Dogs are an important part of our lives.
That means protecting them from parasites.
Ask your vet about NexGuard Plus, a foxilonor, moxidectin, and pyrantil-chewable tablets.
NexGuard Plus choose provide one in-done monthly protection against fleas, ticks, heartworm disease, roundworms, and hookworms.
Plus, they're delicious and easy to give.
Use with caution in dogs with a history of seizures or neurologic disorders.
Dogs should be tested for existing heartworm infection prior to starting a preventive.
Ask about NexGuard Plus choose.
Take your business further with a smart and flexible American Express Business Gold card.
It offers flexible spending capacity that adapts to your business.
You can also earn up to $395 in annual statement credits on eligible purchases at select business merchants.
That's the powerful backing of American Express.
To learn more at americanexpress.com slash business gold card.
Dang! Grandpa was hip! I'm Angela Duckworth.
I'm Mike Mon. And you're listening to no stupid questions.
Today on the show, what does it mean to be cool?
I've never really cared about trying to be cool, but maybe that's just because I felt like it was a hopeless battle for me.
Mike, we have the best email ever from anonymous.
Well, that is a very high bar.
Dr. Duckworth. It's a cool email.
I'm going to read it to you.
Hi, Mike and Angela. Lately, I've been thinking about what it means to be, quote, unquote, cool.
Oh, okay. I get it. Right?
People who have historically been labeled as cool often seem to be caustic, edgy, and anti-authoritarian.
Punk rockers and James Dean in rebel without a cause immediately come to mind for me.
Things that are considered cool are often exclusive and elusive.
Fancy nightclubs, VIP rooms, designer clothing.
Why are these idolized instead of traits like earnestness and things that are more accessible?
For example, in this part, I'm not sure I agree with anonymous.
Why is Rihanna cool and Taylor Swift isn't?
Oh, what? Those are fighting words.
No wonder they typed in anonymous.
This Swifties would have rallied.
Exactly. But this one, I kind of have to agree with why is Gucci cool, but Walmart isn't, and why do I care?
Thanks, anonymous. Okay, let me just say first and foremost, my mother once picked one word to describe me, and it was earnest.
What's the name of this?
Which anonymous just said is definitely not cool.
Okay, Mike, if there were one word to describe my husband, Jason, it would be earnest.
So you're in good company.
But also, Jason, apparently, we are not cool.
Look, when we got this email, I immediately texted my daughters because I was thinking, well, actually, the first thing I did as I talked to my earnest husband, so Jason and I had this very brief conversation about what's cool.
And he was like, I don't know, but it's definitely not what old people do.
It's more like what young people do.
I know. I was going to say respectfully.
I don't know that that's the group to talk about what's cool.
It's like 150 something year old.
So it's the other 50. It's like a New Yorker cartoon.
Right. I know. But okay, then I decided to text Amanda Lucy and they are 22 and 21.
So they are within striking distance of cool, if not possibly in the epicenter of cool.
And so Amanda, text back, sambas are in.
I think those are those Adidas sneakers.
Oh, people are really into Stanley cups right now.
Do you know what those are?
I have seven of them, I think, including one right.
Oh, look, there you go. You have a Stanley cup.
A really big Stanley cup.
Oh, no, all Stanley cups are really big.
That's part of what's funny about it.
Is there? Is that right?
Yeah, everyone's like, why do you need this massive thing of water?
But look, people can argue all they want.
I have a friend. Her name is Lori.
And she was kind of railing against Stanley cups.
And I said, Lori, I don't really care.
I'm not trying to be trendy.
I drink more water and I am more healthy because of this cup.
Wait, what's different about this particular bottle?
It has a handle. It's very large, but it has a smaller base that can fit into your cup holder in your car.
It has a large straw that makes it very easy to get the water.
I love straws. Maybe this all seems dumb, but I will say this.
I bought Lori a Stanley.
Yeah. And Lori went from a hater to an evangelizer.
So they are trendy, but I'm going to go ahead and say they're trendy for a reason.
I will also say I gave my sister a Stanley mug for Christmas.
And her daughters were about the ages of your daughters literally said this when my sister opened to, oh, good, mom, you can finally be cool.
No, what? Yes. Okay. Well, I want to read you the rest of Amanda's text.
Lucy Chimes in. Super depends on the person for girls of our age and educational demographic.
Slicked back buns, bows on shoes, hair, etc.
Red ballet slippers. Amanda Chimes in.
Guys wear their hair off fluffy in the front now.
And I just text back that I have no idea what they're talking about.
Okay. The stomach of cool, maybe inappropriate for uncool, earnest old people like ourselves.
But I think this anonymous question is a great one.
Here's where I want to go.
Well, we're on the topic of your daughters and what they think is cool.
I have a UGov survey here.
Surveyed almost 35,000 US adults in March of 2024.
So this is recent data. Really recent.
Mm-hmm. They asked the question, do you think you're cool?
Oh, wow. I love this question.
What percentage of adults in the US believe themselves to be, quote, unquote, cool?
Okay. I think more people think they're cool than think they're uncool.
At least 50 percent. Maybe I'll say 80 percent.
And the second thing I'm going to rush to say is that I think it probably varies by age.
And I think older people may think they may have a little bit of a realization that they are ripening and not ripening toward cool, ripening toward earnest, maybe.
Before I tell you the answer, if you were asked this question, do you think you are cool?
What's your response? Do I think I'm cool?
You know, I don't think I'm cool.
I would also have said no.
53 percent of adults in this survey said, yes, I think I am cool.
29 percent said no. And 17 percent said, I'm not sure.
Oh, that's interesting.
So only one out of three people said, oh, not me.
I am not cool. Interestingly, 61 percent of Democrats said, yes, I'm cool.
54 percent of Republicans said, yes, I'm cool.
And 47 percent of independence said, yes, I'm cool.
And your guess about age is correct.
75 percent of people between 18 and 29 said, yes, I'm cool.
It's not like old people are cool.
Because the word cool doesn't just mean good, right?
It's not like everything good is cool.
Only some things that are good are cool.
And I don't think it's old things.
So the word cool and what it refers to has shifted dramatically over time.
Like the use of the word?
Yeah. So back in the 1930s, and this comes from David Skinner, who's editor of the National Endowment for the Humanities magazine called appropriately humanities.
But he wrote about how starting in the 1930s, cool started appearing in American English as this casual expression that mostly meant intensely good.
Oh, really? In the 50s and 60s, that's when it grew into this more multipurpose slang word and grew much more prevalent.
And different meanings of cool over time have been self-possessed, disengaged, quietly distainful, morally good, intellectually assured, aesthetically rewarding, physically attractive, fashionable, and on and on.
So it has all these different things, but it is kind of the one word that's really stuck around to mean something generally positive.
Don't we use the word hot to mean the same thing as cool?
I just find that really interesting.
Also often also refers to a person's level of attractiveness, but you can also say that thing is hot, meaning it's getting a lot of attention or it's really popular.
But I will say this, speaking of cool, my family was recently together, this is I guess a couple years ago, and I'm standing there talking to my younger sister, Allison, and in walks my niece, who's amazing, awesome.
I think she's just entering high school at the time.
And she is wearing these huge baggy pants.
And I said something because I thought they looked a little ridiculous.
And my sister, Allison, looks at me and says, Mike, if you want to sound old and not have a great relationship with your nieces and nephews, then say stuff like that.
Otherwise, just be like, hey, you look great.
Also, don't comment on what people are wearing.
I have been schooled in this and don't say anything.
Don't say you look great.
Don't say you don't look great.
Just hey, I just had never seen any pants like that.
I am with you. Okay, in this safe space that we have created for ourselves to have conversations, Mike, that I'm sure, Lucy and Amanda will never hear.
I remember for several years, it was like, are you deliberately trying to look bad?
Like, why would you wear pants like that?
Or there was this, and maybe it's still true, this like half-shirt craze, like it's winter.
But I'm going to bear my mid-drift in a ridiculous looking half-shirt with my pants that look like they're too big on me.
Like, I couldn't understand any of this.
And for me, it wasn't just that I felt like, why not do this other practical thing?
To me, it was kind of like unattractive.
It was aesthetically unappealing.
But I now realize that in addition to the function of a product, like these are pants, they're meant to, you know, keep me warm or something, right?
Like, there's also, I think, signaling.
And I think a lot of coolness is signaling that you are part of a certain social tribe and not another.
Like, okay, what is this stuff that Amanda and Lucy are talking about?
Like ballet flats and I'm slicking your hair back, you know, it's signaling.
Well, here's what's really amazing.
I looked at some old pictures of my grandfather who was wearing this pair of thick black glasses.
The ones that are like on nerds in movies.
Yes, but my grandfather looked great.
He was in a crisp suit, but with these glasses.
And I thought, I remember when I was in high school looking through the pictures.
And I was like, gosh, why would you ever wear glasses that look that dumb?
Fast forward, I don't know, 15 years.
I'm flipping through the same photo book.
And those glasses are in style.
I look at the same picture.
And I was like, dang, grandpa was hip.
And then I realized how dumb I was.
And I was like, man, all of these quote unquote cool things just go through cycles.
I read one thing from this journalist, Mark Bain, who wrote an article called what cool means now in courts.
This really struck me. And I'm not always trying to bag on social media.
But he said one of the most interesting things about cool and social media is that what it's really done is sped up the cycles, where things become cool quicker.
But they also lose their coolness quicker.
Oh, interesting. Because it can catch on and then fade much more quickly than it did in the past.
And so crocs, you know, crocs.
I know, crocs. I have crocs.
Wait, wait, before you tell me they're uncool, I have so many pairs of crocs.
Are they not cool anymore?
No, they are cool. Oh, they are.
Oh, good. But like they were.
And then they weren't. And now they are again.
Oh, I was just wearing them for years.
So I probably missed the uncool period during which I was also wearing them.
You just more than for I've never owned a pair of crocs.
All I know is that I have these two nephews who are like 18, 19.
The one has the hair exactly like you've described with Ralph Puffy in front.
He's very quote unquote cool.
And they both wear white crocs all the time everywhere they go.
And I will admit that while I do not consider myself cool and therefore I'm in the minority of adults in the US.
And I've never really cared about trying to be cool.
But maybe that's just because I felt like it was a hopeless battle for me.
Like I'm not playing that game.
But I will say that as I've gotten older, I do recognize much more than I did when I was young.
The signaling. It's also association.
Do I want to be associated with this individual?
Do I want to be associated with this brand?
Look at how brand sell Nike under armor, etc.
They all try to attach their brand to these really cool figures in sports.
Michael Jordan who's on Nike.
And then of course, there's the entire Jordan brand.
There's Steph Curry in the basketball world who's in under armor.
And there's this collegiality among under armor athletes.
And I'm in the under armor family or I'm in the Nike family.
And people get paid a ton of money to be associated with brands.
Right. I remember my nephew Drew who's, I don't know, probably 12 years old now.
He at maybe six years old was so in love with certain under armor athletes that he was only wearing under armor.
What? And it started that early because of the cool factor at six.
It's like really early like well before puberty is so interesting.
But that's I think the power of quote, cool, right?
And an association with those brands.
You know, one of my very closest collaborators is Colin Cameron, who is one of the founders of neuro economics.
He's at Caltech. We've talked about Colin Cameron's research before.
And he has a colleague there named Stephen Quartz, who's actually a philosopher by training.
And there was somebody who was, I think working in professor Quartz's lab named Annette Aspen.
Anyway, two of them got together and wrote this book.
And it is on neuro economics, but it's actually called cool.
How the brains hidden quest for cool drives our economy and shapes our world.
And what Quartz's research and other neuroscientist research show is that we have a basic human need for status and to be respected.
The identification of this part of the brain from Quartz's lab and others is the medial prefrontal cortex.
In Quartz's words, like this is where social identity lies.
And he has this phrase like a social calculator.
But basically the idea is that we are tracking how other people think about us.
And it's like a number that can go up or down.
And it can change based on who you're with.
But we have a fundamental need to be higher, not lower in status.
I think this is why social media is so powerful.
And I know it's hotly debated.
But it's so powerful. And therefore, as any powerful influence might be potentially very dangerous.
And I think it all goes back to, yeah, our brains are wired to care about signaling, you know, where we fit in in the society.
And ideally, the niche that we occupy is a high status, not low status niche.
So coolness is kind of fundamental to the way we make sense of the world and ourselves.
Right. Well, Mike, I would love to hear the thoughts of NSQ listeners on what it means to be cool.
What does the concept mean to you?
And how important you think it is in everyday life to be cool.
Record a voice memo in a quiet place with your mouth close to the phone and email us at NSQ at Freakonomics.com.
Maybe we'll play it on a future episode of the show.
And if you like the show and want to support us, the very best thing you can do is to tell a friend.
You can also spread the word on social media or leave a review in your favorite podcast app.
Still to come on No Stupid Questions.
What's different about being cool in 2024?
Oh, no, I cut this wood at my house and then I figured out via YouTube how to build this amazing table.
And this is where my family eats now.
No stupid questions is sponsored by NetSuite.
To reduce costs and headaches, smart businesses are graduating to NetSuite by Oracle.
NetSuite is the number one cloud financial system bringing and counting, financial management, inventory, and HR into one platform and one source of truth.
With NetSuite, you reduce IT costs because NetSuite lives in the cloud with no hardware required access from anywhere.
You cut the costs of maintaining multiple systems because you've got one unified business management suite.
And you're improving efficiency by bringing all your major business processes into one platform, slashing manual tasks and errors.
Over 37,000 companies have already made the move.
So do the math, see how you'll profit with NetSuite.
Back by popular demand, NetSuite has extended its one of a kind flexible financing program for a few more weeks.
Head to NetSuite.com slash questions.
That's NetSuite.com slash questions.
No stupid questions is sponsored by Rosetta Stone.
Traveling is so much more meaningful when you understand the language of the place you're visiting.
Rosetta Stone, one of the most trusted language learning programs, has helped millions learn new languages and can help you too.
With Rosetta Stone, you'll learn intuitively.
Your train to listen, speak, read, write, and think in your chosen language.
You'll be prepared for real, authentic conversations.
Plus, their true accent feature gives you feedback on your pronunciation.
And with the Rosetta Stone app, you can learn anytime, anywhere with customizable lessons as short as 10 minutes.
For a very limited time, our listeners can get Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off.
That's 50% off unlimited access to 25 language courses for the rest of your life.
Redeem your 50% off at RosettaStone.com slash questions.
That's RosettaStone.com slash questions.
No stupid questions is sponsored by BetterHelp.
Time flies. We blinked and 2024 is halfway over.
What's something you've accomplished this year that you're proud of?
Maybe you made it out of bed and to work every day?
Or maybe you started shedding some old habits that were weighing you down?
Even when you're making progress, life can feel like it's moving too fast.
We can't slow time down, but we can give you a moment every week to hit pause, set intentions, and reset in therapy.
BetterHelp offers affordable online therapy on a schedule that works for you.
Start the signup process in minutes and switch therapists anytime.
Take a moment with BetterHelp.
Visit BetterHelp.com slash NSQ today to get 10% off your first month.
That's BetterHelpHELP.com slash NSQ.
Now back to Mike and Angela's conversation about what it means to be cool.
What's fascinating about this idea of cool is there are some who want to of course follow the trend or set the trend and be associated with the trend.
But there are also people who as soon as something becomes popular, so maybe I'll just think it was popular and cool.
As soon as it becomes popular, it's no longer cool to like it because you want to be this countercultural person.
I've read a book recently where this guy was talking about how much he loved this new musician, but it's because he was one of the first to find them and to really follow them.
Then as soon as everybody else found this new artist, he was like, yeah, don't like him anymore.
I think you're right. It's not just popular.
Maybe this is why Taylor Swift, I don't know who this anonymous person is who's trying to protect themselves, but like I think Taylor Swift is cool.
Then maybe Taylor Swift is so popular now that she can't be cool.
There is this paper in the American Journal of Marketing on Brand Coolness that was published in 2019.
One of the things that these two marketing people who wrote the article claim is that you can't really be cool in the same way when you go mess.
When everybody else is listening to that music, you can't be cool in that niche way that you were when you got started with some small in-group of people who are early adopters and kind of discovered you, but you can become iconic.
Wait, so it's movement from being cool to iconic?
That's the growth trajectory of it.
They say there's this cycle that goes from niche cool brands, which are, they have this checklist, like rebellious, original, authentic, subcultural, extraordinary, aesthetically appealing, energetic, high status.
That's the niche cool brand checklist.
Then as it spreads to the masses, more people are buying that album or whatever.
Then you can become a mass cool brand and they have a shorter checklist.
They say that mass cool brands are energetic.
They are high status. They're popular.
They're iconic. Then the last one is and still moderately extraordinary, moderately aesthetically appealing, moderately original, moderately authentic, moderately rebellious, and moderately subcultural.
Because you can't be that rebellious at that scale.
I guess so. I guess you've become corporate.
You probably have a chief human resources officer.
You're trying to sell to everyone, not just 1% of the population.
If this chart had a personification, it would be a teenager becomes middle age.
You have higher status maybe than you did before, but you're getting gray.
It's interesting because as I think about what you're describing, one of the cool things, at least in the world I operate, is a Jordan shoe.
I think the famous one is red, white, and black.
There's a very famous Jordan shoe that was red that was breaking the initial rules of the NBA because you couldn't, I can't remember the details, but you couldn't wear that color or pattern or something.
It would have to be more milk toast.
It was this cool iconoclastic rebellious thing.
Maybe go from iconoclastic to just iconic.
That's the progression.
That's what I think is so interesting about a shoes right now.
As they're in this, at least it feels like renaissance where they are the most iconic thing.
They are cool even though they're rather ubiquitous, but they're at different levels of Jordan shoes.
Then they have all these drops.
Part of cool is limited edition quantities.
We're only going to drop X,000 pairs of this shoe.
You have to line up and try to get online on the exact moment and then you either got it or you didn't.
If you didn't, you have to buy it for triple or quadruple or whatever the price on the resale market.
Part of it is creating a level of exclusivity to being able to purchase this thing.
That's where some of the cool factor comes in.
Here's a cool story. You were just talking about underarmour.
I think one of their athletes is Lindsay Vaughan who, as we both know, is a Olympic skier par excellence and kind of an icon in the skiing world.
Lindsay has a foundation for helping girls develop confidence and dare I say grit.
I'm on the advisory board and she has an auction every year that's basically her swag from being an Olympic skier.
She's just like an unlimited number, apparently, of really cool jackets and other stuff that I don't know about because I'm not a skier.
One year, I bought a jacket for Lucy who was, I guess she was 19 or something at the time.
By the way, when I got it for Lucy, it wasn't a surprise.
I know I'm not cool. I was like, Lucy, which of these jackets do you want to buy because it goes to charity and also you need a jacket?
She picks this brown jacket that I would just say I would not have picked.
It's really big. It looks too big.
It doesn't even look like a ski jacket.
It's got all of these decals from all the sponsors.
She gets this jacket and I kid you not.
Anytime I am with Lucy while we are walking around and she is wearing that jacket, we get stopped three or four times per hour with young people always saying something that I can't even like, they don't even say cool jacket.
That would probably be an uncool thing to say.
They probably say something like nice drip.
Yes, they say something that I would have to go home and Google.
Which I'm sure I just used the incredible stuff.
I'm sure we just had a moment of uncoolness there.
But it's marvelous to me in the sense that like, wow, clearly these young people are sending and receiving signals to each other.
I think that is part of coolness.
That there is this secret language that some people don't speak.
That's what makes it cool.
I do think it's interesting because as we're talking about this, she's wearing this amazing Lindsey Von jacket that other quote, cool people recognize and they're having this communication.
But I also think there are segments of cool where maybe within like the engineering community, you are the iconic person that is really cool.
But also within communities, you can signal in a very different way.
And part of their thing might be, I don't care what you all think is cool.
In my world, this is cool.
Right. And so there are subsets of languages.
You can be cool within your niche.
Like maybe you don't even want to be cool in somebody else's niche.
Right. I mean, you and I spoke recently and we were talking about authors.
We loved you had mentioned that you met Judy Bloom and you held hands briefly.
And that was this really cool moment for you.
It was so cool. There are a lot of people who are like, who's Judy Bloom.
Oh, yeah. But they're cool is, Hey, Angela Duckworth, guess who I just met.
And your response is, I don't know who that is either.
And so I think it's important to recognize that there is signaling within groups.
We also have to recognize that there are a lot of different groups.
And it's okay to not have to signal to groups that you're not part of or don't need to be part of or don't care to be part of right.
I would love if you're willing to get your take on this article I read that talks about these four traits of cool.
Oh, wait, what is it by scientists?
It's by a Darden graduate named Johnny Miles who got insights from this professor of marketing named Leline Annick and a Yale management PhD candidate Ryan Hauser.
So academically informed.
Okay. Got it. So they go through these four traits, autonomy, authenticity, attitude, and association.
Now we've already hit on sort of association.
I believe firmly in that one, of course.
Under armor has Steph Curry.
It has Lindsey Vaughan, et cetera.
Nike has Michael Jordan.
So you associate cool with that.
When they talk about autonomy, they talk about this lack of conformity, unconventionality, rebellion, individuality, and independence.
And that it goes away as soon as you become, quote, a mainstream sellout.
Oh, sellout is a good answer for cool.
Yeah. And mainstream is sort of this diss.
It's like, ah, you went mainstream.
You're no longer cool because you just you're corporate.
I think it's the word to you earlier with such a diss.
Ah, you're corporate now.
Wait, so that's autonomy.
And what was the second A?
Authenticity to quote them as highly sophisticated social beings.
We're adept at reading subtle clues to determine whether someone is quote, being themselves or trying to pass as something they are not.
Okay. So for example, if a company or corporation tries to be cool and everyone's like, okay, guys, your IBM, like, let's not.
Right. It just doesn't come across as authentic.
This is why whenever I say hashtag anything, my kids like roll their eyes because that's me trying to do something.
But for them, it's like really authentic.
By the way, we've done behavioral science studies where we have sent text messages to literally hundreds of thousands of people across the United States trying to, for example, encourage them to get their flu vaccine or, you know, boosted for COVID.
And sometimes these not so super cool scientists myself included, we write these text messages that are so, so, so cool or funny.
And wow, do they land like lead balloons?
So what we've recently been recommending to companies is like, don't try to be what you're not.
If you're a pharmacy chain and your brand appropriately enough is not cool.
I don't even know that anybody needs to go to a cool pharmacy.
Right. You probably want to go to an earnest pharmacy before a cool one.
Then write a text message in that voice.
But the authenticity thing is very interesting.
I want to come back to autonomy.
But tell me what attitude is.
So attitude, I think is really interesting.
And and they talk about it and use this phrase, casual effortlessness.
And if you think about it, if you're trying to be cool, that's not cool.
Oh, interesting. So it's kind of a swagger.
Like I didn't spend seven hours trying to get ready.
I spent seven minutes, but like, I look amazing.
Exactly. There was this trend for a long time that you wanted to look like you kind of just rolled out of bed and are here.
But ironically, it took two hours to look like you rolled out of bed.
So it's this idea. The minute you try to show your cool, you're not.
So you've got to portray this attitude of casual effortlessness.
I think that's so interesting.
I mean, if you put it all together and I want to go back to autonomy, because now we talked about association, we talked about authenticity and then just attitude.
The human need for autonomy has been long recognized as one of the basic human needs.
And it's so profound that as soon as you tell someone what to do, they don't want to do it.
Jason and I were remembering different parts of the chapters in our relationship, times that one of us was trying to get the other one to do something.
And it was just like the moment we let go.
Like the moment we were like, you know what, you got to make up your own mind.
I can't make up your mind for you.
You do what you want. That's the moment where it's like, well, actually, I can kind of see your point of view.
And this need for human autonomy is as ingrained as our need for status.
And I think there is this element.
Like if you do think about, you know, James Dean and you think about subcultures and just like the rebelliousness that seems part and parcel of being cool.
You lost me at James Dean, but carry on.
Wait, you don't know who James Dean was.
I mean, I've heard the name.
I'm so sorry. Wait, what?
All right, by the way, I was not like alive while everybody was watching Rebel without a cause for the first time.
I'm not that old. But haven't you seen like posters of James Dean?
He usually has this collar up.
Oh, yes. Of course. I just Google them.
I just Google them. Oh gosh.
I totally know who I mean, I recognize him and I get what you're saying.
Sorry, I did not know. I'm really okay.
Well, there is always this autonomous like because that's what rebelliousness is.
It's just like autonomy to the extreme.
So I think you're right.
I think that's a great list.
You know, you can see the through lines here, right?
Also, I did go ask chat GPT.
What is cool now? Just because I was curious to see.
Oh my gosh. So super want to know what chat GPT says is cool.
And I'll just say from the business side of things, I think this resonates so well.
And it's interesting because chat GPT didn't bring up brands or clothing or TV shows or anything else.
It said that things that are considered quote cool in various contexts, sustainability.
Because there's this increased awareness of environmental issues.
I think that's much more in the forefront of this Gen Z, their mindset, retro styles.
I mean, we've seen that with the jazz.
We've done a bunch of retro jerseys.
And I think they've done that across the NBA.
But those are very popular.
People love to go back to that moment in time.
Yeah. Interesting. Wellness and mindfulness.
That's become such a buzz word almost.
Social activism. I mean, back in the day, there's a very famous quote from Michael Jordan who we've talked about.
And people said, why aren't you more socially active or talking about a stand in his famous quote is Republicans by sneakers too.
Huh. Interesting. Whereas I think today, it's very expected that celebrities take a stand.
I mean, you know, if you have a Twitter account, then you're expected to say something.
And then another one is DIY culture is now cool.
DIY culture like watching on YouTube videos of like how to play the guitar and then playing the guitar.
Like I want to make my own table.
Oh, right. Instead of like going to IKEA.
Yeah, but like it's so much cooler to be like, oh, no, I cut this wood at my house.
And then I figured out via YouTube how to build this amazing table.
And this is where my family eats now.
Yeah. So I just thought it was really interesting to see again, not like I'm saying Cheshire PT is an oracle.
But I see that reflected a lot in the organizations that I work with.
And in society at large that some of the cool things aren't necessarily what you wear.
But it's your attitude.
And it's what you care about.
So I've quoted this to you before I think because I say to myself, oh my gosh, all the time.
But when my French teacher in high school, Dr.
Rowland said in French, beautifully, which I will not try to recreate like all of history is action and reaction.
You know, this kind of pendulum swing from, you know, one thing is cool.
Now it's not. Now it is. But I think there's something deep behind that, which is when you read me this list, like what's cool sustainability is cool.
Social activism, like I wonder whether the reaction.
So the reason why that's cool now is that there's this sense that we're in a purpose deficit.
And I was speaking recently to the US Surgeon General, Vivek Marthy, who is definitely earnest.
I don't know how cool he is, but we've talked about it on those questions about his concern that there's a loneliness epidemic in the United States and globally.
But what we were talking about recently was purpose.
And he asked me about the psychology of purpose.
And we talked about this category that includes being concerned about the climate, being concerned about social change.
And what I think this is a reaction to this idea that it's cool now is maybe that we have felt like we're not doing those things, right?
Because I know that when I was growing up, what was cool was conspicuous consumption.
Everybody was wearing designer jeans for the first time.
And I literally had a neighbor who named his dog Mercedes so that he could call its name every morning.
And that was kind of cool, then I guess.
I don't know if that was ever cool.
But I'm going to go ahead with a strong no.
It's so cute. Like hard to know on that.
But you know, if purpose is cool, all I can say is that I hope it stays cool.
And maybe if you can't stay cool, maybe purpose could be iconic.
Because to me, the need to be part of something larger than yourself and to be in service to something larger than yourself, that's how scientists define purpose.
I hope that's not niche.
I hope it's here to stay because it's something that I don't want to go out of fashion.
And now here's a fact check of today's conversation.
Angela's daughter Amanda noted that the Adidas Samba trainer is quote unquote in.
However, the shoes were recently declared out across social media and a multitude of popular media outlets after UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak was pictured wearing a pair of white sambas during a downing street video in which he was promoting his tax policies.
British GQ senior style editor Marie Clark wrote quote, Sunak took an eternally cool sneaker and ruined it for everyone.
The observer published a headline that read Adidas Samba's where this year's coolest shoes until Rishi Sunak got a pair.
The Prime Minister has since issued an apology.
Later, Angela references a paper from a publication which she refers to as the American Journal of Marketing.
It's actually simply the Journal of Marketing, published by the American Marketing Association.
Also, Mike says he can't remember the details of why the original Jordan shoe was banned for violating NBA rules.
In 1984, Nike produced the first Air Jordan sneaker for then 21-year-old Michael Jordan, who was in his rookie year with the Chicago Bulls.
Jordan reportedly first wore the shoes on the court during a preseason game against the New York Knicks.
The sneakers were primarily black and red and therefore violated the NBA's 51% rule that required players footwear to be mostly white.
Sneaker folklore and the 2023 movie Air suggests that Jordan was fined by the NBA for wearing the shoes and that Nike paid those fines on his behalf as a promotional maneuver.
In fact, there's no evidence that Jordan ever wore red and black sneakers during a regular season game.
Finally, Mike is convinced that he used the term drip incorrectly.
It was actually spot on.
Drip or drip in is slang for stylish clothing and accessories.
That's it for the fact check.
Before we wrap today's show, let's hear some thoughts about last week's episode online to children.
Hi, this is Melissa from Virginia.
When I was a kid, my dad was in the military and so he would be gone for six to nine months at a time, often missing birthdays and holidays.
One year when I was probably seven or eight years old, I got this doll from my dad that I adored and it remained my very favorite Christmas present for my entire life.
And one time I was telling the story to a bunch of people with my mom around and I was telling them about how great it was that my dad got me this doll even though he was on an aircraft carrier and it was so special because he was so far away.
Well, my mom started laughing and that's when she finally told me at the age of 25 that she's the one that bought it for me at the store and that there were no gift shops on aircraft carriers.
So sometimes a lie might be okay.
It was really fun to believe that for a while.
Hi, Angela and Mike. One example from this week's episode that I particularly relayed to was the one with a parent threatening to arrest their child.
Never me and my brother fought and mom would either threaten to call the police on herself to take her away from us or threaten to split me in my brother apart, taking one of us and leaving the country.
Me and my brother fully believed her not thinking that she was lying at all and we realized later that it's maybe why we tend to feel overly guilty when conflict arises.
Hi, Mike and Angela. This is Lexi from Boston.
In one of our childhood homes, my very observant seven-year-old sister noticed that the paint drips on one of our door frames were going up instead of down.
When she asked my dad why this might be, he told her that the door frame must have been painted on anti-gravity day, an event in which gravity stops working on Earth for one day.
He explained that this happens every leap year and that we were two young to remember it happening in the past.
So as diligent little planners, we anticipated it happening in four years and developed strategic plans about how to bungee down our cars and swing set and make sure that the cats and dogs all stayed inside that day.
When leave your finally dead roll around, we asked our dad if he knew the exact date on which we might expect anti-gravity day to fall.
Twitch here responded, wait, you still believe in that?
That was respectively Melissa Gillum, Crystal Chu, and Lexi Cole.
Thanks to them and to everyone who shared their stories with us.
And remember, we'd love to hear your thoughts on what it means to be cool.
Send a voice memo to NSQ at Freakonomics.com and you might hear your voice on the show.
Coming up next week on Most Stupid Questions, what makes a good gathering?
I don't want to have dinner with you for a long time.
My butt hurts. That's next week on Most Stupid Questions.
Most Stupid Questions is part of the Freakonomics Radio Network, which also includes Freakonomics Radio, People I Mostly Admire, and the Economics of Everyday Things.
All our shows are produced by Stitcher and RunBud Radio.
The senior producer of the show is me, Rebecca Lee Douglas, and Lear Baudich is our production associate.
This episode was mixed by Greg Griffin.
We had research assistants from Daniel Moritz-Rapson.
Our theme song was composed by Luis Gara.
You can follow us on Twitter, at NSQ, underscore show, and on Facebook at NSQ show.
If you have a question for a future episode, please email it to NSQ at Freakonomics.com.
To learn more or to read episode transcripts, visit Freakonomics.com slash NSQ.
Thanks for listening. Well, your grandmother told you you were earnest.
You know right there. You're not cool.
My mother. Oh, your mother told you were earnest.
You're definitely not cool.
The Freakonomics Radio Network, the hidden side of everything.
Stitcher Dogs are an important part of our lives.
That means protecting them from parasites.
Ask your vet about Nixgar Plus, a foxilonner, moxidectin, and pyrantil-chewable tablets.
Nixgar Plus choose provide one in done monthly protection against fleas, ticks, heartworm disease, roundworms, and hookworms.
Plus, they're delicious and easy to give.
Use with caution and dogs with a history of seizures or neurologic disorders.
Dogs should be tested for existing heartworm infection prior to starting a preventive.
Ask about Nixgar Plus choose.
I won't let my moderate-to-severe plaque psoriasis symptoms define me.
Emerge as you. In two clinical studies, Trimphaya-gu-sau-kumab, taken by injection, provided 90% clear skin at 16 weeks in 7 out of 10 adults with moderate-to-severe plaque psoriasis.
In a study, nearly 7 out of 10 patients with 90% clear skin at 16 weeks were still clear at 5 years.
At one year and thereafter, patients and healthcare providers knew that Trimphaya was being used.
This may have increased results.
Results may vary. Serious allergic reactions may occur.
Trimphaya may increase your risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them.
Before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis.
Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms of infection including fever, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or cough.
Tell your doctor if he had a vaccine or plan to.
Emerge as you. Learn more about Trimphaya, including important safety information at trimphaya.com or call 1-877-578-3527.
See our ad in Food and Wine Magazine.
For patients prescribed Trimphaya, cost support may be available.
Experience the joy of running in the new Triumph 22 from Sockony, the original running brand.
Stacked with luxury foam cushioning, Triumph 22 turns miles into smiles.
With the ultimate blend of comfort and energy return, shop Triumph 22 at Sockony.com.
That's S-A-U-C-O-N-Y.com.
