Don't just ride the index, seek to outperform it.
With Fidelity Active ETFs, learn more at fidelity.com slash active ETFs.
Before investing in any exchange traded fund, you should consider its investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses.
Contact Fidelity for a prospectus, an offering circular, or a available summary prospectus containing this information, read it carefully.
While active ETFs offer the potential to outperform an index, these products may more significantly trail an index as compared with past ETFs.
Fidelity brokerage services LLC member NYSE SIPC.
Take your business further with a smart and flexible American Express Business Gold Card.
It offers flexible spending capacity that adapts to your business.
You can also earn up to $395 in annual statement credits on eligible purchases at select business merchants.
That's the powerful backing of American Express.
This is your turn to learn more at AmericanExpress.com slash business gold card.
You want to know what we do in my family with action movies?
You watch them? I'm Antelid Duckworth.
I'm Mike Mon. And you're listening to no stupid questions.
Today on the show, what's the relationship between creativity and happiness?
I wonder what this crayon would taste like.
I'll put it in my mouth. Mike, we have an email from one Patrick Dillon from Michigan.
He signed his email Michigan comma USA.
Okay, I wonder where in the Michigan 5, you know how the people use the hand to say where they're from in Michigan?
They do. They always use the hand.
I think that's so helpful of only my state where shapes like a hand.
I know no other state has the ability to do that.
Patrick does not want to tell us where in Michigan he resides, but he does want to ask us this question.
Hi, Angela and Mike. My question is about the opportunity to express creativity and the associated level of happiness in life.
He says, my background is in engineering and I work in my current career as a practicing physician.
While I loved pursuing a degree in engineering, it didn't provide much latitude to express creativity.
And while I find my career as a cardiologist, slash electrophysiologist, exciting and fulfilling, I again find myself with little latitude to be creative in my decision making.
I often look on from the outside at those who can express creativity in their career, like musicians or writers.
And I wonder if there's a link between careers that allow one to be more creative and overall happiness in life.
I would love your thoughts on the topic maybe in an NSQ episode.
Well, guess what Patrick, you're getting an NSQ episode.
Yeah, a whole one wherever you are in Michigan.
Okay, I think this is a really fascinating question.
Basically, is creativity associated with happiness?
Is creativity associated with career happiness?
And Patrick, I do have some actual research for you from the Strategic National Arts Alumni Project.
So they interviewed 13,500 graduates at 154 institutions.
And are they all art students?
Yeah, okay. All at art institutions.
And they found that 92% of people who were in these arts academies found work after graduation.
Oh. Because I think so often as an parent, if your child's like, hey, I want to be an artist, or I want to go into this job, you're like, Yeah, you're going to be a starving artist.
Hey, that's such a good idea.
Maybe we could think about.
And then you give a much more practical answer.
Right. Like you could be an accountant.
And hate your life. Sorry, accountants.
Some accounts are happy.
We'll go with that. But 92% actually found work.
66% of these young artists said that their first job out of school was a close match for what they wanted to do.
So that's, I mean, pretty high.
Yeah. And then 70% of them who are employed as fine artists or photographers or dancers or writers said that they were very satisfied with their job.
I mean, very satisfied, I think, is an incredibly high bar.
Mm-hmm. And they said they were very satisfied not with standing the low pay.
Now, juxtapose that with Gallup in their study on the state of the American workforce.
And they said in their report that 70% of Americans were not engaged or actively disengaged and emotionally disconnected from their workplace.
So it's almost like photo negatives, right?
Right. So this, I will admit, both these studies are a little bit old, ones from 2011, ones from 2013.
But I went back that far because it allowed us to roughly compare timeline to timeline.
That was a long time ago, pre-pandemic.
We've talked recently about quiet quitting, about people who are actively sabotaging their workplaces, all those things.
I think if anything, this has all gotten worse.
But I think it gives some credence to this idea that creative work often is happy work.
You know, you've studied passion and perseverance and grit.
And that you have to, you know, have some level of passion for what you do.
And not just be practical with your career.
But what's your reaction to this and maybe scientifically, where do we go from there?
Okay. So I have had a conversation about happiness and creativity ongoing with Marty Seligman.
The great Marty Seligman.
The great Marty Seligman.
So Marty and I have known each other for now, like two plus decades.
And it's a perennial topic of conversation.
What is the connection between happiness and creativity?
And Marty has pointed out to me that there is a myth that people who are really unhappy are the ones who are the most creative.
Like we think of Sylvia Plath, right?
When we think of Van Gogh, the tortured artist.
You cut off your ear, right?
Yeah. I mean, you know, mental illness, like it's been associated with creative output in music and in art and literature for a long time.
But you know, like take Sylvia Plath, at least Marty's read on Sylvia Plath, was that she wasn't, I mean, she did kill herself and she was somebody who was prone to episodes of depression.
But Marty's conjecture is that she actually had her creative output, her writing, you know, the bell jar, the poetry during her manic episodes.
So it may not have been at all to do with the depressive episodes.
It might have been in spite of those.
But in general, negative emotions like sadness, anger, and anxiety are not correlated with creativity.
Sometimes they're negatively correlated and sometimes there's no correlation.
But the data are pretty clear that negative emotions and certainly depression, which just sucks.
Right. Let it go to depression.
You're very unlikely to be at your creative best.
But even like other negative emotions that are not as extreme, yeah, that's pretty definitive that they don't correlate positively.
So I have a friend, I'm not going to name him here, but he's a genuine rock star.
But he is a very tortured soul.
But I really think so much of his creativity comes from his pain.
I wouldn't say that he's depressed, but he is able to explore the human emotion.
So his lyrics are so profound because he feels pain so deeply.
So how is, walk me through how that's different.
Yeah, how do we reconcile that, right?
Well, okay, can I ask you about your friend?
So this is a musician who expresses his somewhat like tortured relationship with existence through his music.
Is that right? Yes. Well, I think this is complicated.
I don't think depression is quote unquote like good for creativity.
But I do think there's some nuance here.
Freud, who is not recognized as a great scientist.
But I think should be recognized as a, and a student observer of human nature.
You know, Freud had this idea that we have these defense mechanisms that protect our ego.
And you know, we've all heard about these defense mechanisms as being probably bad, right?
Like, oh, you're repressed or you're in denial.
Like in these are what in Freudian taxonomy would be called like immature defenses.
Defenses that get you into more trouble.
Sure. But there were these mature defenses that got a little bit less attention.
One of them is humor, one of them is altruism.
These are ways of dealing with the pain of existence and ways that don't get into trouble.
They get you and other people into a better place.
Humor, by the way, and especially self-deprecating humor is 100% my defense mechanism.
100%. Oh, that's so you.
Well, and people will say to me like, hey, stop with the self-deprecating humor.
And I'm always like, but there's so much to work with.
You're like lay off my defense.
It's like so working for me.
And it is a mature defense in this Freudian taxonomy.
And the one that's most related to Patrick's question about creativity and happiness.
And this is why things are complicated is that there is a Freudian defense called sublimation.
And sublimation is when you, you know, like when Carrie Fisher said, it's when you take your broken heart and turn it into art.
So sublimation is taking pain and then transforming that into artistic expression.
So maybe your unnamed famous torture musician friend is taking negative emotion and sublimating.
And so I guess you could argue like, oh, that's a way in which unhappiness can lead to creativity.
But it's almost like despite being unhappy, you know, like is in general positive mood is correlated with creativity.
And it makes a lot of sense that people who are creative and who are happy go hand in hand, because the act of creation is inherently, I think a joyful act.
You're discovering. You're making something new.
You're doing something for the first time in a new way.
Okay. So let me give a little bit of theoretical cred to this idea that happiness and creativity, not only go hand in hand, happiness does predict creativity over time.
And creativity also has been shown to predict happiness over time.
So it's like a beautiful circular path to creativity and joy.
It is. It's a positive feedback loop.
But here's a theory behind it.
It's the creative genius of a psychologist named Barbara Frederiksen.
And it's called broadened and build theory.
So basically what broadened build theory says is that when we have negative emotions like fear and sadness and anxiety and anger, we do things that are more or less fight or flight.
And that helps us survive in bad times.
And when we have positive emotions like happiness, joy, elation, pride, calm, and so forth, we have those positive emotions because those are a signal that times are good.
And that's when we should broaden the possibilities that we're thinking of and build our resources and connections.
Interesting. And so when you are in a positive state of emotion, when you are happy, your mind kind of spontaneously thinks more creatively, more expansively, you make connections that you wouldn't otherwise make.
So I do think it's a positive feedback cycle.
What's amazing though, as you were describing broadened and build and negative emotions lead to sort of this narrowing positive emotions to expanding, I thought immediately of body language.
Think about when you feel threatened or something, right?
Or you're fearful. You kind of like shrink in or people always fold their arms if they're not open.
But if you're relaxed in this happy state, I mean what immediately came to my mind was laying on a beach with your arm spread and your leg spread and just like being free.
So what's so interesting is that a lot of times people think that emotions are only express through your facial expressions, like your smiling, your frowning, your forehead is wrinkled, or it's not wrinkled.
But actually your body and your body posture is also an expression of your emotions and sometimes even more reliably so.
And in general, I think positive emotions, they're getting you to approach the world.
Like you're not retreating from the world, you're not hiding, you're not like protecting, you're not preserving, you're exploring.
And if you just have this like image of like the carefree four-year-old who's just like picking stuff up and you know wonder what this crayon would taste like, I'll put it in my mouth.
Don't like that. Maybe I'll take it out of my mouth.
Like I think there is something about that image that is what the picture of like creativity and positive emotion looks like.
And if you think about a crying four-year-old or a scared four-year old or an angry four-year-old, you don't get the picture of doing things to explore the world, but in fact the opposite.
That's so interesting to think through.
Right? Yeah. And Mike, I think you and I would both love to hear from our listeners.
A story about a time in your life when you were at your creative peak.
I'm interested in knowing whether you were especially happy or I don't know, maybe especially unhappy.
Regardless, record a voice memo in a quiet place with your mouth close to the phone and email us at nsq at Freakonomics.com.
Maybe we'll play it on a future episode of the show.
Still to come on No Stupid Questions.
Angela and Mike explore how constraints inspire creativity.
I love Napoleon Dynamite.
You do? No stupid questions is sponsored by the podcast How I Built This.
Behind every successful business is a story and some might surprise you.
Like how Chobani's first yogurt factory was discovered on a piece of junk mail.
Or how the founder of the multi-million dollar cosmetics brand Drunk Elephant was told by everyone, including her own mother that the name sounded like a dive bar.
On the podcast How I Built This host Guy Ross talks to founders behind the world's biggest companies.
To learn how they built them.
In each episode, you'll hear entrepreneurs share moments of doubt, failure, and how they were able to overcome setbacks to reach success.
How I built this is like a masterclass in innovation and creativity.
It's a how-to guide for navigating life's challenges from the people who've done it all.
Follow How I Built This wherever you get your podcasts.
No Stupid Questions is sponsored by Rosetta Stone.
Traveling is so much more meaningful when you understand the language of the place you're visiting.
Rosetta Stone, one of the most trusted language learning programs, has helped millions learn new languages and can help you too.
With Rosetta Stone, you'll learn intuitively.
You're trained to listen, speak, read, write, and think in your chosen language.
You'll be prepared for real, authentic conversations.
Plus, their true accent feature gives you feedback on your pronunciation.
And with the Rosetta Stone app, you can learn anytime, anywhere, with customizable lessons as short as 10 minutes.
For a very limited time, our listeners can get Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off.
That's 50% off unlimited access to 25 language courses for the rest of your life.
Redeem your 50% off at rosettastone.com slash questions.
That's rosettastone.com slash questions.
No Stupid Questions is sponsored by BetterHelp Online Therapy.
Take a minute to check your social battery.
How's it doing? Does the thought of social events make you feel excited or exhausted?
It's easy to ignore our social batteries and spread ourselves thin.
And it's important to find the right amount of socializing for you, so you still give yourself the time to recharge.
Therapy can give you the self-awareness to build a social life that doesn't drain your battery.
BetterHelp offers affordable online therapy on a schedule that works for you.
Start the process in minutes and switch therapists anytime.
Find your social sweet spot with BetterHelp.
Visit BetterHelp.com slash NSQ today to get 10% off your first month.
That's BetterHelpHELP.com slash NSQ.
Now back to Mike and Angela's conversation about the relationship between creativity and happiness.
What immediately came to mind when I heard this question is the research out of Michigan State University at winners of the Nobel Prize.
That they are 2.85 times more likely than the average scientist to have an artistic or crafty hobby which one might say is this creative expression.
I've heard that statistic that somebody who wins the Nobel Prize in medicine or economics is more likely, not less likely, to allocate time in their busy schedules for a serious hobby.
Why do you think that might be?
So my immediate thought process is that it gives your brain time to reset.
This is really silly but I do this New York Times puzzle every morning called Connections and it has a 4x4 set of 16 little boxes and you have to say which sets of 4 are aligned to each other.
I'll often read all 16 words and then take a break and go do something else because when you first read them you're like, I don't know how these all connect.
I have no idea. I just go take a little break and when I come back often it's very clear to me very quickly.
Whereas I may not have seen it at the beginning.
That is such a silly little example compared to the science at a Nobel prize winner might be doing.
But I wonder, tell me, is there something to this idea of doing something divergent or something creative that lets your mind process these deep things a little differently?
Well, I have a story for you that I think will resonate because it's similar.
So my dad was an organic chemist for his whole professional career and I have to say he was a awesome organic chemist.
He worked at DuPont his whole life and it's not sexy and it certainly would never win the Nobel prize in chemistry.
But he worked on automotive refinishing products so like car paint but specifically the car paint you get when you have a dent and then you have to get your car repainted which apparently is incredibly complex problem because when you have a car over time because of sun and rain and time the car paint changes color kind of idiosyncratically depending on where you
live and how much sun and so forth.
So when you dent your car and you just have to get that one part repainted you need the car paint to match exactly in color and luminance and like that's what my dad worked on for his whole life.
He reached the highest level of any scientist in DuPont.
He was at the like distinguished scientist level and there's like literally a bronze cast statue of my dad in you know the headquarters.
Wait that is amazing. There's a statue of your dad.
I know who does that? Who wants a statue of anyone really but apparently they cast one of my dad.
So I speak with the authority of you know my father's accomplishments I guess when he said if you're really stuck because I remember asking him in college I was like taking gosh who knows maybe I was taking organic chemistry or you know this is like a really hard science class and I was like I don't understand this my brain's not working and he said to me to go watch an action movie.
Go watch an action movie?
Like a Schwarzenegger film.
You want to know what we do in my family with action movies?
You watch them? This is my brother Dave's favorite joke.
If we ever eat like a big meal like Thanksgiving.
Yeah and you've eaten too much food he always says well better go watch an action movie to work all this off.
I like that you know not sure it's gonna burn calories but here's why my dad recommended he said that when he was working on a really hard scientific problem he would do something totally different take his mind off of it like watching and grossing action movie or read a book or my dad really loved to take baths and read these like serial novels in Chinese.
Effectively the literary equivalent of a soap opera but they were in Chinese so I couldn't read it so I'm guessing and he would you know have these insights that would come to him while his mind wasn't specifically on the task anyway that reminds me of this puzzle that you're doing and you like take your mind somewhere else and then you come back to it and you know my
dad's not the only one right like many scientists have said that when they come to their best ideas it's because they've put a lot of information in their head so it's not that they have just goofed off for their whole lives but you work really hard you put a lot of knowledge in your head you think to the point where you can't usefully think anymore and then in this time
where you're more relaxed and your mind is ostensibly somewhere else there is a part of your thinking let's call it subconscious thinking that is putting ideas together and then you have like the epiphany.
Another thing that I think about and maybe some practical advice for Patrick and maybe some response to why Nobel prize winners are so busy but still find a way to play the piano there was an article in the Harvard Business Review written by Duncan Wardle who's the former vice president of innovation and creativity at the Walt Disney company when I think of creativity
I think of Disney right yeah that would be a good synonym for creativity Disney.
So Duncan Wardle he writes in this HBR article I've learned that people with the fewest number of resources tend to be the most creative and the reason I love that at Qualtrics we've always had this line that constraints breed creativity necessities the mother invention.
He goes on to use examples like distilleries during the pandemic use nothing but the inventory of ingredients they already had to create hand sanitizer or a 3D printing company that creates respirator valves in 24 hours in Italy when they needed them so desperately in all of their ICU units.
And I think of so many stories of people who have used constraints to breed that creativity and I even think about these Nobel prize winners who are the most busy people but those constraints have almost created opportunities for creativity in their own way.
I've got a friend Jared Hess he's a screenwriter and director and producer and he wrote a film while he was an undergrad in college called Napoleon Dynamite.
I love Napoleon Dynamite.
You do so much that's such a great movie.
He said he based it off of his little brother no offense to his little he said those are all lines from growing up but this is what I love about the story of Jared and Napoleon Dynamite is he said so many of his classmates they were assigned to write a screenplay and they would write these things that would need Tom Cruise and Gal Gadot and 200 million dollars to produce
and that was their screenplay.
And Jared and his wife Jeroosha who were classmates they said why don't we do what we can do today we want to control our own destiny so these constraints they had bred the creativity to write something that they could produce.
And so Jeroosha went to every goodwill within hundreds of miles to do all the costuming and Jared you know wrote things that he knew and they went up to Idaho where he grew up and the cast was like sleeping on the floor of relatives houses and they found the guy who played Napoleon Dynamite as one of their classmates they were just very scrappy but because they filtered
all these constraints Jared told me that all the people that worked on Napoleon Dynamite from his classes are still in film today and all the people who wrote these big screenplays none of them are in the movie industry and his takeaway was that because he just figured out how to get started on what he could do today well that day right back then yeah without 200 million dollars
right that's what allowed him to get into the industry and go so you're saying that in your experience and in the experience of the geniuses behind Napoleon Dynamite which is definitely a genius film that like not having infinite resources actually produce something really innovative and I think there's lots of stories like that right where like you wouldn't
have had to be creative except for you did have to be creative right yeah I think that's fair look I think even in a business environment I think that when people have a lot of money so companies that have taken a ton of funding I think that can lead to laziness I think that if you have so many people on your team then people are just busy not necessarily productive so I think
in all of these environments constraints breed that creativity if you don't have a team that's big enough for what you think you need to do then you only do the things that are the most impactful it was the old Stephen Covey do first things first and second things not at all right if you can't do everything then it forces you to figure out what are the few things that will have the biggest
impact let's go there so I wonder you know Patrick is saying I don't have time to be creative I don't know Patrick I'm certainly not in medicine but I wonder if some of the greatest breakthroughs in medicine when we talk about these Nobel Prize winners etc came because they were looking at new ways to do it different ways to do it they gave themselves the freedom to not just
say I want to be excellent at doing ex-surgery but can I do it better or different or in a new way and that's where the breakthroughs come from so I I want to agree with that that absolutely necessity can be the mother of invention what I think we would also want to say though in the same breath is that all this research on happiness and creativity means that like poverty
is not the mother of all invention like having no time to think because you're working three jobs is not necessarily the mother of invention it's more like I don't know if necessity is the mother of invention happiness is the father right because like it's both having some constraints but also I do believe that this capacity to relax a little to be in a good mood and therefore
your mind wanders a little more expansively like I think people rarely say what else you need other than constraints and I think Patrick's question allows us to at least add that happiness is another factor you're absolutely right poverty of course does not lead to creativity it does not lead to happiness and there's so much research about the massive negative
externalities of uncertainty that comes with poverty of all of those challenges that are associated so you don't mean constraints in the sense that like you really don't have enough resources at all you just mean that like there are some constraints in your schedule or your resources that will at some level make you think more innovatively taking a risk here to
bring up Maslow I think we're talking about constraints breed creativity went your further up the hierarchy oh Abraham Maslow the psychologist of a hierarchy of needs yes hierarchy of needs once you have basic needs satisfied right I'm speaking in a high productive work environment not in a hierarchy of needs right I want to say that you know if necessity is the mother
of invention and if happiness is the father of invention I mean if you just kind of bought belong in the world and you follow the rules that education systems and workplaces lay out for us you know we may miss the opportunity to be creative and therefore happier so I don't know Patrick I think there's such a deep link between happiness and creativity you know whatever
you do you probably want to be a little more creative certainly Patrick would like to be I mean what I'd like to end on is this article called happiness and creativity going with the flow written by none other than the psychologist mihali chick send me high and chick send me high you've heard of right like the flow guy of course who discovered the flow state that artists
and other creative people as well as athletes and other high performers end up being like so absorbed in what they're doing that they so often describe it as being in the flow and in this article chick send me high says that creative persons differ from one another in a variety of ways but in one respect they are unanimous they all love what they do it is not the hope of achieving
fame or making money that drives them rather it is the opportunity to do the work that they enjoy doing exactly this episode was produced by me Rebecca Lee Douglas and now here's a fact check of today's conversation in the first half of the show Mike and Angela marvel at how michiganters can share their location simply by pointing to an area of their hand and indeed
residents of the mitten state are known for using the lower peninsula's glove like shape as a convenient cartographic tool Mike says that no other state has the ability to do this but Wisconsin ites would disagree in 2011 Wisconsin was represented as a brown mitten in some of the state's winter tourism ads leading to a controversy between the Midwestern neighbors
Dave Lorenz then Michigan's manager of public and industry relations told the Kalamazoo Gazette we understand their mitten envy but there's only one mitten state a Wisconsin PR man named Tom Lions responded Wisconsin is the left mitten Michigan is the right mitten even children know that one mitten doesn't cut it when it comes to Midwest winters later Angela says
that DuPont headquarters houses a bronze cast statue of her father Yingke Lee this isn't entirely true Lee received many awards over the course of his career including two from DuPont a distinguished scientist award and a lavoixier medal for technical achievement in celebration of his accomplishments a bronze plaque featuring an engraving of Lee's likeness
is on display at the DuPont experimental station facility in Wilmington Delaware finally Mike attributes the quotation do first things first and second things not at all to Stephen Covey author of the 1989 book The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People the line actually comes from the 1966 book The Effective Executive by Peter Drucker whose work was a significant
influence on Covey that's it for the fact check before we wrap today's show let's hear some thoughts about last week's episode on whether GPS and other modern technologies are affecting the way we think hi this is Brad and I loved your episode about GPS the question that I've been thinking about is how many marriages have probably been saved because of GPS no longer
do you have spouses sitting in the front seat of their car arguing over which direction to go GPS now solves that problem and I think it's likely has saved many many marriages hi my name is Matt I live in Nova Scotia canter I share the mindset that modern technology has improved the way that we think a single example that I find myself experiencing regularly is my vocabulary
having essentially the entire wealth of human knowledge at my fingertips at any moments notice has led me to be able to quickly look up and remember new words if I had to think of a word and go home and search it in a dictionary I feel I would have long forgotten it before that point but being able to immediately search it listen to how it's pronounced and being given its
origins in popularity over time definitely make them stick without modern technology words like eponymous and colloquialism would likely not have made it to my lexicon that was Brad Yumansky and Matt Greening thanks to them and to everyone who shared their experiences with us and remember we'd love to hear your stories about a time when you were most creative
were you happy depressed locked in a flow state send a voice memo to nsq at freeganomics.com and you might hear your voice on the show coming up next week on those stupid questions how do we disagree better I'm right no I'm right you all suffer from the sin of certainty maybe you're all wrong that's next week on those stupid questions no stupid questions is part of the freeganomics
radio network which also includes freeganomics radio people I mostly admire and the economics of everyday things all our shows are produced by stitcher and rendbud radio lyric about it is our production associate this episode was mixed by Greg Ripon with help from jasmine clinger we had research assistance from Daniel Moritz Rapson our theme song was composed
by louis scarrah you can follow us on twitter at nsq underscore show and on facebook at nsq show if you have a question for a future episode please email it to nsq at freeganomics.com to learn more or to read episode transcripts visit freeganomics.com slash nsq thanks for listening Patrick poppy poppy how is how are the pieces better the freeganomics radio network
the hidden side of everything stitcher investing involves risk including risk of loss fidelity broker services LLC member NYSPSI PC listening to your favorite podcast that's smart earning your degree online from southern new hampshire university that's really smart with 24 seven access to coursework no set class times and dedicated student support you
can go to school when and where it works for you low online tuition means you can even do it for less and dedicated student support means we'll be with you from day one to graduation and beyond join a community of learners just like you go to snsq.edu today to start your free application you haven't heard about them at christby yet well then you probably haven't heard
the sweet silence up to the first christby bite either go try it for yourself to hear the best not sound you've ever heard
