they're 12 year old babies.
Scary as fuck. These are 12 year old babies.
And he's trying to tell them no one's going to get hurt here.
I just want money. So he's saying, I'm not going to hurt any of you.
I just want money. So then he duct taped all of their mouths.
Oh my God. And like gagged them with like. fabric like behind the duct tape and he was like I don't want anyone making sounds He took their own pillowcases off their pillows and placed them over Jillian and Kate's heads.
Then he said he had them lay down and he said count to a thousand because I'm gonna take Polly out of here to show me where the valuables and money are and And by the time you count to a thousand, she'll be back in the room and I will be gone.
And that's not true. and they were like and so of course they're like okay like we're gonna do it so they started counting they said like 20 minutes later they were still sitting there like in fear there Polly never came back in the room.
So they managed to free themselves, which is like badass.
Amazing. They free themselves. They run around the house.
Polly's nowhere. And they're like, fuck.
So they run into Eve's room and wake her up frantically.
Which, first of all, being woken up that way anyways is, like, very jarring and awful.
Right. Like, having a migraine and then hearing your child... was nowhere to be found and a man came in right took her and you were literally just across the hall and had like no idea like thinking about this i can't i honestly every anytime i think about being in eve's situation i immediately feel like i have to like walk out of the room and just like get fresh air Like it like physically affects me.
Yeah. Like I feel for her so much. Like, so much.
Well, because you have kids, too. I think things like this are so different.
Like, it's horrifying nonetheless, but when you have kids, it makes it so different, I bet.
Yeah, it takes it to a whole nother level because I am the first thing I think of. is if an intruder was in my house, it's not how do I get us out of here?
It's how do I get the girls out of the house?
Right. It's I don't give a shit about me.
I want the girls safe. That's all. I would put them on the roof if I had to.
Like that's the first plan I come up with is how do I get to the girls.
Yeah. and i always have a fucking plan she really does i've heard many of them i do So Eve called the police at 11.03 p.m. and they showed up immediately.
That's good. They notice that the video game cords are all cut.
Things are kind of like thrown everywhere.
That's still like pretty early. Like. it is it's really mean like you you don't think things like that happen at like 10 30 at night right um so i'm pretty sure isn't it 10 30 like right now It pretty much is close to.
And so the lead investigator on the case was Ed Fryer.
He said that right away he could tell this was a stranger abduction.
Right. And he said those are much more rare and they are way harder to track.
Because at least if it's someone that knows the family or some kind of connection, you have that little thread to pull.
But when it's a stranger abduction... What do you have to go on?
Not only do you have nothing to go on, it's like... what the fuck's gonna happen here like this it's always so much worse when it's somebody they don't know Because, again, anybody walks into your house and steals someone out of your house, that's a fucking crazy person.
And you need to get that person back right now.
Yep. So because he wasn't wearing a mask, the investigators brought Kate and Jillian in and were like, can you please give us a description?
Of course, the girls are hysterical. They've just been through fucking hell.
They're traumatized. But you know what?
Those little badasses gave the best they could and they got a really good sketch of them.
Good. because they paid attention. So an APB went out, an all-points bulletin, There was extensive searches immediately of all the homes in the area.
A helicopter was circling. There were canine units.
I mean, it was like. mass search everybody dropped what they were doing to do this um yeah this was one of those cases where like the entire nation came together for this case So when there's a stranger abduction at all, but especially a stranger abduction out of a home,
That's something that the FBI and local law enforcement are really going to put like their full like the FBI is going to come in.
They're going to put everything together.
They're going to work together and they're going to get I mean, they had the Navy, the Coast Guard working on this.
It's like they did not fuck around. So if the problem is time is always of the essence in these cases, because unfortunately, If someone isn't found within the first 24 hours in a child-stranger abduction, the expectation that they'll be found alive... or at all diminishes greatly.
That's so sad. Yeah. And it's like, imagine being the parents knowing that you have 24 hours of real time here.
And you know that after 24 hours, it can happen.
But it's like the possibilities are like, yeah.
So unfortunately, what happened though, is that the APB that went out was initially marked not for press release. which meant that it wouldn't go out over all the police scanners because reporters listen to police scanners.
Right. And they marked it as not for press release.
So that meant they wouldn't go out on all the police scanners.
So all the police in the area were not informed of this.
Oh, no. So there were other deputies in other surrounding areas that had no idea that this was happening that night.
Right. And... unfortunately when you hear what happened that's how it happened it really fucked this case up oh I don't know if it would have stopped what happened, but I think he would have been caught that night, I think.
Yeah. Now, immediately the entire world is looking for her.
I mean, there were like there were, you know, TV shows had her on there, the news, magazines, newspapers, she was like everywhere.
They ended up bringing in like some like crazy forensics company to go over the scene again.
And this company was able to find a palm print on her bed oh wow that it was probably like when he was getting the pillowcases off the bed right not his whole hand but his palm print Unfortunately, it was 1993 and a palm print database was not going to help you out.
Meanwhile, volunteers were scanning every bit of everywhere in Petaluma and the outskirts.
The Navy, like I said, the Coast Guard, they had cadets searching their waterways.
There were literally hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of people actively just jumping into this i love that over 100 000 flyers with her face on them were distributed like Within a first day or two Wow.
Yeah, they had him everywhere and it was like it was the missing poster It had her face on it.
It had that later on it had like the sketch of him on Now, Petaluma Police spoke to Polly's teachers, students, everybody at the schools.
Just asking, like, did you see anything?
Have you ever seen someone lurking around?
Like, was anything weird at all? Because they have nothing.
Right. At this point, they have nothing to go on.
You're just fucking looking for everything. anything.
Literally, they're just grasping into the air.
They talk to a lot of the neighbors, too, around their house.
And a lot of the neighbors said immediately that night, they said they noticed a man in dark clothing with bushy hair. and possibly carrying a bag and he was like skulking around the neighborhood that night and when they looked at the sketch it did match the sketch okay So this kid, he was this little boy.
I don't remember. I don't think they announced how old he was.
He was with two other friends and he said that night that she was abducted at around 9 p.m.
Ugh. And he was standing in like the shadows.
Oh, I hate that. And he said he had bushy hair, dark clothing, and it looked like he was carrying a bag.
Now, they were like, that's weird, but what the fuck are we going to do about it?
We're kids. It was like, that's weird. So they were like, all right, we're just going to go to the video store.
They went to the video store. They're walking back.
He hasn't moved. Oh, oh, I hate that so much.
So they were like, that's weird. So now they're like, okay, tell me exactly what he looked like.
And they didn't show him the sketch necessarily. yeah i got from the girls they were like just tell me what he looked like he described exactly to a t it was him um so they set up like the poly class search center there was like um her father ended up taking like time off of work like a leave of absence to take care of this um they set up a hotline for tips and a lot of people were calling the hotline that were parents of other missing children trying to like give their like tips and also trying to get help for their thing too right so it was like kind of bringing everyone together like especially these all these parents with missing children because yeah that's a that's a club you do not want to be in nope Not at all, no thank you.
But you probably need so badly other people to like, because nobody understands that.
No. Nobody. I don't. Nobody wants to understand that.
Like you can try to fathom it in your brain.
Right. I can't. You can't even get close to it.
No. um it's hard to even fathom like you don't even want it really oh god i i it's honestly like bringing your brain there bringing my brain so dark It's like really dangerous doing my brain there because it feels like it'll like break you.
Yeah, it would. Think about it. So People magazine actually put her on the cover and the case on the cover and dubbed her America's Child.
Because the nation was coming together. The internet was going crazy.
There were updates everywhere. They used some more forensic work, which was still in the early stages in 1995.
So this was the first case that brought a lot of things together.
And they ended up finding in Polly's carpet They found a little tiny fiber that didn't match any of the other fibers.
Wow. And it seemed like it came from a car.
And they looked at all the car carpets in the family and it didn't match any of them.
Okay. So they were thinking maybe it came from somewhere this guy stepped. because fibers can be beneficial in like linking you know yeah sure um They also found a human hair that had been taken out of somebody's head.
The hair had a tiny bit of scalp left on it.
Which happens when you pull hair out of your head.
Directly out of your head. Not just like, dink, but like when somebody has yanked it out of somebody's head.
Right. Unfortunately, because it was 1993, DNA was not in its heyday at this point, so they really couldn't do a lot with it.
That just gave me a headache. That they found these things and were actively looking for these things is pretty impressive.
And at least put them away because eventually, if this hadn't gone or solved, whatever.
Exactly. That's the thing. So meanwhile, Mark Klass, like I said, he had taken a leave of absence from his job to just work on this search full time.
Right. This guy named David Collins was also was another father of another missing child.
Yeah. His son, Kevin, had gone missing in 1984 and he was actually one of the first kids, missing kids to be put on a milk carton.
Oh, wow. Yeah, and he reached out and tried to, like, aid in this whole thing because, like, this is what started happening.
Like, these other... Parents of missing children were like, if I can't find my own child, I want to help someone else.
You know, like they just need to help. Which I think is so cool.
It's like you're... That's like very beautiful.
You're like grieving and like having to deal with your own... trauma and you're seeing it in someone else and being like, I want to help them.
Yeah. Like that's badass. That takes a lot.
It really does. Cause it's like, how do you put your own shit aside?
How do you even muster that like energy to do that?
At the time, because again, they have nothing to go on still.
They're still just looking at this sketch and that's it.
Right. At the time, Winona Ryder actually came out in 1993.
My girl. Yeah, she was. I love Winona Ryder.
I do, too. I love her. She's got issues, but I got them too.
But she's like the comeback kid. She is.
She's the comeback kid. She is. I love her.
And she looks great. Great. Phenomenal.
Like get it Winona. Sister. So Winona Ryder, our queen. offered $200,000 as a reward for her return.
Wow. yeah and when she came out and did that it like really brought more focus to it because you know even these cases that are like everywhere and the whole nation is on top of it they start to peter out yeah of course started happening and the attention wanes so she came out just in the nick of time to like really bring back put it back on yeah the hot burner And this is when it got put on America's Most Wanted with John Walsh and all that.
I fucking love that show. oh we're gonna and you know what i say we don't like covering child we have things we're covering one right now but we the important ones i mean they're all important the ones that I'm able to get through and that I really need feel like I need to tell will do and Adam Walsh is definitely 100% mainly because it It also ties into like Otis tool and Henry Lee Lucas and all that.
So we'll get to that one just so you know.
So Mark was given a polygraph test because, of course, the FBI, you know, he's the dad.
Right. He passed with flying colors, but again, polygraph tests are such bullshit.
Right. Not that I'm saying it's a bullshit that he passed it.
It's just like, why do you even do it? Right.
Right. And the FBI was actually starting to get kind of lost on leads at this point.
Like they were like just grasping at straws.
Yeah. Um, so Mark actually during this time also got a call from a girl who sounded like Polly. god stop the girl said she was in a hotel room and didn't know where she was but her kidnapper had left the room oh my god So he lost his fucking mind because then the line went dead.
Wait, I don't know if this is real or not.
What? Like, was it Polly? Well... So they couldn't trace it because they weren't expecting this call.
Right. So the FBI is like, fuck. we she's gonna call again we gotta get hopefully she'll call again we'll get a trace right right right so they waited waited waited another call came okay Same girl.
She was super anxious, said she couldn't talk, sounded scared, sounded just like Polly.
Okay. And they traced it to a home about 30 miles away. away.
They go there, turned out to be some fucking piece of shit teenage girl.
Are you kidding me? Who had been dared by her fucking piece of shit teenage friends to do it. oh yeah I've never heard that part isn't that messed up that's so disgusting can you imagine one Being despicable enough to dare your friend to call a grieving father who doesn't know where his child is?
How do you even get, like, what? And then two, can you imagine being... despicable enough to go sure friends i'll do that and to do it twice like how did this little group of turd fucks get together in the first place ew What the fuck?
Like, that pissed me off so much. That is not just, like... Because people will be like, oh, teens are stupid.
It's like, no. No, that's not teenage behavior.
Yeah. Like... Like I want to know where that girl is now and what she's doing because I bet it's nothing special.
Because it's like never once did I think that would I ever think that was funny.
We used to prank call people and be like, who's your refrigerator running?
Like, no. Yeah. Fuck off. You prank call people and be like, do you like cheese?
You know what I mean? You'd be like, what? do you like cheese it's like you you do stupid stuff you don't call a grieving father and pretend to be his daughter Was kidnapped out of his house.
That's disgusting. Horrific. I'd punch her in the face if I saw her today.
True pieces of human garbage everywhere in this story.
Um, so they brought back in Jillian and Kate, the two friends from the sleepover at this point.
And they were like, okay, now that you've, like, we've had some time away from... it happening can we try to go over again what he looked like right they ended up getting an even better sketch of this dude And they also I think they also like the person who was drawing it was really, really good, too, because this photo I'll post it on the Instagram. is a really good photo and it really it's insane what people can do it sketch artists Baffle me.
That you can say like... I'm like, are you some kind of psychic?
For real. Do you have something? Because just...
They have to go with a frantic person, usually an emotional person, normally telling them.
And his eyes were kind of big. Right. And they just have to go by that.
Right. I'd be like, I don't know how to draw that.
I have no fucking idea. It's an eyeball.
I don't know. So this new photo went on the missing poster with the $200,000 reward.
Okay. So during all of this, the FBI is still just grasping at straws. so they were positing you know did she run off with a boyfriend no did she do this did you do that meanwhile she was 12 years old and she had never had a boyfriend And she was out of sleep over with her two friends.
And then there's also the fact that her two friends were involved with the whole thing, like tied up as well and watched the whole thing happen.
Right. But and that pissed a lot of people off because they were like, what are you doing even thinking of?
Yeah. Like that you're wasting time. So November 28th, 1993.
This is a couple months after the abduction.
A woman named Dana Jaffe. She was outside on her property about 20 miles away from Petaluma.
Okay. She called police saying she found some like weird shit on her property. and she didn't want to touch it she just wanted them to come down and see it so she brought them never touch it no she was like i'm not touching that shit good for you dana So she had a really big, giant private property.
It had a long, long, long driveway, lots of wooded area, lots of dirt paths. um like a really fancy place so she was rich as fuck she was so they brought her they she brought police down a dirt path that was off her driveway and like way in the woods and she showed them that she had found a piece of silk a pillowcase with makeup smudges on the inside of it packing tape, a condom, a man's sweatshirt, and a pair of girls' tights.
These girls' tights were tied in a knot and a human hair was in the knot.
Oh. So she's like, this is weird, right?
She's like, I don't want this on my property, right?
Shit looks strange. I don't really think I've just accumulated this over any time.
So she said, so they were like, what the fuck?
Like, has anyone been on your property? And she was like, oh, yeah, I did have someone trespass on my property.
And she was like, and I contacted the police.
Why do you not have this on file? Are you fucking kidding me?
Wait a second. What? So they look. she did contact police it was on file but we'll see why they didn't connect us initially god damn it So it was about two months earlier on October 1st.
No. That she had a man trespass on her property.
So what happened was that night. her babysitter, because she had a daughter, the babysitter was leaving her house and And she was going down the really long driveway.
It was really dark. And she saw a man and his car stuck on the side of the driveway.
Again, I say it's a really long driveway.
He was stuck in like a little ditch. So he's like, what the fuck?
So she rolled her window down just a little bit.
Yeah. Just like a tiny little thing just to be like, what the fuck are you doing?
Like, this is private property. You're not supposed to be on here.
And she said he turned around and looked at her and she said he looked crazed. oh like sweaty dirty panic oh my god i would be terrified yeah and she was like what the fuck and so he's like i need you to help me get this car out And she was like, nope.
No. I am like super booked for the rest of the evening.
She was like. I've got a nail appointment, a hair appointment.
I have to wash my dog. I just got to get out of here because you are a sweaty, dirty mess and you look like a fucking wild man. helping you yeah i'm out of here i know i'm driving but also my uber's here so bye Gotta keep that five-star rating, boo.
Well, and he's, so he's like, I need your help.
And he actually walked over to her car and slammed his hands on, like, the roof of the car.
Stop. it and then he was like what's up that driveway and she was like what the fuck so she's like nope and she was like i'm calling the police so she drives away She goes to a payphone and she calls Dana at around 11.24 p.m.
So she's like, she tells Dana what the fuck just happened.
Yeah. So Dana grabs a baseball bat. Hell yeah.
Drives down her driveway to see what's going on, which I don't recommend.
No. But, like, bad bitch alert. Like, bad bitch Dana, but, like, real dangerous.
Could have had a different outcome. Like, you know what?
Dana just called me. Did you just hear all the times I stuttered?
I was like, girl. That's what I just said.
Direct translation. Direct translation. I'm broken.
I am broken. So she drives down there with a huge baseball bat.
Woof. And she saw the car, but she didn't see the guy.
Okay. So she was like, all right, well, that's weird.
So she drives a little off the property, like out of the driveway.
Right. And she calls the police around 1146 p.m.
They came, they searched, they find the dude with his car.
No. He's sweaty, he's dirty, he's wild as fuck, just like they said he was.
He's out here wilding. He seemed drunk.
They could smell alcohol on him and he had leaves and shit in his hair.
Like, he was just a fucking rat. Not normal.
And he told them, and when they pulled up, he was just sitting there like smoking, like leaning on his car. like i'm just out here chilling on this private property so they're like yeah what you doing and he was like oh i was just sightseeing and didn't know this was private property They're like, it's midnight.
So what the fuck are you seeing? And they're like, yeah, bro, you look like you're just sightseeing, like you're covered in dirt and sweat.
But OK. You sightseeing the dirt up close?
I'm confused. So he said he realized that it was private property suddenly and He tried to leave, but his car got stuck in the ditch.
So they were like, okay, well, that's weird.
So they gave him a sobriety test. He passed it, weirdly enough.
Yeah. They looked in his car. It was covered in like empty beer cans, full beer cans, a bunch of clothes, just like weird shit.
They noticed a duffel bag. Now remember, the APB originally went out not to be released to press.
Meaning it didn't go out on the scanner to other officers.
Meaning these officers. This means these two sheriff's deputies that showed up had no idea that they should be looking for an abducted little girl or a guy that looked innocent. exactly like this guy so otherwise they may have known that night and they may have when we see what actually happened they wouldn't have been able to save her I don't think that's so sad but they would have found her Right.
Quick. And they would have been able to arrest him quick.
Oh, that breaks my fucking heart. Yeah. That they could have found her that night.
Exactly. And the parents just could have at least known.
Right. So the dude was starting to get belligerent.
They asked if he had been drinking that evening, and he grabbed a beer, opened it, and just started drinking in front of them.
Oh. So they took it and they were like, no fucker.
So they patted him down. He was, you know, they didn't find anything.
They went back and they ran his license and his registration.
Uh-huh. No warrant came up. Okay. His name was Richard Allen Davis and he was 39 years old.
Shopify's point of sale system helps you sell at every stage of your business.
Need a fast and secure way to take payments in person?
We've got you covered. How about card readers you can rely on anywhere you sell?
Thanks. Have a good one. Yep. Want one place to manage all your online and in-person sales?
That's kind of our thing. Wherever you sell, businesses that grow, grow with Shopify.
Sign up for your $1 a month trial at Shopify.com slash listen.
Shopify.com slash listen. The town of Agde in France is famous for sun, sand, sea and sex.
But lately, life on the coast has taken a strange turn.
The town's mayor, a respected pillar of the community, has been arrested for corruption.
His wife claims he's been bewitched by a beautiful clairvoyant.
Then there's the mysterious phone calls that local people have been getting.
I am the Archangel Michael. The whole town has been thrown into chaos.
As the mayor is unable to carry out his duties, I would like to address you all.
Legal proceedings have been initiated. Join me, Anna Richardson, and journalist Leo Schick for The Mystic and the Mayor as we investigate a story of power, corruption, and magic.
Binge all episodes of The Mystic and the Mare exclusively and ad-free right now on Wondery Plus.
Start your free trial in Apple Podcasts, Spotify or the Wondery app.
Now, Richard Allen Davis had served time in prison recently.
Oh, goodie. At California Men's Colony in San Luis, it's San Luis Obispo. fucking look it up look it up right now i'm looking it up san luis obispo california There you have it.
And that lady doesn't lie, okay? And it's San Luis Obispo.
So he was in the California men's colony in that place. for kidnapping and robbery.
He was originally sentenced to 16 years, but only served eight before he was paroled June 27th, 1993.
Well, the reason this came up clean with no warrants was because the officer accidentally entered the numbers wrong.
Oh, goody. Yeah. The car had recently been purchased from a friend of Richard Allen Davis.
So the name was not like yet in the system of registration, all that good stuff. stuff now if everyone everything had gone the way it should have and the technology was there at the time to like connect warrants and like all that good stuff They would have seen that he had quite a record.
Oh, good. And if he had been detained, they may have also been able to ascertain that he showed signs of this behavior his entire life. life oh shit his whole life this dude is one of those guys that slipped through the cracks a lot of times oh and he never should have been able to get to this point It was a lot of failures along the way that led him to this point.
He grew up on a Native American reservation with his Native American mother, evelyn and his uh caucasian father bob davis both of them were raging alcoholics And when I say not great parents, I mean abysmal parents.
The worst. Yeah, he had four other siblings and his parents divorced when he was 11 years old.
His father actually got full custody. Which is always shocking when the... I'm not saying they don't deserve it, but usually courts hand over to the mother most of the time.
Even now, I feel. Unless... It's gotta be real bad.
Yeah. And especially back then for the mom to not get custody.
I feel like it had to have been real bad.
Exactly. There's something along the lines in the court papers because of the mother's alleged immoral conduct in front of the children. oh yeah um she would allegedly hold his hand two people two witnesses have said they saw her Hold his hand over an open flame to punish him for minor things.
Oh God. And they said one of those times his hand could be seen blistering.
Oh, stop. They also. said one of those times it was clear that he had become so accustomed to this that he just stood there.
What the fuck? And, like, nothing registered on his face.
And his hand was being burned. How do you sit there with your child and do that to them?
How do you hold your child? first of all to harm your child in any way nothing ever makes sense to me about that i think we've made that pretty clear that we do not even begin to live in that realm of reality But first of all, like when you have a kid, the first time I remember I accidentally snipped Lennon's tip of her finger when I was cutting her nails when she was like a baby.
And you probably wanted to jump off cliff first of all i immediately started sobbing like sobbing like full body heaving sobbing because When you see your child bleed, it is, I can't even describe to you the feeling.
And then knowing she did not even care. I don't even think she noticed.
But fingers bleed so much. Yeah, it was.
It was a ton of blood. I'm trying to stop it.
And I'm calling John being like, I'm a horrible mother.
I just did this. It was awful. I know. I'll say like no to them and I'm like, fuck, I'm an asshole.
I am the worst aunt. Shit. And just seeing blood on your child. but and so it's like watching your child's hand blister and burn because you're holding it over an You got to be fucked on the upper echelon of evil to do that.
Yeah. So, I mean, that's the kind of shit he was dealing with.
He... And when he became an adult, he referred to his mother as that gutter snipe dog bitch.
Him and I have that in common. Yes. I also refer to my mother as that Cuttersmith dumb bitch.
Unfortunately, you and him have that in common.
That's so fucked up. I feel like even I wouldn't say that.
No, I feel that's real rough. That's rough.
But still, that was funny. You gotta have a little levity in some of these parts.
And guttersnipe dog bitch is where the levity lies, I believe.
Woof. So basically, his parents were never around.
And when they were around, they were shitbags.
Again, just don't have kids if you're going to be a shitbag.
That's the thing. You're creating other shitbags.
If you want to be a shitbag for yourself, that sucks in and of itself.
Just go be a shitbag on your own. Don't raise other shitbags.
So he started getting in trouble super early.
He first had his first run in with the lot 12 years old.
Wow. What happened? I believe he was, like, stealing, like, mail out of people's mailboxes.
Like, he was stealing, looking for checks and, like, stealing them.
Oh, shit. Interesting. 10 at 12 yeah um he started getting in tons of trouble his parole records all pointed at his seriously unstable home life as probably the thing that was causing his behavior.
Right. But nothing was being done about it, of course.
He also enjoyed, at this time, torturing and killing animals.
Ay, yeah. which as we know is no brainer it's never a sign of anything bad right just serial murders to come So he dropped out of school in the ninth grade.
Oh. And just started binge drinking and just being an asshole.
Goodie. Because, you know, that's what you do.
I said goodie, sorry. many times I can't stop being like oh goody oh fun he would get arrested constantly for burglarizing homes robbing he liked to steal a lot that was his thing you know the thrill of it public drunkenness just being an asshole yeah asshole asshole asshole I just keep saying it So in 1974, he was 21 years old.
He was sentenced to six months for six months to 15 years.
Sorry. that's a casual sentence quite a gap for attempted burglary he only served one year of that sentence and then was paroled okay Seven weeks after getting out of prison, he literally kidnapped a woman at knife point.
Jeez. And I'm sorry, how old was he? 21 years old.
Jesus Christ. Yeah. He grabbed her from a random parking lot and forced her into the passenger seat of her own car and then drove her to a secluded area.
He then whipped out his penis and basically told her, you know what I want you to do.
What the fuck? While he's holding a knife to her face.
Oh my god. So you know what she did? Bit it?
No, but that's intense. No, she did something similarly as intense though.
She grabbed the knife blade with her own hand. held it while opening the door behind her and kicking it open and then ran out of the car screaming oh my god bad alert like Bitch grabbed the knife blade.
That is so badass. That's wicked badass.
That is self-preservation shit. Like, to just... Because every single one of your instincts says don't grab a knife blade.
Yeah. So for her to be able to override that in a fight or flight situation... But if you're going to get a fucking cut versus...
Good for her, man. Well, she got away because luckily a highway patrol officer was driving by at that exact moment and he arrested Davis.
So the asshole tried to hang himself in prison this time.
Unfortunately, he did not succeed. I was gonna say bummer it didn't work.
Yeah, because if he had actually succeeded, he wouldn't have been able to do this.
And we wouldn't, you know, Polly Class's family wouldn't have had to go through this bullshit.
Exactly. So after the suicide attempt, he was sent to a psychiatric hospital.
He escaped that place. Shit. It's always so scary when they're like... i know to escape yeah because it's like it adds like a whole different thing to their fucking personality it really does immediately after escaping he went on like a crime spree of course He broke into a woman's home at one point.
When she caught him, he slammed her over the head with a fireplace poker.
Oh, fuck. Yeah. he uh he broke into an animal shelter he stole money guns and bullets from there which i was like why is that in an animal shelter but i don't know it's do you Right after this, he tried to kidnap a woman in a parking lot again using a gun that he had stolen.
Oh, that's scary. But she was screaming and she got away.
Then he went back to his hometown of La Honda, California and he burglarized a home again.
Damn. When the police were called, they found him hiding in the backyard of the home.
In the backyard? Yeah. Like, just keep running.
Like, yo. Just keep going. Yeah. That's how dumb he is.
You stupid. So he was originally, he was immediately arrested and charged for attempting kidnapping, assault, just burglary.
All of the things. Most of shit. The maximum time he could be set for these crimes that they could actually charge him with was six years.
Wow. He served six years and then was paroled in March 1982 because at this time in California, it was like you serve your sentence, you're paroled automatically.
That's it. Right. um so even the judge though didn't want to let him out but he had to his hands were tied because he said this dude shows no remorse for what he's done like he was worried he was like I don't want to send him back.
And he even at one point was like, don't you feel bad for what you've done at all?
And he was like, no. And then he even said he was like, if I felt bad about what I've done, I wouldn't.
Why would I keep doing it? Right. Like he clearly was like, yeah, I don't give a fuck.
So they let him out. That's so scary. He was let out.
And one night he met a woman named Sue Edwards at a dive bar.
And love was in the air. Oh, yeah. So he met her when she was dealing meth at the bar.
You know, that really gets the boys going.
Taylor's oldest time. It's like my meth brings all the boys to the yard.
My meth lab brings all the boys to the yard. trouble with that i love you i was having a trouble uh so together you know they robbed someone that they both knew because that's what you do in a new relationship.
You find out who you both know and you rob that person.
That's how you and John decided to get married we were like who do we have as a connection between both of us and then we robbed that Annie and I haven't done that yet that's why we're not married but you know what next level shit it's coming Bonnie and Clyde shit let's get it that's just next level shit So let's see.
So they robbed this woman they knew. Davis, while they were robbing her, Davis pistol whipped her.
Oh my God. And threatened to kill her whole family if she didn't listen to what they were saying.
Jesus. So he's really awesome. They then ran up to Washington State together, robbed a bank.
A bank? Yeah. Robbed some more banks and stores.
They went on a literal Bonnie and Clyde spree.
Wow. And were eventually pulled over and arrested.
He got the maximum 16 years in prison. This is when he was sent to California Men's Colony.
So this is bringing us up to when he got out.
The abduction policy. And again, he was released due to prison overcrowding.
He was released only eight years into his 16 year sentence.
Like, build another prison then. I don't know.
That was like a real problem back then. I mean, it still is, but it became a real problem at one point. more we can't just like release people because we can't detain them just let all like the really bad guys out it's fine I mean, if we're going to be real about it, there's people that are in prisons for minor drug offenses that are nonviolent.
So let's let them go. I think that's the way to go.
Because this dude belongs in prison. Yeah.
But it's like, you know. You keep doing it, you keep doing it, you keep doing it.
So because they entered the registration wrong and, you know, the criminal history didn't show up because at that time...
Things all weren't as connected as they were now.
Yeah, like there were limitations in the commuter system and The officers were like, all right, well, nothing came up.
So the office, and again, they didn't get the APB.
So they don't know that, you know, maybe we should look into this guy a little more.
And he passed the sobriety test. Yeah. So there's really nothing to do.
It was just like, this is a weird dude. We should get him out.
So they brought him back to the freeway and we're like, bye, sir.
Wow. Well, now they're like so. So now this is bringing it back to like November 28th, two months later, when Dana was like, what's all the shit on my property?
Yeah. Remember that guy that was on my property two months ago?
Right. Maybe he left it here. I don't know.
So they're like, shit, because they all of a sudden talk to those deputies and deputies are like, yeah, his name is Richard Allen Davis.
You know, this is what happened that night.
And they're like. what oh no and they were like october 1st and they're like yeah and then he's like so they're like fuck like now they're looking at all this shit and they're like oh So now they're like, okay, we got to get a hold of him.
So they got a hold of Richard Allen Davis.
And he was at his sister's place in, I think...
Look it up. Yeah, I'm not even gonna attempt this one.
Hold on, I'll look it up. Ukiah, California.
So that's where he was. They arrested him there November 30th for a parole violation stemming from a DUI warrant on him from October 19th.
That's how they were able to grab him. Got it.
He was immediately questioned about Polly.
He said he had no idea about anything. Yeah, totally.
Didn't have anything to do with it. Never saw her.
Never saw her. Of course not. On December 2nd, they were able to take that palm print that they got and compare it to his.
Because it was no good to them just by itself, but now they have someone that they can compare it to.
Well, it was a perfect match. Oh, good. So they brought this information to him.
They're like, yo, your hand. How's your hand print? end up in there that's like so weird that never happened it's real weird did it just like fly across the air and like materialize on her bed shit So he was like, okay, well, I'm not going to say anything unless I can speak to this sergeant who he had like apparently wanted to tell.
Okay. So the sergeant talked to him and he said he immediately got on the phone and said, I fucked up big time.
And he admitted that Polly was no longer alive.
Oh, God. He agreed to lead investigators to where he had put her body.
And he did so later that evening. she was located off dutcher creek road near highway 101 and this was about 40 miles north from where they encountered him on dana jaffe's property oh wow So that's a little weird.
She was found on her back under a large piece of plywood and there was also other like random things placed on top of her. she was wearing a nightgown that was pulled up under her arms and her white skirt that she had been wearing was pulled up under her arms as well that's she did have on underwear and like a little bra um near her body there was a piece of cloth and a rope there was also hair in the knots of these things they couldn't determine cause of death because she was very decomposed at the time oh my god but they surmised the rope and cloth likely strangled her because of the hair and the correct size of the uh the knot basically um a doctor who did the autopsy on her remains said that um They basically were like, it was an awful way to find a 12-year-old girl.
Yeah, I can imagine. Because it had been a couple of months.
They said that the skull had separated away from her body at that time. time it was she wasn't decapitated when you know before this it just happened to happen that way And they said the hair had fallen from her head.
It was still there, but it like separates off of your skull.
Does it eventually just disintegrate? Um, hair stays around for a long time.
Yeah. But it had like separated from her skull, which is just a very spooky thing. to see.
Yeah I don't like that. She was like partially mummified and like half of her was mummified half of her was skeletonized.
Oh. And again, they couldn't... They said there was, like, no organs left.
There was nothing left. It was... She was really decomposed.
Which made it really hard. So... uh let's see they found uh they unfortunately did find semen on her clothing They used UV light technology to check and they did find traces of semen.
That's horrific. They interviewed Davis and he said he was in the park across from Polly's home that evening, that like really sketchy park. he said he drank a ton he smoked a joint that he thinks was laced with pcp oh shit He said he really doesn't remember much, but he said he didn't know Polly.
He'd never seen her before, but suddenly he was just in her house. oh you know and he remembers some of the binding up of the girls and then poof he was just in the car And he didn't even know that Polly was in there until she said, the rope is too tight.
Please loosen it around my arms. So she said, oh, shit, I didn't know you were here.
Like, he's acting like, yeah, it just happened.
What the fuck? But maybe that is true if he, like, smoked.
I don't believe that at all. I just like that.
Can you imagine? He was very lucid, according to the girls.
He was very with it. imagine though if like that was the case and then she's driving with this guy and then all of a sudden she's like what the fuck yeah no and he realizes you know what that doesn't happen I don't know how that works.
That would never happen. I don't give a shit what drug you're on.
You don't bust into someone's house... and not remember and if he was on if he was really drugged up and had no idea what was going on he was a very thorough person because he literally like ripped up pieces of cloth he cut up wires to tie them up do you cases over their heads he asked them very lucid questions when he um when he like cut the cloth was it there that he cut the cloth or i'm not sure where he got the cause I wonder if he was like prepared to kidnap someone yeah that's the thing he's such a lying sack of shit that you'll never get exactly what happened out of him um so he's he's like oh shit don't know what to do so he said we drove around they got lost a little that's when his car got stuck on that driveway and dana oh she was in the car well and he said he put he then took polly out of the car brought her into the woods to an embankment told her and he said he brought her there just sat her on the embankment and told her not to move or make a sound and he said she was there the whole time he was with those deputies oh my god he said he went and got her after this They got back in the car.
They drove. He stopped at a gas station for her to use the restroom.
This is when he realized he was going to go back to prison for kidnapping, so he strangled her with a cloth and disposed of her.
Here's the thing, though. That's a giant load of bullshit.
Yeah, she wasn't there when they did that.
That's a giant load of bullshit. This guy is just a bullshitter.
So there's no way that she was sitting there the entire time the deputies were there. there no um and then he got her and drove her around with no one seeing her because that's the other thing no one saw her at any gas stations or him And she's not in any surveillance footage.
And then we're supposed to believe that he drove her somewhere else, murdered her, and disposed of her there.
Right. Like, why? That doesn't make any sense.
No. what likely happened and what they know happened.
And I love that he was like, she had to go to the bathroom.
So I love it. well that's him yeah you didn't he constantly tries to make himself not the humanize himself raging monster that he is yeah So what likely happened is he went to that private road on Dana's property.
He probably didn't know it was a private road. um he brought polly into the woods he assaulted and murdered her in there um he then left her wherever he initially was going to dispose her of her in there because again he didn't know this was private property.
That's why all that shit was found in there.
So he left her there, went back to his car.
It was stuck. So he started freaking the fuck out.
This jives with the fact that he was sweaty, dirty and covered in leaves and sticks and acting like super frantic whenever someone approached him.
He knew that he had just assaulted and murdered a child and disposed of them in the woods and now people are approaching him.
Right. So what actually happened was that he spoke to the deputies with her in the woods wherever he had put her.
After he had killed her. So while he's talking to these deputies, Polly's in the woods dead.
Oh, my God. Like, nearby. When they let him go, I think he did, like he claimed, wait for a little while before going back, retrieving her body, and he brought her somewhere else.
He moved her. Yeah. Of course, it's still absolutely sickening to think that those deputies were talking to him and letting him go while Polly was lying murdered nearby. that's so fucked up of course it would it seems worse if she was like alive in the wood like just either way but that's just not true that's not what happened no And I feel like she would have tried to run.
Exactly. None of it. It doesn't add up. It just none of it makes sense. um all the murder stuff was in the woods right there right he did it there he had already moved her afterwards exactly um and that's why he was so like frantic and freaking out and sweaty and disgusting because he knew what he just did so now he admits to kidnapping and murdering her he's like yep did that But he outright refuses to admit that he sexually assaulted her.
Even though they were like, there's semen on her.
Like, you did it. We know this. But they can't. prove it because she's so badly decomposed they cannot prove a sexual assault happened.
Right. But all of them know it happened. they all it's like one of those things it's like his semen is on her but you can't prove without a reason you know it's It just sucks.
So the reasoning he won't admit, because you're like, why won't he just, he's already a monster.
He kidnapped and killed her. Why wouldn't he just admit to what he did?
Well, cause he's a giant baby. He's just a giant pussy.
And he knows that if he went to prison and they knew that he raped a child, that he would be targeted and dead.
Right. And so he's that big. of just a little bitch that he can't bear the thought of going to prison with them knowing what he did to that child.
But don't you think they do know? Well, now they know. right uh but the and it's like the it's so of course people who kill children are also not looked upon favorably by other prisoners So he tried to claim that he didn't realize that she was a little girl.
What? Because he knows if he goes to prison as a child murder, too, he's like... Either way, he's fucked.
So now he's like, oh, yeah, no, I thought she was like... So...
He kept referring to her as, quote, that broad when he would talk about it.
Are you fucking kidding me? This 12 year old.
You abducted her from a sleepover, dude.
It's like you interrupted a slumber party.
Right. She was like four foot ten. Yeah.
She weighed like 80 pounds. And she looks like a little girl.
And if you see any pictures of her, she's just a beautiful little girl.
Right. And she looks her age. She's like this cute little 12 year old.
Right. He's a lying sack of human bowel excretion.
That's what he is. He went to trial. He was convicted on June 18, 1996, convicted of first-degree murder, burglary, robbery, kidnapping, and committing a lewd act upon a child.
Now, when he was sentenced, he did something so reprehensible that...
I mean... It's fucked. It's just beyond.
There's no words for it. there really aren't so i'm gonna play this clip of what he said during his sentencing because it's just beyond i would also like to state for the record that the main reason I know that I did not attempt any lewd act that night was because of a statement The young girl made to me when walking her up the advance.
Just don't do me like my dad. I have to pay my dues, and so should you.
Thank you. That cry in the back is the saddest thing.
Yeah, that was Mark Klass's mother, so Polly Klass's grandmother, sobbing. in what yeah to what she just heard which was not true at all what happened was mark class said he initially like took a beat after that And then he looked over and saw his mother start sobbing and he was like, I just could not stop myself.
So this motherfucker tried to say that Mark Klass had been raping his child.
And that... Like... And then he puts out there as I walked your child to kill her.
To kill her. She looked at me and said, please don't do me like my father.
Like my dad. So he... The amount of just horror that he just placed on this family.
And who comes up with that in their head?
Like, who? Who? You're already a monster and then you do that?
Like what? And that is all. just to get it off of him.
He knows that there's evidence that she was assaulted and he knows that.
And he knows he's going to prison. And he's a little bitch.
So he's trying to put it. And he doesn't give a shit that he's destroyed this family already.
He's just going to keep destroying them even more.
And it's like, even just saying those things and hearing his stupid fucking face saying it makes me just...
I want to retch when I hear him. When he says that statement, it literally makes me gag.
Like... Because it's just so cruel. And apparently... So, like you can hear in it, my class did, like... just jump up and try to like lunge at him and i totally done the same exact thing and he was held back and escorted out of the out of the room There has never been a time where it is more warranted for violence and for violence to be allowed than this, in my opinion.
Like, this poor man lost his daughter to this fucking monster who walked into her home and stole her out of her fucking bedroom during a sleepover.
Literally. He raped her, he murdered her, and left her tiny little body in the elements alone.
And then he has the fucking audacity to claim that her father is a pedophile.
And that one of her last statements was about that.
No, and it wasn't. And he wasn't. The depths of just... evil that this guy is is beyond you can like smell it it is honestly i swear it's That's why this case, hearing that stuff... You smell the evil.
I had to step away. I was like, I feel like it's like... it envelops it like creeps into you it's like this really makes you oh it just stresses me out Bye.
So Judge Thomas C. Hastings sentenced Richard Allen Davis to death. for the murder, kidnapping, and assault of poly class.
Good. I'm going to play just another really quick clip. another quick clip because what the judge said was what we're all thinking. a traumatic and emotional decision for a judge.
You've made it very easy today by your conduct.
Because I know that the death penalty can be very black and white for a lot of people and I respect that.
I myself, I've said it before. This is not the first time I've said it.
I sit in a very gray area with it. I think there's a lot of gray in it.
Yeah. this case really makes me firmly sit in my gray area because I know, in fact, Mark Klass at one point was like, I know prison for the rest of his life will not be like a picnic for him, but it's not enough.
No, it's not. And he was like, I want him gone.
And in his like statement to him, he even said he was like, the sooner you are taken off of this earth, the better we all will be for it.
It's true. And I believe that. And I mean, not everybody's going to agree with me.
No one needs to yell at me about it. This is my opinion.
You can have your opinion if you're. against the death penalty I totally respect it not only do I respect it I get it yeah I get both sides I can 100% see both sides of this argument Because there's cases where I'm like, yeah, that doesn't, no.
It doesn't fit. Because they can get it wrong.
That's the other thing. Because the thing is, sometimes it fits and sometimes it doesn't.
And they can get it wrong. But in this case, it's like, cool.
And it's like, but this case, it's like, get that fucker off the earth.
Like, this is an evil son of a bitch. Or just let her dad murder him. i know that's like can that be allowed let them do it by dad not lethal just do it And the last little clip I just want to play is Mark Klass's father, Polly's grandfather, what he had to say about what this was. piece of shit said about his son this is epic i love this this guy's awesome he says it in such like a colorful way and you're just like yeah here it is As far as this man is concerned, I wouldn't wipe him off my shoe.
I'd burn the shoes. and flush the ashes down the sewer and I still wouldn't get down to where he is.
My wife became hysterical. Because this...
This man succeeded in what he was trying to do, which was pierce my son through the heart and pierce the rest of the family.
It was just plain despicable, and it shows the kind of people child molesters are.
Like, fuck yeah, grandpa. I know. Literally.
That is exactly how I feel. This is so weird of me to say, but I really love his voice. he does have a great voice he does like he should narrate he should host something yeah he has a wonderful voice it's very soothing yeah and it's just it's exactly like despicable I was like that is the perfect word when he says I wouldn't wipe him off my shoe.
You can feel the emotion. I'm going to start saying that to people.
I'm going to be like, I wouldn't wipe you off my shoe the emotion in that statement you're just like gives you chills because you're just like what he's feeling I can't imagine beyond beyond Because not only did he take his granddaughter away from him in the worst way imaginable, but then he says that about his son.
Yeah. It's like he is just getting like pounded on.
This guy is just making sure. And he said he's like he pierces our family over and over.
Yeah, and he said he succeeded. like he succeeded in doing what he wanted to do and you can tell because in the court video you can see this little fucking smirk on his face like he's happy with what he did And in the courtroom, Richard Allen Davis also would like flip the camera off and like kiss at the camera.
And so he didn't give a shit. He had zero remorse.
I hope he gets, like, fucking bludgeoned to a bloody pulp every day.
Unfortunately, he's still fucking alive.
That's fine I hope he gets beaten up every day He's in San Quentin State Prison He's waiting his execution by lethal injection He still has not met his fate yet.
This case also brought into effect the three strikes law. and it was introduced under the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994
It basically is mandatory life imprisonment if a convicted felon has been convicted of a serious violent felony. and also has two or more previous convictions.
One of those has to be a violent felony.
The other one could be something like a drug offense.
Okay. But it's three strikes, you're out.
Right. So it's like if you have two violent felony on your record...
And you get caught for some drug offense.
You go to prison for a mandatory life sentence.
It's one of those things a lot of people have a lot of feelings about it.
I could see. Yeah, I get it. But I think it was this case kind of like had something to do with it because it was like, this guy has been in prison how many times? for violent things and it's like he should have been in for like forever he was let out way too many times right And it's like he was let out way too quick.
Well, and obviously rehabilitation just is impossible.
It wasn't happening for him. So it's like, come on.
Also, APBs were changed to broadcast to all police channels after this.
The Poly Class Foundation was started by Mark Class.
The Poly Class Foundation, it's in Petaluma, California.
It's a national nonprofit. It's basically for the safety of all children, recovering missing children.
They try to get public policies in place that will help keep children safe in their communities.
They have actually on their website, it says they've helped save more than 9,500 families of missing children.
Wow. They counsel families of missing children, help people different ways to find their kids.
They work with the law enforcement. They help make and distribute posters for missing children.
This is a great foundation. They have an e-volunteer force that will distribute the posters and They'll help search.
They have a hotline that has a 24-7 hotline for these things.
Uh-huh. Basically, he's just trying to help so that like this doesn't happen to anybody else and that he knows what these parents are going through and he wants to help.
What a beautiful, beautiful gesture. He's also the founder and director of the Class Kids Foundation.
It's a foundation. Basically, the mission is to stop crimes against children.
Aw. They have a nationally recognized search and rescue team.
Mm-hmm. uh they help i mean they send out search managers they help uh send out canine units wow They, let's see, they work with the child abduction response teams in local, state, and federal agencies across the country.
They will provide on-site and off-site online monitoring and lead submission to agencies conducting anti-child trafficking operations.
They have a hotel information system database, which provides agencies with a database to match online images with locations.
And all of their services are free of charge.
Oh, OK. This is amazing. Yeah. So my class is like really doing the damn thing. and i guess um eve um polly's mother like is very quiet she wants to to stay away from most of this but she also is on the board of the poly class foundation good um And she the the father of Polly's younger sister, Annie, she was separated with at the time they got back together.
Oh, that's beautiful. So I hope they're living a wonderful life together.
I do too. Mark Klass was also very open recently about his opinions on Governor Newsom halting executions.
Uh-huh. he was fucking pissed. Oh. And he came out and was like, he's working on the side of evil.
Because in San Quentin is also Scott Peterson.
I mean... A lot of horrible fucking monsters.
I mean, I'm sure a lot of people have different... feelings about Scott Peterson because that last documentary came out and everybody all of a sudden doesn't think he did it but Yeah.
I mean, it's one of those situations that I understand why my class is pissed Because he's been waiting a long time to see this fucker die.
And honestly, I would be in his shoes. Almost 25 years.
So he was not happy that it hasn't happened yet.
Because he's also getting up there. It's like he wants to watch this happen.
He wants to see it while he's alive, right?
In fact, he said he would... This is probably not funny to most people, but it's funny to me.
He said he would bring champagne to the execution.
Oh, yeah. Same. I would do the exact same thing if you fucking murdered and raped my child.
And especially if you are a parent. You get it.
Listening. You get it. Yeah. Come on. Don't tell me you don't get it.
I would absolutely do that. If someone did anything to my children, I 100% would toast watching them die.
That's without a doubt. So again, this is a case that really definitely brings up the gray area with... uh you know death penalty you know where you stand on that but again we respect If you stand on against, if you stand on for, or if you're with us in the gray, we get it.
I see all the sides for sure. I don't think we can ever just make a final.
No. Nobody will all agree on what we should do with that.
But so that is the horrific story of poly class.
That was a rough one. The only good thing about it is that some good has come out of it.
Yeah, that's true. And her father has for sure made sure that her name is attached to as many good names. things as possible i love that so yeah all right Well, if you need a break and you're on Instagram right now because you're like, oh, I need to look at some makeup tutorials, just pause for a second and follow us on instagram at morbid podcast hit us up on twitter a morbid podcast send us a gmail preferably a nice one Morbid podcast at gmail.com.
Hit up the Facebook group. It's awesome in there.
Morbid podcast. i don't know facebook.com morbid podcast is that what it is yes i don't know it's great find it Go on Facebook.
Look up Morbid A True Crime Podcast. The group comes up.
Yeah. It's awesome. And then maybe donate to the Patreon because a lot of exciting fucking things are happening with that. yeah patreon.com slash morbid podcast we hope you keep listening and we hope you keep it weird but not so weird that you're a fucking asshole lunatic even though you did have a bad childhood it doesn't give you any excuse to be a fucking mean mean mean mean dude and fucking hurt people and don't flip off the camera and make kissy faces and accuse people's dads of bad things that they didn't do because they didn't do that and you're a monster and then you're gonna really get fucked up in prison and it's it's okay i hope you do Yeah.
Bye. Thank you. If you like Morbid, you can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wondery.com slash survey.
